4.07 avg rating — 771 ratings

"Does Alabaster actually have an angel following her? Or is she just a murderer? Tonally much darker than Supernatural but if you enjoy outsider PoV fic that starts with the Winchesters being murderers, this might be the character for you. "

3.86 avg rating — 18,639 ratings

"Seanan literally started this series to avenge Jo's death (https://seananmcguire.tumblr.com/post... // https://seananmcguire.tumblr.com/post...) "

3.81 avg rating — 19,968 ratings

"If you dig around on tumblr, you will discover this is SPN fic with the serial numbers filed off and gender swapped. "

3.83 avg rating — 7,698 ratings

"Ramiel bears a passing resemblance to another angel, but he at least doesn't get sent to super-hell, just regular hell where the rest of the found family lives (including love interest) in the library and archives there. Second book but if you want to skip to the good bit with the love interest and found family, this is the book for you. "

3.99 avg rating — 49,046 ratings

"Third in a trilogy, so you should read the others first, but this is where the gay payoff happens. The series as a whole is more female-focused but Holly Black does good faerie folklore based stories. "

4.06 avg rating — 5,944 ratings

"Gay angels (inasmuch as Gaiman's neuter but present as male-ish can), avenging angels and murder? Tonally outmatches Supernatural "

3.96 avg rating — 11,061 ratings

"Carrying on from Silver in the Wood, we go on a proper case with Tobias, Silver and Mrs Adela Silver and things get eerie."

3.70 avg rating — 6,600 ratings

"Demons and angels playing the long game with humans. If you're sore about Good Omens, this will heal you."

4.24 avg rating — 108,574 ratings

"Queerness, death, the wide and varied and combined different Latinx beliefs and cultures, and family issues. Much happier than SPN (and a lot of my recs) but a good choice if you'd like a 'what about hunters from other cultures?' type of story."

3.98 avg rating — 23,786 ratings

"The son of a practical folklorist buys a manor house and befriends the local Green Man.
Later, his mum has to come investigate. "

4.20 avg rating — 32,349 ratings

"Reclusive families bound up in supernatural tradition and magic. The queerness is more about not fitting in gender norms (and general no fitting in) but squint and you'll find some. "

really liked it 4.00 avg rating — 19,498 ratings

"In an alternate 1912 where a cleric opened up a portal that let through djinn and beings that call themselves angels, Fatma el-Sha’arawi is a special investigator tasked with solving crimes relating to these supernatural beings. Badass with a penchant for British suits, she stops the world from ending and also gains a girlfriend in this novella. "

4.01 avg rating — 100,805 ratings

"Siblings, terrible parenting, attempted murder and fae, in-between, worlds. Darker than SPN and a lot more British."

3.59 avg rating — 4,825 ratings

3.97 avg rating — 17,670 ratings

3.96 avg rating — 1,924 ratings

"Get your gay faeries here. The rest of the series is also good, though much more focused on the female characters and the power they hold. "

3.87 avg rating — 541 ratings

4.31 avg rating — 79,528 ratings

4.25 avg rating — 824,283 ratings

"Look, everyone knows that SPN cribbed bits from Neil Gaiman in the early series. You might as well read the ones which have gay angels in them."

4.27 avg rating — 84,781 ratings

4.53 avg rating — 80,842 ratings

"Two (not stated to be gay but definitely 'companions' to each other) angels end up running hell. Read the rest of Sandman as well. "

3.70 avg rating — 64,069 ratings

"The gay faeries show up here, flirting with each other via an intermediary. Dark, but with the female lead is not as gay as it could be if it had been published ten years later. "

4.10 avg rating — 990,220 ratings

"Again, everyone knows that SPN cribbed bits from Neil Gaiman in the early series. This one is explicitly about belief and religion and the way America changes those things."