Litwit Lounge discussion
Lounge: OPEN, please come in...
>
What are you currently reading?
message 1601:
by
Reed
(new)
Dec 18, 2021 08:07PM

reply
|
flag

Maybe it’s because of my familiarity with the story, but I really enjoyed the book. Not that there weren’t a few surprises. For instance, I didn’t expect Dickens to interject occasionally as a narrator, of sorts.
Compared to my favorite movie adaptation with Alistair Sims (which I watch annually on Christmas Eve), I was surprised not to read about the future of Alice, Scrooge’s former fiancee. (She is Belle in the book.) Nor his interaction with his charwoman on Christmas Day nor Tiny Tim’s certainty that it was Scrooge who sent the Cratchit family the turkey. Then I learned that these scenes were created for the film. Dickens hadn’t actually included them in his book. In some ways, I wish he had because I do love that 1951 movie.
Overall, there is a reason why this book is so beloved and its messages are clear. Dickens shows us that despite our past we are all redeemable. That’s good to know. "God bless us, everyone!"










It's not so great a novel as 1984, but it is an easier read. It would probably whet your appetite for the greater work.







I’ve been hibernating this winter, but I’m finally ready to peek out to see what’s going on in the Litwit group.
Thank goodness for books! I’ve retreated from an insane world to rereading "All Creatures Great and Small" by James Herriot. Love it—and I think I’ll be reading the rest of his books this year. I need to be nurtured.
The second season of the PBS TV show just ended and I don’t want to leave the comfort of the Yorkshire Dales, so I joined a Facebook group. I can’t tell you what a blessing it is to talk about kindness and community.
I hope everyone in the group is well and safe.









I'll link to my review on the reviews thread Reggia. In the group Werner referred to, we're doing a close study and reading just one chapter a day, with breaks where the original installments ended, so it's a l-o-n-g read. This time of reading, I started it last year, and am half way through with the group :)
It's ages since I read The Space Trilogy: Out of the Silent Planet, Perelandra, That Hideous Strength by C.S. Lewis, and really would like to read those again!


I've read and very much enjoyed your review, but haven't "liked" it - yet! Don't worry - I will at the end of our read! The reason is that I've noticed some friends pick up on my current status, and whereas of course I would love them to read your review, now would be a bit prescient. Not that you give any spoilers - you don't of course - but you do give a judgment e.g. about Esther's reliability, and some members are still considering that one (although most have formed an opinion, changed it, and changed back!)
I enjoyed your alternative perspective ... I thought you would appreciate the letter to Rev. D. Macrae :) Oh, and your comment about whether it's a mystery is also one which might be better read either before or after the novel, rather than during it. (I feel differently about that bit by the way, as I think there are quite a few mysteries, and wonder which you consider to be the main one! Perhaps it's the one just coming up ... ) Also, those used to reading Victorian fiction may consider Esther pivotal, (dramatisations simplify it to this too) but the one character who is present in all the story threads is actually (view spoiler) ! He is privy to far more than Esther.
Anyway, that's just why I haven't "liked" or drawn attention to it for those involved in the read, as we have so much more to come :) If they find it for themselves and read it, of course that's fine and up to them. (I don't read reviews in the middle of a read usually, but some people might.) I had a friend once, who would look at the cover of a book, maybe read the first few sentences - and then read the last page !! Aaargh! We're definitely all different!
Apologies for the length of this post. And thank you very much for the shout-out for the group in your review. I do appreciate it :)


...still working on Flirting With French, and added a text I picked up 2 decades ago: Introduction to Philosophy: A Christian Perspective.
...will decide by this evening what new fiction to begin.

I've just begun All Creatures Great and Small. It's a compilation of the Yorkshire vet Alf Wight (writing as James Herriot)'s first two books, plus three chapters from his third! Not surprisingly (since I was born and brought up in Yorkshire) it's a many times reread for me. Real comfort reading, but how could I resist when one of my other groups chose it as a group read. Just lovely for lazing in the garden and reading in the sun on a summer afternoon :)

Although All Creatures Great and Small has been on the back burner lately, I am reading it, too. Some of the stories I am recognizing from the newest PBS series... the first in the book actually.

Now I'm involved in the "Daily Dracula" project. Each time there is a new date in this epistolary novel, I get a the relevant chunk sent to me by email (though I'm actually reading the Gutenberg edition). It started on May 4th, and will go on until November - as the original does. It's great fun! There are three days without entries now though so I need to discipline myself ...
You can sign in at:
draculadaily@substack.com (they don't ask for info) and there's an archive to catch up :)








I expect to finish the book and post a review around the end of this month, or early in July.


Peter O'Donnell's iconic character Modesty Blaise is one of my favorite fictional action heroines. Although


I wonder now whether you would enjoy Pictures from Italy by Charles Dickens. The two authors sound as though they had a similar sense of the the absurd - and arguably carried it past the point where it is generally thought appropriate. On the other hand, I know some Americans thoroughly enjoy American Notes For General Circulation, which are similarly unrestrained.
I saw the film Modesty Blaise on TV as a late teen, and then read the book, though I never saw the cartoon strips. Now I can't remember a thing about it!

Bionic jean wrote: "I saw the film Modesty Blaise on TV as a late teen, and then read the book, though I never saw the cartoon strips. Now I can't remember a thing about it!"
Like you, I've never seen the cartoon strips (except for bits and pieces in reviews); and I've never seen the movie, either. (Though I've heard a lot about it --see below!) My introduction to the character was through one of O'Donnell's short stories back in my youth, though I got a very late start on reading any of the rest of the canon. (Long story!)
The book you linked to (Modesty Blaise, 1965) is the series opener; there were ultimately 11 novels and two story collections, and the cartoon strips are being or have been reprinted as a series of graphic novels. Originally, the idea of the movie was inspired by the cartoons (which are serious stories, not comical ones!), and O"Donnell was hired to do the screenplay. But the filmmakers then decided to do the movie as a parody of the James Bond movies instead, and hired a different script writer. But they commissioned O'Donnell to do the novelization --which he did, using his own screenplay, not the other guy's, as the basis. (That book is the series opener and genesis of the book series.) So there's actually relatively little resemblance between it and the movie (which proved to be a box office flop).


Good to see you chiming in, Reed. Be sure and let us know how you liked Tribute.
I'm still reading through All Creatures Great and Small, and after a long hiatus have returned to Les Misérables and am reading the 2nd volume. I started to watch the Netflix musical to get me to the part at which I left off... and didn't much care for it.
I've just recovered from Covid and was back to work this past week. Soon I'll be headed to the east coast for 2 weeks, and that may change my reading choices. We shall see! For now, I'm super-excited to soon be walking in green grass while surrounded by trees. Oh! the things I used to take for granted. :-)
Books mentioned in this topic
Benito Cereno (other topics)Great Short Works of Herman Melville (other topics)
The House on Vesper Sands (other topics)
The Naming of the Birds (other topics)
Helsing: Demon Slayer (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Herman Melville (other topics)Liane Zane (other topics)
Francine Rivers (other topics)
Heather Day Gilbert (other topics)
Samuel Taylor Coleridge (other topics)
More...