Discover new books on Goodreads
See if your friends have read any of Noorilhuda's books
Noorilhuda’s Followers (138)






























More friends…
Noorilhuda
Goodreads Author
Genre
Member Since
August 2014
URL
https://www.goodreads.com/noorilhuda
Non-Fiction: https://www.scribd.com/noorilhuda
http://newslinemagazine.com/contribut...
Fiction:
- ‘The Governess’ (2014): Praised by Historical Novel Society, Midwest Book Review and Kindle Book Review U.S., the novel has done well in the UK where it's regularly picked up as an ebook & frequently lands in Top 100 Free lists (#1 in 'Death & Grief,' #2 in 'Religious & Inspirational Romance,' #13 in 'Parenting & Families'): http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00MF8BJQE
- ‘Catharsis’ (2015) received mixed reviews: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B010IQSFN4
Non-Fiction: https://www.scribd.com/noorilhudahttp://newslinemagazine.com/contribut...
Fiction:
- ‘The Governess’ (2014): Praised by Historical Novel Society, Midwest Book Review and Kindle Book Review U.S., the novel has done well in the UK where it's regularly picked up as an ebook & frequently lands in Top 100 Free lists (#1 in 'Death & Grief,' #2 in 'Religious & Inspirational Romance,' #13 in 'Parenting & Families'): http://www.amazon.co.uk/dp/B00MF8BJQE
- ‘Catharsis’ (2015) received mixed reviews: https://www.amazon.com/dp/B010IQSFN4
...more
Annual Schedule for Free Ebook Versions of 'The Governess' & 'Catharsis':
The Governess & Catharsis will be free across Amazon on the following events:
* Christmas+New Year's Day (25-29 Dec.)
* Memorial Day Weekend (25-29 May)
* Independence Day Weekend (4-8 July)
* 'Catharsis' on Halloween Weekend (31 Oct.)
* 'The Governess' & 'Catharsis' on Thanksgiving Weekend (4th Thursday in Nov.) 21-25 Nov.
Ebook: ASIN: B00MF8BJQE
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00MF8BJQE
https://www.am Read more of this blog post »
* Christmas+New Year's Day (25-29 Dec.)
* Memorial Day Weekend (25-29 May)
* Independence Day Weekend (4-8 July)
* 'Catharsis' on Halloween Weekend (31 Oct.)
* 'The Governess' & 'Catharsis' on Thanksgiving Weekend (4th Thursday in Nov.) 21-25 Nov.
Ebook: ASIN: B00MF8BJQE
https://www.amazon.com/dp/B00MF8BJQE
https://www.am Read more of this blog post »
Published on April 16, 2024 10:00
•
Tags:
inspirational-romance, kdp, mystery-thriller
|
The Governess
3.26 avg rating — 68 ratings
—
published
2014
—
2 editions
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
Catharsis
2.89 avg rating — 44 ratings
—
published
2015
—
2 editions
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
* Note: these are all the books on Goodreads for this author. To add more, click here.
Noorilhuda
is currently reading
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
Noorilhuda
is currently reading
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
Noorilhuda’s Recent Updates
|
Noorilhuda
rated a book it was ok
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
Elder fraud is a very real scary thing. Senior citizens, that is people over the age of 60 are among the most vulnerable in the society. They are pensioners, they have retirement funds, they have savings, maybe a bit of property to their name as well
Elder fraud is a very real scary thing. Senior citizens, that is people over the age of 60 are among the most vulnerable in the society. They are pensioners, they have retirement funds, they have savings, maybe a bit of property to their name as well, a car and house or apartment, they have medical ailments and mobility issues, and in the western world and in countries like Japan, they usually live alone or employ a caretaker, and are susceptible to scams designed to impoverish them off their hard-earned money and ownership. And scams that work on them can be tried on young people too. A con is a con, a pyramid scheme is a pyramid scheme, an online or by mail fraud is a fraud. The U.S. Federal Bureau of Investigations site has information on different cons initiated against elders and tips to follow to safeguards against scams. This criminal activity and its aftermath is at the very heart of Guilt, Keigo Higashino’s latest non-Kaga and non-Detective Galileo mystery. The English translation has been done by Giles Murray. It was originally published in Japan in 2024 as Hakucho to komori (Bats and Swans) by Gentosha Bunko. I love Keigo and his ability to talk about Japanese culture, norms, food, societal ills and history in a hard-nosed step-by-step police procedural. The detectives here both Godai and Nakamachi are as dry as Kaga and their work is as slow and dull as that of real law enforcement. But the story has a heart and a lot of curiously ill-placed emotion. Kensuke Shiraishi, the dead man whose murder starts the investigation in 2017 is not a bad person - far from it, he is the most likeable character in the book; Tatsuro Kuraki, his alleged killer who makes a full confession to the police is not a bad person either, he is also not the killer - in case you think this is a spoiler, it’s not, because the confession occurs very soon at 15% mark, chapter 9 with following chapter explaining in detail