Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
Whose death made you cry the most?
message 51:
by
Julia
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Nov 30, 2012 08:02AM
Sirius. Ever since going to Hogwarts Harry had been surrounded by figures that were nurturing and parent-like...but it was the first time Harry felt like he had family back, Sirius did all he could to ensure Harry's safety, along with advocate for him and understand him at a time when even who he was around at Hogwarts didn't understand as much. Sirius was empathetic and a real person Harry could feel candid around, who never doubted Harry for a minute or withheld serious informatio. He was like a Father who treated Harry the way Harry desperately wanted to be treated. All of the deaths were sad, but my heart broke when Sirius was killed.
reply
|
flag
Fred because of the Weasley's reaction and how hard it would be for George to carry on. What was one without the other? And Hedwig. I think because it was so shocking at the very beginning. It made me realize she was really serious and characters were going to die. It was going to be bad.
Dobby and Severus Snape...
Fred, Remus and Tonks.
Me too! Honestly i cried for everyone.
dumbledore and dobby
Fred Weasley. he's my favorite character and always will be :'( ughhhh i'm crying now just thinking about it.....
Dobby, and Sirius Black
no doubt fred and dobby
I read HBP on a PC - my cousin's ebook. And bawled when Dumbledore whispered 'Please'.I sobbed when Dobby's eyes turned into glassy orbs in Harry's arms.
I cried when Fred collapsed, his face permanently frozen in a smile. It just about killed me narrating that part to my kid brothers - they are twins too...
I cried for them; and my heart ached for Hedwig, for Colin, for Lupin and Tonks. JK had a field day collecting broken hearts...
Sirius Black mostly, because his whole lie seemed so unfair to him. He was the odd one in his family, never got on with them, got thrown out, his bro becomes death eater and then goes missing, his best friends killed and he's blamed for it, spends a long time in prison, mad with grief, comes out of jail only to live in hiding and being taunted by his arch nemesis for cowardice and then dies at the hand of his evil, nasty cousin. And his name is not even cleared from the crime he did not commit. Phew, that's a little too much, isn't it??
The only happy time he had in his life would be his school years, that seemed really unfair. I just couldn't accept his death. He was like a bright flame that burned out too fast... :'(
And of course, i really didn't want Fred to die, too. Poor George...
DOBBY. :( and also Fred!
FREEDDD!!!!!!! :( :( :( ;(
I liked Dobby too, but he was happy, he died as a free elf.... Its just different. Sirius' death was so unfair. He should've been given a chance at happiness...
also fred and sirius
Fred made me cry alot. To me he was my HP book crush. When Sirius died I was sad, but even more so when Snape died.
kind of ironic that snape is supposed 2 b a bad guy but he was the 1 that most people r the most sad bout(and yes, i know that snape isn't actually a bad guy)
Fred... Dobby... Hedwig... just--every death that happened was very heart-breaking!!!!! HP series are the books that are always worth the long reads! :( It just breaks my heart all over again!
Mostly all exept Voldemort.......... DEATH TO VOLDEMORT!
Kynzie wrote: "Mostly all exept Voldemort.......... DEATH TO VOLDEMORT!"so mean :)
Sirius and Dumbledore. Harry's father figures :(
in chronological order...Hedwig
Dobby
Fred
Severus Snape
Dobby, Fred and Snape!
The only time I cried reading this book was when Harry went into the forest. During the movie, that part choked me up, but I really, really cried when Snape was holding Lily's body. I still can't watch that scene without crying, no matter how many times I've seen it now.
Sirius Black. But when Fred died, I just felt numb--no feeling. It was too painful to even feel!
Angeline wrote: "Sirius Black. But when Fred died, I just felt numb--no feeling. It was too painful to even feel!"kind of the same for me
SnapeDobby
Fred
:'(
DH:Snape and Fred, Dobby just got on my nerves. OOTP:Sirius
I cried most when Sirius died. :(
I did not cry but I was very upset for Fred and Dobby.. and Remus and Tonks too I guess
I didn't crie for any of them.But if I were to pick,it would be Harry(although he didn't actually die)and Fred.:(Also Remus and Tonks.Heck all of the deaths are sad(except for Voldemort,Belatrix and all the other death eater deaths.);)
The only deaths I didn't regret were those of Voldemort and other Death Eaters. Everyone else made my eyes at least a bit moist and put a lump in my throat.
I did not get to attached to any character as to go to the extent of crying.But Fred and Dobby were the most enjoyable and loyal/innocent, respectfully, and those were the saddest for me.
Dobby. He was one of my two favorite characters. I almost never cry while reading, and I cried when Dobby died. And I cry every time that I reread that part.
The Death of Dobby. I seriously creid buckets. His death is due to unconditional love, loyalty and bravery. It was to protect Harry and his friends, even if he had to sacrifice himself.
DEFINITELY Dumbledore and Sirius. For one, I felt like Sirius had so much to offer if he had just stayed in the book longer! =( I remember in the third book he offered Harry to stay with him one day, and I was sooo excited for that one day. I felt so happy to know that Harry had a "parent" in a sense - and he felt like he was his parent too. As for Dumbledore, I was totally not expecting that so it was unreal! But I'm thankful that he had impacted Harry's life while he was alive as much as he could. I'm happy that he is in the majority of the novels. :)
Headwig, Fred, and Dobby. Also Remus and Tonks because poor little Teddy was left alone.
dobby for certain and Lupin and Tonks also...sucked....a lot...
Freds and dobby ='(
Fred! he is like a friend through out the whole series. I grew up with him and the whole gang. Losing Fred affected me the most.
Severus! I cried as hard as I did when I watched Titanic. The memory of his childhood with Lily, James making fun of him and "After all this time?" "Always" line totally got me.
Fred. No question.
Lupin and Tonks no question! I was really sad for fred and mad eye moody too though. I always had a thing for mad eye... :(
And the death of hedwig was sooo unnecessary...that made me sad too.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
