Team Sherlock Holmes! - chat

[Ruthie]

Hmm, I'll have to look at the list and see who I think it might be

[Ruthie]

Ready Player one?

[Ruthie]

From Alaina's comment when y'all were guessing Character 5 and it ended up being Kaz

"Not sure what color eyes Wade has but he is in a ya book and I'm pretty sure he has brown hair."

[Ruthie]

I'll have to see how I can fit a guess with the books I've finished

[Ruthie]

guessing that they play video games/computer games

[Ruthie]

Ok I posted my book for the video game/computer game guess

[Alaina]

She said yes to your question Ruthie

[Alaina]

Character Five
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[go to a party
male
another planet
brown hair
ya book
brown eyes
famous (eventually)
someone is probably killed
video/computer games (hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[has a cousin
live outside US
half-siblings
female
epic/high fantasy
captain
royalty
supernatural/paranormal
grow plants
blue eyes
blonde hair
green eyes
mythological
black hair
two mc's
violet eyes (hide spoiler)]

[Alaina]

Character Five
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[go to a party
male
another planet
brown hair
ya book
brown eyes
famous (eventually)
someone is probably killed
video/computer games
future (hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[has a cousin
live outside US
half-siblings
female
epic/high fantasy
captain
royalty
supernatural/paranormal
grow plants
blue eyes
blonde hair
green eyes
mythological
black hair
two mc's
violet eyes
feature an ex (I don't think so?) (hide spoiler)]

No answer (so far) for:
curly hair
poor
multiple villains

[Ruthie]

Ok so it must be the ready player two guy right??

[Ruthie]

ready player one I mean

[Alaina]

That's what I'm thinking but I want to wait to see what Felicia says about the ones she hasn't answered yet.

[Celia]

Question, how is it incorrect that the book takes place OUTSIDE the US but correct that it takes place ON ANOTHER PLANET?

[Caroline]

I mean, the questions we asked were whether another planet was mentioned or part of the book setting, and whether the MC lives outside the US. So the questions were about different things

[Celia]

Ah ok

[Alaina]

Plus, if I think our character is from the book that I think it is.. it sort of works. Mostly because you could go to another planet in a video game (of a sort) but not be outside the US.

[Alaina]

Okay so I'm still waiting on the following questions to be answered:

1. Do they have curly hair?
2. Are they poor?
3. Is the MC facing multiple victims?
4. Does it involve kidnapping?
5. Do they find treasure?
6. Does he have a girlfriend?

Hopefully the answers will point towards who I think it is - Wade from Ready Player One - and if not, I guess we will go back to the drawing board lol

[Alaina]

Character Five
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[go to a party
male
another planet
brown hair
ya book
brown eyes
famous (eventually)
someone is probably killed
video/computer games
future
girlfriend (eventually)
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[has a cousin
live outside US
half-siblings
female
epic/high fantasy
captain
royalty
supernatural/paranormal
grow plants
blue eyes
blonde hair
green eyes
mythological
black hair
two mc's
violet eyes
feature an ex (I don't think so?)
curly hair
kidnapping (hide spoiler)]

No answer (so far) for:
multiple villains

[Alaina]

Okay with our known answers - I'm going to guess Wade.

My phone kept autocorrecting villains to victims so I was definitely confusing Felicia on that question. My bad!

[Alaina]

Looks like our guess for character 5 is correct! So we can start posting for character 6 now :)

[Felicia]

Character Six
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Female
in a relationship
in college
brown eyes (yes? Not answered on fandom page, going off fan art)
brown hair

(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
someone held hostage
MC a vampire
moon on the cover
blue eyes (see above)
live outside the US
live in the future (hide spoiler)]

[Isabel]

i'm immediately thinking of Tessa from After. could anyone guess for fanfiction or abusive boyfriend?

[Felicia]

Character Six
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Female
in a relationship
in college
brown eyes (yes? Not answered on fandom page, going off fan art)
brown hair

(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
someone held hostage
MC a vampire
moon on the cover
blue eyes (see above)
live outside the US
live in the future
anything to do with music
have magic
wearing a dress on the cover (hide spoiler)]

[Alaina]

Isabel wrote: "i'm immediately thinking of Tessa from After. could anyone guess for fanfiction or abusive boyfriend?"

I don't think that book is on the first two pages of the list.

[Alaina]

Hmm well I knocked out Mia from Where She Went since that book has so much music in it.

I was thinking it could be Abby from Beautiful Disaster but according to her wiki page she has brown hair and grey eyes. So that's a no go.

[Alaina]

I'm not sure what other book has the characters in college on this list but when I get some more free time - I'll look.

