Kaseadillla’s Comments (group member since May 04, 2016)

Kaseadillla’s comments from the EVERYONE Has Read This but Me - The Catch-Up Book Club group.

Hannah wrote: "As the new Bladerunner film has just come out, can I also throw in Do Androids Dream of Electric Sheep? by Philip K. Dick :D"
i loved this book i would totally read it again. second.

One Salt Sea 10/6
GO GO GRYFFINDOR

Kerri wrote: "Harry Potter and the Half-Blood Prince October 4 SLYTHERIN!"
Ashley wrote: "Niccolò Rising 10/5 Slytherin Ashley E."
Sha wrote: "Slytherin India Authentic Vol. 2 : Kali, Oct 5 An Unsuitable Heir, Oct 5"
Alva wrote: "Call Me by Your Name 8/30 Why We March: Signs of Protest and Hope 9/30 Wuthering Heights 10/5 Slytherin!"
7 points for Slytherin!!!!!!!

Khrystyna wrote: "Millennium Snow, Vol. 2 (Millennium Snow, #2) August 5th, 2017 Ravenclaw!"
Sinovera wrote: "The Pillars of the Earth 10/5 Ravenclaw"
Linda wrote: "The Blue Moon Circus Oct 4 Ravenclaw"
Amanda wrote: "Catching up because I guess I missed a couple. The Forgotten Spurgeon
21 September Dry 26 September Free of Me: Why Life Is Better When It's Not a..."
Khrystyna wrote: "Millennium Snow, Vol. 1 10/4 Ravenclaw!"
7 points for Ravenclaw!!!!!!

Melissa wrote: "I wanna join!! I'm a Hufflepuff!! Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone 8/4 Dangerous 8/10 Animal Farm 8/12 The Handmaid's Tale 8/19 Harry P..."
Tori wrote: "Spider-Man/Spider-Gwen: Sitting in a Tree10/3 Spider-Gwen, Vol. 4: Predator10/3 Adventure Time Vol. 1310/3 ...."
Chelsea wrote: "What the Dead Know 10/4 Hufflepuff!"
Cristin wrote: "Finished 10/3 - Stormbreaker
Hooray for Hufflepuff!"
18 points for Hufflepuff!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

Danielle wrote: "A Court of Wings and Ruin 5th October Gryffindor!!"
Calvin Tower wrote: "Fly High Griffindor! Fly High Gryffindor Kurohime, Vol. 2 10/4 Kurohime Vol. 3 10/4 Coraline 10/4"
Erica wrote: "Indiana Jones and the Dinosaur Eggs October 4, 2017 Gryffindor!"
Sarah wrote: "The One and Only Ivan October 4 GRYFFINDOR!"
Calvin Tower wrote: "I hope this format will work for the rest of my books. I exported it from the My Books tab. For Gryffindor: [Darwin's Game 11] (Darwin's Game, #11) 10/2/2017 History's Strongest Disciple Kenichi ..."
Angela wrote: "The Dreadful Tale of Prosper Redding 9/23 The Bad Beginning 09/25 This Savage Song 09/30 Gryffindor!"
Kaseadillla wrote: "An Artificial Night 10/4 GO GO GRYFFINDOR"
Kaseadillla wrote:"Late Eclipses 10/5 GO GO GRYFFINDOR"
Danielle wrote: "A Monster Calls 6th October Gryffindor!
55 points for GRYFFINDORRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR lots of R's

Late Eclipses 10/5
GO GO GRYFFINDOR

Marcos wrote: "Kasey, I think you mean the link to the edition on the top of this page - or any specific edition of "The Raven".
But that would mean that I had read that specific edition, which I won't have.
I'..."

Makes sense. I honestly don't really pay attention to the edition... that's probably my bad. I definitely just found a copy of "The Raven" online for free and read it.
On another note, there's a bookclub dedicated to feedback for Goodreads - I think I've seen threads about partially completed books before...
https://www.goodreads.com/group/show/...

you can mark just the one work as read if you search for "the raven" or follow the link above.

Totally, Shawna! Welcome aboard!

Welcome, Mercedes!

