Reading the Detectives discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Archived threads
>
What mysteries are you reading at the moment? Old thread
message 651:
by
Jill
(new)
Aug 19, 2016 05:14PM

reply
|
flag
I'm just in the middle of Snobbery with Violence by Marion Chesney aka M.C. Beaton - this is the first in her Edwardian Murder Mystery series and is a quick, fun read. The main characters are Lady Rose, a former suffragette, and Captain Harry Cathcart, a veteran of the Boer War. Enjoying it so far.
Leslie wrote: "Maybe we should set up a separate thread for deals so that they don't clog up the 'what are you reading' thread? Just an idea..."
Good idea, Leslie, thanks for that - I've just set up a thread:
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Inevitably, some offers and deals will still be mentioned in other threads, but it should be helpful to have a specific thread for them.
Good idea, Leslie, thanks for that - I've just set up a thread:
https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
Inevitably, some offers and deals will still be mentioned in other threads, but it should be helpful to have a specific thread for them.

I've just started reading A Perfect Match, the first in the Lloyd and Hill series about a pair of police detectives by Jill McGown, which was published in 1983.
I just picked up the second in the series at an Oxfam shop, which is a Christmas-themed book, Murder at the Old Vicarage, but thought I'd like to start with the first in the series. Enjoying it so far. Sadly the author died a few years ago.
I just picked up the second in the series at an Oxfam shop, which is a Christmas-themed book, Murder at the Old Vicarage, but thought I'd like to start with the first in the series. Enjoying it so far. Sadly the author died a few years ago.
I just finished Darktown: A Novel, which is set in 1948 Atlanta. It is about the first 8 black police officers in the city and is a really good read - highly recommend it.

Have just noticed that Anthony Horowitz has written a GA type mystery Magpie Murders. Looks really good and I know we were talking about him a while ago.
It is on NetGalley, on Orion. I downloaded it yesterday, so any NetGalley reviewers may want to request.
During the last six weeks I have read quite a few mysteries, not all "classics".
The Nature of the Beast, last year's entry in Louise Penny's Three Pines series. This year's entry is due today and I'm on the waiting list. I love this series. I thought a major part of the plot was fantastical and then learned in the epilogue that that part was true.
The Alienist an historical mystery by Caleb Carr. It is set in New York at the turn of the last century, when Teddy Roosevelt was chief of police. Excellent historical content and atmosphere.
The Maltese Falcon by Dashiell Hammett. I read this because in the next entry in the Mary Russell / Sherlock Holmes series I'm due to read, they are in San Francisco and meet Hammett, so felt I should have read him. All I know about Hammett I got from Lilian Hellman's autobiography. I really enjoyed the book though couldn't take it as seriously as Hammett would have liked. The movie characters took over.
Journey to Munich, by Jacqueline Winspear, latest in Maisie Dobbs series. I have mixed feelings about this series; Maisie is too introspective for my taste. This was an interesting story and good view of Munich post-Hitler, pre-WWII.
Finally, I am currently listening to Rumpole for the Defence and loving it - already ordered the next set of cd's from the library.
The Nature of the Beast, last year's entry in Louise Penny's Three Pines series. This year's entry is due today and I'm on the waiting list. I love this series. I thought a major part of the plot was fantastical and then learned in the epilogue that that part was true.
The Alienist an historical mystery by Caleb Carr. It is set in New York at the turn of the last century, when Teddy Roosevelt was chief of police. Excellent historical content and atmosphere.
The Maltese Falcon by Dashiell Hammett. I read this because in the next entry in the Mary Russell / Sherlock Holmes series I'm due to read, they are in San Francisco and meet Hammett, so felt I should have read him. All I know about Hammett I got from Lilian Hellman's autobiography. I really enjoyed the book though couldn't take it as seriously as Hammett would have liked. The movie characters took over.
Journey to Munich, by Jacqueline Winspear, latest in Maisie Dobbs series. I have mixed feelings about this series; Maisie is too introspective for my taste. This was an interesting story and good view of Munich post-Hitler, pre-WWII.
Finally, I am currently listening to Rumpole for the Defence and loving it - already ordered the next set of cd's from the library.

