Team Sherlock Holmes! - chat

[Felicia]

The wiki page I used for Thomas didn't mention being an orphan or his parents. And I read these so long ago I didn't remember. Lol.

[Alaina]

LOL same for that series.

[Ruthie]

I posted a bunch of new guesses

[Alaina]

Thank Ruthie! Please double check what has already been guessed before doing so next time so people aren't guessing the same thing. I changed some of mine so that we don't have the same guesses.

[Ruthie]

Alaina wrote: "Thank Ruthie! Please double check what has already been guessed before doing so next time so people aren't guessing the same thing. I changed some of mine so that we don't have the same guesses."

Oh I'm sorry! I thought I checked the previous guesses, I must have not been on the most recent page. Or we were working on our post at the same time, not sure.

[Felicia]

Character Thirteen:
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
fantasy book
involved in a war
female
in a relationship
death of a family member or friend a main talking point/theme in the book
get in an accident
live with people other than their parents
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
blond hair
male
an athlete
contestant in a competition
green eyes
royalty
related to a God
orphan
black hair
lgbtqia+
child
magic in the real world (hide spoiler)]

[Dr. Andy]

Possibilities:

Mare from Red Queen
Karou from DoSaB?
Rose from VA?
Amy from Across the Universe
Essun from the fifth season
Bitterblue from Bitterblue

[Alaina]

Interesting choices.. I'll see if my next book will help narrow that list down

[Dr. Andy]

The question marks are ones that I’m like they work minus the magic in the real world part 😅

[Alaina]

LOL I figured.

[Kim]

could it be emma carstairs from lady midnight?

parents' death drives her every interaction
fantasy
lives with not her parents
in a relationship with julian (parabatai)
fairy war

the accident is the only piece i can't fit

[Dr. Andy]

Kim wrote: "could it be emma carstairs from lady midnight?

parents' death drives her every interaction
fantasy
lives with not her parents
in a relationship with julian (parabatai)
fairy war

the accident is t..."

Shadowhunters has magic in the real world tho. Emma is also blond and that's in incorrect as well

[Kim]

Andy wrote: "Kim wrote: "could it be emma carstairs from lady midnight?

parents' death drives her every interaction
fantasy
lives with not her parents
in a relationship with julian (parabatai)
fairy war

the a..."

that's right! oh the details i forget...

[Dr. Andy]

Kim wrote: "Andy wrote: "Kim wrote: "could it be emma carstairs from lady midnight?

parents' death drives her every interaction
fantasy
lives with not her parents
in a relationship with julian (parabatai)
fai..."

It was so close tho :(

[Alaina]

Hmmm I'm thinking it might be Mare now. Since we got a yes to brown hair, brown eyes, AND colored hair. According to her wiki page she has brown eyes and brown/gray/purple hair lol

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "Hmmm I'm thinking it might be Mare now. Since we got a yes to brown hair, brown eyes, AND colored hair. According to her wiki page she has brown eyes and brown/gray/purple hair lol"

I wanna say when she starts using her lightning it makes some white/gray streaks??

[Dr. Andy]

I added three more questions that should all be a yes for Mare

Magic- lightning
POC - Aveyard has said Mare is the futuristic/dystopian version of the latinx race
Enemy is a queen - Elara is an asshole

[Alaina]

Andy wrote: "I added three more questions that should all be a yes for Mare

Magic- lightning
POC - Aveyard has said Mare is the futuristic/dystopian version of the latinx race
Enemy is a queen - Elara is an as..."

LOL YEAH SHE WAS

[Alaina]

I added 4 more questions lol
Do they steal anything? Mare is my little thief.
Are they poor? She was definitely poor AF
Do they have siblings? Her mom and dad definitely got busy
Do they fight a monster? Honestly I just threw this one in because I didn't know what else to guess for this dumb book. BUT some people were straight up monsters in this series

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "I added 4 more questions lol
Do they steal anything? Mare is my little thief.
Are they poor? She was definitely poor AF
Do they have siblings? Her mom and dad definitely got busy
Do they fight a mo..."

That sounds good to me!!

[Alaina]

Woohoo! If we get the yes's to the ones we are hoping to get - I'll guess Mare

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "Woohoo! If we get the yes's to the ones we are hoping to get - I'll guess Mare"

Woot!

