The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
260 views
WINTER CHALLENGE 2024 > Completed Tasks: PLEASE DO NOT DELETE ANY POST IN THIS THREAD!

Comments Showing 1,151-1,200 of 2,679 (2679 new)    post a comment »

message 1151: by JenJ (new)

JenJ IA | 346 comments JenJ IA

30.8 - Delicious Dee's Task: Codex Alera
For this task, you will pick one option (A, B or C) and read book A and book B from that option. Your page count needs to be more than 500 pages (so 501+) and at least one of the authors must be NEW TO YOU.
Required: specify which option you chose and state the new to you author(s) in your post.

Option C – The Furies
The six furies are air/aeris, water/aqua, fire/ignus, earth/terra, metal/ferrous and wood/flora.
Required: State which fury you picked. - Air (book B) - Aeris (book A)
Book A - Pick one of the furies listed above – read a book where all the letters of the fury can be found in the title. (AERIS)
The Sticky Note Manifesto of Aisha Agarwal by Ambika Vohra - 368 pages
Ambika Vohra is a NEW TO ME author

Book B - Use the same fury as the book you used for Book A and read a book where all the letters of the alternate name can be found in the authors name. (AIR)
Class Mom by Laurie Gelman - 290 pages

368 + 290 = 658 total pages

~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 30
Total Points: 380/995
Tasks Completed: 24/59
BB: 1
GO: 0
NF: 3


message 1152: by Brooke (new)

Brooke ♥booklife4life♥ (booklife4life) | 40 comments brooke4.0

10.2 Read a book which is set in at least two countries.

Le Tour du monde en 80 jours by Jules Verne (audio read, this is the top MMP)

Setting on GR page:
London, England (, 1911), Suez Canal (Egypt), Bombay (India), Calcutta (India), Hong Kong, Yokohama (Japan), New York (State) (United States), Liverpool, England (United Kingdom), London, England (, 1872), Singapore, Atlantic Ocean, South Asia, India, England

Claiming one Golden Oldie as this is published in 1872

Pts this post: 10pts
Golden Oldie: 1
Total pts: 65pts


message 1153: by Brooke (new)

Brooke ♥booklife4life♥ (booklife4life) | 40 comments brooke4.0

10.6 Read a biography, autobiography or memoir about an artist, musician, poet or writer.

La mujer que soy by Britney Spears (audio read, no MMP, this is the highest paperback)

Claiming one It's a Fact as this is nonfiction

Pts this post: 10pts
Golden Oldie: 1
It's a Fact: 1
Total Pts: 75


message 1154: by Mrsgeo (new)

Mrsgeo | 301 comments SHEMAC

10.4 - Wonderful Wetlands

Read a book with a word of four or more letters in its title that can be made from WORLD WETLANDS DAY. Letters may be used only as often as they appear.

Required: State the word: STAND

Stand in Place
(PB Stand In Place)

This task points: 10
Total season points: 295


message 1155: by Mrsgeo (new)

Mrsgeo | 301 comments SHEMAC

10.10 - Cold As Ice

Read a book from one of the following lists:
Nordic Noir
52 Book Club 2023: #24 Nordic Noir
Nordic/Scandinavian Mysteries: Female Voices

Required: State which list your book is found on - Nordic/Scandinavian Mysteries: Female Voices page 1, #6

My First Murder
(PB Ensimmäinen murhani)

This task points: 10
Total season points: 305


message 1156: by C (new)

C | 350 comments Lora
Task: 20.9 Moderator's Pet -Jen B's Task: 90s Nostalgia, using Option 2A
Book/Author: Toto / A.J. Hackwith
How it fits: MPG Retellings

Points for this task: 20
Total points: 240
Big Book tickets for this task: 0
Big Book tickets total: 0
Golden Oldies tickets for this task: 0
Golden Oldies tickets total: 0
It's a Fact tickets for this task: 0
It's a Fact tickets total: 1


message 1157: by Karen D (last edited Jan 14, 2025 04:07PM) (new)

Karen D | 673 comments Task 20.5 Bigger is Better- Elizabeth P's Task: Celebrating the SRC

Option 3: Read a book with a word of 4 or more letters in the title (subtitles do not count) that can be made from the letters in READING CHALLENGES BRING ME JOY

Book: All in Her Head: The Truth and Lies Early Medicine Taught Us About Women's Bodies and Why It Matters Today
Word: Head

Points this task: 20
Total points: 455


message 1158: by Karen D (new)

Karen D | 673 comments Task 25.1 - KmarieD's Task: It's My Birthday

Option 3: Read a book with both individual MPG Mystery and MPG Romance or the combined MPG Romantic Suspense.