An Artificial Night 10/4
GO GO GRYFFINDORRRRR

An Artificial Night
October 4, 354 pages

Total Group Pages = 267,557

I think that total should be 267,203

Sha wrote: "Slytherin 03 Oct Let It Shine"
Akshay wrote: "Girl Mans Up 04/10/2017 Slytherin."
2 points for Slytherin!!

Amanda wrote: "Gender Roles and the People of God: Rethinking What We Were Taught about Men and Women in the Church 3 October Ravenclaw"
KarenMc wrote: "The Witches: Salem, 1692 10/2/17 Ravenclaw!!"
2 points for Ravenclaw!!

Calvin wrote: "Another book for Gryffindor Coraline 10/3"
Calvin wrote: "I am going to start with posting my regular books for the time frame. If I have time I will go back and add in the shorter boots and graphic novels. I hope I haven't missed any. For GRYFFINDOR: ..."
17 points for GRYFFINDORRRRRRRRRRRRRRRRR

Daniela wrote: "The Graveyard Book 10/03 Ravenclaw."
1 point for Ravenclaw!

Alissa wrote: "1. Final Girls 2. Read date: 10/2/17 3. Hufflepuff"
Mariana wrote: "Sharp Objects Oct 3 Go Hufflepuff!"
2 points for Hufflepuff!!

From Sarah: "I think down the line setting a limit like that would make sense.
Right now though, the group bookshelf isn't all that big since this group hasn't been around for all that long. It would limit options significantly right now. "

Sarah wrote: "Kaseadillla wrote: "lethe wrote: "Allegra wrote: "I would suggest reserving this list for titles the group read at least 6 months ago (or even a year)." +1" Allegra wrote: "As a general comment on ..."

Adding your comment to the other thread BOTM catch-up feedback discussion here.

Allegra wrote: "I'll second..."
lethe wrote: "+1"
Leesa wrote: "Is there a way to link the ..."
Cheryl wrote: "I agree that books ..."

Moving the feedback discussion to the BOTM catch-up feedback discussion here. Thanks everyone!

Hi all - polling the group here given the discussion currently going on in the Dec '17 BOTM Catch-Up suggestion discussion. Thanks Allegra, lethe, Leesa, and Cheryl for bringing it up.

For the new monthly catch-up category, considering a few things...
going forward, should there be a restriction on which books can be "re-read" as a group? We're thinking that books read within the last 12 months (whether for this category or the two main monthly categories) should be excluded from nomination. That way, we're not reading a book more than once in a given 12-month period.

Thoughts? concerns? Thanks in advance for your feedback.

Leesa wrote: "Is there a way to link the current read to the old thread Kasey? That way, those in the group who have already read the book and commented are still involved and they can join in from where they le..."
Hi Leesa - the plan is to move the old threads back into the "currently reading" folder if/when books are voted as official bookshelf re-reads for the group - I agree with you, better to discuss with all and be able to see old comments rather than start completely anew.

Joanna wrote: "Third Son's a Charm 10/2 Slytherin"
Allegra wrote: "I've fallen behind on this, so I hope I'm not missing anything (or doubling up), but here goes... Radio Golf September 26 The Slippery Slope September 30 book:Breakfa..."
4 points for Slytherin!!!!

Shawna wrote: "Just joined! Hufflepuff! Hidden Figures: The American Dream and the Untold Story of the Black Women Mathematicians Who Helped Win the Space Race August 15 book:Big Little Lies|19..."
Welcome!
2 points for Hufflepuff!!

Calvin wrote: "Late to the game, but: Gryffindor Congratulations on being sorted into Gryffindor"
Welcome to team Gryffindor - make sure you post the books you read here to get house points!
Sarah wrote: "Caraval 10/2 Go, go Gryffindor!"
1 point for GRYFFINDOR

lethe wrote: "Allegra wrote: "I would suggest reserving this list for titles the group read at least 6 months ago (or even a year)."
+1"
Allegra wrote: "As a general comment on this new category...
Since old discussions are not taken do..."

Totally get that. The plan I have in mind is that we can only re-read a book once every 12 months, aka if it wins this category it cannot be re-read by the group again for 12 months. May make sense to broaden that to ALL books read within the past 12 months.
Might leave it alone for now and see how it works for a few months, then institute this rule if it makes sense?