Dresden Files discussion

5438 views
Novel series like the Dresden Files?

Comments Showing 551-600 of 1,083 (1083 new)    post a comment »

message 551: by Ben Fiore (new)

Ben Fiore | 48 comments After having just read Butcher's Molly short in Dangerous Women, what I'd really like to read is something genre-similar that features a female protagonist that isn't a PNR - something with a compelling female lead that is confident and relatable. I tried out the Weather Warden series and while I really enjoyed the mythos built in the series, the romantic elements soured me to branching into any of the other series' by that author.


message 552: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
I'd like that to. Many that "most" of our members don't think of as PNR still strike me as said PNR. I keep looking.


message 553: by Kat (new)

Kat | 14 comments PNR books are basically based around the relationship plus it has more sex scenes with other story lines thrown in. I haven't found anything out there that doesn't have some romantic under tones in it, even the Dresden Files. A book with a female lead who has relationships and/or sex in a book or series does not always equate to PNR, as some people like to think.


message 554: by Alison (last edited May 21, 2014 10:38AM) (new)

Alison @ Ben I felt like that about Fated too, but I found it was definitely worthwhile to read the rest - I was partially swayed by the opinions on here. On the other hand, I knew very quickly that MHI was not for me, but The Iron Druid Chronicles was right up my street. In fact, the dog in The Iron Druid Chronicles is one of my favourite UF characters and makes me laugh! BUT occasionally the stuff about mythical lore and the various Gods, does make me glaze over!

Some series I have read quite a few books before I realised I didn't care about the characters to bother reading any more (Sandman Slim). It depends on what else I can find to read!

I can't remember whether I read a book found through this site, so thanks guys - I don't mind reading duplicate recommendations!

PS @ Forney_bill Kim Harrison's latest book in The Hollows series has a high level of PNR, so maybe it has been increasing book by book and I never noticed. LOL!


message 555: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
I wasn't trying to argue the definition Kat. It's just that some of us are looking for books that are not quite as dominated by the relationship than others whether they actually fall under the genre title PNR or not.

I've tried Patricia Briggs, Jeaniene Frost, Ilona Andrews, Kim Harrison, Rachel Caine and others. These all to one extent or another I found too "close to" PNR, even though they may not fall under that genre to others. My point is I agree with Ben's comment or action that I keep looking for a female protagonist book more oriented on the plot and characters themselves than the romantic relationships. As you mentioned the romance is in the Dresden books but it doesn't dominate the books nearly so much.

I've noted before it's a matter of taste. I'm not criticizing the books you like just looking for something a little different.


message 556: by Alison (new)

Alison @ Mike I definitely agree that The PNR element is higher in the books by the authors you listed and the common denominator is the male or female POV. That's why I look at the PNR votes on the right hand side when choosing books to read.

Interestingly, I would like a PRN element in the Alex Verus series because I keep waiting for something to happen!


message 557: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
(view spoiler)


message 558: by Kat (new)

Kat | 14 comments Oh no, it's cool! Many people feel that way, its hard for most to see past the romance part when the lead character is female. There's always sexual tension/frustration built into a storyline, question is whether it's the main arc or just another part of events that happen along the way.

Some of the authors you mentioned are definitely PNR while the others fall into UF category. People have asked what makes them different from each other and my usual response is the amount of sex written into the book or series.

As for The Hollows, Rachel's HEA has become an integral part of the series but I think its because we are so invested in her character and how the series will end. I believe many people want to see the same for Harry (or any beloved character they follow) if and when the series ends.


message 559: by Alison (new)

Alison @ Mike Yep. (view spoiler)

@ Kat I agree it's all about the amount of sex LOL! Well, maybe with a bit of lusting too! ;-) I hope Rachel does have her HEA, but then I do love a happy ending. (view spoiler)


message 560: by Sharon (new)

Sharon | 27 comments Have you ever checked out Lilith Saintcrow's Dante Valentine series? Dark UF, but I don't recall romance being much of a factor in it. It reminded me a lot of the Dresden Files. It's been a few years since I read them, though, so maybe my memory is faulty.

Vicki Pettersen's Zodiac series is another one that comes to mind. I stopped reading them when they started getting really really dark and I don't remember a romance line in them at all.


message 561: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
I tried Petterson's Zodiac books. Not as romancy as a lot but it still didn't really draw me in. I've looked at Dante Valentine but haven't tried them yet.

Alison (view spoiler)


message 562: by Bob (new)

Bob | 68 comments Mike (the Paladin) wrote: "We tend to forget to. Also we're always getting new people who don't read through the entire thread so they don't realize they're bringing up books that have been recommended several times..or they..."
Mike,

I brought up the Steve McHugh series last year. Amazon had sent an email saying Crimes Against Magic was similar to other books I had purchased on my kindle. The beauty of the kindle is that you can try the novel for free before you buy it. Crimes Against Magic started off with a big bang opening ( like Dresden) and I was hooked.

