All About Books discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
General Archive
>
What have you just read? Opinions, recommendations & reviews
message 1901:
by
Cathie
(new)
May 20, 2014 09:11AM

reply
|
flag

Thanks for letting me know.



My review is here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

I liked Cranford more than North and South, but Wives and Daughters has been my favorite so far. I hope to get to Mary Barton this year sometime!



Now Ive started Blood Meridian and I have to say I've never read anything more violent before; pure ruthless, unwarranted violence. McCarthy is one of a kind.

Unfortunately Blood Meridian is just gratuitous violence without any character exploration or gripping plot. I think it's McCarthy's worst novel and I am a huge fan of his. Books like "The Road" and "No Country for Old Men" are in my opinion much better. I don't get why "Blood Meridian" is so highly acclaimed.
I finished "Invisible Man" by Ralph Ellison and that was definitely a thumbs up.
All the best!
Just finished Love Marriage. Liked it but not loved it.
I liked the story of this big family - I always love big families stories, I tend to feel at home as if it were mine! - and the History of the Tamil people which I didn't know at all.
I found sometims complicated the fact that the writer passed from one theme to another through the link of one word, confusing me a bit: big families complicated plot, and if you jump up and down is not always easy to follow you!
I liked the story of this big family - I always love big families stories, I tend to feel at home as if it were mine! - and the History of the Tamil people which I didn't know at all.
I found sometims complicated the fact that the writer passed from one theme to another through the link of one word, confusing me a bit: big families complicated plot, and if you jump up and down is not always easy to follow you!


Thanks for letting me know."
Sure! She put time into the research of this novel which really impressed me, considering it's not historical fiction per se.
Enjoy!

Also just read in the last 24 hours because I could not put it down, The Storied Life of A. J. Fikry, also 5 stars. You have got to read this book!

Thanks for letting me know...."
I have read others by the author and was impressed. Often they concern art.
Dhanaraj wrote: "@ Laura T: You learned something about Tamils from Sri Lanka. That is nice to know for a Tamil like me."
Yes Dhanaraj! I was thinking about you the whole book, I really didn't know the story of that terrible "war" in Sri Lanka ... men can be terrible, all over the world repeating the same mistake ever and ever, never learning ...
Yes Dhanaraj! I was thinking about you the whole book, I really didn't know the story of that terrible "war" in Sri Lanka ... men can be terrible, all over the world repeating the same mistake ever and ever, never learning ...

Yes Dhanaraj! I was thinking about you the whole book, I really didn't kno..."
The genocide in Sri Lanka never came to the public focus. But then the Tamils had a tough time there and even now they have a difficult life. The Tamils that you encounter in the West are mostly those who escaped the civil war situation in Sri Lanka. They are like people without the homeland.

Yes Dhanaraj! I was thinking about you the whole book, I re..."
My son started reading some time ago The Cage: The Fight for Sri Lanka and the Last Days of the Tamil Tigers but he has put it now on a break. In the future I hope I'll have time to read it too (otherwise I will ask my son to make me a summary).


Perhaps people are interested to know better what happened in Sri Lanka. I haven't read the book so I don't know if the author takes some part. I think it is always interesting and useful to know also what is happening in the other countries. Have you read the book?

I have a couple of his books in my wishlist: The Cat's Table and Running in the Family. Will add also yours!


I had seen the film and it wasn't bad. I have read a short piece of your review (I rarely read full reviews of books I haven't yet read) and it however intrigues me.

My review: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...
So now I have broken all my rules and immediately bought another by the same author! I will read the other books I have waiting later.



Will try to get other English translations.

Thanks ;)

My review is here: https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

Thanks for those titles. They are new to me.

My review is here: https://www.goodreads.c..."
Read that one. Our reviews highlight many of the same points. https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

My review is here:..."
We did, too! I think like you, I didn't love it but thought it was worth reading. I am interested to read more of her work.

