This is the list for your recommendations of good fiction set in a time before the author was born --NOT any old book set in a time that's now past, nor books about modern people who happen to be researching the past! :-) Okay? (Also, let's NOT include alternate world scenarios --just actual settings.)
Tags:
fiction, historical-fiction
Werner
2334 books
205 friends
205 friends
Susanna - Censored by GoodReads
3386 books
851 friends
851 friends
Bettie
15674 books
19 friends
19 friends
Cheryl Niepomnik
1 book
46 friends
46 friends
Armamix
1342 books
69 friends
69 friends
Anam
621 books
3 friends
3 friends
Laura
13062 books
316 friends
316 friends
Pokątnik Złowieszczek
8198 books
356 friends
356 friends
More voters…
Comments Showing 1-50 of 77 (77 new)
message 1:
by
Seth
(new)
Jun 21, 2010 02:58PM
Several of these don't seem to fit the requirement of "set before the author was born." Should some librarian go through and prune, or just live with it?
reply
|
flag
Seth, I'm the list's creator/moderator (and also a Goodreads librarian); but because of limited time, I don't monitor it as closely as I probably should, and I also haven't read a number of the listed books, so can't make that kind of call in most of those cases. I'll give it a going-over now, and delete anything I see that shouldn't be there; but maybe any other librarians who read this will want to help, too? Thanks for letting us know about the problem!
I'm happy to note any books that don't seem right (1984 by Orwell springs to mind... certainly not *historical* to him!). I'm a librarian as well but I don't want to go removing people's votes from a list without either consensus or the list creator approving.
Yes, 1984 was one of the five books I just deleted. I jotted down four more titles with 20th- century settings that are "iffy," but I'll need to check the author's birthdates; and I'll be leaving on vacation tomorrow for a week, so can't do that until I return. In the meantime, Seth, you have my permission to remove anything that you know was set in the author's own time; I created this list for genuine historical fiction, in the genre sense!
Ones that are not historical fiction, in my view:Little Women, by Louisa May Alcott (set in 1860s and 70s, LMA was born in 1832)
Fatherland, by Robert Harris (I am very dubious. Hitler wasn't still Fuhrer in our 1961.)
What is the What? by Dave Eggers (set in very recent Sudan)
The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn (Set, I believe, in the 1850s, when Mr. Twain was a riverboat pilot on the Mississippi.)
Susanna, thanks for your helpful feedback! (And sorry I took so long to respond; you posted on the day I left on vacation, and I haven't been back long.) Someone else must have deleted the Eggers book, and I evidently got Little Women when I went through the list last week; but I can't believe I missed Huckleberry Finn! I've just deleted that one, and the Harris book as well.
Is Am I Not A Man? The Dred Scott Story history, or historical fiction? It looks like history to me from the description, but I haven't read it.
Susanna, I have the same question, but I haven't read it either. I'll do some more checking on that!
Susanna, the Library of Congress' assigned subject headings for the Shurtleff book identify it as fiction, and so does the catalog record for it in World Catalog. So I'd say that it does belong here.
I didn't think The Jungle was historical fiction; didn't Sinclair set that novel in his own time?ETA: Northanger Abbey is historical fiction??
No, Susanna, neither of those are historical fiction! I haven't checked over this list lately; I see I need to do that ASAP. Since I posted clear guidelines at the top, when I created the list, for what goes on it and what doesn't, I never expected a problem; but I guess not everybody actually reads that part. (Sigh!)
Well, I'm a Twilight series fan myself; but if anyone tries to claim it's historical fiction and puts it on here, either of us that catches it can delete it on sight! :-) Okay, I've deleted the two books you spotted, as well as What Is the What and Elie Wiesel's Night. (I didn't check the last two pages this time, but hopefully they're free of any anomalies.) I'll try to do a more thorough check later.
I think I also saw North and South by Mrs. Gaskell on here; I am dubious about that one as well. Written in 1855; set, I think, a little earlier than that (like a lot of Dickens), but within the author's lifetime (b. 1810). (The same reason I didn't vote for Vanity Fair, a superb novel.)