Sandy wrote: "Finally, I am currently listening to Rumpole for the Defence and loving it - already ordered the next set of cd's from the library. "
Oh, I love Rumpole! I enjoyed all the books and the TV series was excellent too - Leo McKern was just perfect.
Oh, I love Rumpole! I enjoyed all the books and the TV series was excellent too - Leo McKern was just perfect.
I'm enjoying A Perfect Match by Jill McGown, but am being distracted by the many scanning errors in the Kindle edition!
Earlier on it said that someone was the "widow of the kite Charles" - it took me a moment to work out that 'kite' should be 'late', because a k and i look vaguely like an l and a!
Now there have been two references to 'defective' instead of 'detective', and, to make it worse, someone just said 'I have taken pity on the defective branch of the police farce', instead of the 'detective branch of the police force' ! Can't publishers afford proof readers any more? I've come across so many similar errors, especially in Kindle books but also in print copies.
Earlier on it said that someone was the "widow of the kite Charles" - it took me a moment to work out that 'kite' should be 'late', because a k and i look vaguely like an l and a!
Now there have been two references to 'defective' instead of 'detective', and, to make it worse, someone just said 'I have taken pity on the defective branch of the police farce', instead of the 'detective branch of the police force' ! Can't publishers afford proof readers any more? I've come across so many similar errors, especially in Kindle books but also in print copies.

I also read Last Rights. It's the third historical mystery that I have read recently where the historical aspect is very interesting, but the mystery part not as compelling. This one is set in London during the Blitz and I enjoyed the information on Jewish life in London during WWII. The second historical mystery where I had a similar experience was Murder in the Marais which is partly set in Paris under German occupation. Both books end up being 3.5 stars for me rather than a full 4 star.
I've read, "Last Rights," Carolien. "Delayed Death," looks good and has been added to my TBR list, so thanks for that.

The Anthony Horowitz, so called, 'Golden Age' novel, is set in 1955, so I guess that just about works, Leslie. I always, personally, think of the GA as being between the wars, but of course, authors like Christie wrote far beyond that period.
I've started the Rabbi series by Harry Kemelman by re-reading Friday the Rabbi Slept Late, this time on audio. I read a few in the series a few years & years ago. Excellent. And I think I was reminded of them by this group, perhaps Everyman, so thanks to whomever.
Books earlier than the 1920's (I've read some set in the early 1900's) don't have the same feel to me, or writing style. I have read later books, 1950's, and they work better for me than those earlier novels somehow...
Just started a really good, contemporary crime novel: Missing, Presumed. Set in Cambridgeshire and looks to be the first in a series.
Susan and Leslie, I tend to love early 1900s detective novels, but agree they feel different from the later ones.
I've just finished The Quiche of Death which I enjoyed - looking forward to reading more Agatha Raisin!
At the moment I'm reading one of the early Patricia Wentworth books republished by Dean Street Press, The Astonishing Adventure of Jane Smith: A Golden Age Mystery.
So far I'm enjoying the characters but finding the plot extremely far-fetched, as with the other early Wentworths I've read so far. Once again this is more of a thriller than a mystery, with a strong element of romance.
I've just finished The Quiche of Death which I enjoyed - looking forward to reading more Agatha Raisin!
At the moment I'm reading one of the early Patricia Wentworth books republished by Dean Street Press, The Astonishing Adventure of Jane Smith: A Golden Age Mystery.
So far I'm enjoying the characters but finding the plot extremely far-fetched, as with the other early Wentworths I've read so far. Once again this is more of a thriller than a mystery, with a strong element of romance.

I read the first couple of Agatha Raisin's and then stopped, Judy. I liked them too and should go back to them.


This book has a high body count and the conclusion captures the complexity of the society and characters involved. It is well written and as far as I can ascertain, it is one of those series that improves over time, so I'll be reading more of them. Not a mystery as such, bit more to the thriller side of the spectrum.
I read it as part of a reading challenge that I am doing in another group which involves reading books written by authors from the Murder is Everywhere blog. I've mentioned quite a few of them in this thread during the year. The link to the list of books and challenge is here: https://www.goodreads.com/topic/show/...
I'm having great fun reading the stories set across the world this year and in the process discovered a new term in the mystery/thriller genre namely Sunshine Noir http://murderiseverywhere.blogspot.co.... Some of the authors have now launched a book of short stories based on the idea and I'm very keen to read Sunshine Noir. There's a lovely list of authors involved in the book.
Yes, I think it's a great idea to read books set in a lot of different places. I'd been vaguely wondering if I might read a detective story set in each European country - maybe I could start doing that next year.
That would be fun, Judy. Pushkin Press have released some good European crime novels with their Pushkin Vertigo series.
http://pushkinpress.com/pushkin-verti...
http://pushkinpress.com/pushkin-verti...
Thanks, Susan - by coincidence, I'd had an email about this imprint just the other day, but it had completely slipped my mind! It sounds as if there are some great titles on their list.
Yes, I've read a couple. Lots of European Noir and many set in our time period. If you decide to do a tour across Europe, I will try to join in as much as possible. I love European crime novels.
That's great, Susan - I'll give it some more thought! As you say,lots to choose from - I haven't read any of the popular Scandinavian crime novels as yet...
I've just started the secondE.R. Punshon Bobby Owen mystery,Death Among The Sunbathers, and was intrigued to see the introduction say there are striking similarities with Murder Must Advertise. Serendipity strikes again!
I've just started the secondE.R. Punshon Bobby Owen mystery,Death Among The Sunbathers, and was intrigued to see the introduction say there are striking similarities with Murder Must Advertise. Serendipity strikes again!
Wonderful, Judy. Plus I will set up a buddy read for the first Nigel Strangeways perhaps the beginning of October? A Question of Proof
.
If anyone is interested in joining in then please do.

