Ultimate Popsugar Reading Challenge discussion
2020 Challenge - Advanced
>
09 - A book from a series with more than 20 books


If so, I really like Storm Front and would likely read Fool Moon for this prompt.


Would you recommend starting with the first or are there some later in the series that are good as stand-alones?"
You don't have to start with the first, I think I started with Hard 8 and then went back and read the others. In my opinion, if you were only going to read one then it should be Finger Lickin' Fifteen. We have that on audio book and my teenage son liked it so much we listened to it 3 times.

They have Siege of Stone by Terry Goodkind on there. I’m guessing they mean it as part of his Sword of Truth series since it’s a part of that universe, but seemingly a spin off series of Sword of Truth.
I’m curious if that means the entire universe would count as one series even if they’re spin offs.
I started reading the Sword of Truth series years ago and never finished it so if it counts I might actually get around to picking up where I left off this year. The only thing is, I think there’s only maybe 11-15 books in the original series depending on how you count them, but there’s between 20-22 in the full universe (again depending on how you count them).
Do you all think the full universe counts or only the original series?


I’m curious if that means the entire universe would count as one series even if they’re spin offs."
Sara wrote: "Would the Dresden Files count? There are 16 "main" works but the series also has a number of side novels, in-universe short story collections, and other additions."
Personally, I'd count side novels, spin-off series, and short story collections in the same universe. So yes to both.


I am going with the Alex cross series for this prompt. The series looks really interesting !

Lots of Pratchett books work as standalones, but ..."
I agree that it's easily the weakest book in the Discworld series and not one I'd recommend to anyone getting into the series.
For those who aren't familiar with Pratchett, the Discworld books are divided into sub-series and the first book in each sub-series can usually be read as a standalone:
- Death series: Mort
- Witches series: Equal Rites (which would also work for 'book with a pun in the title')
- City Watch series: Guards! Guards!
- Rincewind series: The Colour of Magic
- Moist von Lipwig series: Going Postal
- Tiffany Aching series (middle grade / YA): The Wee Free Men
- Industrial Revolution series: Moving Pictures
My personal recommendations would be Guards! Guards! or Going Postal, they're actually two of my favourite books ever let alone favourite Discworld books.

There are 18 Tortall novels (not counting the second Numair book which is due to come out this year) but if you count Tortall: A Spy's Guide and Tortall and Other Lands: A Collection of Tales then that would make 20. I'd say go for it!





Lots of Pratchett books work as st..."
The City Watch books are my favourite of these. I have only one left.

The Boxcar Children

My Review:
https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


I guess in theory, the new graphic novel adaptations of the Babysitters Club could also work if you're willing to stretch the prompt a bit. The original series had way more than 20 books, but the graphic novel versions have about 5 or 6 so far. I don't know if people consider them a separate series or part of the same thing.


Jonathon Kellerman's Alex Delaware series has 35. I am planning on reading the newest one for this prompt. I have been reading this series forever and have read all of them so far!!

I'm going to read Tears of the Giraffe by Alexander McCall Smith.

It's #2 of the series "No. 1 Ladies' Detective Agency". I hope it's fine to start with book 2, I found it in a second hand book shop in the UK and didn't realize it's part of such a big series.

Meh. There are 20 full-length novels, but then he released a collection of short stories a while back with the same characters The Cleverness of Ladies, which makes it 21 in the series.... kind of. I'd count, if you're motivated to read from the series. https://www.goodreads.com/series/4341...

I'm going to read Tears of the Giraffe by [aut..."
They are all great, hope you enjoy them.

I was going to recommend the Xanth series as well. They were a favorite in my teen years (So full of puns which is right up my alley) I did not realize that there is now 43 of them and can be read as stand alone novels. Most would also fit the prompt pun in a title. I highly recommend checking them out.



Fruits Basket, Vol. 1 & Fullmetal Alchemist, Vol. 1
I would also consider Kelley Armstrong's Otherworld books. The goodreads page is a bit of a mess because there are multiple interlocking series. But if we consider the series as any book happening in that universe, there are a lot more than 20. I recommend starting with Bitten or The Summoning.


And I highly recommend the audio versions - they are SO well done, it's one series I'll always get as audio.

I'd totally count that.











The canon of Sherlock Holmes is 56 stories and 4 novels. I've used short stories for prompts, so I'd say yes for myself. It's your challenge, your rules. What matters is if you want to use short stories.


Personally, since the prompt says "20 books," I only count whole books. That means I don't count standalone short stories, and if a group of short stories is published together as a book, I count it as 1 book.
But, like Heather said, it's your challenge and you can do what you want! Last year I ran out of time and ended up using some short stories for prompts anyway.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Black Stallion (other topics)The Black Stallion (other topics)
The Black Echo (other topics)
The Cat Who Had 60 Whiskers (other topics)
Purity in Death (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Lilian Jackson Braun (other topics)Agatha Christie (other topics)
Kelley Armstrong (other topics)
Alexander McCall Smith (other topics)
Gertrude Chandler Warner (other topics)
More...
Would you recommend starting with the first or are there some later in the series that are good as stand-alones?