SciFi and Fantasy Book Club discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
What Else Are You Reading?
>
What Else Are You Reading in 2024?
message 151:
by
Brett
(new)
Jan 28, 2024 08:36PM

reply
|
flag

This is the best 'Watch What You Wish For' story I have read.
My review here

My rating: 4 of 5 stars
I don't normally like criminals as protagonists, even petty ones. But Zahn crafts worlds that pull me in, overcoming my hesitation.
My review here
Just started Farside Cannon by Roger MacBride Allen for the TBR cleanup challenge.

My rating: 4 of 5 stars
I don't normally like criminals as protagonists, even petty ones. But Zahn crafts worlds that pull me in, overcoming my hesitation.
My re..."
I love Timothy Zahn's Dragon series.
Finishing some big chonky books. City of Golden Shadow was okay. I just don't think I'm a Tad Williams fan. I often lament how rarely editing is taken seriously in our spellcheck age, and he's a prime example of someone I think could benefit from someone they respect enough to listen when they say "nix this entire chapter." So much redundancy. A big plot, but lost in the writing.
On the other hand we have Pandora's Star. This is some of the cleanest plotting I've seen in a book this big, but this man has never heard a detail he didn't love. Absolutely fixated on body weight and the cubic sizes of rooms. Not the worst thing since the rest is so engrossing but probably "A large room" would have sufficed over the 3-4 sentences describing it, in certain sections.
On the other hand we have Pandora's Star. This is some of the cleanest plotting I've seen in a book this big, but this man has never heard a detail he didn't love. Absolutely fixated on body weight and the cubic sizes of rooms. Not the worst thing since the rest is so engrossing but probably "A large room" would have sufficed over the 3-4 sentences describing it, in certain sections.

OK, Pandora's Star is going on the TBR list.

I had problems with that Tad Williams series too. However I love
The Dragonbone Chair and the rest of that epic fantasy series
and
The Dirty Streets of Heaven is almost as good. It's about an angel who is an advocate for those between heaven and hell. God Rest Ye Merry, Gentlepig in particular was pretty funny (werepig).
and
Shadowmarch is almost as good (another epic fantasy)
and then there is this standalone for cat lovers: Tailchaser's Song
The Osten Ard series falls lower in my estimation and at the bottom is the Otherland series.

My review of Penric and the Shaman
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

Now, gotta finish up a quick intro on the Achaemenid empire (persia during the greek times up to when Alexander the Great snuffed it out.
Then I'm thinking of reading Nettle & Bone by T Kingfisher

In regards to Tad Williams, I started with the Dragonbone Chair series and enjoyed it, then moved on to a different series and could never get into it. So my suggestion would be if you haven't read the Dragonbone Chair series, give it a try. Not to try and interest you in reading a great deal more of Williams but to see if that is more your flavor. Not Sci-Fi in any real sense, ore fantasy

I enjoyed the story as a piece of fiction, but not cohesive enough as an adaptation.

So true! ^_^ Check out the series thread! And read Fox next! It finishes the arc from Shaman before the series moves on to other adventures.
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Didn't much like Dragonbone Chair honestly. The first Shadowmarch book got my hopes up but the second one shattered them. I really tried!

My review of Penric and the Shaman
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show..."
Loved Penric and Desdomona series! it was quite fun, pretty cool way of demons, not from hell, but can possess!




Another fan of R.A, Salvatore who is a great author and can write a great story. I've read every Drizzt book he's written and I'm hoping he isn''t done yet.

I enjoyed the story as a piece of fiction, but not cohesive enough as an adaptation."
I have read the author's note at the beginning of the hardcover edition, which is the book I have. Her research into the legend, which she discusses, is both detailed and very impressive. My comment was only that the childhood education, including martial arts, makes the character reminiscent of Laxmibai, a major heroic figure of nineteenth century India. Not much (and not enough) has been written about Laxmibai in English, but see Rani Laxmibai: Warrior-Queen of Jhansi by Pratibha Ranade. I'm glad you enjoyed the story as a work of fiction.

Found a podcast series on Rani of Jhansi. I will listen to that first due to easy access on Audible.