If anyone is interested in joining in then please do.
Carolien wrote: "I finished Blood of the Wicked last night and it was an interesting read. For some reason, I have not read many South American books, but as a South African, I can relate fairly easi..."
Carolien, I've just been reading your thread - many thanks for posting the link. What a fantastic challenge. I'm tempted by the sound of quite a few of the books - Sunshine Noir sounds particularly intriguing. It looks as if you are well on course to complete the challenge by the end of the year!
Carolien, I've just been reading your thread - many thanks for posting the link. What a fantastic challenge. I'm tempted by the sound of quite a few of the books - Sunshine Noir sounds particularly intriguing. It looks as if you are well on course to complete the challenge by the end of the year!
Susan wrote: "Wonderful, Judy. Plus I will set up a buddy read for the first Nigel Strangeways perhaps the beginning of October?
That's great, Susan. I'll get hold of it and look forward to joining in.
That's great, Susan. I'll get hold of it and look forward to joining in.


If anybody is considering Europe, I would highly recommend The 7th Woman for France. I cannot remember who recommended the series - it may even have been Cara Black in a long ago blog post on Murder is Everywhere. I started it yesterday evening and have been compulsively sneaking it in all morning around my errands.
Leslie, well done and hope you enjoyed your long reading journey! It would be great to hear more about it - do you have a list of all the books you've read for this challenge, or a shelf/thread about it?
Also, Carolien, thanks for the France recommendation. I know that feeling of having to put life on hold as much as possible to get on with a book...
Also, Carolien, thanks for the France recommendation. I know that feeling of having to put life on hold as much as possible to get on with a book...
Oh, I've read that, Carolien. Fun series, although I found the love story a little too much at times! The Lying-Down Room, Arab Jazz and The Dark Angel are all great French crime books.

copied from the Cozy Mysteries Group
Here is my READ AROUND THE USA Challenge (starting 8/2012)
Progress: 43 mysteries + 7 non-mystery books = 50 completed out of 51
Oklahoma

visited 49 states (98%)
Create your own visited map of The United States or Brazil travel guide for Android
Thanks for that list, Leslie, that's very interesting - quite a feat to read all those. Looking through the list, I think I've only read some of the non-mystery titles.
Was it difficult to find books for some of the states?
Was it difficult to find books for some of the states?

Was it difficult to find b..."
Well, I haven't really gone out of my way to find certain states until this year (I was starting to get tired of this dragging out so long!) so it is hard to say how difficult some states might be if someone tried to complete this challenge in just a year. For me, the hardest have been the states with small populations -- Oklahoma, North Dakota, Idaho, etc.
I just finished Missing, Presumed
. Very good - literary crime and a good start to what will, hopefully, turn out to be a series.

I have opened a thread for the first Nigel Strangeways mystery A Question of Proof, which I am going to offer up as a Buddy Read in October.
Although not a Golden Age mystery, I wondered if anyone would be interested in a Buddy read of Not a Creature was Stirring, the first Gregor Demarkian novel, in December?
Although not a Golden Age mystery, I wondered if anyone would be interested in a Buddy read of Not a Creature was Stirring, the first Gregor Demarkian novel, in December?
I'm intrigued to read Not a Creature was Stirring, Susan, after reading your review of it - I'll get hold of a copy in time for December so I can join in!
Good news, Judy! Although it was not written during our period, it has a very traditional flavour and is a mystery that I enjoy re-reading.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Earthly Remains (other topics)A Rule Against Murder (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
Earthly Remains (other topics)
The Lake House (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Kate Morton (other topics)E.F. Benson (other topics)
E.F. Benson (other topics)
Ed McBain (other topics)
Leslie Charteris (other topics)
More...