date
newest »

Gary wrote: "Evgeny wrote: "I am afraid I have to organize a fight to death between the following people:
Robert E. Howard
J.R.R. Tolkien
Roger Zelazny
Robert Jordan
J.K. Rowling
to figure out who is the best...."
...and now I am very much jealous.
Robert E. Howard
J.R.R. Tolkien
Roger Zelazny
Robert Jordan
J.K. Rowling
to figure out who is the best...."
...and now I am very much jealous.

Eric, that was sublimely eloquent!

I think my most favorite would always be J.R.R. Tolkien for his extremely awesome world, but I really lived with J.K. Rowling Harry Potters and also loved Mark Lawrence Prince of thorn series.
Still so many names coming to my mind and I'm trying hard not to create a long list ...

Gibsy, I'm going to cast my vote for Sunshine by Robin McKinley. While it's not a classic, or a bestseller, or the type of book you use for a capstone project, it is the only book that ever prompted me to write to an author pleading for a sequel. (Still waiting...)


I think my most favorite would always be J.R.R. Tolkien for his extremely awesome world, but I really lived with J.K. Rowling Harry Potters and also loved Mark Lawrence P..."
It's almost an impossible question, I realize! The one-two punch of Tolkien and Rowling is almost unbeatable. Maybe we just need to have a Mount Rushmore of fantasy authors and we can just assume that those folks are on everyone's favorites list and begin the conversation from there... :)

Gibsy, I'm going to cast my vote for Sunshine by Robin McKinley. While it's not a classic, ..."
Another one I'll need to add to the list, Allie!
(And I think you need to share that Bowie story...)

Robert E. Howard
J.R.R. Tolkien
Roger Zelazny
Robert Jordan
J.K. Rowling
to figure out who..."
That makes two of us! :)

And recently I really enjoyed Maggie Steifvater's 'the Raven Boys' quadology (is that a word?). I thought she wrote really well in that series.
So, my favorite is...the jury's still out, sorry.

It's really kind of a Sophie's choice situation, isn't it? :)

Perhaps shamefully, Sophie's Choice is one book I've still not read. And I just ruined it for myself when I was confirming that I had the definition correct, alas.

Absolutely loved that series...especially the final book. I still have to write my review.
Not sure about the setting (small town Virginia...sorry Sean...I'm sure Virginia is a wonderful place to live, but I would have never picked it for the setting of an urban fantasy) or the plot (somewhat light on the fantasy elements, but they are there). However, the characters simply amazed me. I felt like I knew them, and they were intimate friends. Even Henry, who arrived late.
And Ms. Stiefvater's style combined insight and wry humor with beautifully rendered social dynamics, and witty, natural dialogue.
The whole series always leading up to that prophesied kiss (Will it happen? If so, will he die?), but a separate kiss completely captivated me.

My teenage son has been trying to get me to read Brandon Mull's Fablehaven or Beyonders for a few years now. I finally capitulated this year (and no, I didn't make him buy me a pony), and read Beyonders. Great fantasy story with a flawed quest, and darker than I expected.
Glen Cook's style can be a bit ponderous, but he carved his own niche in the fantasy genre.

I think reading a summary of Sophie's Choice is infinitely preferable to actually reading the book...

Absolutely loved that series...especiall..."
Seems like setting an urban fantasy in a small town is kind of an oxymoron, no? And Northern Virginia is really just one giant, sprawling suburb of DC, Mr. D, which makes it very different from the part of the state where there are places named, um, Lynchburg...
I've always been curious about Fablehaven and Glen Cook, though I've never picked up either.
Sean wrote: "Dave wrote: "Anna wrote: And recently I really enjoyed Maggie Steifvater's 'the Raven Boys' quadology (is that a word?). I thought she wrote really well in that series.
Absolutely loved that serie..."
Oops, I forgot Glen Cook. Can I ever be forgiven?
Absolutely loved that serie..."
Oops, I forgot Glen Cook. Can I ever be forgiven?

I may have applied the urban fantasy label incorrectly...Stiefvater's series is probably better described as "low fantasy" (that just sounds offensive).
I can't keep up with all the sub-genres.
Same with music. There used to be only one kind of metal.
Sean wrote: And Northern Virginia is really just one giant, sprawling suburb of DC
My family loves DC although we usually stay in Maryland vs Virginia. Nothing against Virginia...just a shorter Metro ride from Bethesda to the Mall.
Sean wrote: ...which makes it very different from the part of the state where there are places named, um, Lynchburg
Hopefully, named after Mr. or Ms. Lynch and not the physical act. Familiar with Lynchburg, too. B&W's nuclear division was headquartered there. Almost all of the original documentation for B&W's nuclear plants is located in Lynchburg. Fascinating reading on all of the features that would prevent a nuclear meltdown from ever occurring at a B&W plant (I'm looking at you, TMI-2).
Sean wrote: I've always been curious about Fablehaven and Glen Cook, though I've never picked up either.
I haven't read Fablehaven, but my son promises that the series is better than the Beyonders, and I liked the Beyonders (more than I probably should since, I think, the series would be deemed "Middle Grade"). Glen Cook's work can be a bit...what's the word?...dense? Requires a higher level of concentration than I can currently muster.
Oops...I think I pontificated again. Sorry. :(
Where's that Tijuana pony image?

