Cozy Mysteries discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archived
>
When you're not reading a cozy....
message 1101:
by
Leslie
(new)
Nov 27, 2010 07:52PM



reply
|
flag





I'm about 1/5 of the way through. I would say that it seems like a good, but not great book. One of those books that's been hurt by being over hyped. (Kind of like Girl with the Dragon Tattoo.) If you go into it expecting something great or an instant classic, you're going to be disappointed.


I'm about 110 pages into it and it's so-so Took a break from it and read a cozy and am also reading
Major Pettigrew's Last Stand which I hope to finish today and get back to Juliet


The second one is my favorite. I did not love the series until book two.


Another book board friend told me the same thing about the 2nd book, so we'll see!


Lower your expectations for this series. It's not revolutionary- it doesn't contribute or expand the genre. I think a lot of it is people who wouldn't ordinarily read mysteries (because genre fiction is not real literature) felt the need to justify their liking this series. Overall, it's really good, it's just not great. It's amazing in that most men don't usually write female characters this flawed who are likable or sympathetic or human. They usually have them killed, raped, imprisoned with the attitude that they've gotten their just desserts.
Shay wrote: "Lower your expectations for this series. It's not revolutionary- it doesn't contribute or expand the genre. I think a lot of it is people who wouldn't ordinarily read mysteries (because genre fiction is not real literature) felt the need to justify their liking this series. Overall, it's really good, it's just not great. It's amazing in that most men don't usually write female characters this flawed who are likable or sympathetic or human. They usually have them killed, raped, imprisoned with the attitude that they've gotten their just desserts. "
I totally agree. I think that only people (European, at least) who hasn't read thriller has discovered the Northern thriller with this (I've read Sweden thrillers at least twenty years ago, and they weren't new ones). And about female characters, I totally agree. If you read urban fantasy (written by women, of course), you'll find a lot of strong female characters.
I totally agree. I think that only people (European, at least) who hasn't read thriller has discovered the Northern thriller with this (I've read Sweden thrillers at least twenty years ago, and they weren't new ones). And about female characters, I totally agree. If you read urban fantasy (written by women, of course), you'll find a lot of strong female characters.




Yeah, I am only about 30 pages in and it's reading more like a chick lit with the twin sister business. I am now lowering my expectations...and wishing I hadn't bought it. Unfortunately, I am beyond the 14 days that B&N gives you to return purchases, so I'm a little miffed. But hopefully I can take something away from this book!


I'm having a hard time with this book, not even 80 pages in. I think it's one of those books that because it has a literary connection (Romeo and Juliet) that the book is immediately thought of as literary itself. An undeserved (and overrated) reputation.
I'm sorry to hear the two of you aren't enjoying Juliet, as it is one on my to-read-someday list. Based on book site discriptions and reviews seen on a couple of book blogs, I was expecting it to be more "chick lit" than "literary." Odd, neither of you did, but guess it's all in how a person reads the blurbs, etc. Here's hoping it gets better for you both!



I'm about a fifth of the way through the book and I don't know if I'll be able to finish it. It just gets worse as you go on. I'm finding it easier to give up on books since I have about 600 books + that I have waiting in my pile (real and ebook). So, there's not reason to read a bad book, in my opinion.

It's 444 pages long to boot! There are much better books out there to invest that kind of time in a book that is only just "ok". I'm glad to see it's not just me. Some days I question my own judgement.





It's not perfect, but I enjoyed the complex plot. I liked books 2 and 3 more, again for the plot and tension. I learned something about Sweden, too!

I'm about a fifth of the way through the book and I don't know if I'..."
I am only on page 40 and I feel like I am trudging through mud. I was expecting something more literary and I am sorely disappointed. I think this is one of those books I may put down and come back to in the future when I don't care about reading something great. I have soooo many new books that I am excited about that I really don't want to waste my time on this one right now. I am also eyeing all these great Christmas books that I really want to get into. So, in conclusion, I think I am shelving this one!

I'm about a fifth of the way through the book and I d..."
I'm debating whether or not to rate it. I sometimes rate books I don't finish when the reason I don't finish them is I don't think they were good. To me, this book falls in that category. I think that its average GR rating of 3.85 is not really deserved.


And I managed to read all 4 of the Twilight books without turning into a "blithering idiot"! Amazing!

Okay. I just try not to make fun of things that others read, so maybe I'm a bit touchy when people make fun of what I read. I'm just happy when people read.....PERIOD!






Don't worry. People get crazy about their Twilight love on here. I get in trouble all the time for showing my *cough* lack of love for the series on my YA group, and Melodie still likes me (I think!) :)

Yes, I still love you, Heidi!! LOL

I suppose they must. Thank you for your kind words. However, I think this is the wrong community for me.
Well, I'm reading Prince Charming Doesn't Live Here by Christine Warren. It's a revisited version of a short story, and I'm liking it till now.




I read the first one, Clan of the Cave Bear, years ago. But, I'm #5 or so at the library for #6, so I've got to read them all before then because I think it's over 100 holds and it'll take forever to get if I have to cancel my hold.


There are "conversations" throughout the book with Jeff and the guys and one had me absolutely peeing in my pants! Jeff said he had a Dead Obama puppet that he put in the garage and Achmed says "He was an imposter! He NEEDED to be put in a garage." Then Jeff asks, "Did you ever talk to Dead Osama?" and Achmed replies, "One time. He was afraid of the dark so I gave him my Dora the Explorer nightlight." I swear, I laughed about that for at least 20 minutes!


So glad I purchased it... the best $1.00 I have spent this season.

Currently reading The Christmas Train by David Baldacci, part of the Christmas Spirit reading challenge I am participating in through January 6 (Epiphany).

I read that several years ago and liked it.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
A Multitude of Monsters (other topics)Alibi in High Heels (other topics)
The Second Life of Nick Mason (other topics)
Torch Ginger (other topics)
The Good Girl (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Gemma Halliday (other topics)Craig Shaw Gardner (other topics)
Kristi Charish (other topics)
Sharon J. Bolton (other topics)
Gemma Halliday (other topics)
More...