BOok: The Lost Story

Option 4: Read a book with a single author whose initials can be found in GALAPAGOS ISLANDS.

Book: House of Glass by Sarah Pekkanen

Points this task: 25
Total points: 480


message 1159: by Theresa (new)

Theresa | 300 comments Theresa

15.3 - Mysterious and Wise
Option 2 - 1 book meets both criteria
2 numbers of 2, 8 and 9 in page count
75% red, yellow, black

Conclave by Robert Harris by Robert Harris

Tineye
45% - #b01d15 - red
23.7% - #7a1513 - red
12.4% #d71a10 - red
7.6% - #efe0d6 - pink
3.9# - #300b0f - brown
2.5% - #eaa988 - orange
2.1% - #c2661a - brown
1.6% - #b77e7b - brown
0.7% - #dfa318 - orange
0.3% - #f7cd91 - yellow

Points this post - 15
Total points - 45


message 1160: by Theresa (new)

Theresa | 300 comments Theresa

15.4 - It's Starting to Look A Lot Like Christmas
Option 2 - 1 book
Wreath on the cover
Author initials in Merry anD bright

The Christmas Party (Bailey Family #1) by Mikayla Davids by Mikayla Davids

Pints this post - 15
Total points - 60


message 1161: by Meg (new)

Meg (megscl) | 2466 comments MEGSCL
30.7 - Amy FL’s Task: The Headaches of Home Ownership
Option 2: Read a book with a title word (ignore subtitles) of four or more letters that can be made from MOLD REMEDIATION.
(Name) - My Name Is Lucy Barton
Option 3: Read a book by an author whose first and last initials can be found in MARISSA.
Cursed Bread by Sophie Mackintosh

Total
165 points - 1 big book - 2 It’s a Fact


message 1162: by Meg (new)

Meg (megscl) | 2466 comments MEGSCL
30.6 - XBM’s Task – A Partridge in a Pear Tree
Option B:
Read two books, each with a related homophone in the title from this list of homophones: http://www.singularis.ltd.uk/bifroest...
For/Four
For Today I Am a Boy
Four Aunties and a Wedding

Total
195 points - 1 big book - 2 It’s a Fact


message 1163: by Truitt_T (last edited Jan 14, 2025 06:19PM) (new)

Truitt_T | 440 comments 5.8 New Year, New Beginnings

Task: Title word from NEW YEAR BRINGS FRESH BEGINNINGS
The Nanny Contract by Jason Collins
Only digital edition - approved for length here.

NANNY: New YeAr briNgs fresh begiNnings

Points this post: 15
Total Points: 945/ 995
Tasks Completed: 56/57


message 1164: by Julia (new)

Julia (julia103) | 2719 comments Julia103

15.3 Mysterious and Wise
Option 1
Book 1: Read a book with a cover with at least 75 percent of any combination of these THREE colors, RED BLACK AND YELLOW according to Tineye.

Socialism . . . Seriously: A Brief Guide to Surviving the 21st Century
red 79.6% #ee3324
yellow 4.3% #eebb27
black 2.1% #272221)

This book is non-fiction, so claiming one It's A Fact ticket

Book 2: Read a book with at least 2 different lucky numbers (2, 8 and 9) in the page count.

Children of Darkness

I read the Kindle edition. There is no MMP. The top paperback Children of Darkness is 182 pages.

