Goodreads Librarians Group discussion

note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
360 views
Book & Author Page Issues > Please Combine Editions?

Comments Showing 501-550 of 914 (914 new)    post a comment »

message 506: by Liz V. (new)


message 507: by Liz V. (last edited Oct 02, 2019 12:33AM) (new)


message 519: by Arenda (last edited Oct 05, 2019 10:54AM) (new)

Arenda | 26452 comments #341 done
#343-366 done
#367 combined the "sixth edition" editions. Not going to add the primary author of the "fifth edition" to other editions where he is not credited on the cover.
#368-378 done
#379 skipped for now done
#380-381 done
#382 skipped for now done
#383-385 done
#386 was done by someone
#387-393 done
#394 some editions were already combined; the third and fourth link should not be combined with the others as they contain more than just the novel.
#395 was done by someone
#396-404 done
#405 skipped for now done
#406-410 done
#411-413 These were combined in a different thread. Please don't post the same request more than once.
#414-417 done
#418 done; except I can't tell if appendix and annex have the same content
#419-421 done

#422 skipped for now done, except some that are an adaptation and should not be combined with the original

#423 Separated the Portuguese edition from the omnibus editions and combined with the matching English and other editions. Also separated adaptations.

#424-433 done

#434 There are actually two books, original German titles: Wir Kinder vom Bahnhof Zoo and Christiane F: Mein zweites Leben. Most were already correctly combined. I've combined a single edition with the other editions for each title.

#435 done
#436 was done by someone
#437-442 done

#443 The one you marked as a duplicate is the same edition (9780674022874) linked twice.
I've combined the French edition Charles Baudelaire. Un poète lyrique à l'apogée du capitalisme with the other editions with the same title.
The Finnish edition Silmä väkijoukossa. Huomioita eräistä motiiveista Baudelairen tuotannossa only contains Über einige Motive bei Baudelaire and should not be combined with editions that contain more than just that essay.
The German editions, one of them Baudelaire Übertragungen are only 76 pages and probably don't have the same content.

#444-445 done
#446 It doesn't look like these have the same content. Essais 1, 1922-1934 is combined with the English and German editions, Essais 2 1935-1940 is definitely a different book than Essais 1. The English and German editions have the same title, but might also have different content, based on a comparison of the description on the English Illuminations: Essays and Reflections and the German Illuminationen. Ausgewählte Schriften 1.

#447 done
#448 not done, as the first link also contains "other writings on media"
#449 was done by someone
#450-458 done
#459 was done by someone
#460-474 done
#475 Combined the first and second link. Not sure about the third link, lack of details. Cover says "The Arabian Nights", not: "Stories from The Arabian Nights".
#476 done
#477 not done; the second link is only volume 5 according to Worldcat; the first link is a collection, note the difference in page count
#478-483 done
#484 someone has combined them
#485 skipped for now done
#486-488 done
#498-490 done, but please make a separate post for each book next time
#491 done
#492-493 done, but please make a separate post for each book next time
#494-495 done
#496 done, but please make a separate post for each book next time
#497-498 done
#499 done, but please make a separate post for each book next time
#500-523 done
#524-525 were done by someone
#526-535 done


message 539: by Liz V. (new)

Liz V. (wwwgoodreadscomlizv) | 43962 comments Thanks Arenda.

Could you look at #371 again?


message 550: by Liz V. (new)

Liz V. (wwwgoodreadscomlizv) | 43962 comments Thomas Whately :
Observations on Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds, Parks, Farms, Ridings, &c. Illustrated by Descriptions: To Which Is Added, an Essay on the Different Natural Situations of Gardens
Observations on Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds, Parks, Farms, Ridings, &c. Illustrated by Descriptions: To Which Is Added, an Essay on the Different Natural Situations of Gardens
Observations on Modern Gardening; Illustrated by Descriptions... plus 4
Observations on Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds ... &c. by T. Whately . to Which Is Added, an Essay on the Different Natural Situations of Gardens plus 3
Observations on Modern Gardening: Illustrated plus 4
Observations on Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds ... &C. By T. Whately . to Which Is Added, an Essay on the Different Natural Situations of Gardens - Scholar's Choice Edition plus 3
Observations on Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds, Parks, Farms, Ridings, &c. Illustrated by Descriptions: To Which Is Added, an Essay on the Different Natural Situations of Gardens
Observations on Modern Gardening: Illustrated
Observations on Modern Gardening, Illustrated by Descriptions
Observations on Modern Gardening: Illustrated by Descriptions... - Scholar's Choice Edition
Observations on Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds, Parks, Farms, Ridings, &c. Illustrated by Descriptions: To Which Is Added, an Essay on the Different Natural Situations of Gardens
Observations on Modern Gardening: Illustrated by Descriptions plus 2
Observations on Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds ... &c. by T. Whately . to Which Is Added, an Essay on the Different Natural Situations of Gardens plus 1
Observations on Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds ... &c. by T. Whately . to Which Is Added, an Essay on the Different Natural Situations of Gardens
Observations On Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds ... &c. By T. Whately . to Which Is Added, an Essay On the Different Natural Situations of Gardens

Horace Walpole with William 1735-1785 Wollet & Thomas -1772 Whately :
Observations on Modern Gardening, and Laying Out Pleasure-Grounds, Parks, Farms, Ridings Etc., Illustrated by Descriptions: To Which Is Added, an Essay on the Different Natural Situations of Gardens plus 1


back to top
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.