Around the Year in 52 Books discussion
Weekly Topics 2018
>
46. 4 books linked by the 4 elements: Book #4 Air

Breath, Eyes, Memory
When Breath Becomes Air
I'm also considering The Silent Sky: The Incredible Extinction of the Passenger Pigeon. Since birds fly in the air, I'm guessing this is a reasonable choice???





This isn't a series I would normally pick up, and I'm happy that it'll take me out of my comfort zone. I'm hoping it's good enough to bear four books.
Book 1: Water - Week 28
Book 2: Air - Week 46
Book 3: Fire - Week 14
Book 4: Earth - Week 4





Great! Love to have someone else reading the same thing. Sounds so good!



Michele, it all depends on how much you want to stretch the connection. I would say it's a bit more tenuous but I'm sure you could argue it :)

LOL I like that! I've been thinking about re-reading Jane Eyre, too!
I'm a little surprised that I'm struggling to find something for this element. Right now, I've tentatively penciled in Castle in the Air.

A: Storm Born
Q: How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
A: The main character is the daughter of a god (?) that was the God of Stoms, or something like that, and she got his powers.
Q: Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
A: Squirtle is my option, so, yes, Water is my type.

As for what elements I prefer... I don't know? Air is a good one, I guess.

I would say so. I picked Beneath a Scarlet Sky by Mark T. Sullivan, thinking the same thing. I'm trying to read in order, so I'm not anywhere close to reading it yet & things could always change, but that's what I'm planning to read for this prompt right now.

I would say so.."
Well, alrighty then. Thanks! :)
- What are you reading for this category?
Prized by Caragh M. O'Brien
- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
(view spoiler)
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
Water -- It's so peaceful to look at and listen to water.["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>

- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
(view spoiler)
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
Water -- It's so peaceful to look at and listen to water.["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>["br"]>


How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
Well, mostly the cover/title? I tend to associate birds with air. (It turned out that the content had a little bit to do with air too, at one point.)
Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
I have honestly no idea.


This book is related to element through the title. I prefer the element of water. We have way too much wind and too little water where I live.

Coming Up for Air
How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
Title
Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
I'm a Taurus, so I prefer Earth.


The dog stars by Peter Heller
How is it related to Air?
Hig is a pilot who spends a lot of his time watching the stars.
Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
If I had to pick one, it'd be earth.

Isaac's Storm: A Man, a Time, and the Deadliest Hurricane in History
- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
Content - Hurricane
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
Water

I read The Air We Breathe by Andrea Barrett
- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
Title, obviously. Also, it is related by content in that the story is about TB patients in a sanatorium. Fresh air is important for their recovery.
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
Water

- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
I've been using books that have the element word in their title (so I'm choosing my four books based on that same criterion, but they aren't really linked). The sky is full of air so I think I will count it for this category.
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer? I have no idea! They're all good! Air is the most necessary, water is intriguing, earth is both soothing and mysterious, fire is both warm and dangerous ...


Shock Wave
By :Clive Cussler
How is it related to the element ( cover,title, content,item, etc)
In the cover is a helicopter so I went with that plus all for books I'm using for the for element challenges are wrote by Clive Cussler.
Which of the 4 elements do you prefer? I would have to say all of them.

- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)? title
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer? air or water never really thought about it

The Stone Sky by N.K. Jemisin
- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
The title has the word "sky" in it, and one of the major plot points in the book involves the moon and a set of flying obelisks
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
It depends on how I am interacting with them - I like to breath, so air seems pretty important.

Beneath a Scarlet Sky by Mark T. Sullivan
- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)? the passion with which the author writes about the air in the Alps while skiing (to save lives), you can't help but feel it.
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
Earth and Air combined. Mountains, clean fresh air, beautiful green trees; I'll take that over a beach any time.

(finished)
How I'd it related to the element? Title - though this one was more tenuous - I wanted the actual word (Air) mentioned in the title but couldn't find something I wanted to read.
Which element do you prefer - Water if I have to choose.

The Stone Sky by N.K. Jemisin
- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
The title has the ..."
I have read the same book for the category (and I didn't even check). I guess it fits then :)

I read Thin Air by Michelle Paver
How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
The word air is in the title
Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
All the same to me. We need them all.


The Feather Thief: Beauty, Obsession, and the Natural History Heist of the Century by Kirk W. Johnson


How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)? Air (or sky) appears on the cover.
Which of the 4 elements do you prefer? I think I like water best, although all are important.

All the Birds in the Sky , it was really quite lovely.
- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
The cover has lots of birds, titles reference birds and sky. One of the main characters learns she's a witch by talking to a bird, her first spell is how to fly. Another character's life work is trying to figure out anti-gravity so people can fly.
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
They're all pretty important. I think i'm pretty balanced between them all since I like hiking, swimming, a good breeze and a warm fire.

Coming Up for Air by George Orwell
When Breath Becomes Air by Paul Kalanithi
My 3rd book for my triple challenge will be:
The Eyre Affair by Jasper Fforde (because Eyre and Air sound the same...and for a 3rd go around that is close enough)!
From a reading perspective, I've enjoyed the Water prompt the best...by far! Earth was 2nd.

- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)? Birds in the sky
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer? I prefer water probably the most out of them. I enjoy the ocean, lakes, waterfalls, streams, etc.

- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
Has air in the title.
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?
depends on what I'm doing :P
Books mentioned in this topic
Castle in the Air (other topics)Airman (other topics)
Fly Girls: How Five Daring Women Defied All Odds and Made Aviation History (other topics)
Breath, Eyes, Memory (other topics)
Silver Clouds (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kenneth Grahame (other topics)Mary Stewart (other topics)
Claire Vaye Watkins (other topics)
Kirk Wallace Johnson (other topics)
Michelle Paver (other topics)
More...
-----------------------------------
Suggestions:
GR Hurricane shelf
GR Wind shelf
Air travel books (listopia)
Balloons on the cover (listopia)
Romance novels with Air in the title (listopia)
Fantasy books with the 4 elements
Librarything Air Tag
-----------------------------------
Optional questions:
- What are you reading for this category?
- How is it related to the element (cover, title, content, item, etc)?
- Which of the 4 elements do you prefer?