So far the series has been good, I like how the author mixes the past with the present. Not on pare with Jacka or Butcher but still a good read.


message 563: by Bob (new)

Bob | 68 comments Alison wrote: "@ Mike I definitely agree that The PNR element is higher in the books by the authors you listed and the common denominator is the male or female POV. That's why I look at the PNR votes on the righ..."

Alison stay tuned for Novel 5 in the Alex Verus series, I believe you will get your PNR between Alex and Ann. Mike is right Luna and Alex straightened out their relationship in Cursed.... Master and Apprentice only friends as you will see in Chosen.


message 564: by Bob (new)

Bob | 68 comments Alison wrote: "Just finished Chosen, the 4th (latest) Alex Verus book - and what a stonking read (well 'listen', because I do audiobooks)! Best thing I've read in a while and can't wait for book 5 in September. ..."

Ben,

Do not give up on the Alex Verus series. The series improves with every novel. You will not be disappointed!


message 565: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments Kat wrote: "Hi all! I'm fairly new to the group and to UF in general. I'm an old school scifi/fantasy girl, growing up on series like Dragonlance, The Rift War Saga, Elfquest etc. I just recently started the D..."

welcome to the group of nerds, I hope you enjoy our stay. We had cookies, but I got hungry. I reccommend reading The Secret Histories series, along with the Cal Leandros series, to get your start on UF.


message 566: by Gianluca (new)

Gianluca (gianlucag) The Nightside series (Something from the Nightside, first book) uses a similar formula (first person view, paranormal investigations, etc..), though it's not nearly as good. I made it up to the 5th novel before I gave in to my urges and started re-reading The Dresden Files.
I'll probably pick the series up again later, since there are 12 books in total, but I'm not particularly excited about it. It's very over the top, especially after the first novel, and the writing style is quite repetitive. The main storyline also lacks a certain dept. But the author offers some really interesting ideas and character designs, and the books are a quick read, so I recommend it.


message 567: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments Gianluca wrote: "The Nightside series (Something from the Nightside, first book) uses a similar formula (first person view, paranormal investigations, etc..), though it's not nearly as good. I made it..."

I would half recommend the Nightside series. For those who do not have as much money to spend on books, I'd say to read the Secret Histories, as the books are just too small to recommend to those of us without enough money to buy a lot of books. For those of us who like third person books better, I'd recommend the Ghost Finders series.


message 568: by Gianluca (new)

Gianluca (gianlucag) Damian wrote: "I would half recommend the Nightside series. For those who do not have as much money to spend on books, I'd say to read the Secret Histories, as the books are just too small to recommend..."

I didn't take the money factor into consideration. I guess half recommend would be a fair enough assessment, all things considered.
I have yet to try the Secret Histories, but it's high on my to-read list.


message 569: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
There are a couple of series called "The Secret Histories". I believe Damian is talking about the series by Simon R. Green. The first one is The Man With the Golden Torc.


message 570: by Alison (new)

Alison @ Mike re Alex, Luna and Anne. (view spoiler).

After finishing Kim Harrison's latest book in The Hollows series (5 stars from me), I've started Lilith Saintcrowe's Dante Valentine series and I'm about half way through the first book. Not too keen at the moment because I'm not liking the main character much tbh. Apart from one character (view spoiler), the characters are not that well written. I get what the author is trying to do though, which is why I will probably finish the book before deciding whether to read any more. There are too many other series I want to try to waste time!


message 571: by Kat (new)

Kat | 14 comments Dante Valentine series was kind of a hard read for me, mainly I think because there wasn't references or descriptions concerning some of the futuristic aspects (at least not that I'm aware of anyway). And yeah the main character was pretty annoying lol I'm the type of person who will finish out the entire series even if I'm not too fond of it, it just takes me a lot longer and some motivation to do it. I did like her YA series Strange Angels though, it was pretty good. Haven't read the Jill Kizmet series yet, maybe sometime in the future after some of the other series I'm working through right now.

Love TUP and The Hollows! :)


message 572: by Bob (new)

Bob | 68 comments Alison wrote: "@ Mike re Alex, Luna and Anne. My problem with Alex and Luna is that in one book Alex tells Luna there are rules about the relationship between a master and apprentice, suggesting that it was a di..."

Alison: At the end of Cursed, I thought Luna and Alex had reached an understanding as to their relationship as Master and Apprentice.


message 573: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments Mike (the Paladin) wrote: "There are a couple of series called "The Secret Histories". I believe Damian is talking about the series by Simon R. Green. The first one is The Man With the Golden Torc."