This post: 15 points, 1 NF
Total points: 385
BB: 5
GO: 3
NF: 3
Completed tasks: 19
Books read: 27


message 1165: by Jayme(theghostreader) (last edited Jan 14, 2025 07:45PM) (new)

Jayme(theghostreader) (jaymetheghostreader) | 3040 comments Repost from post #840
30.9 Ringing in the new year
Option 1 read a book with 0022245 in the page count
A Christmas Memoryby Richard Paul Evans
224 pp
Option 2 food on the cover
cupcakes on the cover
Christmas Cupcake Murder (Hannah Swensen, #26) by Joanne Fluke by Joanne Fluke
304 pp
Total: 528 pp

Task +30
Grand Total: 85


message 1166: by Ann A (last edited Jan 14, 2025 07:42PM) (new)

Ann A (readerann) | 1091 comments 20.3 Review Raffle- Trishhartuk's Task: Wordplay
Option 3a: Something Lost, Something Gained: Reflections on Life, Love, and Liberty
28 letters, divided by 4 words = 7

Note ** According to the FAQ's, the comma wouldn't count here because it's a "character", not a letter

Total points: 60


message 1167: by Joanne (new)

Joanne (joabroda1) | 1557 comments Joanne MI

10.6 Inspiration Strikes

a biography, autobiography or memoir about an artist, musician, poet or writer

You Don't Belong Here: How Three Women Rewrote the Story of War

Approved in help thread # 29

Claiming 1 IAF

Points this task 10
IAF this task 1
Season Total 145
IAF 2


message 1168: by Jessica (last edited Jan 16, 2025 01:58AM) (new)

Jessica S | 289 comments Jessica S

15.3 Mysterious and Wise

Option 2: One-book task - book with a cover with at least 75 percent of any combination of these THREE colors, RED BLACK AND YELLOW and book with at least 2 different lucky numbers (2, 8 and 9) in the page count.

Smile Behind the Lens of the ‘Dating Game Killer’ (True Crime) by Ryan Green Smile: Behind the Lens of the ‘Dating Game Killer’ by Ryan Green

Points this task: 15
Total Points: 520


message 1169: by Tess (new)

Tess (tessavanessa) | 2114 comments TessaVanessa

Challenge 5.6 Meanwhile, Back in the Southern Hemisphere

Read a book set in the Southern Hemisphere AND first published in December or January.

Cocaine Blues by Kerry Greenwood

Takes place in Australia and was first published in January, 1989

Points this post: 5
Total points: 785
Tasks Completed: 49


message 1170: by Tess (new)

Tess (tessavanessa) | 2114 comments TessaVanessa

Challenge 10.8 Run Away! Run Away!

Read a book from the first 25 pages of the Mythology shelf: Mythology Books

The Siren by Kiera Cass

Found on page 8 of the list.

Points this post: 10
Total points: 795
Tasks Completed: 50


message 1171: by Tess (new)

Tess (tessavanessa) | 2114 comments TessaVanessa

Challenge 15.1 Groundhog Groundhog Groundhog

Book 1: Read a book with a 4 or more letter word in the title that can be formed from one of these two phrases: SIX MORE WEEKS OF WINTER or SPRING WILL ARRIVE EARLY

I'm So Glad We Had This Time Together: A Memoir by Maurice Vellekoop

WORD=TIME found in the phrase SIX MORE WEEKS OF WINTER

Book 2: Read a book that has a repeated word consecutively in the title.

Mirror, Mirror by Jen Calonita

Points this post: 15
Total points: 810
Tasks Completed: 51


message 1172: by Nick (new)

Nick (doily) | 3392 comments Nick KY

25.3 Beth NC’s Winter Solstice


Opt. 1. Shortest Day. From the Best Short Books list, I read The Incendiaries by R.O. Kwon.

Opt. 3. Longest Night. From the Best Long Books list, I read 2666 by Roberto Bolaño.

CLAIM TWO BIG BOOKS for 2666 at 912 pp.

Points This Post: 25
Total Points So Far: 365

BB’s So Far: 500+ (2) 750+ (1) = 4 BB’s


message 1173: by Trish (last edited Jan 15, 2025 08:46AM) (new)

Trish (trishhartuk) | 3675 comments trishhartuk

20.6 It’s a Fact - Julia103's Task" Getting Older
Includes a claim for a Golden Oldie ticket.

Option 1: Read a book where a main character is a senior citizen.