I just finished reading Dread Empire last year, and Mocker is one of my all-time favorite fantasy characters. And still, I forgot Mr. Cook until I was rummaging around the bookshelf the other day. I, too, need forgiveness. :(
Dave wrote: "Evgeny wrote: Oops, I forgot Glen Cook. Can I ever be forgiven?
I just finished reading Dread Empire last year, and Mocker is one of my all-time favorite fantasy characters. And still, I forgot Mr..."
Erikson took Mocker wholesale for his Malazan epic (renaming him Kruppe).
I just finished reading Dread Empire last year, and Mocker is one of my all-time favorite fantasy characters. And still, I forgot Mr..."
Erikson took Mocker wholesale for his Malazan epic (renaming him Kruppe).

I have not read Erikson's books, but if Kruppe is a re-visit to Mocker then I need to get started. My favorite anti-hero (even his physical description), and such a tragic backstory (and middle story) yet no complaining ("Frodo, Wil Ohmsford, Rand, Garion, and Taran, if you don't stop whining..."). I have no qualms about reading a sincere form of flattery where Mocker is involved.


I have not read Erikson's books, but if Kruppe is a re-visit to Mocker then I need to get started. My favori..."
Wil Ohmsford is being particularly vociferous, Dave.

Honestly, the bigger names are all impressive, but I'm recently digging the current batch of independents. I LOVE Andrea K Host, L. Jagi Lamplighter, Jordan Elizabeth Mierek, Jen Estes and will fight anyone who says they aren't as good as the big names in SF&F.
I may be forgetting one of my favs, but I just ate, so food coma brain fog. I reserve the right to add a name or two as my brain recooperates. I recommend checking the lovely ladies mentioned above out!

I'll have to check those authors out!!


For urban fantasy, I really love Melissa F. Olson. Her writing keeps improving. And for YA, I love Leigh Bardugo. I can't wait for

Ah, I see I was unable to limit my answer to just one author. *hangs head in shame*

Honestly, the bigger names are all impressive, but I'm recently digging the current batch of independents. I LOVE Andrea K Host, L. Jagi Lamplight..."
Jen - I love checking out independent authors. Thanks for the recommendations. :)

Totally agree on Sanderson, Jen, though I've been much more into Stormlight than Mistborn, for some reason. Still, that guy is remarkable!
I've never really gotten into urban fantasy...

Robert E. Howard
J.R.R. Tolkien
Roger Zelazny
Robert Jordan
J.K. Rowling
to figure out who..."
Evgeny wrote: "Sean wrote: "Dave wrote: "Anna wrote: And recently I really enjoyed Maggie Steifvater's 'the Raven Boys' quadology (is that a word?). I thought she wrote really well in that series.
Absolutely lov..."
Anna wrote: "I think all of my favorites have pretty much been named, er, perhaps Italo Calvino? Arguably not exactly a fantasist, though. Or Patricia Wrede, though I've only read her 'Dealing with Dragons' ser..."
Ok I won't mention the signed copy of Andrew Robinson's Garak DS9 novel or the Marina Sirtis signed picture that she gave me for being allowed to love on my sister's service dog. Lord, I miss that dalmation. Then there is the signed Damn Yankees program that is signed by Vincent Price who was playing Applegate and Pia Zadore who was playing Lola. I now have two of those since my sister-in-law gave me my late brother's program as well. There are others of mine signed by Chloris Leachman, Hal Linden, Joel Grey, John Raitt, Ken Berry, Elaine Joyce, and Mickey Rooney, among others. I wish we could find my brother's autographs from the Alex Karras run golf outing he ran at the course he co-owned in my high school years home town. One of them was Marvin Gaye. Johnny (Tarzan) Weismuller was there as well. Enough of my meandering thoughts.

For fantasy, I love Neil Gaiman's work and Terry Pratchett as well, as I've see in this discussion. But nice books I read also by David Eddings, Brandon Sanderson, Robert E. Howard, Terry Brooks, George R.R. Martin, J.R.R. Tolkien (of course), Patrick Rothfuss, Robert Jordan, Michael Moorcock, Fritz Leiber.
For Science fiction, in the same way there is a whole universe of authors, so I report here only my favorites: Roger Zelazny, Robert Heinlein, China Miéville, Ray Bradbury, John Shirley, Poul Anderson, Dan Simmons, Frank Herbert, Larry Niven, Philip Dick,
Douglas Adams, Arthur C. Clarke, James S.A. Corey, Isaac Asimov.
It's difficult I have listed all the autors that deserve it, but these are a good bundle.



Merritt was a heck of a writer. I couldn't list everybody.


I tend to be nostalgic and end up enjoying the first book I read by authors most of the time, so that's why Mistborn has a special place in my heart, but I did really enjoy The Way of Kings too. I have a feeling that once it's completed The Stormlight Archives will be a very impressive series, considering all the planning he's put into it.
I resisted urban fantasy for quite a while. Now I really enjoy it, but it isn't for everyone and I always end up returning to fantasy (sans the urban).
You're right. Eddings and Gemmell are also two good ones. I discovered Gemmell late though, so I need to catch up. So many books...


(Which kind of sounds like a threat, even though I don't mean it to be...)

Same for me! *hangs head in shame*

Robert E. Howard
J.R.R. Tolkien
Roger Zelazny
Robert Jordan
J.K. Rowling
to figure out who is the best."
I met Zelazny. My SF Book Club edition of the Amber series is signed by him (It was two HC he signed each)