Team Sherlock Holmes! - chat

[Alaina]

lmao twinning andy

[Dr. Andy]

So that leaves us with Rose, Katy and Samantha rn. Lemme go see if i can find a physical description of them

[Alaina]

I think Samantha has green eyes

[Dr. Andy]

looked up katy on lux wiki and she has heather gray eyes

[Alaina]

Should we final guess Katy??

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "I think Samantha has green eyes"

That sounds right. i think the cover has green eyes.

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "Should we final guess Katy??"

lets do it lmao

[Alaina]

Katy does make sense - in WV, forbidden love (human vs alien), brown hair, grey eyes, she moved to WV for her senior year (#travels), in school. Pretty sure it's tagged enemies to lovers.

[Alaina]

YAY we got it right!! Okay guys we can start posting for Character #4!

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "YAY we got it right!! Okay guys we can start posting for Character #4!"

yay

[Kim]

I’ve finished “the invisible life of addie larue” and will review tonight. Should I guess:

Female
Name starts with A
Wears glasses (Henry)
Green eyes (Luke)

[Celia]

Since we're at the beginning I would be open to any, whichever you feel fits.

[Alaina]

Character Four:
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[Male
Brunette
From a YA book (hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[Magic
Blue eyes
Friends to lovers
Religious
Encounter animals
Go into a Forest
Person of color (hide spoiler)]

[Alaina]

Kim wrote: "I’ve finished “the invisible life of addie larue” and will review tonight. Should I guess:

Female
Name starts with A
Wears glasses (Henry)
Green eyes (Luke)"

Hmm I would do glasses or green eyes. Since it looks like our character is a Male.

[Alaina]

Well not having blue eyes knocks out Augustus from the fault in our stars.

[Alaina]

Not sure what color eyes Wade has but he is in a ya book and I'm pretty sure he has brown hair..

[Alaina]

Honestly so many male characters have brown hair lol so I'm going to need more information before I come up with a list of suggestions

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "Honestly so many male characters have brown hair lol so I'm going to need more information before I come up with a list of suggestions"

Right lol

[Alaina]

lmaaao I guess we can maybe narrow things a bit more once I write reviews in the morning.

[Dr. Andy]

Alaina wrote: "lmaaao I guess we can maybe narrow things a bit more once I write reviews in the morning."

Definitely. I probably wont have anything until tomorrow at the earliest

[Kim]

posting tonight for glasses :)

[Felicia]

Character Four
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
Brunette
From a YA book
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Magic
Blue eyes
Friends to lovers
Religious
Encounter animals
Go into a Forest
Person of color
glasses
takes place in USA (hide spoiler)]

[Felicia]

Character Four
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
Brunette
From a YA book
play games (idfk?)
brown eyes
travels
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Magic
Blue eyes
Friends to lovers
Religious
Encounter animals
Go into a Forest
Person of color
glasses
takes place in USA
have siblings
dies
High School
green eyes
related to a God
LGBT community
live in Europe
chosen one (hide spoiler)]

[Alaina]

Okay, well, I hate this character - it's official.

It's not - Augustus, Four, Peeta/Gale, Nick, Mark, Werner, Wade, anyone from the infernal devices, Kai, Will, anyone from night circus, anyone from the heroes of olympus, anyone from a song of ice and fire, not aspen/maxon, not park, not august, not theo decker, not kvothe, no one from the mortal instrument, not Louie, not Day, no one from a court of thorns, no one from red queen, not kaladin, not thorne, not wolf, not adam/warner/kenji, not ky/xander, not chaol/dorian, not don, not ove, not etienne, not ari/dante, not Noah, not puck/ash, not achilles/patroclus, not elder, not malyen/darkling, not daniel, not prince marek, not simon snow, not sam (because he died), not derek,

maybe...
jack from room but I think that's set in the US??
jacob from miss peregrines? I know he lived in Florida and he went to Wales though..
simon from the mortal instrument?? but he had glasses in the beginnin.. in the US
tengo from 1Q74? ..but I don't know his hair/eye color nopeeee
kaz from six of crows?
patroclus from the song of achilles? ..and nope, he is in the lgbt community.
Eragon from the inheritance cycle? he has brown hair and eyes in the book
travis maddox from beautiful disaster? ..unless the book is set in USA - then no.

Also can't be: Cassie from The Fifth Wave, Darrow from Red Rising, Celaena from Throne of Glass, Christian from Fifty Shades of Grey, Katy from Obsidian.