The Body in the Library, Agatha Christie
Read the kindle edition. Top MMPB: here (220pg)
The GR character description for Miss Marple calls her “an elderly spinster” (https://www.goodreads.com/characters/...), as does Wikipedia (https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Miss_Ma...).
Golden Oldie: First published in 1942

Points this Task: 20
Books Read: 1
Golden Oldie: 1 – The Body in the Library was first published in 1942

Total Points: 320
Tasks Completed: 22
It’s a Fact Tickets: 4
Golden Oldie Tickets: 5


message 1174: by ❀Tea❀ (new)

❀Tea❀ (ttea) | 268 comments Tea


5.10 - Comfort zone

Read a book of your choice that meets SRC rules.

Mirror Dance by Lois McMaster Bujold
- MMP edition Mirror Dance


---
Points this thread: 5

Total points: 5


message 1175: by ❀Tea❀ (new)

❀Tea❀ (ttea) | 268 comments Tea

15.5 - Old Saint Nick

Read a book with a single author who shares initials with one of names: Santa Claus, Father Christmas, Kris Kringle and Saint Nicholas

Rise of the School for Good and Evil by Soman Chainani
- author's initials are SC (like Santa Claus)
- IL: MG - BL: 5.5 - AR Pts: 10.0 https://www.arbookfind.com/bookdetail...
- PB edition Rise of the School for Good and Evil (no MMP)


---
Points this thread: 15

Total points: 20


message 1176: by ❀Tea❀ (new)

❀Tea❀ (ttea) | 268 comments Tea

20.3 - Review Raffle- Trishhartuk's Task: Wordplay

Option 3a

Read a book with a title of at least two words where the total number of letters in the title can be averaged by the number of words, to get a whole number.

Stalking Darkness by Lynn Flewelling
- 16 letters & 2 words -> 16/2=8 - whole number
- MMP edition Stalking Darkness


---
Points this thread: 20

Total points: 40


message 1177: by ❀Tea❀ (new)

❀Tea❀ (ttea) | 268 comments Tea

20.9 - Moderator's Pet -Jen B's Task: 90s Nostalgia

Option 1

Read a book with EXACTLY 5 words in the title

The Waters of Eternal Youth by Donna Leon
- 5 words in the title
- MMP edition Las aguas de la eterna juventud or english PB The Waters of Eternal Youth


---
Points this thread: 20

Total points: 60


message 1178: by ❀Tea❀ (last edited Jan 15, 2025 09:15AM) (new)

❀Tea❀ (ttea) | 268 comments Tea

25.4 - JennRenee's Task: Cold Nights With Winter Reads

MPG Thriller

Book 1

Read a book with a word of 4 or more letters made from this quote:
Winter was made for warm blankets and large books.

Broken by Karin Slaughter
- word Broken can be found in quote - ....warm blankets ... books
- mpg thriller
- MMP edition Broken


Book 2

Read a book by a single author whose first and last initial can be found in either COLD NIGHTS

Tripwire by Lee Child
- author's initials LC can be found in word COLD
- mpg thriller
- MMP edition Tripwire


---
Points this thread: 25

Total points: 85


message 1179: by Jen B (new)

Jen B (jennybee618) | 885 comments JEN B

20.1 Most Improved -Kathy KS's Task: Family and Holidays


Option 2 - Read a book set at least 50% in one of the places in which some of our family members live: California, Kansas, Mississippi, North Carolina, or Germany.

The Only Survivors by Megan Miranda

This book is set in North Carolina. From GR description, "Their annual meeting place, a house on the Outer Banks, has long been a refuge." The Outer Banks are part of North Carolina.

TOTAL POINTS: 285


message 1180: by Charlston (new)

Charlston Goch (list_addict) | 211 comments Readerboard Name: List_Addict

5.10: A book of your choice

Beneath the Sugar Sky by Seanan McGuire


Total this challenge: 5


message 1181: by Tess (new)

Tess (tessavanessa) | 2114 comments TessaVanessa

Challenge 25.2 Nick KY’s Task: Rivers

Option 1: Read a book first published in 1968 or in a year after 1968 that ends in the digit 8 (1978, 1988, 1998, 2008, or 2018).

Spiral by K.L. Denman

Published January 1, 2008

Option 2: Read a book with one of the 8 original River names as a word in the title, subtitle, or series title. Plurals and Possessives are accepted.

