Does Social Security work?
I say it does, but that does not stop it from being attacked. The words Ponzi Scheme are being thrown about. The fact it is underfunded is being used as a argument that it doesn’t work. Some in government are calling for it to be replaced with private accounts. I read one official say there is plenty of money to pay all the benefits to those now collecting, but we can’t continue. Well, that’s not true on either point.
No doubt Social Security is underfunded, but that is the fault of every Congress since the 1990s and of the Americans they fear will not support higher taxes or other changes. That is not a valid reason to claim the system can no longer work.
It’s true the worker to retiree ratio is shrinking-fewer workers to support a growing number of retirees and that needs to be considered as well and can be over time by increasing the tax paying base - another discussion.
The irony is that making Social Security sustainable requires relatively minor changes and increases in funding. If changes had been made gradually over the years, they would hardly be noticed. For example, today just increasing the payroll tax by 3% (1.5% each on employer and worker) and applying FICA to employer cafeteria plans results in 97% of funding covered for the next 75 years (Committee for a Responsible Federal Budget SS calculator.) That amounts to about $17.00 a week for the median wage earner - meaning half would pay less. That seems a small price for future retirement income. The increase would be considerably lower had it been applied ten years ago.
The challenge now is a general anti-government anti-tax ideology in favor of individual empowerment and responsibility.
What’s missing is a realistic understanding of human behavior- in this case related to finances and long-term planning. Americans are not even adequately saving and managing money for their share of retirement income, let alone all the required income.
I used to joke that there was no reason to worry about Social Security, it will always be there. My confidence is waning.
The post Does Social Security work? appeared first on HumbleDollar.