[Felicia]

Character Thirteen:
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
fantasy book
involved in a war
female
in a relationship
death of a family member or friend a main talking point/theme in the book
get in an accident
live with people other than their parents
brown hair
brown eyes
colored hair
use a weapon
kill someone
teenager
get captured
kill someone
fight a monster
have siblings
steals
poor
magic
enemy a queen
POC
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
blond hair
male
an athlete
contestant in a competition
green eyes
royalty
related to a God
orphan
black hair
lgbtqia+
child
magic in the real world
have tattoos
blue eyes
take place in Europe
live in the future
feature vampires (hide spoiler)]

[Alaina]

We can start guessing for character #14 now guys!

[Dr. Andy]

okay posted a bunch lol

[Felicia]

Character Fourteen:
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Female
sci-fi story
Teenager
risk their life
play a sport (participates in activities considered a sport but not actually for sport)
in a relationship
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
have magic
Poor
POC
Religious
a nerd
an adult
a child
blue eyes
LGBT
work in an office (hide spoiler)]

***Also, good luck on deciphering if my answers to your guesses are correct or not. All of the rest of your characters are characters I don't know that well. So, I'm relying heavily on Wiki pages here people. Take that how you will. LMFAO.

[Alaina]

Oh man..

[Alaina]

For some reason I'm being very hopeful that it could be Katniss lol

[Caroline]

I'm also wondering if it could be Scarlet or Cress? But I'm not sure if they do any sports activities. I don't remember Scarlet too well, and I never read Cress.

[Alaina]

I don't think we will get scarlet or cress since Enola got Cinder.

[Caroline]

Yeah, I wasn't sure if that would rule it out. They are different characters. 🤷‍♀️

[Dr. Andy]

If anyone has a book with a bow and arrow that would be useful lmao

[Alaina]

LOL I know right? I have a book that works for sibling and I just finished it. I also have arrows in text in the one I'm reading right now.

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "LOL I know right? I have a book that works for sibling and I just finished it. I also have arrows in text in the one I'm reading right now."

epic! the one i finished might work for something brown. I'll look through it.

[Alaina]

I think she has black hair and grey eyes.. maybe your book has that?

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "I think she has black hair and grey eyes.. maybe your book has that?"

i have dark hair

[Dr. Andy]

oh wait poor is in the incorrect guesses and Katniss was definitely poor. so maybe it's not her?

[Alaina]

Hmm...

[Dr. Andy]

the only other scifi books with teenage female MCs on the list are Pandemonium (Lena) and Across the Universe (Amy) if we don't include the Lunar Chronicles since Enola had Cinder.

[Alaina]

Hmm ask for brown hair? lmao

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "Hmm ask for brown hair? lmao"

I did!

[Dr. Andy]

we should ask if it takes place in the USA: both hunger games and pandemonium are in the futuristic US

and if it takes place in space or a spaceship: that would work for Across the Universe and Lunar Chronicles.

[Alaina]

Woohoo

[Alaina]

🥳🥳

[Alaina]

I'm about to dive into . That could work for America.

[Celia]

Should I ask if it's a retelling for Lunar Chronicles? Just finished

[Felicia]

Character Fourteen:
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Female
sci-fi story
Teenager
risk their life
play a sport (participates in activities considered a sport but not actually for sport)
in a relationship
brown hair
live in the USA
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
have magic
Poor
POC
Religious
a nerd
an adult
a child
blue eyes
LGBT
work in an office
have a sister
use a bow and arrow
retelling (hide spoiler)]

[Felicia]

Character Fourteen:
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
brown eyes
live on the east coast
involved in an accident
in school
have a nickname
Orphan
a rebel
get betrayed
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
have magic
Poor
POC
Religious
a nerd
an adult
a child
blue eyes
LGBT
work in an office
have a sister
use a bow and arrow
retelling
in space
green eyes
have tattoos
get in a fight
go on a trip
speak another language
face demons
lose their memory
have a significant other/spouse
hazel eyes
have a pet
have a job
artistic (hide spoiler)]

[Alaina]

Okay, here are all the correct guesses in one message:
Female
sci-fi story
Teenager
risk their life
play a sport (participates in activities considered a sport but not actually for sport)
in a relationship
brown hair
live in the USA
brown eyes
live on the east coast
involved in an accident
in school
have a nickname
Orphan
a rebel
get betrayed
live in a city
escape from someone/something

[Alaina]

Looks like Felicia missed two questions. So I'll update the above message if they are right.