

Liar! You want us to buy you a pony so you can sell it as the best birthday gift a father has ever given his daughter! :P
It's difficult to name a fa..."
See, the whole idea behind a favorite, Trish, is that you pick ONE. :)
That said, excellent list, and I'm in whole-hearted agreement on many of them! (GRRM, Tolkien, Rowling, etc.)

I CAAAAAAN'T *wails*


(Seriously, if my house ever burnt, I'd die trying to save all my books from the most expensive special edition to the cheapest paperback.)
Sean wrote: "That said, excellent list, and I'm in whole-hearted agreement on many of them! (GRRM, Tolkien, Rowling, etc.)"
Thanks. I'm sure I can come up with more names if I stood surrounded by my babies but I'm at the office right now (I left out authors who wrote fantasy for kids mostly, like Roald Dahl, or other well-known names like T.H. White for instance).

Both excellent choices, Meghan! That King bastard is pretty damn good regardless of genre... :)

Since I've only read horror books of his, I deliberately left him out (he already is the King, what more could he want?).

So in terms of my favorite author......hmmmmmmm......I'll have to just say the author of my favorite fantasy series. Which is still (after all these years), Harry Potter. So J.K. Rowling it is!
But sci-fi....that's a horse of a different color. So many to choose from! Ursula LeGuin is definitely a favorite of mine, but I have to go with the author of my favorite all time epic/sci-fi masterpiece/modern classic, Frank Herbert (Dune forever!!!!!)
Gibsy, have I told you how completely I adore your words. You, sir, are one of the absolute best wordsmiths I've ever encountered in this or any of my lifetimes:)


Then (because I haven't read Dune yet) I have to name Asimov, of course, as well as H.G. Wells (if only for that very funny fact that people believed an audioplay of his War of the Worlds was an actual news story and panicked) ... I'll read a few important works of the genre this year so I might be able to name some more later (I have some serious catching up to do).

HOW COULD I FORGET???
For fantasy I HAVE to also nominate Terry Pratchett of course!!!

(and yes, Philip Pullman wasn't bad either)

So in terms of my favorite author..."
You are entirely too kind, mademoiselle J. LeGuin is superb--I was a lit major in undergrad and wrote my capstone these on gender and the limits of language in The Left Hand of Darkness (which is, quite possibly, the most English majory topic for a paper; I was like a walking stereotype, apparently). I dug Dune, too (pun intended). Good stuff.

Heloise is all about grabby-handsiness, Michelle! :)
It's mind-blowingly incredible the impact JK Rowling has had on a generation of readers; I'm not sure anyone has ever had so wide or broad an effect on a group of young people. At least, not an author, and not in such a positive way. What an amazing human.
As for that Gaiman guy...effortless indeed; a little TOO effortless, if you ask me. He may need a kick in the knee pits for making it look so easy...

Right?! It's one of my favourite pics of him (that and the one with the rubber duck on his university hat).


since you named all my other favorites, we'll call it a team effort.

HOW COULD I FORGET???
For fantasy I HAVE to also nominate Terry Pratchett of course!!!
(and yes, Philip Pullman wasn't bad either)"
Haha! That shirt is amazing.

But for Fantasy: Philip Pullman?
For Sci-Fi: John Scalzi, maybe?


Sorry about the toothache, Figgy! But, good choices. :)

Fantasy struggled for so long...
From my youth:
Patricia McKillip, Anne McCaffrey, Robin McKinley, Susan Cooper, Tracy Hickman & Margaret Weiss, David Eddings, Stephen Donaldson, Piers Anthony (*shudder*)...
And then a little later:
Robert Jordan, Lois McMaster Bujold (lots of good sci-fi, too...ambi-genre-ous), Mercedes Lackey, Cinda Williams Chima, Jane Yolen (Wizard's Hall?), Brandon Sanderson, Garth Nix...
But my favorite would be between Lloyd Alexander and Terry Brooks with the nod going to Mr. Brooks because I still remember how the 14-year old me felt at the close of Elfstones...a heartbreaking and noble ending. I hadn't felt that since Frodo and Bilbo went to the Gray Havens (read at age 12).
I couldn't agree more with your assessment of the genre. Thank you.

