Review Group discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Finished rounds
>
GROUP 12
date
newest »


Th..."
Just wanted to say a huge thank you to Ubiquitous for this thoughtful and considered review. Much appreciated. Alison & Sean

https://www.goodreads.com/review/show...

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
Will post to AMZN US/UK
Thanks Jay, KA, and everyone in the group!

And in Round 4, just Glyn, Brannon, A.K., Jennifer, and Philip...
Almost there, folks!

Please remember, if you are going to be late with a review, but are still planning to do it, you must contact your reviewee and let him/her know.
We still have two outstanding reviews (and I don't mean good!) in Round Two, four in Round Three, and five in Round Four.


http://www.goodreads.com/author/show/...
Firstly, let me say that I am not regular reader of fantasy novels. Because of that, this book was way outside my comfort reading zone, and I did contact the author telling him that it would be unfair of me to review his book. I just wasn't grabbed by it.
So, what I have decided to do is to look at the writing, as far as I can, from a fantasy reader's point of view.
The two young characters were well portrayed and almost believable, and where I could follow it and the descriptive passages were succinct enough to follow the storyline. One has to question the apparently random use of capital letters - maybe there was a pattern to this, but I couldn't see it.
For a fantasy addict, it could be be that the omnipotent style of writing was acceptable, but for me there was little depth to it.
I won't be posting this review to Amazon, unless of course you want me to Ubiquitous, as it may appear to be a damning piece, and I don't want it to be that.



http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/...
However, I can't find your review on Goodreads for the Leaving Traces series - please post a link when you can. Thanks, A.K.!

Thanks A.K. and K.A.!



Alison & Sean

Round 2:
Philip
Round 3:
Sandra (?)
Brannon
Jennifer
Philip
Round 4:
Brannon
Jennifer
Philip
Jennifer is the one you're missing, right? Have you tried contacting her via PM? If you have, and you haven't gotten a reply, I'd say you're not going to get one at this point. Several people are missing a review, as is common at the end of one of these rounds, unfortunately.
What people have done in the past is set up a thread in the General and Registered Readers section asking for reviews to fill in where they've been shorted. This usually works pretty well. If you want to do that, we'll see what we can do to get it on the front page for a while.

Round 2:
Philip
Round 3:
Sandra (?)
Brannon
Jennifer
Philip
Round 4:
Brannon
Jennifer
Philip
Jennifer is the one you..."
Hi K.A. Have sent a PM as you suggested.
Alison Lambert Nagle


http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/..."
Thanks Jennifer - really glad you liked the language, pacing and plot. Sorry about the use of the vernacular ....and the sex...
That I think reflects the cultural differences between our countries. We are, after all divided by a common language! Our characters are Brits, Kiwis and Aussies, who do tend to use vernacular and swear words in public more than perhaps Americans do.



They certainly swear a lot in American movies and on my current favourite show, Breaking Bad!:)

Point being, it depends a lot on the American doing the reading, and the American doing the writing, how much cursing is tolerable.

I'm thinking about creating a show called 'Barking Bad', featuring one of my dogs...


I'm thinking about creating a show called 'Barking Bad', featuring one of my dog..."
There's an outfit group called Barking Mad who helped me when the local council tried to fine me for the crime of allowing my dog to swim in the sea on a deserted beach in winter at 6.30am!
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Gone for a Soldier (other topics)The Argument (other topics)
Cherry Wood (other topics)
The Burning of Cherry Hill (other topics)
Yesterday Mourning (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Glyn Smith-Wild (other topics)Philip Maxwell (other topics)
Thanks, everyone. That was my last review for this group. Thanks to K.A. and Jay for giving us this opportunity. I appreciate it.