Heir of Fire
discussion
Vote: Who do you think Celaena should end up with?
message 351:
by
Albishka
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Apr 06, 2016 06:18AM
First I was shipping Chaol, I admired his steady principals, but then the same principals made him hard to accept Celeana and Dorian's magic. And though I still love him for his devotion to Dorian, I don't think that he is a good match for Celeana. I don't like Rowan and Celeana either, their relationship has somewhat spontaneous and desperate tint for me, Aedion is just a relative. Now I am in Dorian's team, his character 's developing is amazing through out the story.
reply
|
flag
I always wanted Dorian and Celeana to be together but I can't choose because at some point she loved all Dorian, Chaol and Rowan but I still feel that Celeana and Dorian would make a nice match! I ship Celeana and Dorian :)
Lauren wrote: "I personally don't care for Dorian because I don't trust him. He seems to not accept Celaena while Chaol does and Rowen is amazing"How-what-why-!!!!!??? What! How could you say that! In crown of midnight, and throne of glass he loved her as a friend he has always been there for her has always been there for her to talk to, to be welcomed to be accepted and just because he's related to that (bad word) king, dons't mean that he's not in every way perfect. And did you even READ the books!? In Heir of Fire and in Queen of Shadows, sure Chaol had grown to accsept some of the parts of her, but he was just a A-hole to her, threatened her court and her friends! ... And I vote Rowan by the way.
Yeah I agree Chaol made it clear that he didn't support Aelin at all in QOS. He was awful.
New to this convo, but Aedion?
I have always shipped Dorian and Celeana and I will still go down with my ship!
I just can't understand why people don't ship Celaena with Dorian. I mean, Dorian was the only one who accepted her from the very beginning. He liked her even knowing she was an assassin. Besides, they complement each other. In powers and in personality. Celaena made him grow into a man. They're literally meant to be. I mean, fire and ice, queen and king. Both are powerful and didn't know that before. They're like Gavin and Elena. If they don't end up together, my heart will break in tiny little pieces.
Elentiya wrote: "I just can't understand why people don't ship Celaena with Dorian. I mean, Dorian was the only one who accepted her from the very beginning. He like her even if she was an assassin. Besides, they c..."I totally agree with you. They are the perfect match. And they would make a phenomenal king and queen.
Lauren wrote: "I personally don't care for Dorian because I don't trust him. He seems to not accept Celaena while Chaol does and Rowen is amazing"Well, actually, I feel like Dorian accepted Celaena a bit better because of the magic in his own blood. Chaol still had a little, as Dorian said,"fear and a hint of disgust" in his eyes. That may refer to him, but it still goes both ways. Rowan is more inclined to accept her because he's Fae himself, and Maeve is his aunt. But I don't really ship Celaena with anyone (or maybe I just ship her with everyone) because, to me, she's just so compatible with everyone. There's always a factor to match her with. I think I may ship her with Sam most though.
Rowan all the way. He is the ice to her fire, and she is the fire to his ice; proof that they balance each other out. I love Rowan with his "overprotective Fae bullshit"-he really cares about her and she cares about him. They would do ANYTHING for each other. I don't care that Rowan is 300+ years old or that he is her distant cousin; they are perfect for each other. (Let's just hope that Aelin can become immortal so they can be with each other forever. In all, ROWAN IS AMAZING SWEET KIND AND CARING AND IS THE PERFECT MATCH FOR AELIN; PERIOD!
Rowan, of course!!!! Rowaelin forever!!!
Rowan, i think their relationship was much deeper than any of her other ones. Chaol and Dorian were like pillows that she needed to fall on but with rowan he didn't pity her he understood her in ways the others can't and pushed her to fight. Maas is such an amazing writer.
Dorian!! And guys, is there a thread something like this but where you add number to one and take from another eveyrtime you post? To keep track of it. Like a point game.