Fantasy struggled for so long...
From my youth:
Patricia McKillip, Anne McCaffrey, Robin McKinley, Susan Cooper, Tracy Hickman & Margaret Weis..."
All luminaries of the genre, Dave! Agreed that things change over time; for me, now, it's Rothfuss, GRRM, Gaiman, etc., but, as a youth, Tolkien, Salvatore, Weis/Hickman, Feist, Brooks, Rawn, etc.

since you named all my other favorites, we'll call it a team effort."
:D Yay!

He actually had it made and wore it to some form of convention / reading. No idea if he really wasn't their first choice back then, but it's simply brilliant! :D

He actually had it made and wore it to some form of convention / reading. No idea if he really wasn't their first choice back then, but it's simply brill..."
I'm just mad that I didn't think of it first! :)

Never read Rawn. I'll have to try the author's books. I struggled with Raymond Feist. Not sure why. All my friends loved Riftwar.
I still can't let go of Tolkien, Brooks and Alexander. About the only books that I re-read regularly although Brooks' bibliography is becoming unwieldly.
I'm not ready to commit to the long-term relationship that Martin requires. I'm still suffering from Jordan. Humanity was not meant for authorial monogamy.
I have a love/hate relationship with Sarah Maas' books. She's an incredible writer (rare for me to read 600+ page books in a few days) with a brilliant imagination, but I can't get used to the sex-capades alongside the fantasy elements.
Sabaa Tahir's debut (fantasy) would have been my favorite read of 2016 if not for Pierce Brown.
And I forgot Hilari Bell who is vastly under-rated.
In the beginning, Tolkien created the fantasy genre, and saw that it was good.
Star Wars arrived and created a flood that caused thousands of fantasy readers to focus on sci-fi and forget Tolkien.
JK Rowling then gave birth to the immaculate conception which became fantasy's savior, and brought the genre out of obscurity. The fantasy (Roman) calendar reckoning was changed to BR and AR (Before Rowling and In the Year of Rowling).
The subsequent popularity caused fantasy to fracture into many sub-genres each with its ardent adherents proclaiming the virtues of their devotion.
Tolkien then sent Martin to sway all to the one and true high fantasy genre.
Or something like that...

I also wrote a paper in college on the same stereotypical lit major topic. On the exact same book as it turns out:)

Never read Rawn. I'll ..."
Well said, Dave! Heh. Oh, JK and her immaculate conceptions...
I might quibble with defining Star Wars as sci-fi, though: that's totally fantasy dressed up in sci-fi clothing.

Hey, you know what they say--great minds...are probably doing something other than what we're doing.

Terry Brooks - 30+ years after the initial read and an MTV incarnation, the ending of Elfstones still devastates me.
And...

(The other pony image, the one from Tijuana, was Not Safe For Work.)

Terry Brooks - 30+ years after the initial read and an MTV incarnation, the ending of Elfs..."
That is one sparkly pony, Dave...but, I do love me some Tijuana ponies.
And, I'm totally with you on Elfstones!!

I grew up with Rowlings' books (still got photos somewhere of me in costume for many a midnight release...) but then finding Hogfather by Terry Pratchett by complete accident one day completely changed my life!
“Everything starts somewhere...The philosopher Didactylos has summed up an alternative hypothesis as "Things just happen. What the hell." - Still living by this philosophy to this day, haha!

I grew up with Rowlings' books (still got photos somewhere of me in costume for many a midnight release...) but then f..."
Can't go wrong with either of those luminaries, Beth!
What the hell indeed...


I loved many authors and all because of various reasons but I suppose I'll go with my first, my first encounter too with high fantasy and certainly the one who shape my imaginary and my will to kick some bad guy asses.
Sir JRR Tolkien.
And although I love many new authors I will give a second name.
Reading his books shaped my vision of the aesthetic, of the dreams and adventures in strange lands.
Abraham Merritt.
I have many others but I will stop here. I will give honors to the Ancient ones.
(Of course I could also add a recent author I met who write wonderful stories about the arthurian world... :p )

I've never read De Lint...sounds like I should check him out!

I loved many authors and all because of various reasons but I suppose I'll go with my f..."
Hey, the Ancient Ones are revered for a reason, right?
That Gibson guy, though...he's a hack.

Science Fiction wise, I haven't read as much, but for the moment that would be Ada Palmer, because her Terra Ignota series just blew me out of the water.


I agree about Hobb, Mili! Her books aren't thrill-a-minute page turners, but she's a master stylist who builds great characters!

