All About Books discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
General Archive
>
What have you just read? Opinions, recommendations & reviews
message 901:
by
Kristi
(new)
Dec 09, 2013 07:58AM

reply
|
flag

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...


It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonialism, exploitation not only of human beings but also of the earth.
It is a good book but in some way the spoken language acts like a brake for emotions and feelings. I think that if I hadn't alread seen the movie, I would have missed a lot only reading the book.
All in all I liked the book and the themes in it, but I didn't like a lot the writing style though I know that Celie was illiterate so the spoken language is more credible.
I don't recommend the book but the movie, it is way better in my opinion. Will watch it again as soon as possible.

It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonialism, exploitation not only ..."
Interesting. I read the book when it first came out, before there was a movie, and felt that the book was the better of the two. Thinking about some of the discussion about Their Eyes Were Watching God regarding the dialect (which was similar in many aspects to the way Walker wrote Celie), I wonder if there is a cultural barrier -- perhaps this style of dialogue is more readily understood here in the US (even by my white upper-middle class self) than it would be to people for whom English is a second (or third, or fourth!) language?
Or perhaps not...

It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonialism, exploitat..."
I haven't read it in English. I think in English the spoken language would have been impossible to understand for me (I add here the English edition because so it is easier for everyone to understand the book I have read).
I remember that in the movie the emotions arrived straight to the spectator; in the book they aren't so fluid. The spoken language is more effective in the movie rather than in a book.

It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonialism, exploitat..."
Leslie/Dely...I just added "The Color Purple" to my "to read" list. I thought the movie was brilliant. Dialect can be tricky. I thought "Huckleberry Finn" was a difficult book to make it through because of it. Will have to see here.
dely wrote: "Leslie wrote: "dely wrote: "I have finished The Color Purple by Alice Walker. 3 stars for me.
It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonia..."
The english was not that easy, especially because of the use of "black slang", something like Their Eyes Were Watching God, but the book was really worth the effort!
It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonia..."
The english was not that easy, especially because of the use of "black slang", something like Their Eyes Were Watching God, but the book was really worth the effort!
dely wrote: "I have finished The Color Purple by Alice Walker. 3 stars for me.
It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonialism, exploitation not only ..."
Really? I loved the book, studied it at school so the teacher was pretty much reading it out and we could understand it. Loved how Celie's illiteracy is portrayed.
It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonialism, exploitation not only ..."
Really? I loved the book, studied it at school so the teacher was pretty much reading it out and we could understand it. Loved how Celie's illiteracy is portrayed.

Yes, I think that listen to it is much better. It's because of this that I liked the movie: conversations are more immediate and so also their meaning and the emotions of the characters.

It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonialism, exploitat..."
I read it at school as well and absoultey loved it, I wasn't too bothered about the lanaguage but I know a few of my class mates struggled with it. We watched the film after we'd read it, which is also good, but as with a lot of things I preferred the book.
dely wrote: "I have finished The Color Purple by Alice Walker. 3 stars for me.
It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonialism, exploitation not only ..."
I have had this in my cupboard for ages, might give it a try :)
I finished Allegiant yesterday and would not recommend it, unless you want to die inside.
It is a book full of interesting themes: racism, sexism, religion, discrimination, colonialism, exploitation not only ..."
I have had this in my cupboard for ages, might give it a try :)
I finished Allegiant yesterday and would not recommend it, unless you want to die inside.

I finished Allegiant yesterday and would not recommend it, unless you want to die inside"
LOL!
Jenny wrote: "Becca wrote: "
I finished Allegiant yesterday and would not recommend it, unless you want to die inside"
LOL!"
Haha seriously though I still can't even give it a star rating because I'm so shellshocked!
I finished Allegiant yesterday and would not recommend it, unless you want to die inside"
LOL!"
Haha seriously though I still can't even give it a star rating because I'm so shellshocked!



I'd second that Leslie. It's a good introduction to Tolstoy without having to plod through 800+ page books (although I loved these books)...
Leslie wrote: "I just finished The Death of Ivan Ilych. I would recommend it, but it is a bit of a downer. An excellent introduction to Tolstoy though -short and easy to read!"
I thought I had it in a complete wrks of Tolstoy that I have but today I've discovered it contained only novels!!!!
I'll give a look at my lilbrary; they should have it!!!
I thought I had it in a complete wrks of Tolstoy that I have but today I've discovered it contained only novels!!!!
I'll give a look at my lilbrary; they should have it!!!




Why? Well, me too, I didn't like it a lot so I can understand your rating but I am curious to know your opinions about it.

It tells the story of Changez, a young intelligent Pakistani that goes to the Unites States to study. He is one of the best students and when he finishes university he has a really good job in one of the best firms of New York. He also falls in love with a beautiful American girl.
It seems that all his dreams come true but after the attack to the Twin Towers something is changing inside him. We have his opinions about the Unites States, about Pakistan but above all about his longing to his hometown and his people. He is fought between his career and his inner feelings.
The story is a first person narration because Changez is telling his life to an American sitting in a restaurant in Lahore while they eat together.
It is thought provoking and very interesting. It has an open end but I think this is the perfect end for this book.
Yes, I recommend it.

