Pair 1 - A1 - Romantic Suspense VS. B2 – Witches

[Dee]

From the winner of Group A - Romantic Suspense and the runner-up of Group B - Witches

[Dee]

Readers
AnniLuvs
Calilia
Chanelle
Ezi - Troublemaker
JoJo
Katie
Lioness7
Ramneek
Shannon (Wckdktty)
Ty
Vi
Pamela Su
Sofia
Grace
Cathy
Joyce
Elizabeth
Liz

Votes
Romantic Suspense - 1
Witches - 1

[Ty]

You hate me, don't you?

[Dee]

no, I don't, the magical margarita mixer does

[Vi]

Well, it likes to do that with everyone it seems. I JUST finished a witches book!!

[✿~Danielle~✿]

I'm good with both these two

[Dee]

mwahahaha!

[Calila]

Just to be sure..."Calilia" is me right?

[Dee]

whoops...yes, I failed spelling in case you can't tell!

[Calila]

Thanks Dee!

[Calila]

I'm bummed...I got all excited thinking "Ohhh I have a witch book!!!" turns out it's not out until Oct. 28th. =/

[Dee]

lol - bummer!

[Shannon]

Group A - Romantic Suspense is
Group B - Witches is 4 Stars

[✿~Danielle~✿]

Round 2
Romantic Suspense VS. Witches

Romantic Suspense: Forged in Steele by Maya Banks (Sept 24) ★★★★
Shelved - Romantic Suspense
Theme: 4/5
Enjoyment: 4/5
TOTAL: 8/10

Witches: The Witch With No Name by Kim Harrison (Sept 25) ★★★★★
Shelved - Witches / Romance
Theme: 5/5
Enjoyment: 5/5
TOTAL: 10/10

WINNER: Witches

[Ezi]

This is easy:
☑Romantic Suspense: Sinner, Savior (Done 10/4) ★★★★1/2
☑ Witches: Shadow of Night (Done 10/7) ★★★★


Ranking:
1. Romantic Suspense
2. Witches

[Katie]

Round 2: Romantic Suspense VS. Witches


RS: Open Season - 337 pages/GR - Popular Romantic Suspense - 10/2/14, 4 stars
W: Moon Called - 288 pages/GR - Popular Witches Books

Though I enjoyed Moon Called more than Open Season, it didn't really have any focus on witches at all.

WINNER: Romantic Suspense

[Ramneek]

Pair 1 - A1 - Romantic Suspense VS. B2 – Witches
Total: 2/2

Romantic suspense: Carter Reed 17th Oct, ****
Witches: Daughters of Darkness 18th Oct, *****


Romantic suspense: Carter Reed
Theme: 3/5
Enjoyment: 4/5
Total: 7/10


Witches: Daughters of Darkness
Theme: 4/5
Enjoyment: 5/5
Total: 9/10

WINNER: WITCHES

[Jojo]

Round 2 - Knockout

Pair 1

Romantic Suspense - Hidden by Kendra Elliott - 24/09/14
Theme - 5/5
Enjoyment - 4/5
Total - 9/10

Witches - Witch Weigh by Caroline Mickelson - 26/09/14
Theme - 4/5
Enjoyment - 2/5
Total - 6/5



Winner - Romantic Suspense

[Calila]

Okay my brain just is not comprehending this challenge at all. I'm completely blanking on if there are any rules to picking a book? Like a special list or a special shelf or something? Or is it just if it applies it'll count?

Someone help! LOL

[Dee]

Calila - books gave to be shelved as romance and have something in the description, title, other shelving that indicates the theme

[Calila]

Dee wrote: "Calila - books gave to be shelved as romance and have something in the description, title, other shelving that indicates the theme"

Thanks Dee! That's what I thought but my brain is just on vacation today or something. LOL

[✿~Danielle~✿]

I'm done with both mine. results post

[Pamela Su]

Romantic Suspense: Tequila Mockingbird (Romance and Suspense as Genre on main page and on the list for Best M/M Mystery/Crime/Suspense/Thriller Books of 2014)

Witches: Reclamation (MC is referred to in the book as a male witch in a female-dominant magic society, also has witches as a genre on the main page)

*** RESULTS ***

Romantic Suspense: Tequila Mockingbird
Theme: 5/5
Enjoyment: 4/5
TOTAL: 9/10

Witches: Reclamation
Theme: 5/5
Enjoyment: 4/5
TOTAL: 9/10

...crap. A tie. Eep, what do I do?! I felt the themes were both very well represented in both books. So I'll end this tie breaker based on enjoyment.

I enjoyed Reclamation a bit more but I wouldn't give it a full 5. I'll say it has a higher weighted 4.

WINNER: WITCHES

[AerinLuvs]

Round 2
Romantic suspense v. witches

v. A Demon and His Witch

[Lioness7]

Hi guys, I'll try to get my books up tomorrow. I am running a little behind this month.