[Felicia]

Character Six
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Female
in a relationship
in college
brown eyes (yes? Not answered on fandom page, going off fan art)
brown hair
YA book
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
someone held hostage
MC a vampire
moon on the cover
blue eyes (see above)
live outside the US
live in the future
anything to do with music
have magic
wearing a dress on the cover
famous
orphan
live on the East Coast
have a tattoo (not entirely sure but probably not) (hide spoiler)]

[Celia]

Cath from Fangirl seems to fit. We could guess something to do with fandom, wearing yellow on cover, involves writing, computer on cover/uses a computer, or set in Nebraska to confirm.

[Celia]

Or one word title, two people on cover, male and female on cover, etc

[Celia]

Or wears glasses. These are just my thoughts.

[Ruthie]

Celia Buell wrote: "Cath from Fangirl seems to fit. We could guess something to do with fandom, wearing yellow on cover, involves writing, computer on cover/uses a computer, or set in Nebraska to confirm."


I'll post for yellow

[Alaina]

I went with are they a twin since it looks like she has a twin sister.

[Celia]

Oh yeah that's a major plot point I forgot to mention

[Isabel]

i just finished , what should i guess for?

[Alaina]

Isabel wrote: "i just finished , what should i guess for?"

Hmm.. since we just final guessed our 6th character. Maybe guess if our 7th is a female?

[Felicia]

Character Seven
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
involved in a crime
get sick (possibly but not sick like the post would assume?)
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Visits a best friend
mother dead/gone
live in a small town
have a job
go to school (hide spoiler)]

[Felicia]

Character Seven
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
involved in a crime
get sick (possibly but not sick like the post would assume?)
female

(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Visits a best friend
mother dead/gone
live in a small town
have a job
go to school
male (hide spoiler)]

[Felicia]

Character Seven
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
involved in a crime
get sick (possibly but not sick like the post would assume?)
Caucasian
brown hair
deadly
murders someone
have a sister
have a job (I had this under incorrect before, I was wrong my b lol)
mother dead/gone (this was also under incorrect, which is wrong. bahaha I suck)
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Visits a best friend
live in a small town
go to school
take place in the modern/contemporary world
POC
brown eyes
have a brother
dancer
live in the USA
red hair
participate in competitions (hide spoiler)]

[Felicia]

Character Seven
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
involved in a crime
get sick (possibly but not sick like the post would assume?)
Caucasian
brown hair
deadly
murders someone
have a sister
have a job (I had this under incorrect before, I was wrong my b lol)
mother dead/gone
teenager
blue eyes
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Visits a best friend
live in a small town
go to school
take place in the modern/contemporary world
POC
brown eyes
have a brother
dancer
live in the USA
red hair
participate in competitions (hide spoiler)]

[Alaina]

Hmm for some reason I'm getting Juliette vibes (from shatter me). I did ask if our character was a teenager and if they had blue eyes so maybe once those are answered - I can see if it is her or not.

[Alaina]

Hmm okay going with Juliette. Let's hope it's correct - if not, sorry!

[Alaina]

It looks like we got Juliette correct! So we can start guessing for Character 8 now :)

[Felicia]

Character Eight
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
female
brown hair
(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
multiple POV book
black hair
blonde
red hair
live outside the US (hide spoiler)]

[Alaina]

Oh goodie.. a female with brown hair.. THAT REALLY NARROWS IT DOWN TWIN

[Felicia]

Alaina wrote: "Oh goodie.. a female with brown hair.. THAT REALLY NARROWS IT DOWN TWIN"

You know she lives not outside of the US!

[Alaina]

Felicia wrote: "Alaina wrote: "Oh goodie.. a female with brown hair.. THAT REALLY NARROWS IT DOWN TWIN"

You know she lives not outside of the US!"

Still not helpful lol.

[Felicia]

Sorry, lmfao.

[Kim]

Just finished The Faerie Prince. I figured I could guess:

- is royalty (mc princess)
- magic (mc can do magic)
- evil step mom

Thoughts?

[Felicia]

Character Eight
Correct guesses:
(view spoiler)[
female
black hair

(hide spoiler)]

Incorrect guesses:
(view spoiler)[
Male
multiple POV book
brown hair
blonde
red hair
live outside the US
blue eyes
part of the LGBT community
desert setting
royalty
african american
contemporary romance book
half-human-half creature
an artist (hide spoiler)]

*****PLEASE LOOK AT THESE AGAIN, I REALIZED I HAD PUT SOME IN THE WRONG CATEGORY.

[Alaina]

Always giving us false positives/negatives twin. Tsk tsk.