Dorian all the way!! I don't like Chaol idk why..
chAOL OF COURSE! HE HAS CHESTNUT HAIR (ok sorry thats not a reason) he just lOVES AELIN SO FREAKING MUCH LIKE I NEARLY DROPPED THE BOOK WHEN SHE WAS LIKE 'IM SORRY' LIKE BITCH SUNXUYDBCUORWYBXOFUY definitely chaol yes chaol
or dorian
I vote for Dorian, but since we met Rowan, i have to vote for him too :) i can´t decide.
I vote for Dorian. He and Celeana fit together perfectly. Plus you can tell throughout that she has deep feelings of love for him. The author makes a point of how she feels deeply for him. Plus Dorian loves her sooooooooooo much they could grow and nurture one another by their companionship. They are made for each other. Chaol is not up there with Dorian or Celeana when it comes to feelings and relationship too. I feel perhaps the author perfers him because he feels safe to her and she doesn't want to give into the idea giving Dorian another thought because he's supposed to be a "spoiled prince"/ hence the wrong choice/ or "bad boy"? But he's not!
Rowan because he accepts all of her and everything that means. He knows and understands loss. He's damaged like she is but somehow he doesn't let that keep him from developing a relationship with Aelin. Where as Chaol only loved the idea of her. Somewhere along the way he forgets who the King is to her. He took everything she had from Aelin to the point she was called Celaena because of it yet he can't get over the magic and her feyness. Which saved her and others because of it. I understand the shock but to wholly disregard her as a person and it's all of a sudden the only thing she is. I can't accept him for that blinding loyalty he as for the King. Even Dorian hates his father but Chaol follows him even after he knows what happened to Celaena in the mines. The king is the reason why she had to become an Assassin. She never stopped being fey and had Celaena remembered that she was Aelin, those two wouldn't have had a relationship. Celaena was running from her responsibilities in the 2nd book. Chaol in a way helped her because of who he was (Captain of the Guard) to a man who destroyed her home. How could those two end up together if he could not see how evil the king was until he did what he did to Dorian and killed that girl not to mention everyone in the mine. Really, no one can be that blind and he supposedly loves her. -coughs- right - coughs-
Rowan because he and celeana balance everything out
Rowan all the way! He is so great, I love how his feelings for Celeana don't develop until he fully knows and understands her. That is how all relationships should start. I believe it is critical for people to be able to motivate each other. Rowan pushes her and tests her, making her a stronger person and that's exactly what a relationship should do. Not to mention how close they are and their amazing friendship that is building. Celeana deserves someone who can support her and understand her, Rowan is the one who can do that.
Rowan all the way. he is strong and caring and understands loss.
Alex wrote: "Team Chaol 4Ever! After reading the first 4 books, everybody was on "Team Rowan" I don't see him as anymore that a best friend for Celaena/Aelin. I will go down with my ship!!!! CHAOLAENA/AELIN"I totally agree with you I would have been Chaol for life if it kept going in the book. The character that SJM developed really ended up being a changed Chaol. Before I read the third book I couldn't stop talking about Chaol then Rowan came and it became such a hard choice I would have ended up being happy with anyone of them!
I used to be for Chaol, but Rowan has totally won me over!Sarah J. Maas really acknowledges that it doesn't have to be one prince charming and then they live happily ever after, but you can go through a couple of relationships that just don't work out in the end. And also still be friends! I love the fact that yes people can love each other a lot but also not work as a couple, and sometimes its better to move on when you have grown apart. Chaol just couldn't accept Aelin the Queen and Fae, and his fear of her heritage and magic only strengthened her own fears. Rowan taught her to fully be herself and not be afraid of her power, and he accepted her unconditionally. Chaol loves her, but only when she fits his image of who she is.
My point is; I vote for Rowan!
Definitely NOT Chaol... i don't know why but I don't feel like his character was ever... important to the book.(SRRY)I'm team Rowan all the way! :)
ROWAN!!! ROWAN!!! ROWAN!!! ROWAN!!! 😁😁😁😁😁😁
CHAOLLLL... I ship them so hard. no matter what happens
The Book Addict wrote: "Randomfreckles wrote: "Either Rowan or Chaol for me. I love Rowen because he is strong..."I agree that Chaol loves Celaena, but do you feel there are parts of her he cannot accept?"