Dangerous Waters by Sandra Robbins

River used: ClearWATER

Points this post: 25
Total points: 835
Tasks Completed: 52


message 1182: by JennRenee, Moderator (new)

JennRenee (jennreneeread) | 2904 comments Mod
5.7 National Cocoa Day
Read a book with a hot beverage on the cover, such as coffee, tea, cocoa/hot chocolate, hot cider, etc. The beverage should be visible; no empty containers.

read Fresh Brewed Murder (A Ground Rules Mystery #1) by Emmeline Duncan
Fresh Brewed Murder

points this post 5
total 825


message 1183: by JennRenee, Moderator (new)

JennRenee (jennreneeread) | 2904 comments Mod
10.7 - I Want To Believe
Read a book with an MPG of Paranormal. The genre may be embedded, e.g. "Paranormal Romance" or "Paranormal Horror".

read Love and Other Conspiracies
Romance
Contemporary
Audiobook
Contemporary Romance
Paranormal
Fiction
Adult
Paranormal Romance

points this post 10
total points 835


message 1184: by JennRenee, Moderator (new)

JennRenee (jennreneeread) | 2904 comments Mod
10.8 - Run Away! Run Away!


Read a book from the first 25 pages of the Mythology shelf: Mythology Books

read Hounded page 3

points this post 10
total 845


message 1185: by JennRenee, Moderator (new)

JennRenee (jennreneeread) | 2904 comments Mod
10.10 - Cold As Ice

Read a book from one of the following lists: used list Nordic Noir page 1

read Black Ice

points this post 10
tota points 855


message 1186: by JennRenee, Moderator (new)

JennRenee (jennreneeread) | 2904 comments Mod
20.10 Group read

read Weyward
discussion post 16

points this post 20
total 875


message 1187: by Joanne (new)

Joanne (joabroda1) | 1557 comments Joanne MI

Repost of message of 1138

25.4 JennRenee's Task: Cold Nights With Winter Reads


Book 1 Read a book with a word int he title of 4 or more letters made from this quote:
Winter was made for warm blankets and large books.

The Mark of the Assassin - The word Is MARK

Book 2 Read a book by a single author whose first and last initial can be found in either COLD NIGHTS or WINTER READS

Rogue Justice by Stacey Abrams S.A. in Winter Reads.

The shared genre is Mystery

Points this task 25
Season Total 135
IAF 1


message 1188: by C (new)

C | 350 comments Lora
Task: 25.5 Jessica S’s Task: The Music of Christmas, using options 3 and 5
Book 1:
Book/Author: On Pens and Needles / Sandra Orchard
How it fits: author's initials are SO
Book 2:
Book/Author: Adrift in Currents Clean and Clear / Seanan McGuire
How it fits: MPG Urban Fantasy

Points for this task: 25
Total points: 265
Big Book tickets for this task: 0
Big Book tickets total: 0
Golden Oldies tickets for this task: 0
Golden Oldies tickets total: 0
It's a Fact tickets for this task: 0
It's a Fact tickets total: 1


message 1189: by Jukka (last edited Jan 15, 2025 05:04PM) (new)

Jukka Särkijärvi (nitessine) | 718 comments JUKKA

Reposting.

20.7 Shorter is Sweeter - Kristen IA's Task: Holidays and Hiking
Option A:
1: Author's initials are in LIGHTS.
4: Book that is #1 in a series.
Revival, Vol. 1: You're Among Friends by Tim Seeley is #1 in Revival.

Total Points: 220/995
Total Books Read: 18
Tasks Completed: 14/57
Big Books Total: 0
Golden Oldies Total: 7
It's a Fact Total: 0


message 1190: by Jecca (new)

Jecca | 735 comments Jecca
10.6 - Inspiration Strikes

Read a biography, autobiography or memoir about an artist, musician, poet or writer.

I Know Why the Caged Bird Sings by Maya Angelou

Claiming IAF

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 10
Total Points: 320
Total Tasks Completed: 15
* * * * * * *
Big Books:
Golden Oldies:
It's a Fact: 2


message 1191: by Jecca (new)

Jecca | 735 comments 15.10 Winter Retreat

Read a book with a cover that shows a secluded house or cabin (no other buildings visible on the cover) in a snowy landscape.

