Data’s Double Edge: Why Spreadsheets are Both a Lifeline and a Possible Lie

Can you even begin to imagine the confusion and chaos that follows a major disaster, and the difficulty of communicating and coordinating a response? This is a situation where data management, especially with a simple but powerful tool like a spreadsheet, shows its magic.

One very well-known situation that comes to mind is the Space Shuttle Challenger disaster. Facing a complex amount of data, engineer Richard Feynman and his team had a hunch about the cause. They used a simple spreadsheet to plot launch temperatures against O-ring damage, creating an easily understandable graph that clearly showed more brittleness with temperature drops. This simple act cut through a massive amount of data that would have taken months to examine, quickly determining the reason for the failure.

A bit of online research reveals another great example: the 2014 Ebola outbreak in Africa. After a shaky start with manual data entry, a spreadsheet was developed and used to vastly improve the tracing and tracking of infected people. Using data visualization, public health officials were able to identify disease hotspots and enact quarantine areas, which slowed the outbreak to an eventual standstill and saved many lives.

While spreadsheets are powerful for analyzing and presenting data, they share the same vulnerability with handwritten math: they are only as good as the information you put into them. A single mistake—whether a miscopied number in a manual calculation or a flawed assumption in a spreadsheet—can invalidate the entire result.

The danger, I feel, with spreadsheets is that their automated power and clear outcomes can hide these errors, creating a false sense of certainty. This is the case for everything from public health data to retirement planning, where a small, incorrect input can lead to a dangerously misleading outcome. The usefulness of the output will always depend on the accuracy of the input. In simple terms, it's just the same as using the wrong numbers in an equation.

Spreadsheet skeptics, it seems to me, confuse this fundamental characteristic of all "variable driven" mathematics to debunk the very nature and real world utility of a well-designed spreadsheet.

 

 

The post Data’s Double Edge: Why Spreadsheets are Both a Lifeline and a Possible Lie appeared first on HumbleDollar.