Nothing But Reading Challenges discussion
Around the World Team Challenge
>
Team Have Book, Will Travel
date
newest »

message 251:
by
☼♎ Carmen the Bootyshaker Temptress ☼♎
(new)
Apr 04, 2016 06:03AM

reply
|
flag

Ooh that's a good one. I'm pretty sure it will work.
I read Soulless last month ( 26 March), which I think will also work for alternate history.

That's what I believed they were going for. I just haven't had the chance to get to my book since I've been sick for the past week. Hopefully I can get to it soon since I'm behind in a few of my challenges :(

I don't think anyone has said so far that they can't do alternate history. I haven't really read any steampunk before although it has been on my radar, but it seems to me that they mostly work. I'm really enjoying Ink and Bone as well, so I'm glad that the next task made me pick it up sooner. It's shaping up to be a 4 star book. :)
Hope you feel better soon Carmen. :(

I've added a new sheet in for our next stop - thanks Berit! We're off again. :)


haha, I did the same thing. I read Soulless, another steampunk book, earlier this month without even realizing it could be used for this until a few days ago.
I posted this awhile back but here is what is explained for the alternate history task per the Q&A.
● No fantasy worlds.
● Must occur on earth.
● Our history must be different in a major way (i.e. Hitler rose to power, the South won the Civil War)
I had read Soulless & Blameless but I couldn't see where history was different in a major way (as technology wasn't approved per the last challenge) & that this wasn't a fantasy world given the vampires & werewolves.
● No fantasy worlds.
● Must occur on earth.
● Our history must be different in a major way (i.e. Hitler rose to power, the South won the Civil War)
I had read Soulless & Blameless but I couldn't see where history was different in a major way (as technology wasn't approved per the last challenge) & that this wasn't a fantasy world given the vampires & werewolves.

This is the exact wording from the FAQ:
It's an alternate history to the one we know. So one in which Hitler rose to power, or the South won the Civil War.
It's a different history from the one we know, and can only be our world (no fantasy places/worlds) though the genre could be anything as long as it's set on Earth and is different in a major way to what we know.
To me, a fantasy world means Narnia or Middle Earth, and Earth with vampires and werewolves is still Earth, not a fantasy world. It's ok if you don't agree with me on that! That wording could be a bit ambiguous - if any genre is allowed then surely fantasy set on Earth is allowed?
If the Industrial Revolution took place in a different way as I assume is usually the case with steampunk, then to me that is Earth and different in a major way to what we know.
But this is only my opinion, and I think the semantics could be discussed forever. Everyone sees things differently, and there are good arguments for and against.
I haven't read any of the other books to be able to say if they fit the goal. For me, if whoever read them thinks they fit, that's fine, especially as we don't have a captain or mods to make the call, and this challenge isn't really the same kind of competition as other challenges have been.
Most important is that we have fun and it doesn't become a chore - why most of us passed on reading about cowboys I imagine. ;)
Sarah wrote: "I haven't read any of the other books to be able to say if they fit the goal. For me, if whoever read them thinks they fit, that's fine, especially as we don't have a captain or mods to make the call, and this challenge isn't really the same kind of competition as other challenges have been"
All that was said was what "I" read, thought & interpreted. And it would have been silly & a total waste of my time to post a link for the Q&A if I didn't think it was open to interpretation. LOL! I'm just not a fan of wasting time so everything with me is literal. It's scary to think how much time could be lost implying things that get confused, twisted or just go over someone's head ;)
All that was said was what "I" read, thought & interpreted. And it would have been silly & a total waste of my time to post a link for the Q&A if I didn't think it was open to interpretation. LOL! I'm just not a fan of wasting time so everything with me is literal. It's scary to think how much time could be lost implying things that get confused, twisted or just go over someone's head ;)

I don't think the vampire/werewolf aspect should affect it because, like Sarah said, it's not set in a fantasy world, but ours.
At least that's how I interpreted it. If the steampunk technology aspect doesn't work for the goal and I can search for another book that might fit better. It just may take me a bit longer to finish.


4/24/16
3 stars
I've been trying to spell out a person's name for a challenge and just finished with this one. I have an alternative history book I will start as soon as possible.
And Berit, I salute you on reading 11/22/63. I have that one on my TBR list and the size of it scares me. :-)



I've been so off for the past few weeks. If I need to change my alternate history book I have one that I can use that's tagged alternate history and then work on the girl dressed as a boy. I think that's where we're at. I'm not even sure. Hehehe

For the next stop, I reckon we can probably do a spell out without reading any extra books?


(Actually we can probably juggle most things, so any letter out of SAN JOSE will do.)
If you want to go with the detour, then we have four books already read for girl dressed as a boy - we would need books from Zee, Berit, Carmen, and Holli.
I think this is up to you guys who would have to read something whether you want to or not. I don't mind either way.

I'm on the app so I can't link but the book is called Never Home

So that leaves us with either any book from Zee for the spell-it; or books from Zee, Carmen, and Holli that work for girl dresses as a boy.
Up to you three which you want to go for. ;)

Most recent is Miss Peregrine’s Home for Peculiar Children - read 31/5/16, 4 stars


5/3/16
1 star (it promised me vampires and lied!)

5/4/16
3 stars

5/5/16
3 stars

5/5/16
2 stars

5/9/16
2 stars
(I think there's a scene in this book where Fei is dressed as a boy, but I'm not positive.)

5/14/16
4 stars

5/17/16
3 stars


5/20/16
4 stars

5/23/16
2 stars

5/23/16
2 stars

5/24/16
2 stars

5/25/16
1 star

5/26/16
1 star

5/28/16
2 stars

5/31/16
4 stars

6/2/16
2 stars

6/4/16
4 stars
Several of the books listed were skim reads and others were audiobooks and why my list is long. And I'm not going to wait so long to list my books anymore.

I vote yes :)

According to the rules we could ask for another itinerary and go around the world again, or we can decide to finish our trip here.
For me, as WOBBLE is starting, (and I expect we've all signed up for that, right?), I'd rather concentrate on that and hang up my guidebook. What do you all want to do?
Books mentioned in this topic
The Book of Dragons (other topics)Phantom Lover (other topics)
Two for the Dough (other topics)
Fight For Me (other topics)
A Dark-Hunter Christmas (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Jennifer L. Armentrout (other topics)V.E. Schwab (other topics)
Scott Hawkins (other topics)
José Antonio Villareal (other topics)
Douglas Adams (other topics)
More...