The Diary of a Young Girl
question
when do kids typically read this book

I read this book in 6th grade. I recommended it to a niece last year. She read the play version in 8th grade. I thought 6th or 7th grade was a good time since that is how old Anne was when she wrote. Are schools shying away from the book and doing the play rather than the diary itself to "shield" kids?
reply
flag
I read this book when I was in 8th grade. My teacher had it as an assignment when we studied world war 2. She wanted us to learn about Anne Frank. So right after reading this book I began to keep a journal writing almost everything about my life. All that was just because of reading The Diary of a Young Girl.
deleted member
Jul 11, 2014 06:47AM
1 vote
I'm almost in 8th grade and I'm considering reading it. :)
I was around 11, or 12, but I didn't get the concept the first time i read it. I had to read it again later to actually understand the story.
I read it when I was maybe 12, which I think is a pretty good age to read, considering a) that's about how old Anne was when she wrote it and b) kids that old should already take a bit closer look in that kind of events in history.
I think I was 14 when I read this book. Very affecting. I found a lot of similarities between Anne and myself, and felt in a weird way like by writing her thoughts down she made a connection between us.
When I used to teach 8th graders, we read the play because it was provided in our text. Many of my students at the time would pick up the diary itself to read because we had read the play. In the school district where I teach now, they still teach the play in 8th grade, but use selections from the diary as well.
I read it in 7th grade, and I feel that was the right time
(emotionally) for me.
(emotionally) for me.
my son is 11, and in yr 6 at school, he has just read this as part of their war topic.
I was about 7 years old. I was a very advanced kid. It was a great lesson for kids these days.
Read this book in 4th grade and gosh, thank goodness I didn't finish it. I reread it in 7th grade for school, and gosh am I glad I didn't read the whole book when I was 9. Kind of surprised that this book was school required, considering there's some content that I think is a little "inappropriate" for kids. I mean, Anne does talk about sex quite a bit. And a lot of it disturbed me. So, I don't know, maybe its just me, but I don't think kids should read this til' at LEAST 7th or 8th grade.
I read it when I was in 9th grade. When I was looking for a nice book in library, I came across Anne Frank' Diary. The name sounded so familiar. I declined the book first because of it's size and the preview that mentioned about World War 2. I thought it would be war - is and something, but I ended up borrowing it. It was worth it, though.
I was young and my daughter was in 5th grade when asked to read it.
I knew that book since I was maybe 9, but I read it when I was 16.
I think you can understand why this book is important when you're older and when you had a few history courses haha :)
I think you can understand why this book is important when you're older and when you had a few history courses haha :)
I think I read it for a school summer reading assignment the summer before 9th grade. Looking back, I wish I had read it earlier on my own. :3
I think i read it at 14 or 15, and it was a revelation to me.
I read it again at 33 and still i think that she was quite beyond her years,
I read it again at 33 and still i think that she was quite beyond her years,
My class didn't study it (I think we should have ...) but I read it when I was in grade 8. I tried to read it when I was younger (when I was just getting into chapter books) but it didn't intrigue me than. Read this book when you will have an appreciation for it.
I don't remember when I read it but it was for school. I think I was 12 or 13? After I read it I was very interested in the Holocaust, I mean I knew about it, we all heard about it but this was real and I stated reading a lot of book regarding it, and learning from it. I also was into "diary-like" book, so I read the Journal of Zlata (I am translating the title) and so on. Very interesting to see the perspective of those that are in the war, in chaos themselves.
My daughter is 11 and she just read it. She loved the book! She is very mature for her age....
I used the script version of this (the play) to teach about Anne Frank and the Holocaust. Students were initially very interested, and I think they were somewhat tantalized by the notion of reading another kid's diary, even if it was from a long time ago. Here's the other thing that was interesting to me: they were shocked by the ending. I had high poverty teenagers whose parents told them which gang they were supposed to get jumped into as a matter of family pride. They had seen blood run in the streets. Yet to find out that in this story, there was no happy ending and the grown-ups were ultimately unable to protect the kids was deeply disturbing to them. Some of them took awhile before they believed this was true.