Yes I was. I was not aware of that there were multiple series with that name. Thank you.


message 574: by Jason (new)

Jason | 1 comments Benedict Jacka is a good read


message 575: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
Cool. There's A Secret History series, The Secret Historyand and some others. If you just put in Secret History you get several books pop up. LOL


message 576: by wayword_witch (new)

wayword_witch | 162 comments Jason wrote: "Benedict Jacka is a good read"

I liked him too!


message 577: by Brad (new)

Brad Skupnik | 10 comments The Droods..excellent series. Sorry, for those that have not read them. That is the family name with the main character being Harry Drood. The Secret History series.


message 578: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments Brad wrote: "The Droods..excellent series. Sorry, for those that have not read them. That is the family name with the main character being Harry Drood. The Secret History series."

EDWIN DROOD, philistine!


message 579: by Brad (new)

Brad Skupnik | 10 comments Dammit. Sorry. Been awhile since I read it. Thanks for catching that one. Yikes! Do I have to turn in my literacy card now?


message 580: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments Brad wrote: "Dammit. Sorry. Been awhile since I read it. Thanks for catching that one. Yikes! Do I have to turn in my literacy card now?"

yes


message 581: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
Wait, wait...if it's his first time he gets a "do-over".


message 582: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments Mike (the Paladin) wrote: "Wait, wait...if it's his first time he gets a "do-over"."

No, he must now join the ranks of illiterate people. He's got a passport and is now moving to the deep south in America.


message 583: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
Them's fighten words pilgrim... I'll have you know I'm a southerner and I can read writen as good as anybody and can count way beyond 20!


message 584: by Brad (new)

Brad Skupnik | 10 comments Harsh Damien. I think I'll hold onto my card for a bit and see if the literacy police come and take it. Heh.


message 585: by Meredith (new)

Meredith VanOordt (ladybookwormcharterminet) | 7 comments Brad wrote: "Harsh Damien. I think I'll hold onto my card for a bit and see if the literacy police come and take it. Heh."

Shoot fire, I'm a southerner too, and I say give him another chance not - everybody can get past the sixth grade and read books that big.


message 586: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments I'll consult the council. Maybe we can make an exception. And Mike, if them's were fitin words, I'll hook ya one before you even know it.


message 587: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
....you know boy, there's only one thing you really know about a fat old man.

And that's that he survived to get to be a fat old man.


message 588: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments And there's something you know about a fat young man. The fat old man feeds the fat young man for days.


message 589: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
"be careful when starting a fight with an old man. If he's too old to fight he may just shoot you."

I have a patch that says that...


message 590: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments hopefully the old man's eyes are still sharp, or else the one shot he'll get will miss.


message 591: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
I never miss. My wife and son both had poker chips I shot the center out of.

https://www.facebook.com/mike.thepala...


message 592: by Ben Fiore (new)

Ben Fiore | 48 comments Who could have predicted a semi-anonymous Internet forum could become so contentious and inflammatory. ;)

As a neutral third (fourth actually) with absolutely no authority, I deem that Brad gets off with a warning on this one (given the specific forum, dropping the name Harry inappropriately in such a manner is hardly unexpected). And the rest of you ask yourself What Would Harry Do?


message 593: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (last edited Mar 09, 2014 07:27PM) (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
Harry Dresden or Harry Potter? Our Dresden would go scorched Earth...


message 594: by Ben Fiore (new)

Ben Fiore | 48 comments Fair point. Potter isn't exactly a poster-child for good judgment either. For the chosen one he kind of Forrest Gumped his way through things.


message 595: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
Sometimes... I always did think that he showed some real problems with his emotions in some of those situations.


message 596: by wayword_witch (new)

wayword_witch | 162 comments *sighs* Ahh, men. That was awesome. :)


message 597: by Jeremy (new)

Jeremy (lazerwraith) | 48 comments In my humble opinion Harry Potter was an idiot, but then I usually think all kids in most novels are.

That's why I love the House of Cards TV series...Frank is the opposite of clueless idiot.


message 598: by Mike (the Paladin), White Council (last edited Mar 10, 2014 11:06AM) (new)

Mike (the Paladin) (thepaladin) | 358 comments Mod
Well...(view spoiler)

Oops I almost left a major spoiler.


message 599: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments Natasha wrote: "*sighs* Ahh, men. That was awesome. :)"

hue


message 600: by Damian (new)

Damian (denis517) | 109 comments I recommend The Lost Gate by Orson Scott Card. I picked it up because I am a fan of the Ender's game series and the style of magic is very cool. The story is great as well.


back to top