I found that the story picked up towards the end. I don't know how far you are into it, but in my mind the real story doesn't really start until he is an adult...


I'm already two-thirds into it! I agree that the pace picks up a bit, but I keep thinking that Philip is a little pathetic in his love relationships, especially that with Mildred! Makes me grind my teeth...

Jean, would love to hear what you think :)

Unfortunately Blood Meridian is just gratuitous violence without any character exploration or gripping plot. I think it's McCarthy's worst novel and I am a huge fan of his. Books like "T..."
I have to agree with what you said. I bought it because of the hype. I really enjoyed the borders trilogy by him but this one is just VIOLENCE.
And Invisible Man is on my list. Definitely gonna buy it when I have some money saved for another visit to the bookstore. Its one of my weaknesses, I cant help myself whenever I see good books and I carry my list in my wallet. Every single time I spend more than necessary. But what you're gonna do? Its books :D


I did a reread of Invisible Man, having read it ages ago, but on my second reading I found it dated. I am extremely picky and only rate according to my own personal reaction. Since then so much else has been written in the same vein. Ellison was friends with Richard Wright, so I have decided to reread Native Son. That is waiting for me on my Ipod.

I also had trouble with Sarah's Key. I found the info on the Vel' d'Hiv fascinating, but the modern thread failed completely! I am glad it worked for you though.

Petra wrote: "I just finished reading The Ocean at the End of the Lane and would recommend it. It's quirky, "other worldly", fun and even thought provoking. It is fantasy, with a blend of "real" ..."
I'm "half way" with Gaiman books: some I love - Coraline, some others leave me perplexed ...
I'll see to this then if you say so Petra
I'm "half way" with Gaiman books: some I love - Coraline, some others leave me perplexed ...
I'll see to this then if you say so Petra
Chrissie wrote: "I did a reread of Invisible Man, having read it ages ago, but on my second reading I found it dated. I am extremely picky and only rate according to my own personal reaction. Since then so much else has been written in the same vein. Ellison was friends with Richard Wright, so I have decided to reread Native Son. That is waiting for me on my Ipod. "
Those were the books of my course in angloamerican literature in University, along with Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass and The Autobiography of Malcom X. Extreamly interesting!
Those were the books of my course in angloamerican literature in University, along with Narrative of the Life of Frederick Douglass and The Autobiography of Malcom X. Extreamly interesting!
I read The Invisible Man a few years ago and I really didn't get it. I found it quite boring and I think that was because I found it very dated. Is be tempted to reread now I'm a bit older (I was 18!) and have a greater understanding of the meaning of the text but my memories of struggling through it are putting me off!
Heather wrote: "I read The Invisible Man a few years ago and I really didn't get it. I found it quite boring and I think that was because I found it very dated. Is be tempted to reread now I'm a bit older (I was 1..."
I reread it one year ago with Rowena and I have to admit it IS dated. But I think it express really well how things were back then in the USA, not using a realistic register - which would have been much more easy, like Richard Wright ...
I reread it one year ago with Rowena and I have to admit it IS dated. But I think it express really well how things were back then in the USA, not using a realistic register - which would have been much more easy, like Richard Wright ...

This is important to keep in mind, but since I am not "judging" the value of a book it doesn't usually affect my rating. If I don't like it I don't! I think a four star rating went down to a two for me! SOME books keep their high ratings. They are the wonderful books. Those are the real classics, I think.
I hope I enjoy Native Son as much as I did the first time.

I also had trouble with Sarah's Key. I found the info on the Vel' d'Hiv fascinating,..."
Chrissie, I agree. That is where the book fell short for me - especially as it neared the end.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Red Shoes for Rachel: Three Novellas (other topics)Kindred (other topics)
Kindred (other topics)
Kindred (other topics)
The Promise Girls (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Octavia E. Butler (other topics)Octavia E. Butler (other topics)
Octavia E. Butler (other topics)
Marie Bostwick (other topics)
Deon Meyer (other topics)
More...