twilight lovers! discussion
Books in the Twilight Series
>
How old should you be to read Breaking Dawn?
message 101:
by
Marissa
(new)
Jan 25, 2009 09:36AM
exactly
reply
|
flag
oh are u in the age group of to young or not there yet?
i just didnt like twilight enough to go on... and i am 12... but i knew that stuff when i was 10 in FLASH/
Umm, not sure when I figured that stuff out. I think I took one of Those Classes in, like, fifth grade. The summer after it, I mean. And yah, my mom doesn't know about the... er... questionable content of Breaking Dawn. I didn't tell her because then she probably wouldn't let me read it, and that would be VERY bad! I mean, I try to avoid Those Parts, I just read the rest of the book. :P
i was 12 when i read it in the summer so before 7th grade, and i am very mature about it. My mom hasnt read them and she had no clue what they were about. I think it 12+ should read it. i thought it was interesting that guys would read it. did u think that would be weird? like guys 12 and older?
ya that is interesting for the guys especially under age 12 that read it. although i know one guy and he said that it was the worst book in the series, and i thought it was the best!
Miranda {kewL} wrote: "LOL, but they don't get specific about it. Some "young adult" books get really into what they are doing... btu all BD does is say i went to the water, and they wake up. I mean they do say that it w..."
Yea but then Bella begs Edward to have sex with her again and that's a really bad example for kids out there reading this series.....
Yea but then Bella begs Edward to have sex with her again and that's a really bad example for kids out there reading this series.....
yes but then again, when you think about it, you should probably NOT have sex with a vampire because of what happened to the one half person half vampire(i forgot his name, the one who showed up in the clearing) his mom died and hated his dad and although rennesmee was nice but when bella was still carrying her, she was hurting her and breaking ribs
Umm, yeah. Pretty much >_<For the guys who read it... I wonder how they reacted? On second thought, maybe I don't want to know :P
message 116:
by
Stephanie, Loves Vamps and Werewolves but Zombies scare me!!
(new)
Mod
message 119:
by
Stephanie, Loves Vamps and Werewolves but Zombies scare me!!
(new)
Mod
but remember in eclipse when bella was at least trying before they were married!
Stephanie wrote: "BUT AT LEAST THEY WERE MARRIED!!!!"yeah, but it was like what 2 weeks before they were suposidly in love. its the first bf/gf relationship for them both it doesnt seem like its realy love to me,
i luv all you guys :)I totally LOVE the twilight series
and i also think people 12 and up can read breaking dawn( depending on their maturity level)
my teacher actually told me i should wait until i was a little older
but i didnt. i figured i could handle it. :)
im just going along with everything.....hehe
just 3 days to finish up reading this book but recover back from vampire fever almost taking 3 weeks..
yeah. it took me 2 days the first time, 3 days the second time
I'm 11 and I read it, It wasn't that bad!
I haven't read itbut my gf said they skipped all of the bad stuff
\I think I agree with Massie because unless you're going to immature about it, don't read it...wait did that even make sense? Anyways...that's what I think.
noshe didn't skip
she said the book skipped most of it
oh yeah!!!! i get it now....im soooo smart! lol jk
i don't think it's too bad. and i'm not twelve yet! (almost!)
i agree that most 6th graders just can't handle that!
i mean my freind doesn't know wut 'rape' means!
i guess i'm more mature than most 6th graders, and that's y it didn't bug me too much.
i'm sorry!
that sounds like i'm concieted right?
i don't mean it like that, but it is true!
Madi xD
i agree that most 6th graders just can't handle that!
i mean my freind doesn't know wut 'rape' means!
i guess i'm more mature than most 6th graders, and that's y it didn't bug me too much.
i'm sorry!
that sounds like i'm concieted right?
i don't mean it like that, but it is true!
Madi xD
i agree w/Madi. i read it the day it came out (almost one mi 7th grade year), so yeah its all on maturity level!
No, it doesn't sound conceited! Just... yeah, I think it depends on how, like, mature you are or whatever. Because it's all subjective... some, say... 12 year olds can totally handle it, while others are like "Wait, huh?" So... yeah.
Emily wrote: "I agree. What goes on in Breaking Dawn is nothing compared to what is being talked about in school today...even middle school! If the world were as it should be, I don't think anyone under the age ..."i agree with u completely.
MASSIE (aka Lizzy) wrote: "i want to read it, but im 11 and im waiting till im 13 or 14. plus my mom wont let me read it."your mom won't let you read it? i just turned 15 last week, but my parents did not want me to read it at first. i thought that was just over the top. its not even explicit and im beyond the questionable maturity. in the end they let me read it.
That just sucks! I've been done with it for months!
I disagree! Sixth graders can handle it just fine! EVERy sixth grader in my school can handle BD. Unless they skipped a grade!
I was saying sucks for jessica. She's 15 and not allowed to read it
twilight lovers!
Books mentioned in this topic
The Kite Runner (other topics)Puerto Rico 1898: The War After the War (other topics)
New Moon (other topics)
Breaking Dawn (other topics)
