From the Bookshelf of Nothing But Reading Challenges…

Fangirl

Rainbow Rowell

Start date: August 22, 2014

Finish date: August 30, 2014

Discussion: Books of the Month

Why we're reading this: To get to the discussion, CLICK HERE

We voted and you picked this one as the Young Adult BOM. …more
[close] To get to the discussion, CLICK HERE

We voted and you picked this one as the Young Adult BOM.

Find A Copy At

Group Discussions About This Book

Showing 2 of 163 topics — 23,372 comments total

Books of the Month

* The Names by Florence Knapp - Sep 25 Adult / Non-Fiction BOM (starts 16 Sep)
By Moderators of… , Challenger-in-Chief · 12 posts · 76 views

last updated 16 hours, 38 min ago

* The Covenant of Water by Abraham Verghese - Sep 25 Theme BOM - South and South East Asia (Starts 5 September)
By Moderators of… , Challenger-in-Chief · 35 posts · 68 views

last updated Sep 12, 2025 09:26PM

showing 10 of 226 topics view all »

What Members Thought

Mar 20, 2019 Vanessa Gayle ⚔️ Fangirl Faction rated it it was amazing

Shelves: cover-love, romance, new-adult, reviewed, contemporary, favorites, own-physical-read, uno-challenge

Disclaimer: This review MAY contain spoilers.

This book is bloody brilliant! Truly magnificent! I was so hooked on reading this that I took a sick day at work just so that I could finish reading it in one sitting.

I really connected with the main character more than most I read about. There were so many parallels between the main character, Cath, and myself that it felt like this book was about me or written specifically for me. I am from Omaha, Nebraska just like the main character and the autho Disclaimer: This review MAY contain spoilers.

This book is bloody brilliant! Truly magnificent! I was so hooked on reading this that I took a sick day at work just so that I could finish reading it in one sitting.

I really connected with the main character more than most I read about. There were so many parallels between the main character, Cath, and myself that it felt like this book was about me or written specifically for me. I am from Omaha, Nebraska just like the main character and the author so I got every single Omaha, Lincoln, or Nebraska reference. Every single place mentioned is one that I have been to. Cath even lived in South Omaha, a predominantly Mexican part of Omaha, which is where I have lived most of my life as well. The taco trucks, the blizzard/weather, the stores and gas stations, and restaurants mentioned, and even the bookstore that they all went to at the end of the book when the last Simon Snow book was released are all places that are real for me and that have meaning for me so I felt extra connected to the story and to Cath's character. Even the parts of Cath that had nothing to do with geography were significant for me. Cath's anxiety, her love for a book fandom, the fanfiction, her father's bipolar disorder, the way that Cath deals with her mother issues, just all of her is so like me that it's scary. I truly loved her character and her story.

The cast of supporting characters was so delightful. I loved each and every character in this story. Each character had a purpose and brought so much to the story. I love how flawed these characters were. Rowell had no qualms about making these characters as real as possible with imperfections, weaknesses, and bad habits. These are, of course, balanced out with very positive character attributes, but the inclusion of the not so good ones makes me appreciate the characters, the story, and the author even more. Most authors like to have what I refer to as shiny characters. Essentially, characters that are blindingly beautiful and can do no wrong. Perfect. And no one is perfect. This is one thing in literature that I think authors can struggle with because authors love their characters like their own children and can't bring themselves to portray them in a negative way. Rowell's characters felt extremely real.

A lot of contemporary YA stories have the same plots rehashed in different ways, but the plot of this story is utterly unique. And the story is truly captivating. It caters to nerds like myself. The story has a very beautiful and realistic portrayal of nerd culture. At least the facet of nerd culture concerning fanfiction. As a book nerd and a reader and writer of fanfiction myself, I felt the story very accurately illustrated this part of nerd culture. And it was so very exciting to read about it since it isn't something that I've seen done before. It is always empowering and invigorating to feel represented. And this book definitely represents me. Apart from the subject matter of the story, I also very much loved the sequence of events and the main character's journey. The story is told so beautifully and honestly.

Overall, I was really blown away by this book. It captivated me from the first page. Everything about it is magical. I have never reread a contemporary story before, but this is one that I know I will revisit in the future. I can now certify that I am a Rainbow Rowell fan for life. She has written a story that has truly left a mark upon my soul and has spoken to me unlike any book has before. This book is special and I urge everyone to experience its glory.

More reviews on my blog: Novel Nerd Faction ...more

9 likes · Like · see review

Jan 29, 2015 Michelle rated it really liked it

Shelves: reviewed, 2015, choice-awards-2013

It's official; I love Rainbow Rowell. This is the third book I have read by her and I can safely say now that I love her work. She writes realistic, flawed characters and I always feel like I can relate. Her relationships have rung true for me in all three books. And while I don't write fan fiction, I can completely understand Cath's social anxiety and just plain being an introvert. When you find yourself nodding your head to scenes as you read, you know you have found the right author for you. ...more

3 likes · Like · see review

Jan 01, 2014 Seahorse Library rated it really liked it

Shelves: genre-ya, genre-romance, genre-contemporary, on-my-bookshelf

See more reviews at Words Read & Written

I enjoyed this, I read it in one sitting. But I don’t think I’d ever read it again. I don’t think I’d even buy it for my bookshelf.

Why?

I just hated Cath. She bugged me. She’s so bland and boring and introverted and reading about her just made me realise how all the books I really like, have female characters that are fierce and driven and… not completely and utterly (as Cath’s roommate called her) pathetic.

I mean, kudos for the author for writing a char ...more

1 like · Like · see review

Nov 04, 2013 Morgan rated it liked it · review of another edition

Shelves: audiobook, fiction, young-adult, geek-appeal

This isn't about 'fangirlS' plural or fandom in general. This is about one fangirl who writes a bunch of slash fanfic about a series that is about teenage wizards--but isn't Harry Potter.

It's not even in a world where Harry Potter doesn't exist. The wizarding world doesn't even seem very interesting at all:

- The spells are super lame. (Presto changeo? Really?)
- There are wizards and vampires and MERWOLFS mentioned? Like...werewolf/mermaids? (I listened to the audio so I might be off base on how ...more

Like · see review