I agree. I hate Chaol because he seems like he is limiting Celaena from being the savior she needs to be.
DORIAN OR ALONE. Dorian helps her be more positive, playful, and loving towards the world. He doesn't try to complete her, and rarely gets in the way of her strife. My other vote is alone, because she knows what she has to do, and does it. I have the same feelings towards Katniss in The Hunger Games. Even if she might be happier, she has devoted herself to her people, and for their case it is better if she ends up alone.
Chaol ALL the day, every day.
ROWAN!!!!! CAUSE WHO WOULDN'T. All right, but seriously.
Rowan.
Hey fellow bookworms!I know this is really off topic, but I was wondering if you guys could take the time to fill out a survey. My society and culture teacher recently issued a personal interest assignment.
I have chosen to study the impact that female protagonists in fantasy fiction (such as Celaena) have had on women and how they empower individuals and deconstruct social stereotypes and gender norms. I believe that this is a really important and relevant social concept and would really appreciate your input. :)
Here is the link to the survey:
https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/RN5MRJV
rowan because they are alike in many ways .i just finished the fourth book and am about to read the fifth
Sabrine wrote that she will think horror if Aelin doesn't end up with anyone i think that too
God I HATE Chaol. So much. He may love her but Dorian is right when he gives him a verbal lashing about only loving parts of her. His entire attitude towards magic pisses me off. The way he behaved when he saw her Fae form at first just made me want to kill him on the spot. Lol. I loved Dorian and Celaena but I understand why that wouldn't work given the political angle here. Still ship them so hard though. Even though she treated him quite horridly in the second book. Made me want to smack her. Aaaarrrggghh.
Rowan would be amazing with her, but I get the sense she doesn't yet feel that way about him in Heir of Fire at least. She still loves Chaol (stupid SOB). Hope she and Rowan can figure it out.
My vote is either Rowan or Dorian. Chaol can burn in hell. Lol.
I haven't finished this book yet. I am too scared to. I can't bear the thought of Dorian losing Sorscha. It is something I am too afraid to read about because I just KNOW I'm going to cry all night for this poor, sweet Prince. Damnit. Must soldier on.
Cassandra (The book & movie dimension blogger) wrote: "Dorian is my first pick. And then would be Rowan. Anyone but Chaol. I am so shocked Sarah J. Maas would even make him a love interest. It made no sense. The Chaol and Celaena romance also might h..."
EXACTLY.
Its been awhile since I read this book( ive been reading Sarah J Maas' other series Court of Thorns and Roses) But I would definitely have to say Rowan He is perfect for Celeana. He is a protector without being too much. He is there for her in every way.
She should end up with Rowan, because he’s the best thing in this book. Not Chaol because he’s a stupid piece of shit. I see her and Dorian as friends, and her and Adeion are cousins...
Aedion is her cousin can people not
Hey everyone,Just wondering if you can help me out by completing a survey for my major work about dystopian literature. Here is the link: https://www.surveymonkey.com/r/H8LMR8R
Thanks in advance :)
Choal, he's flawed but he has a good heart and tries to be a better man, like many of us flawed mortals he both stumbles and strides in his quest to be a better person and I feel like he grew up with Celaena in a way. This Rowan guy isn't interesting to me, he does not have the same flaws and struggles that Choal does, hes too perfect, I don't like it! haha.... Just being honest.
Also, I feel Maas concentrated more on the romance with Choal than Roawn as the series has developed... But that could just be me
Dorian because he accepted her right off the bat, and was kind to her from the start plus it's adorable how they share a love of books. I absolutely hate The rowan ship (no offense to anyone who ships it) I just can't stand him and what happens in the next two books makes me kinda upset. ( I won't say due to spoilers for Empire of Storms) .
Rowan..... plsssssss
I don't want to justify my reason. I just want them together plzplzplz
I don't want to justify my reason. I just want them together plzplzplz
is this even a question? rowan ofc
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