These Silent Woods by Kimi Cunningham Grant by Kimi Cunningham Grant

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 15
Total Points: 335
Total Tasks Completed: 16
* * * * * * *
Big Books:
Golden Oldies:
It's a Fact: 2


message 1192: by Jukka (new)

Jukka Särkijärvi (nitessine) | 718 comments JUKKA

10.3 A Mountain of Books
Book whose page count comprises 9, 1, 4, 4 in any order.
Skullkickers, Vol. 1: 1000 Opas and a Dead Body by Jim Zub has 144 pages in the top paperback edition, though I read the Kindle version.

Total Points: 230/995
Total Books Read: 19
Tasks Completed: 15/57
Big Books Total: 0
Golden Oldies Total: 7
It's a Fact Total: 0


message 1193: by Jecca (new)

Jecca | 735 comments Jecca
20.9 Moderator's Pet -Jen B's Task: 90s Nostalgia

Option 3- Trends -read a book with one of the Beanie Baby animals from this list on the cover - Cat

We Solve Murders (We Solve Murders, #1) by Richard Osman by Richard Osman

~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~~
Points This Post: 20
Total Points: 355
Total Tasks Completed: 17
* * * * * * *
Big Books:
Golden Oldies:
It's a Fact: 2


message 1194: by Robin P (last edited Jan 15, 2025 05:43PM) (new)

Robin P | 1609 comments ROBIN P

20.6 It's a Fact - Julia103's Task: Getting Older
Option 1: Main character is a senior citizen
Death Comes to Marlow - listened to audiobook, linked pb
This is the 2nd in the series, for the 1st book, The Marlow Murder Club, the GR description starts "Judith Potts is seventy-seven years old". The second book takes place about 6 months later.

Points this post: 20
Total points: 565

BB:0 GO:2 IAF:6


message 1195: by Lisa (new)

Lisa Hickman (lbhick) | 1527 comments Lisa MD

20.4 - Robin P’s Task: Christmas Carols

Option 3: Author Initials match: AB, AS, AT, BA, BS, BT, TA, TB, TS, SA, SB, ST

Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson
Just Mercy by Bryan Stevenson

***I claim an IAF ticket***

🎀🎄🎅🏻❄️🎀🎄🎅🏻❄️🎀🎄🎅🏻❄️🎀🎄🎅🏻❄️🎀🎄🎅🏻❄️🎀🎄🎅🏻❄️

COMPLETED TASKS:

Points This Post: 20
Total Points: 350 / 995
Total Books Read: 26
Total Tasks Completed: 20 / 57
Big Book Tickets: 1
Golden Oldies Tickets:
IAF Tickets: 4


message 1196: by Karen D (new)

Karen D | 673 comments Task 15.9 My Bloody Valentine

Read a book with MPG Romance as well as MPG of War, Thriller or Mythology

Book: Finlay Donovan Jumps the Gun

Points this task: 15
Total points: 495


message 1197: by Ann A (new)

Ann A (readerann) | 1091 comments 20.1 Most Improved -Kathy KS's Task: Family and Holidays
Option 3: Read Write Own: Building the Next Era of the Internet
Published in 2024

Total points: 80


message 1198: by Lois (new)

Lois | 2632 comments 10.5 - A Gateway to the Past


Set prior to 1903: The Limehouse Text by Will Thomas

Series description noting "Victorian London"

Chapter 1 specifies: "It was a Wednesday morning, the fourth of February, 1885."

Points this post: 10
Total points: 275


message 1199: by Lys (last edited Jan 16, 2025 01:10AM) (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 271 comments Regarding Message 1091


Read a biography, autobiography or memoir about an artist, musician, poet or writer.

Orwell's Roses

Orwell was a writer.

Points this post: 10
Total points: 75
Books Read: 7
Tasks Completed: 7


I forgot to claim a non fiction ticket for this one.


message 1200: by Lys (new)

Lys (lysrowan) | 271 comments
5.10 Comfort zone
Read a book of your choice that meets SRC rules.

The Wee Free Men

Points this post: 5
Total points: 50
Books Read: 4
Tasks Completed: 4


Reposting and adding that this has a UG level in Bookfinder. Thank you.

Accelerated Reader Quiz Information IL: UG - BL: 4.7 - AR Pts: 11.0
Accelerated Reader Quiz Type Information AR Quiz Types: RP, VP



back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.