It tells the story of Changez, a young intelligent Pakistani that goes to the Unites States to study. He is..."
I just saw this was made into a movie -- funny how some things seem to appear everywhere once you start noticing. This is the third encounter I have had with this title in the last 12 hours, having never heard of it before yesterday.

It tells the story of Changez, a young intelligent Pakistani that goes to the Unites States to..."
Didn't know there was a movie. Will look for it!




Now I want to read "The War in the Air" - another of his which I think must be just as prescient! :)


Leslie wrote: "I just finished another Fairacre book -- Miss Clare Remembers. Enjoyable light reading about English country life during Miss Clare's lifetime (1885-1960 or so). The effect of WWI ..."
I didn't know it was about WWI; really looking forward to read it then. Sometimes I find more illuminating books like this for the "sociological picture" of a country in certain historical period than more important "historical novels"
I didn't know it was about WWI; really looking forward to read it then. Sometimes I find more illuminating books like this for the "sociological picture" of a country in certain historical period than more important "historical novels"
Jenny wrote: "Almost forgot to mention: I've finished The Death of Ivan Ilych by Tolstoy yesterday. I read it in two sittings and was truly amazed by it. The title really is the plot, we follow a ma..."
Totally agree: I've finished it right now and found it amazing: in really few pages there are a lot of things!!!!
Totally agree: I've finished it right now and found it amazing: in really few pages there are a lot of things!!!!
Leslie wrote: "I have finally finished Phineas Redux - another wonderful satire from Anthony Trollope! I would recommend it if you like Victorian literature or are a fan of political satire."
Same mind as usual!
Same mind as usual!


On the other hand I think anything might be a bit of a disappointment after Phineas Redux

Harry Frankfurt's essay on bullshit is very interesting: yes, it is called "On bullshit" and it's a piece of 20 pages on bullshit. He explains how he regards the term, and explains different meanings from OED regarding the term and its affiliations. His main point is that bullshit is mainly the state of indifference regarding the state/concept of truth. That means that any statements or actions which are made out of no real or honest connection with the thing that is done, statement that is made, it's bullshit. He even underlines the substantial difference between the liar and the bullshitter. A very good read.
I enjoyed very much my second read as well. I feel a little guilty for the fact that I didn't like "The Great Gatsby" back when I first read it. So I am thinking of re-reading it.
However, this short story of Fitzgerald was very, very intense. It has profound meanings regarding a possible pretty precious life lesson : every time you are mistaken, a fist comes in and saves your good sense by stopping your animal instincts of being or possibly becoming a fully entitled jerk. Fitzgerald's style was supreme, I loved every sentence. Also, the short story in itself is worth reading.
Ps: sorry for not providing links on Goodreads for those titles I mentioned. I'm mobile and it seems rather hard for me to handle that option from this device.

On the other hand I think anything might be a bit of a disappointment after Phineas Redux"
Yes but I had already requested it by interlibrary loan before the decision to postpone was made. {Jean & I both belong to another group which is reading the Inspector Morse series, in case anyone is wondering...}
Ramona wrote: "I finished reading an essay by Harry Frankfurt, "On bullshit" and a short story by F. S. Fitzgerald, "The four fists". It just happens that I would gladly recommend both of my most recent finished ..."
I didn't really like Gatsby all that much when I read it either, I loved the film though and that has encouraged me to maybe give it another chance. I hope you enjoy it better if you reread it. And don't worry about not posting the links, a lot of us are on mobile and can't :)
I didn't really like Gatsby all that much when I read it either, I loved the film though and that has encouraged me to maybe give it another chance. I hope you enjoy it better if you reread it. And don't worry about not posting the links, a lot of us are on mobile and can't :)

It is something like James Herriot's books and it tells of the homeless cats of the cat shelter of the city where I live. It has been written by a voluteer of this cat shelter so the stories aren't well written but the important thing is the content and the stories are touching. In addition to this, the proceeds will go to charity to this cat shelter.
I can't recommend you this one because it has never been translated but I can recommend you to not forget the homeless cats. I'm sure there is a cat shelter in every town and the voluteers always need help: money, food, wood blankets...Don't forget homeless cats and help them in the way you like the most!



Two good ones, just finished, are from 1900, of that light English humorous novel genre, lacking an equivalent today, I think. Both very well known in their day, and first read by me as a teenager in the 1960s in Penguins. Of course all these and similar are free on Amazon Kindle these days.
The Brass Bottle, by F Anstey, about a young architect attending an auction for the Professor-father of the girl he admires, failing to buy the lots required but buying a large oriental brass bottle instead. When he opens it .........
The Wallet of Kai-lung, by Ernest Bramah, one of six or more books of Chinese tales told by the Chinese equivalent of a troubadour, who unrolls his mat, attracts a crowd, and tells (tall) stories involving Mandarins, magicians, dark forests .....
Books of this period are almost always well-written, well-plotted, and entertaining. Not War and Peace, of course, but well worth a go.
I suppose a bit similar to Jerome K Jerome's Three Men in a Boat, which is broader humour, less subtle.
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Red Shoes for Rachel: Three Novellas (other topics)Kindred (other topics)
Kindred (other topics)
Kindred (other topics)
The Promise Girls (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Octavia E. Butler (other topics)Octavia E. Butler (other topics)
Octavia E. Butler (other topics)
Marie Bostwick (other topics)
Deon Meyer (other topics)
More...