Susanna, I've checked over the rest of the list, and Vanity Fair was apparently deleted already. North and South is on here; but it turns out to be the one by John Jakes (set during the Civil War), not the one with the same title by Mrs. Gaskell. So, we're in good shape for the moment!
Thanks for the heads-up, Bill. I've just tracked it down and deleted it --again. (Sigh!) It's a never-ending job.
I just spotted The Hunger Games number 343 which needs to be deleted.
Werner wrote: "Done! Thanks for catching that, Alice."
I was going down the list last night to see what I missed.
I was going down the list last night to see what I missed.
I see Pride and Prejudice has crept on (currently #51). Miss Austen was writing about her own time. You want me to delete it, Werner?ETA: Also, Seabiscuit (#69) is non-fiction. As is John Paul Jones: Finding the Forgotten Patriot (#177).
Little Women is back, at #96.
Yes, Susanna, you can delete all four of those! Thanks for your help; it's much appreciated. (Tending to these lists is like keeping a garden weeded; it's a never-ending task!)
That's not historical fiction either; Harper Lee was born in 1926, and sets the novel in the mid-1930s, when she was about Scout's age. I'll delete that one too, Susanna, thanks for catching it!
How on Earth is the entire Saxon Stories series by Bernard Cornwell on this list, but none of the Sharpe series?
You could add them; it's easy to add books to lists. At the top of the list, at the tab next to "all votes."
Yes, Peter, by all means add the Sharpe series, if you've read the books and can recommend them! My guess is that whoever added the Saxon series hadn't read the Sharpe books --I haven't either, though I've seen and really liked a couple of the adaptations on DVD. (I do have the first three books of yet another Cornwell series, his Starbuck Chronicles, on my to-read shelf; they were a gift from my son-in-law.)
I am a great fan of historical fiction. Its my favorite genre along with family saga's. Glad I found this list. It would be my pleasure to contribute to this list and learn from it as well.Werner and Susanna, you two seem to be doing a great. I would like to help as well.
I was quite surprised not to see Kane and Abel on the list. So I added that. Its one of my favorites of all time.
Thanks for the encouragement, Ankit! Yes, by all means add any good historical fiction you've read that you'd like to recommend to others; that's how this list (and other lists on here) get built up. (You don't need anybody's permission to add books to a Goodreads list. :-) )
Misfit wrote: "Susanna wrote: "I'm just shocked Twilight hasn't crept on."It will eventually :p"
That is hilarious, but sadly true!
Jeannie HudsonJeannie HudsonThis my own historical suspense. One of the best! No
kidding. I have the reviews to prove it.
Jeannie, if you think your book(s) should be on this list, go ahead and add it. Any member of Goodreads can add books to lists, as well as vote for ones that are already here.I've never read The Red Tent, though it's been recommended to me. But hopefully some of the other people who've commented on this list have!
Hello~Wanted to mention a revised reading list that folks might enjoy. It is a Historical Fiction Series list. It is lengthy and well organized into various sections (military, nautical, ancient world, family saga, set in Europe....).
I'm putting this link out there with enthusiastic hopes that someone(s) will discover a new series to dive into!
http://1mpages.com/HistoricalFiction....
I scrolled through the first 500 on this list, surprised not to find anything by Susanna Gregory (two great historical series - one set in the mid 1300's in Cambridge, England and another series during restoration England) or Paul Doherty (loved his series set around 1300 featuring crime fighter working for the king, Hugh Corbett)
Mitch, anytime you find a Goodreads list that's lacking some books you think should be there, you can add them! Any Goodreads member can do that; you don't have to be the list creator, or a Goodreads librarian. I haven't read any of Gregory's or Doherty's books myself (and I only add books to lists if I've read them), but I'm sure they'll be worthy additions for this list.
Related News
The friends-to-lovers plot is a familiar trajectory, in fiction and in life. It’s a path to good times! And bad times. And, as many can attest,...
Anyone can add books to this list.