Also also - Twin said no to space. UGH.

[Kim]

I’d vote for Jacob from miss peregrine. What would be a good clue to guess to determine it’s him? There’s nothing very particular about him (he’s a teen, has both parents, no particular skills)

[Alaina]

I would go with teenager lol

[Alaina]

Hmm wait no, okay here are some potential questions:

Jacob - Do they see a psychiatrist? Hang with peculiars? Go through a time loop?
Eragon - Do they have a dragon?
Kaz - Do they have a limp? Plan heists? Love money?

[Alaina]

I asked for Dragon and Limp with two of Vicki's books. Felicia said yes to Limp and no to Dragon. So I'm thinking it's Kaz because he has a limp.

[Alaina]

Great news! Kaz was correct!! So we can start guessing for Character 5 :)

[Dr. Andy]

yay finally

[Kim]

And that’s why I’m not the official guesser lol. Way to go team!

[Ruthie]

Ok Sorry I've been MIA. I have three books ready to post but not sure what the first guess should be. Here are the books and possible ideas:


red hair, girl, boy, king, married, engaged, england, etc


black hair, african american woman, blue eyes, russian, fangs, vampire, witch, mother, club owner, wears contacts, doctor, fundraiser, queen


girl, young adult, queen, magic, grandma, mom, "hero in hiding" trope, prophecy, "chosen one" trope, dragon, shifter

[Ruthie]

I've written the reviews but haven't added to spreadsheet or made a guess yet. wanted to see what y'all think I should guess

[Felicia]

TEAMS!

I just wanted to make everyone aware that I am in a wedding this Friday. With all the preparations and such I am off work the next three days and will have very limited access to my home computer to update scores or even check the guesses. However, I will have my phone for Alaina and Aly to text me. But I may or may not get back to them right away. Depends what I am doing at the moment.

With that being said, if anyone is banking any books because they're not sure what to guess, I suggest you figure those out and post them today so I can at least leave work today (4pm EST) having updated teams as much as possible.

[Alaina]

Ruthie wrote: "I've written the reviews but haven't added to spreadsheet or made a guess yet. wanted to see what y'all think I should guess"

Honestly, we know nothing for our current character so I say - go crazy!

[Alaina]

Character Five
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[go to a party
male (hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[has a cousin
live outside US
half-siblings
female
epic/high fantasy
Captain (hide spoiler)]

[Ruthie]

Sorry I missed Felicia's message about posting guesses. I'll post some guesses soon and then Alaina can text Felicia

[Alaina]

Ruthie wrote: "Sorry I missed Felicia's message about posting guesses. I'll post some guesses soon and then Alaina can text Felicia"

Sounds like a plan!

[Ruthie]

Ok Alaina I made guesses:

Are they royalty?
Are they a supernatural/paranormal creature?
Is another planet (not earth) mentioned or part of the book setting?

[Alaina]

Ruthie wrote: "Ok Alaina I made guesses:

Are they royalty?
Are they a supernatural/paranormal creature?
Is another planet (not earth) mentioned or part of the book setting?"

Sent to Felicia

[Alaina]

She said:

No to Royalty & Supernatural/Paranormal
Yes to another planet

[Alaina]

Hmm maybe...

Mark from The Martian? He does go to Mars.. but I don't remember a party.
John from I am Number Four? Read this back in 2017 though so not sure

I just got out of a meeting so I can keep looking through the list to see if any other book mentions a different planet and such

[Dr. Andy]

Posted about plants!

[Kim]

i just finished "The Siren" but not sure of a good guess to go with.

[Alaina]

Hmm.. well since I don't think it's Mark or John - I'm honestly not sure who are character could be. I didn't have time to look through the list again yesterday. So if your book works for teenager, I would guess that? Or something with mythology? That way we can knock out all the books that have mythology.

[Kim]

I’ll post for mythology, feels like a bigger swing

[Alaina]

Sound good!

[Alaina]

I just asked all the questions - sorry was really busy with work today. Didn't even realize we had so many posts on our thread.

[Ruthie]

I have a few books I've finished so once we see what she said about our new questions, I'd be able to post some guesses today

[Alaina]

Character Five
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[go to a party
male
another planet
brown hair
ya book
brown eyes
famous (eventually)
someone is probably killed (hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[has a cousin
live outside US
half-siblings
female
epic/high fantasy
captain
royalty
supernatural/paranormal
grow plants
blue eyes
blonde hair
green eyes
mythological
black hair
two mc's
violet eyes (hide spoiler)]