My review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

My review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show......"
I am very happy for you! :)

My rating: 4 of 5 stars
SAIL: your drilling rig through the brisk Icelandic winter seas!
RELAX: in cold sleep as you cruise interplanetary space!
MINGLE: with the cheerfully grifting 'Conners' of Luna's Central Colony!
RACE: the 6,000 km Sunway! [Don't fall behind - you will get cold during the two week night.]
MEET: your new neighbors; the exiled, rejected, and eccentric residents of Farside Station!
BEHOLD: the amazing Farside Cannon!
My review here



Brett, I'm cat-paralyzed, too! I was just discussing that with @Mindy. I have 4 out of 5 on me, and oh my gosh I need to shift something fierce. Far be it for us to disturb our felines, though! It's a good thing #5 is off being either aloof or offended because there's only so much of me to go around 😹

The Lathe of Heaven: Le Guin could pack a lot into less than 200 pages. The VBC discussion was excellent, too. A great way to start off the year. (review)
Killashandra: I read the first book of this trilogy several years ago and wasn't all that impressed, but the second was a lot of fun. (review)
The Bridge Kingdom: conceptually, romantasy should be just my thing, but in my very limited experience so far, both the romance and the fantasy are too poorly executed for me to enjoy. A huge disappointment. (review)

Marc I just finished the audiobook, which I recommend, such a fun story! hope you like it

I read the Lunar Chronicles during my reading a lot of YA books. I thoroughly enjoyed them, though, I think Scarlet was my favorite. It's always the sassy heroine for me.

Word for World is next up for me to read!


It's meant mainly for Christian readers, but whatever, I'll just adjust my mindset.

now temporarily leaving scifi, reading Matt Waters Ancient Persia: concide history of the achaemenid empire. woohoo!!

My rating: 3 of 5 stars
Good, solid sci-fi. I liked Farside Cannon [set in the same universe a century earlier] a bit better, but the overall GoodReads rating shows others prefer this one. Personal taste.
My review here
Time for another change of pace: Frankenstein. It has been on my bookshelf about 30 years and I can't recall ever reading it.


Earlier in January I read:
Emily Wilde's Map of the Otherlands - 5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
A Study in Steel (A Tale of the Greatcoats) - 4 ⭐⭐⭐⭐
The Lies of Locke Lamora - 5 ⭐⭐⭐⭐⭐
and a non-fantasy book.
Now I'm starting A Master of Djinn today.



That book is absolutely brilliant Colin. I loved every word of it.


Since the start of the year I have completed The Hero of Ages - Sanderson, Maelstrom - Taylor Anderson (A quick dark horse favorite series of mine!), and I finally pushed through The Eye of the World - Jordan after many DNF attempts. I really want to get to the Sanderson books and feel I really need to check the series off my list as a SF/Fantasy reader, but I am just not sure Jordan is for me.
Currently Reading The Long Earth - Pratchett/Baxter and Leviathan Falls - James S.A. Corey. Book 9 of 9! This will be the first major series I have read since high school 30 years ago and that was short YA novels. Milestones even in my 40's lol.
So that leaves 104 books on my TBR (not counting some known sequels to series just not added to my list yet, such as Era 2 Mistborn), 36 of which are owned and on the shelf.
Shortlist:
- Warbreaker - Sanderson
- Distant Thunders - Anderson
- Dune - Herbert
- Defiant - Sanderson
- The Blade Itself - Abercombe
- The Dragonbone Chair - Williams
- Ruin of Kings - Lyons
- The Forgetting Moon - Durfee
- A Game of Thrones - Martin
- Lords of the Middle Dark - Chalker
- Ship of Magic - Hobb
- Rhythm of War - Sanderson
That is about as short as I can get it. LOL SOO MANY WORDS! lol

Sounds interesting - that the writer made such a bleak premise readable and engaging
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
I’d Rather Have a Cat than a Harem! Reincarnated into the World of an Otome Game as a Cat-loving Villainess Volume 1 (other topics)Odin's Child (other topics)
Bee Sting Cake (other topics)
Neuromancer (other topics)
Gardens of the Moon (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Andrea Stewart (other topics)Brian McClellan (other topics)
Robin Hobb (other topics)
Charlie Jane Anders (other topics)
Robert Jordan (other topics)
More...