Harry Potter and the Deathly Hallows
discussion
Whose death made you cry the most?
message 1:
by
[deleted user]
(new)
Nov 07, 2012 05:49PM
For me, it's Dobby, no contest.
reply
|
flag
i found Harry's walk into the woods to meet Voldemort to be the most affecting, when he asked his mum to stay close to him even if he couldn't see her i got choked upand the moment earlier in the book when he gave mrs weasly a hug on his birthday and "tried to put so many things into the hug" - that was a sweet moment
but i realise both are parental moments, and i'm a parent
Sushma wrote: "Harry's parents"haha they were always dead?
Severus Snape.
It has to be Albus Dumbledore!!! I frigging hated Snape for that! But in 7th part when it is revealed that it was all part of the plan and Snape was all along playing by Dumbledore's orders - it seemed a little unreal to me!!!!!!!!!
So wait... are we discussing the entire Harry Potter series? Or just DH? Because Sirius and Dubledore died in earlier novels, whereas Harry's parents were dead the entire series. Really, way too many amazing characters died for me to pick the one that affected me the most. Fred, Tonks, Lupin, Dobby, Severus (dwelving into earlier novels)Dumbleddore, Sirius, and yes, even Hedwig, were all very sad deaths for me. (I am aware Hediwg died in the 7th book) Anyway, I really was quite sad to see so many people die, especially since some of them were my favorites.
I didn't cry at any of the deaths, or the entire series for that matter :/
in the book it was Dobby but in the movie it was Snape. i cried for both
Fred, without a doubt. I cried for poor Molly, whose boggart had shown her family dead, as her worst fear came true. And for George, losing his twin and his best friend.
Snape. And I loved the whole chapter about Lily and Severus when they were kids.
Fred Weasley, Sirius Black, Severus Snape, Tonks, Lupin and Dobby!
Sandyboy wrote: "i found Harry's walk into the woods to meet Voldemort to be the most affecting, when he asked his mum to stay close to him even if he couldn't see her i got choked upand the moment earlier in the..."
The moment Harry walks into the woods and asks his mother to stay is the one of the most heart wrenching moments I have ever experienced in a book! I cry just thinking about it! The other moment would be Severus Snape, when he asks Harry to look at him I just lose it!
Fred, twins really hit home with me....
Jocelyn wrote: "For me, it's Dobby, no contest."i cried in that part both in the book and the movie very emotional.
i cried a lot during many of the deaths in the series lol
I was heartbroken when Fred died. The idea of losing your twin and best friend like that makes me choke up still. Also I was outraged when they killed Hedwig. And Sirius. Having no family and then finding some and then losing them again just sounds absolutely horrible for anyone, especially a child, to go through.
If I am honest when reading the series it was Dumbledores death that undid me... but at that point I was really really into the books so by the time DH came out I was a bit fed up with the delay and felt the book wasn't as good as I had imagined it would be (nothing against Rowling at all).In regards to the movies I must admit Dobbys death does get me, as does the Weasley twin and Severus.
Cedric affected me the most. They way Harry held on and carried him out ... . Then Snape.
Sirius Black!!! Dumbledore too, but seing that it was all part of a plan it effected me less than Sirius...
probably dobbys.
severus!and tonks and lupin :'( and dobby and fred!
Snape, Lupin and Fred. And Dobby. All of them. Voldy
tonks and lupin wasnt that sad in the books. I cried so much woht fred and dobby though.
Snape!! And the whole part of the story where you find out about him and Lily and that he was a good man all along, beautiful! Has stayed with me to this day <3
Hedwig. Her death was the death of the little boy Harry once was. After that he had to take on all the responsibilities that come with growing up and for Harry that included Voldemort.
Definitely Snape :(
So many sad ones! I agree that when Harry walked into the woods to die, the conversation with his mom got me. But the actual deaths, either Sirius, or Dobby. Both loved Harry so fiercely, that when they were taken, it hurt.
Ruth wrote: "Fred, without a doubt. I cried for poor Molly, whose boggart had shown her family dead, as her worst fear came true. And for George, losing his twin and his best friend."<Me too! You took the words right out of my mouth.
Fred, Remus, Snape, Sirius, and Dobby.. :(
FredFredFredFred!The separation of the two forever-together Twins was too much for me :'(. They were SO cool together! The thought kills me. Why did Rowling have to do that to us?!
LoveFredAndGeorgeForever. :)
Dumbledore for certain, but also when Fred died was hard.
From DH, it has to be Dobby and Snape, but overall I am never ever gonna recover from Sirius death, I cried for days.
In the books, Dumbledore. I know we spent WEEKS trying to figure out how he was faking his death.In the movies, I cried hardest with Sirius and Snape and Cedric. Well done scenes.
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