Read it in my early 40s... Never had the opportunity to read it in school...
I read it at 16. But then, I'm a French man. Nobody told us to read it at school. And it was considered more a girl's book than a boy's, which is wrong. This is good for anybody.
I read this book in 4th grade alone, and in 6th grade, I read it in a classroom. For me, it wasn't very challenging the first time I read the book.
I was really young. 3 rd grade maybe. I was reading some pretty heavy stuff...
I got it for Christmas when I was in 4th grade, and I read it then. My Dad was a WWII vet who helped with the liberation of Dachau and also served as an MP at the Nuremburg trials, so he felt it was important.
I came across it in the school library when I was about 12. When I moved to Europe I realised we had been given a censored version, about 30% shorter than the full diary, that cut out all her wonderings about sex and some of the scarier stuff. I still read it every few years, to remind myself that my life may be less than perfect, but I can look out the window or go outdoors whenever I want to!
I read it when I was 13 and taking a 9th grade English course
I read this in middle school, I would say 8th grade. It had a huge impact on me.
I read this book in 4th grade and probably didn't understand some of the material and sayings. i have a high reading level though. It is good to talk to someone about the sadness of the content in the book so you don't get too depressed. I think late middle school (like 8th grade) or early high school is a good age because by then you know what the holocaust is and such. You would also be able to understand the material more.
In our school, 4th graders read Number the Stars, a book also about the Holocaust. That inevitably leads to many 4th graders reading this.
Anne was between 11 and 13 years old when she wrote it. I would say that is the age to read it for the first time. In school the first in depth study of WWII happens in fourth or fifth grade.
Susan wrote: "I read this book in 6th grade. I recommended it to a niece last year. She read the play version in 8th grade. I thought 6th or 7th grade was a good time since that is how old Anne was when she w..."
We read the play in my 9th grade English class. We went with the play because it provided a more accessible format (according to the teacher). I don't think there was any concern for "shielding" us from the contents but I was pretty oblivious to such censorship at the time. I was young and didn't care why one form or another was chosen.
...I suppose the fact that my instructor was also the Theater teacher may have had some impact on the choice of formats.
We read the play in my 9th grade English class. We went with the play because it provided a more accessible format (according to the teacher). I don't think there was any concern for "shielding" us from the contents but I was pretty oblivious to such censorship at the time. I was young and didn't care why one form or another was chosen.
...I suppose the fact that my instructor was also the Theater teacher may have had some impact on the choice of formats.
I read it when I was 10 years old and I'm glad I did. I think more than ever it's important that kids know the world is not all about social media and Hunger Game movies. What Anne went through was horrifying and real and dwarfs the issues most children face today.
Orinoco Womble (tidy bag and all)
True, Thierry, I've come across several young people lately who thought this was a novel and were very critical of how "poorly written" it was. You co
...more
· flag
· flag
Macedonia has a different educational system, so let's say, I read it when I was 12, I think.
5th or 6th grade but i was probably in 4th when i read it
I read this book when I was 14 beacause I knew that there was an extract of it in the school book, so it was a nice opportunity to look smart in front od my classmates...
I think I was in about Gr. 8 or 9 when we read it in school...
(added). Actually, no. I remember the teacher discussing it with us. I was in Gr. 4 when we read it in school.
(added). Actually, no. I remember the teacher discussing it with us. I was in Gr. 4 when we read it in school.
I was 7 or 8 the first time I read it. My mother read it with me together with some other books from the period.
I read this in the fourth grade, but I think it depends on the teacher more than anything.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
The Diary of a Young Girl (other topics)
Books mentioned in this topic
The Diary of a Young Girl (other topics)The Diary of a Young Girl (other topics)