96 Mystery and Thriller Recommendations by Mood and Setting

Posted by Sharon on April 3, 2023


One of the fun things we’ve discovered over the years, here at Goodreads World Headquarters, is that there are many, many, many ways to shuffle and categorize books. The traditional genre tags and topic lists are useful. But if you get a little wacky with it, interesting connections present themselves.
 
To wit: our inaugural Mystery Week Choose-Your-Own-Adventure recommendation list. We’ve sorted the stacks in the mystery aisle to accommodate themed pairs of opposites. Are you in the mood for a Locked Room mystery or something with Wide-Open Spaces? In the Air or at Sea? Hot or Cold? Small Town or Big City?
 
The categories and connections below should mostly explain themselves, though some might require a little sleuthing. (In Church Versus State, for example, we’ve bunched religious investigators and themes in one pile, and espionage thrillers and matter of state in another.)
 
The books included here are a mix of new releases and old favorites, with an eye toward representative classics. You’ll find a wide range of mystery subgenres (Noir! Cozy! Horroresque!) from a lineup of usual-suspect authors (Christie! Grisham! Highsmith!). You’ll also find some of the best new talent in the genre, with books by Jesse Q. Sutanto, T.J. Newman, and Deepti Kapoor.
 
Rummage around the book cover images below, and tap or click through to get more information about each title. Feel free to add what you like to your Want to Read shelf.
 

Locked Rooms...

...or Wide-Open Spaces

 

Small Town...

 
 

...or Big City

 
 

In the Air...

...or at Sea

 

Work...

...or Play

Hot...

...or Cold

Historical...

 
 

...or Far Future

      

Amateur Detective...

...or Professional Sleuth

 

Church...

...or State




Which this-or-that situation are you choosing for your next mystery read? What other titles would you suggest for the categories above? Let's talk books in the comments below!
 

Find more mystery recommendations:






Comments Showing 51-60 of 60 (60 new)

dateUp arrow    newest »

message 51: by OT (new)

OT I'm a bilingual english-spanish reader. ¿Could we have the same categories in Spanish please? Muchas gracias.


JULIAN DOUGLAS-SMITH Surely The Daughter of Time by Josephine Tey should be the first entry under "Historical"!


message 53: by Sophie (new)

Sophie Really not very useful categories or recommendations.
No mention of International, LGBTQ+ writers...


message 54: by harper.r (new)

harper.r Ashley wrote: "While I appreciate the effort, I don't think this is the way we think of books. I've never said to myself "Gee, I'm in the mood for a mystery, but it better be set in a cold climate or I'll be disa..."

I feel exactly the same! didn't find this list very helpful.


message 55: by John (new)

John Racek If you like thrillers, BEST WHEN SERVED COLD, by: D.A. Dawson is a must read. John


message 56: by Phoebe (new)

Phoebe Edgbaston Apart from Karen Slaughter, lots of other writers not included. How about P.D. James for those who like Christie and Sayers (very different writers) or Marjory Allingham - better than either: try "Hide My Eyes" or "Traitor's Purse". A good American series, which reads more like British detection are the Rabbi books of Kemelman: but for "different countries", how about the work of James Mclure, set in South Africa; racy, but about much more than sex and violence?

I've been into detective fiction since I was about 5, and listened to my father reading aloud to my mother, so I've covered a lot of authors, and styles over more than 50 years!


message 57: by Deirdre (new)

Deirdre How is Murderbot a historical mystery? It’s sci-fi!


message 58: by Deirdre (new)

Deirdre Wish I could delete my above comment. I see now that Murderbot (Martha Wells’ All Systems Red) is actually “futuristic.” Great book. I hadn’t thought of it as a mystery, but it works


message 59: by Elke (new)

Elke Loos This this or that concept is really fun!


message 60: by Linda (new)

Linda Arnold "While I appreciate the effort, I don't think this is the way we think of books. I've never said to myself "Gee, I'm in the mood for a mystery, but it better be set in a cold climate or I'll be disappointed." " (Ashley)

Living in the Denver area as I do, I don't like to read books set in winter in the few warm months we get.

I would also like to see a list of some holiday themed books. Not so much Christmas or even Halloween, those are everywhere. I'd like to read about (and then actually read) some books set over the 4th of July, and other holidays.


« previous 1 2 next »
back to top