Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
Whose death made you cry the most?
message 151:
by
Jessica
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 28, 2014 07:00PM
Sirius! I was so excited for Harry, it was like he finally had a parent figure in his life (besides Molly Weasley, etc.) They were just becoming really close and then he was gone! But Fred's was pretty bad too..
reply
|
flag
I cried so hard for Dobby, Sirius Lupin and Tonks all tie for second place.
Bellatrix Lestrange... Just joking, Dobby's death. But the saddest moment was when Hermione was talking about her mum and dad in the forest of dean.
I would say it was a combination of dobbys death as well as freds! but then again remus and tonx were going to have a baby so every death was sad and cry worthy.
For me it was Sirius and Harry. Sirius had finally gotten out of the house and gotten to go fight and feel important and then he went and died. I just felt so bad for Harry too. He had finally gotten a parent someone he could love and claim as his own and then Sirius died and I was just like dang can Harry not have one little thing.
Although I know that Harry didn't permanently stay dead, for those few moments that I thought he was it was so horrible. He had been through so much already and I was so sure that he was going to come out of it alive. I also had to think about how he was feeling and what he was thinking. He loved Dumbledore and to me I would have seen it as his last ultimate betrayal and that's horrible that he had to come to terms with all of that as he went to his death. I cried like a baby when I read that part and I cry every time I read it even though I know now that he's gonna come back.
For me it was Harry's death. The first time I read that part of the book, it was devastating. To think Dumbledore set Harry up to die, and the turmoil Harry went through as the realization of what he had to do hit him...it was a lot to deal with. It was especially hard when he was in the forest, and having his mother walk with him as he went to face Voldemort. Those were IMO some of the most powerful scenes of the whole series, and even though I know Harry survives, it's still hard to read.
In the books I cried a lot in the bit where Harry is in Dumbledores office after Sirius' death and definitely Dobby's death, especially seeing it on the big screen.
In the books, Fred's death hurt me the most. We had already lost so much J.K. why did you have to take Fred too? To do that to his family, especially poor Georgie. Ugh. It's pissing me off just thinking about it.In the movies it was Dobby's death that made me cry. His tiny little body hunched over in the sand, in his shabby little pillowcase. Harry crying. Ron holding Hermione, who had just been tortured. It was one of the saddest moments in the movies.
BookGirl wrote: "I was surprised when I didn't shed tears over any of the deaths but I was extremely upset over Hedwigs. I felt it was so unnecessary."I also agree, 100%.
Hedwig, Dumbledore,dobby,james and lily, lupin, tonks, fred,snape i wouldnt know! i was soo upset when they all died!
Sirius Black, hands down.
sirius and dumbledore
mine was Fred's and Hedwig and Dobbey just thing of them makes me cry
Sirius Black!!! No contest. The only thing close to a family snatched just from within his reach. Made to stay away from him even when he was alive, his death was the most shocking, didn't make me cry though. :"|
omg i totally forgot about him omg Sirius defo who i cried the most hse the reason when i'm reaing arry potter i skip number 5 cause of when he dies
Fred. He is my favorite character that's why I was so sad. I also cried a lot for the little creatures like Hedwig and Dobby. It was obvious somehow that a figure like Snape would die, although I was also sad when he died.
The deaths that made me cry where the ones I felt were completely unnecessary and senseless: Dobby, Colin Creevey (he was just a kid), Fred, Lupin, and Tonks.
Dobby and Fred.... though so many amazing people died! I was practically bawling my eyes out in the cinema!
Meyke wrote: "SIRIUS BLACK"That was a bad one foe me too.
Ruth wrote: "Fred, without a doubt. I cried for poor Molly, whose boggart had shown her family dead, as her worst fear came true. And for George, losing his twin and his best friend."Same here, when Fred died, I had to put the book down for a minute, because I couldn't even see.
The boggart thing reminded me, even in Molly Weasley's worst nightmare, Fred and George were together. When Fred died, it was a nightmare beyond a nightmare come to life.
I can't write anymore or I'll cry again.
Dobby was pretty sad too, but he died a hero's death, Fred didn't even get that much, he died in battle with a tin of other people.
The real question should be "was there a moment during the seventh book you weren't crying?"
I will never cry as much as I cried when Dumbledore died. I also cried (not as much, but still) when Dobby and Fred died.
literally everybody who died i cried at
Dumbledore. I liked him alot. :-( He was too wise to die.
none of them made me cry.. but Fred's death made me really sad.
Fred's.In Order of the Phoenix, Molly sees a Bogart, when it saw her dead family members it shows the twins together...because even in death she can't imagine them apart.
Fred was young, he was in the DA and he was important. I am still not over his death.
Sirius.B and Dobby
Fred and Sirius (They are so funny or so good at pranks)
If we are speaking only of The Deathly Hallows, then I would have to go with my favorite teacher ever, Remus J. Lupin. I found his loss completely unnecessary, considering it only served to turn Harry into Sirius for his young son.Of course, if we are speaking of the entire series, then hands down it would be Sirius, the last person Harry could count as family, because he certainly didn't count the worthless Dursleys! If Voldemort ever went after them, I'm not sure that Harry would feel affected in the slightest. But Alas, Sirius Black! At least he went out with an act of heroism.
Sirius.. and i cried for Fred too I really liked the duo, ie , Fred & George right from the beginning...
it has to be the greatest wizard of all time..a mastermind..dumbeldore.
and dobby too...he was so nice and stayed loyal to Harry even in the end!
Severus Snape. He was so devoted to Lily that he was willing to give his life for her son. Oh look, my eyes are sweating again.
Rosie wrote: "Severus Snape. He was so devoted to Lily that he was willing to give his life for her son. Oh look, my eyes are sweating again."That is so sweet, aww
message 200:
by
Tana Lovegood of Dumbledore's Army✞~
(last edited Jul 18, 2014 12:55PM)
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Fred, definitely Fred :( Also Bellatrix because I CRIED TEARS OF JOY
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