Then there is Carter's co-conspirator on reviving the great pulp fantasy character Conan the Barbarian by Robert E. Howard. deCamp wrote lots of great stuff. My favorite are the Harold Shea stories.
Jack Vance's Dying Earth tales and Fritz Leiber's Fafhrd and Grey Mouser along with Conan were the inspiration for Gary Gygax and Dave Arneson in creating D&D. Here would grimdark fantasy be without Michael Moorcock and his Elric and his soul stealing sword Stombringer.
Edgar Rice Burroughs and his various science fantasy series, Mars, Venus, Pellucidar among others were among my earliest favorites. Oh those Ace Publishing books by Burroughs with covers by Roy Krenkel and some fellow named Frazetta.
Other favorites not named by others:
Robert Aspirin's Myth series
Jeffrey Poole's Lentari series.
Nicholas Eames Kings of the Wylde



HOW COULD I FORGET???
For fantasy I HAVE to also nominate Terry Pratchett of course!!!
(and yes, Philip Pullman wasn't bad either)"
This shirt is fantastic!! Hahahaha

Right now, Sanderson has just blown my mind with the Mistborn series.
I loved Tolkein as a kid so he's got to go on the list.
Gaiman, most of the time. I just couldn't get into American Gods for some reason. I might have to revisit this one day to see if I was in just one of those moods that year. hahaha
Rowling of course because it's fucking Harry Potter.
I've loved all the Dresdren books so Jim Butcher's got to go on the list.
And, I'm really looking forward to reading some of Steven Erickson's' books one day because I've heard they are epic!
God, so many great writers!! Aaaaaaand of course, Sean Gibson. 😏😉

Thanks my friend.

Right now, Sanderson has just blown my mind with the Mistborn series.
I loved Tolkein as a kid so he's..."
Good reinforcements and additions, Ginger! I mean, except for that hack poser Gibson...
This thread is making me just want to sit and read for like 7 days straight...

George R.R. Martin's character work is why I was able to read the first 4 ASOIAF books before Game of Thrones premiered back in 2011 in a span of 5 months despite the fact I didn't get a firm grasp of all the names, Houses, etc. until like the middle of the 3rd book. To have such a command of voice that none of his widely different POV narrators sounds like any of the others, and that most of their voices and stories and arcs are fascinating is what makes ASOIAF such an accomplishment in fantasy despite its incomplete state.
Has Alan Moore been brought up yet? Because his run on Swamp Thing can give Neil Gaiman's Sandman a hard run for the title of Best Fantasy Comic Book. Lyrical, beautiful, and profound despite the fact it was a B-level DC horror book before he started writing it. Moore didn't even shy away from its pulpy horror roots, hell he embraced them and made it genuinely creepy, weird, and shocking. Saga of the Swamp Thing is arguably better than Watchmen or V For Vendetta.
There are a few others I want to mention but I'm typing this on my phone (which I really need to charge).
I am afraid I have to organize a fight to death between the following people:
Robert E. Howard
J.R.R. Tolkien
Roger Zelazny
Robert Jordan
J.K. Rowling
to figure out who is the best.
Robert E. Howard
J.R.R. Tolkien
Roger Zelazny
Robert Jordan
J.K. Rowling
to figure out who is the best.
Liar! You want us to buy you a pony so you can sell it as the best birthday gift a father has ever given his daughter! :P
It's difficult to name a favourite author, really, because many have contributed a lot to the genre. Peter S. Beagle has given us The Last Unicorn and prose as beautiful as that mythical creature. On the other hand, GRRM has created an epic ranging as far as the actual War of the Roses that his books of ASOIAF represent. Then there is Urban Fantasy (a sub-genre I didn't know about for the longest time) that, while in no way groundbreaking or showing literally fantastic prose, has given me swoon-worthy characters thanks to authors like Ilona Andrews (imaginary boyfriends for the win!). We also have the HP series that not only rekindled kids' and teenagers' passion for reading (there are actual studies about that to prove it) but that has also has given me, personally, so much on so many different aspects of life that I keep buying different editions, which is why I keep re-reading the books constantly and watching Fantastic Beasts for more than 13 times in the meantime (I'm not even kidding about that). And what about novellas like those of Seanan McGuire? That is to say nothing of the classics like Lewis or Tolkien that are a league all of their own.
How am I supposed to choose?!
YOU WANT ME TO PICK A FAVOURITE LIMB TO KEEP, TOO, MAN?!