Strangeattractor
asked
Lois McMaster Bujold:
What helps with figuring out how to tell a type of story that isn't told often? For example, when you were working on the Sharing Knife books and realized you had set up demographic and long-term problems that your characters would tackle in books 3 and 4, what helped you come to grips with how to do it? How did you bridge the gap between wanting to write a story with an unusual shape and actually doing it?
Lois McMaster Bujold
The short answer is whining, lots of whining, but more seriously, there is a certain inherent orneriness in picking unusual plot shapes or protagonists, a kind of low mutter of "I'll show them!" After the initial set-up, I do have to write my way into my books scene by scene, and let the story itself show me where it's going and how it's going to get there. I don't know how much suspense this creates for the readers, but it certainly creates suspense for me.
So there isn't exactly a gap to bridge. There is wanting, and there is doing. There really isn't an in-between state that isn't just more wanting. (Or whining.) "Planning" for me is diffuse, broken into small bites and spread throughout the whole of the doing.
In other words, at the working face I am never writing a novel. I am writing, at most, a scene (and then another, etc.) Or half a scene, or a paragraph, or whatever functional unit I can actually hold in my brain at one time.
But, certainly, there seems not much point in writing a story just like everyone else's, because they've already done that. I could just read theirs, for a lot less trouble. (Which is not quite the same thing as taking a trope or idea that delights me from the genre cornucopia off to a corner to play with my way. I certainly do that.)
Ta, L.
So there isn't exactly a gap to bridge. There is wanting, and there is doing. There really isn't an in-between state that isn't just more wanting. (Or whining.) "Planning" for me is diffuse, broken into small bites and spread throughout the whole of the doing.
In other words, at the working face I am never writing a novel. I am writing, at most, a scene (and then another, etc.) Or half a scene, or a paragraph, or whatever functional unit I can actually hold in my brain at one time.
But, certainly, there seems not much point in writing a story just like everyone else's, because they've already done that. I could just read theirs, for a lot less trouble. (Which is not quite the same thing as taking a trope or idea that delights me from the genre cornucopia off to a corner to play with my way. I certainly do that.)
Ta, L.
More Answered Questions
Sybal Janssen
asked
Lois McMaster Bujold:
"Hallowed Hunt" is rapidly becoming one of my favorite books; I've read, and reread it about three times in the last six weeks. You are so deft in the way you unfold a story about character from "left field" becoming the tool for restoring order to a system that became unbalanced through a misguided use of power. Since a question is required, did "Hallowed Hunt" draw some inspiration from shamanistic practices?
Kate Davenport
asked
Lois McMaster Bujold:
Just gobbled up the Physicians of Vilnoc. Thank you. But I wondered, when divesting himself of chaos, couldn't Penric rot a condemned building from the top down or kill and rot a tree? (a wistful thought for me since I have several volunteer maples I will need to hire an arborist to remove) It would seem less efficient, but also less fraught.
About Goodreads Q&A
Ask and answer questions about books!
You can pose questions to the Goodreads community with Reader Q&A, or ask your favorite author a question with Ask the Author.
See Featured Authors Answering Questions
Learn more