[Elizabeth]

Romantic suspense:
vs.
Witches:

Romantic suspense: Behind Closed Doors, 10/2/2014, ★★★★
vs.
Witches: Biting Cold, 10/2/2014, ★★1/2
Winner: Romantic suspense

[Calila]

Romantic Suspense -
A Reason To Believe - Shelved as Romantic Suspense
10/01/14
Theme- 4* ;Enjoyment - 4*
vs
Witch -
Mind Magic - MC is a "mage" also Shelved as "Witches"
10/01-02/14
Theme 5*; Enjoyment-3*

Although I enjoyed my Romantic Suspense book more, but the book for Witch fit the theme better giving it the edge in that one, so I don't know which is the winner. I'm going to go with which one I enjoyed more.

Winner- Romantic Suspense

[Vi]

Romantic Suspense: Kill Me Twice by Roxanne St. Claire - 3 stars

Witches: Binding the Shadows by Jenn Bennett - 4 stars.

Winner: Witches

[Ezi]

I finished and I chose Romantic Suspense. Post 15

[Joyce]

Romantic Suspense: Loyalty in Death finished 10/5/14
Theme: 5/5
Enjoyment: 4.5/5
Total 9.5/10

Witches:The Enchantment Emporium
Theme:5/5
Enjoyment:4/5
Total:9/10

Winner: ROMANTIC SUSPENSE

[Sassafrass]

Romantic Suspense:
Hardwired
(shelved as Romantic Suspense 5 times)
Theme: 4/5
Book: 3.5/5
Total: 7.5/10

vs

Witches:
A Demon and His Witch
Theme: 5/5
Book: 4.5/5
Total: 9.5/10

WINNER: WITCHES!!

[Ty]

okay. first pair done!

Romantic suspense: Brothers In Arms
theme: 3
enjoyment: 3
total: 6

Witches: Wickedest Witch
theme: 5
enjoyment: 3
total: 8

witch, it is!

[Dee]

how did I know that was going to be Ty's result ;)

[Ty]

hey! as you can see, the enjoyment rating was the same. tho, MM made it a tad bit more tolerable...

[Pamela Su]

I tried reading some Eve Langlais novels recently... -_-

A little too boring for me. The books I read started off okay but then became draggy in the middle

[Sofia]

Romantic Suspense Shame

Witches: Wickedest Witch


Winner: Romantic Suspense

[Sofia]

Ty we chose the same book for the witches book!

[Sassafrass]

Sofia wrote: "Ty we chose the same book for the witches book!"

I chose an Eve Langlais book too! I have Wickedest Witch. I'm going to save it for the next round..just in case.

[Ty]

yeah, I went back to the first round thread to look for suggestions. :)

I don't mind Eve Langlais. Very mindless and tongue-in-cheek. Quick, fun reads to fulfill challenge requirements... ha.

[Sassafrass]

Ty wrote: "I don't mind Eve Langlais. Very mindless and tongue-in-cheek. Quick, fun reads to fulfill challenge requirements... ha."

exactly. I like her humor.

[Cathy]

Romantic Suspense - Black Hills by Nora Roberts
Theme 5/5
Enjoyment 3/5

Witches - The Witch with No Name by Kim Harrison
Theme 5/5
Enjoyment 3/5

I didn't really get into either book, but I have enjoyed the whole Rachel Morgan series by Kim Harrison and generally like witch books. I'm going to go for Witches to win.

Winner - Witches

[Sofia]

Sassafrass wrote: "Sofia wrote: "Ty we chose the same book for the witches book!"

I chose an Eve Langlais book too! I have Wickedest Witch. I'm going to save it for the next round..just in case."

I think R.S. will win this round. Read the book anyway. It was good.

[Grace]

Romantic Suspense vs. Witches

Romantic Suspense
Law Man by Kristen Ashley

2/5 Theme
3.5/5 Enjoyment
5.5 Total

Witches
Wickedest Witch by Eve Langlais

4/5 Theme
3/5 Enjoyment
7/10 Total

Winner: Witches

[Dee]

as a reminder, this round ends Oct 23 at 6pm EST - please make sure you have your pairs completed/posted by then

[Liz]

Hi! For this group I will read:

For Romantic Suspense: The Collector by Nora Roberts.
Finished: Oct. 19. ★★★ 3/5

And for the Witches: Hex Hall by Rachel Hawkins.
Finished: Oct. 21. ★★★★ 4/5



WINNER: Witches

and

[Shannon]

Group A - Romantic Suspense is 4 Stars
Group B - Witches is 4 Stars

Winner Witches

[Pamela Su]

Finished my read just in time! :)

It was a tie because they had the same points, but unexpectedly Witches won for me, because I enjoyed it a smidgen more.

ETA: results in Msg 23

[ConstantReader76a]

Just finished!
Romantic Suspense: 2 Stars

Witches: 2 Stars

I've been in a book slump lately and found it very difficult to find suitable books to read for this challenge.

Both represented their respective themes well. I did not really enjoy either of them, but felt that 1 star would be too harsh. I select Romantic Suspense as the winner purely because A Discovery of Witches has ruined me for other "witchy" books.

[Shan ~A~]

A1 - Romantic Suspense: Secrets Exposed by Lisa Renee Jones

vs.

B2 – Witches: The Book of Life by Deborah Harkness

[Dee]

as a reminder, this round ends Oct 23 at 6pm EST - please make sure you have your pairs completed/posted by then

if you want to particpate in the Elite Eight - sign-up thread is here (locked until tomorrow)