ClaireB’s Comments (group member since Jul 06, 2014)

ClaireB’s comments from the Nothing But Reading Challenges group.

Act 2 Scene 6

(view spoiler)[ I love Scorpius. His firendship with Albus warms my heart. The perfect bromance.

I know some people have accused this book of queerbaiting, but I don't see it like that. For 1, Scorpius is clearly infatuated with Rose (btw his little attempts at flirting/getting her attention are really funny). And 2, Is it not possible anymore to have strong friendly feelings for someone without it being interpreted as romance?
Sure they would make a cute couple. But I don't read this particular play this way. (hide spoiler)]

That's all I'm able to read this morning. I'll come back to it this evening.

Chapter 3

Monty: (view spoiler)[ I think his forced exile is so unfair. He shot a pedophile. It shouldn't matter that it was a wolf girl he saved in the process. What about the 6 other victims. shouldn't Monty get some credit for that? (hide spoiler)]

Act 1 Scene 11

(view spoiler)[That scene with the Old Trolley Witch is so bizarre. I don't know if I can believe something like that would ever happen in the Harry Potter universe. For some reason, it sounds to me like a scene Rick Riordan would write. (hide spoiler)]

Act 1 Scene 9

(view spoiler)[ Same here. I can't believe Harry would say that about his son. "I wish he was more like James". Nope. I refuse that statement. Luckily, Albus was not around to hear it. (hide spoiler)]

Act 1 Scene 7

(view spoiler)[And we get to the worst scene ever. I was absolutely dreading it. I just hate it. So much.

That Albus tells Harry Harry he'd rather not be his son is horrible BUT kinda comprehensible. He's an angry teenager with daddy issues. He's got trouble dealing with the expectation people have of his because of his parentage. But that Harry would say that ! I just cannot believe it. It's the worst thing a father could say to his son. I just hate it.

Harry wants to give Albus his old blanket, the last item he has left of his mother. While it has a huge sentimental value, he should have known a 14 year old would not exactly be thrilled to get that. certainly not when his brother gets the invisible cloak... (hide spoiler)]

Act 1 Scene 4

(view spoiler)[ Quite honestly, my favorite thing about the play is Scorpius. He's such a sweetheart.
But the rumors around him are ridiculous. How anyone could ever believe that is beyong me!

Also, poor Albus. The pressure of being Harry Potter's son must be stiffling. I can't believe how everyone is treating him, just because he's a Slytherin. Especially Polly Chapman. She's horrible. But Rose and James also have some part in it.
The last sentence of scene 4 breaks my heart.


little side note. I find it interesting that Harry calls Draco by his first name. I wonder how that happened. (hide spoiler)]

Judy wrote: "✿ Claire ✿ ~ The Clever Berry wrote: "Starting today. The first time I read it, I really liked it. But I wonder now if it was just out of nostalgia, seeing the characters again for the first time i..."

yes I know... (view spoiler)[ between the time traveling plot (there are always things that don't work with this kind of plot) and the personality changes (particularly Ron and Harry) there's a lot that makes no sense... I'm dreading a particular scene between Harry and Albus... I'm sure you know which I'm talking about. (hide spoiler)]

Starting today. The first time I read it, I really liked it. But I wonder now if it was just out of nostalgia, seeing the characters again for the first time in so long. Since then I've read a few reviews. I lot of them were quite negative... And some of it made sense to me...
So this time I'm going in with a more critical mind BUT I still intend to enjoy this.

Finished!

(view spoiler)[I can't say I was really surprised by the conclusion, having seen the tv show. But I can say I was shocked at how Lemuel dealt with the problem. I don't think it happened this way exacty in the show. I believe they should have handed the kid to the police.
about that kid. What a psycho. The way she smiles at the thought of the death of Creek's dog and of Audrey gave me chills. No remorse whatsoever.

Overall I really liked it, although I thought it was a bit slow. In comparison the tv show is so much more action packed. I also wished we could see more of Manfred's psychic gifts. We got barely anything at all in this book. (hide spoiler)]

Midnight Crossroad (Midnight, Texas #1)
by Charlaine Harris

Date Read: 03/06/18
Pages: 384
BOM/BR? Yes Link to thread
Characters: Manfred, Bobo Winthrop, Fiji Cavanaugh, Olivia Charity, Lemuel, Aubrey, Xylda, Arthur Smith, Price Eggleton,

chapter 31

Mr Snuggly: (view spoiler)[haha, that cat makes me laugh. "I can talk, woo-hoo". He's so sassy. And with all the mess that's going on, he has the gut to ask for some salmon for after his nap. LOL (hide spoiler)]

Chapter 23

Bobo: (view spoiler)[It's nice for once to have a man capable of recognizing when he needs help. and even better, that he could use the help of women (Olivia or Fiji). No macho nonsense. Thank you ! (hide spoiler)]

Laura wrote: "HI Claire! Welcome!

I think we are going to be treated to more of those "hair" conversations!"

thanks !

looking forward to the banter !

Devann wrote: "I feel like if you read this one first though then the actually first book would kind of pointless since [spoilers removed]"

You're right Devann. (view spoiler)[Knowing Jill already killed before will immediately make her a suspect and there'll be no suprise at all in the end. Not even on the fact that Jack could have gone back any time... (hide spoiler)]

Chapter 21

(view spoiler)[Manfred is invited to a witchy lesson at Fiji's. The evening doesn't end on the best term with Manfred outburst. Do you think he's right warning Fiji against continuing such lessons?

personnaly I'm a bit divided. On the one hand what Manfred says is true. Magic can be very dangerous if not used well.
But on the other side, what Fiji is teaching them is innocent enough and she could teach them the right way. She knows what she's doing after all. These people could easily search on the internet and try to learn on their own without supervision and I don't see that ending well. (hide spoiler)]

Laura wrote: "I don't know what took me so long to read this book but I'm definitely finding it interesting and entertaining.
chapters 1 &2

Meg[spoilers removed]
Simon[spoilers removed][spoilers removed]

Ok,..."

I really like Meg, too. (view spoiler)[ She sounds like a very sweet person who had to deal with a lot. She's strong but vulnerable at the same time. if that makes sense. lol
She definitely piqued the curiosity of everybody. and mine as well. I'm really curious to learn more about her.

and that conversation with Simon about the hair was funny. (hide spoiler)]

Cathy M. wrote: "✿ Claire ✿ ~ The Clever Berry wrote: "I'm already reading so many books right now, but I can't pass up the opportunity to br this book. I've wanted to read it for so long. It'll also be my first An..."

I just finished reading chapter 2. I'm really enjoying it so far. I can't wait to find out more !

I'm already reading so many books right now, but I can't pass up the opportunity to br this book. I've wanted to read it for so long. It'll also be my first Anne Bishop book. I heard she's a good writer !

(Team Hermione)

Chapter 2

(view spoiler)[It's so ironical to see how disinterested she is of all the historical facts Frank and the vicar tell her, knowing how vital it will be for her once she goes back in time. In a way, it was lucky she married Frank. (hide spoiler)]

Eldarwen wrote: "Oh, ok [Spoiler Removed]"

(view spoiler)[I don't think the reverse trope exists... sadly? haha. We can try and come up with a name. But right now I have no inspiration. lol

If wikipedia is right, the name comes from a Green Lantern comic issue in which the hero found his girlfriend dead in his fridge. From there, a group of feminists noticed that women were needlessly killed as plot devices all over in comic books and started making lists. They even have a website for it. (hide spoiler)]