why and how he did it. And of course he didn’t do it. The general wisdom is always that he’s hiding the identity of the real killer for sentimental reasons. He is also dying of colorectal cancer [revealed in chapter 41 at 76% mark, but something you can guess from a mile away.] Junji Fukuma is not a bad person either - he’s the guy who had the misfortune of being arrested for a crime he didn’t commit and who later on died in police custody. These men, their wives and their children are all good, decent people. They are all hardworking people. So how come all these families get destroyed? The root of what happens today is found 30 years ago in the life and murder of a certain Shozo Haitani, a former insurance company salesman who gave consumer information to scammers and helped them gain trust of potential clients aka victims. His Modus Operandi is given in detail on [in Chapter 8 at 12%-13% mark] as follows: “You gentlemen are probably _____” I like the book, the story and the characters but I think Keigo played it safe in coming up with the killer of Kensuke Shiraishi and the killer’s reasons for committing the crime - the psychology behind the motive is nothing new, so the revelation is underwhelming. Thanks to the publisher Minotaur Books, an imprint of St. Martin’s Publishing Group for the ARC of the first edition published in U.S. 2026. LINK TO REVIEW ON YOUTUBE: https://youtu.be/CA-JYCgWR54 ...more |
|
|
Noorilhuda
rated a book liked it
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
Endometriosis from harm to hope - a chronic illness guide by Casey Berna LCSW (‘Licensed Clinical Social Worker’) published by Sheldon Press, an imprint of John Murray Press this February (2026). Berna has endometriosis too and she describes her pers
Endometriosis from harm to hope - a chronic illness guide by Casey Berna LCSW (‘Licensed Clinical Social Worker’) published by Sheldon Press, an imprint of John Murray Press this February (2026). Berna has endometriosis too and she describes her personal experience alongwith that of others in this book. ‘This book is dedicated to my brave and resilient daughter. May disease or illness never make you doubt your self-worth. May you never mistake your lack of capacity for a lack of competence. May you always believe your lived experiences. May you never suffer fools who invalidate you. May you always feel loved.’ Casey Berna [2%] ENDOMETRIOSIS & PAKISTANI WOMEN: “In Pakistan, the estimated prevalence of endometriosis is 16.8%” According to an article published in Journal of Gynecology Obstetrics and Human Reproduction (Volume 50, issue number 9, November 2021, co-authored by Mohammad Hasan Raza Raja, Nida Farooqui, Dr Nadeem Zuberi, Mussarrat Ashraf, Dr Arfa Azhar, Rozeena Baig, Bisma Badar, and Dr Rehana Rehman). - this of course is as per reported data - because most of endometrial patients are silent sufferers. For e.g. a symposium “Endometriosis: a conversation to accelerate action on helping women who are suffering in silence” was held at Capital Hospital Islamabad in March last year (2025) A news report on it was published in Dawn March 10, 2025. It quoted Capital Hospital’s Executive Director Dr Mohammad Naeem Taj as saying that: “About one in four women undergoing laparoscopic procedures is diagnosed with endometriosis.” Dr Taj, a leading laparoscopic surgeon of Pakistan, underscored the significant yet often overlooked prevalence of endometriosis in Pakistan. He also pointed out that the disease remained poorly understood and inadequately addressed due to a number of factors including insufficient medical knowledge, limited public awareness, inadequate research funding and societal taboos surrounding women’s reproductive health. In her keynote address, Prof Dr Syeda Batool Mazhar stressed the importance of early diagnosis and personalized management tailored to individual fertility desires and pain severity. She also stressed the positive impact of lifestyle modifications and advocated for accelerated programs focused on women’s rights and empowerment, particularly in health-related matters, to ensure informed decision-making in disease management. Dr Sheeba Noreen, head of the Department of Obstetrics and Gynaecology at Capital Hospital, addressed the diagnostic delays caused by societal stigma surrounding menstruation. Dr Hadia Aziz, Associate Gynecologist, highlighted the societal invisibility of endometriosis sufferers which denied them adequate healthcare and recognition of their pain. She emphasised the state’s moral and political obligation to acknowledge their suffering and provide essential resources.” GLOBAL / U.S. STATISTICS ON ENDOMETRIOSIS: So the experience of Pakistani women is not that different from those in rest of the world. According to the non-profit Endometriosis Foundation of America, Endometriosis affects an estimated 200 million women worldwide and approximately one in 10 women in the U.S. (that would be 6.5 to 9 million women btw in America alone) Office on Women’s health, part of U..S Department o9f Health & Human Services, quotes a study to give statistics on how prevalent this chronic disease is: ‘It may affect more than 11% of American women between 15 and 44.1’ [’Incidence of endometriosis by study population and diagnostic method: the ENDO study’.] World Health Organization quotes similar stats: that it ‘affects an estimated 10% (190 million) of reproductive age women worldwide.’ [15 Oct. 2025] DELAY IN DIAGNOSIS: What is important to remember is that on average, there is a 7-10-year delay in diagnosis [as per EndoFund website.] That’s a hell of a long time to be unwell and unsure and scared. And there are plenty of books in the market on this subject in all kinds of languages. It’s always good to consult your local health care worker, General Physician, gynecologist, reproductive endocrinologist, functional medicine expert or nutritionist, too. I’m sure plenty of listeners are interested in finding as much info about it as possible and in this regard, the book by Casey Berna will comfort an affectee and enhance the possibilities of cure or manage the symptoms. NOT A GYNECOLOGICAL SUBSPECIALTY: She makes it a point to mention that ‘endometriosis is not a gynecological subspecialty’ [pg.25] and how ‘most of the health care providers do not learn much about it in medical school’ [page 24] - now this is something that is very important in relation to Pakistan, where the only recourse available to women is a gynecologist referral, no specialist or general physician is recommended or answers your questions. You’ll have to go to a gynecologist and get yourself tested and they will give whatever medication they think is good for you to reduce or eliminate the endometrial cyst. So even if you are single, unmarried, virgin or non-sexually active, you still have to sit in a labor room / waiting area with married women who are either in some month of pregnancy or are trying to get pregnant. The gynecologist surgeon whose speciality is maternal and fetal / baby care before and after pregnancy, not endometriosis, will have 5 minutes to do an ultrasound on your ovaries / pelvic region basically or abdomen or breasts to check for endometrial tissue - and you are only getting it checked on the advisement / direction of a general physician, since the GP has no such expertise or facility. Some gynecologists have their own fertility centres or IVF treatment facilities and they are laser focussed on profits off the baby-making machine. The clinic will be extremely crowded with no privacy and the doctor will simply have no time to discuss your ‘symptoms’ or anxieties or queries. They have scores of clients waiting. Fee for consultation 3-5K. Ultrasound: 4-7K per area. Blood tests: 500 rupees - 20K (if hormone indicators are also tested). Medicines: 3K-plus per month, which may or may not reduce pain, make you bloated, depressed or fat. The OB/GYN surgery on ovaries to remove cyst or endometrial tissue may render you infertile completely - a risky gamble of a surgery. Now Berna in this book differentiates between a general OB/GYN doctor (who monitors pregnancies and deliver babies) and a gynecological oncologist who screens and treats cancer patients. However, there is no multidisciplinary specialist for endometriosis. She says that American doctors usually rely on the Management of Endometriosis Practice Bulletin by American College of Obstetricians & Gynecologists (ACOG) to diagnose and treat it. [page 26] Btw, the ACOG recommends that if pain is severe and does not go away even after treatment, then a hysterectomy i.e. removal of ovaries may be done. [https://www.acog.org/womens-health/fa... ] In fact, Berna says that “so much of the research surrounding endometriosis and treatment for the disease are based on stopping menstruation, or dramatically reducing estrogen levels inducing menopause-like symptoms, or surgically removing our ovaries and/or uterus to treat the disease. We are told time and again that if we can make it to menopause we will feel better. Some of us are even encouraged to go through surgically induced menopause to be able to find relief from all of our endometriosis symptoms. Some people do feel better once they are in menopause. I often wonder how many of these people also had adenomyosis or other uterine-based conditions that did get better after menstruation stopped. We know that endometriosis, adhesions, fibrosis and inflammation exist in menopausal patients.” [pg. 60] INFERTILITY: There are a lot of myths around this disease. The most important thing to remember is that not everyone with endometriosis is infertile, as Casey Berna notes on pg. 43. The American Society of Reproductive Medicine estimates that 30-50% of women with endometriosis suffer from infertility and 25-50% of women with infertility have endometriosis….but there are multiple factors that contribute to infertility in endometriosis patients and she goes on to describe all of them [pages 43-44] DEFINITION: Even though endometriosis is normally discussed in relation to reduced fertility, Casey Berna defines it as “a systemic inflammatory disease that can impact nearly every organ in the body. By definition, endometriosis is the presence of endometriotic lesions (or tissues) found in various locations outside of the uterus. These lesions are similar in nature to the tissue that lines the uterus, except endometriotic lesions create their own estrogen and stimulate the release of excess prostaglandins [which are hormone-like lipid/fatty compounds], often inciting an inflammatory response from our own body’s immune system. The inflammatory response is our body’s way of trying to heal, yet the body is not able to eradicate the lesions. Pain, inflammation, organ dysfunctions, fibrosis, and adhesions commonly develop wherever endometriosis exists and also contributes to systemic inflammation throughout the body.” [pgs 1-2] She calls it ‘an unwelcome intruder in the body,’ ‘an excruciating and invasive disease that impacts 1 in 10 individuals assigned female at birth, and loess commonly has been found in cisgender males.’ [pg. 2] Page 4: “While endometriosis can impact fertility and sexual health, it is far from the only thing. It can impact the ten other systems in the body including _____” [she lists down the other body organs] She says it’s not simply a hormone imbalance, that it’s not a curable disease, that it’s not just a white woman’s disease or caused by sexual trauma, but most importantly she writes, endometriosis is not just ‘in the patients head’ as women sufferers are so often brushed aside on this pretext. [pages 4-5] SYMPTOMS: Right at the beginning [page 1], Casey Berna quotes a 26 year old woman’s symptoms as following - you’ll find real case studies and views of actual sufferers in this book: And another one aged 16 who is quoted on page 8, etc. She goes on to lay out the all-encompassing and diverse set of things a person feels when they have endometriosis on pages 7-8]. And says on page 10 that “in our thirties and forties, (health care) providers more readily recognize endometriosis if we are white and struggling with infertility. But by then, the disease has been thriving in our bodies for decades.” [pg. 10] MULTIDISCIPLINARY TREATMENT: On pages 17-31 she gives multidisciplinary options available to affectees. She starts by naming the types and side effects or drawbacks of all medications that may be prescribed to an affectee: for e.g. the NSAIDS (nonsteroidal anti-inflammatory drugs), the combined hormonal contraceptives, progesterone and progestins, GnRH agonists (which put you in a menopause-like state) and GnRH antagonists (drugs with significant side effects to the individual and their fetus), surgical treatment options available (for removal / excision of endometriosis) which according to Berna, may include a team of a general surgeon, a colorectal surgeon, a urologist and sometimes a cardiothoracic surgeon, while majority of OB/Gyns cauterize or burn the surface of the endometriotic lesions, called the ablation technique. [pages 21-22]. Even after doing all this, there is no guarantee that these options will reduce the symptoms and or reduce the chance of the disease progression to other parts of the body. But she recommends pelvic floor therapists and mental health practitioners, pain management specialists, acupuncturists, nutritionists and functional medicine practitioners for a truly multidisciplinary care for endometriosis. [pg.23] On pages 65- 90 she discusses the possibility of other chronic health issues simultaneously with endometriosis and challenges in their proper diagnosis and treatment such as adenomyosis, uterine fibroids, interstilial cystitis female bladder pain syndrome, polycystic ovary syndrome, fibromyalgia syndrome, myalgic encephalomyelitis / chronic fatigue syndrome, hypermobile Ehlers-Danlos Syndrome, postural orthostatic tachycardia syndrome, mast cell activation syndrome, even long COVID. Autoimmune disorders like lupus, rheumatoid arthritis, celiac disease, Multiple sclerosis, inflammatory bowel disease, addison’s disease, sjorgens disease, hashimotos thyroiditis etc. can also co-exist at the same time as and overlapping endometriosis. You’ll see that the symptoms of these syndromes and disorders mirror those of endometriosis with fatigue, pain, and gastrointestinal issues recurring theme. From pages 91-183, she goes on to talk about the toll all of this takes on mental health. A huge range of medical trauma is discussed. The needs of such an individual on a personal, familial, societal and advocacy level are pointed out. SUPPORT PROTOCOL FOR ALL PROVIDERS: Health care professionals can review the support protocol she wants them to follow given as Appendix A on page 185- 188. So all in all, this book provides a summary of the multitude of issues surrounding the subject of endometriosis and it will be helpful to anyone who wants quick, easy to read info on all basic aspects of the disease to better prepare on what to expect from one’s own self and others. Thanks to the publisher for the ARC. All the best to the author in her health journey. LINK TO REVIEW ON YOUTUBE: https://youtu.be/C-CpxeBsdjU ...more |
|
|
Feb 12, 2026 03:24AM
· like
· see review ·
preview book
See a Problem?
We’d love your help.
Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of
Endometriosis From Harm to Hope by Casey Berna.
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Not the book you’re looking for?
Preview — Endometriosis From Harm to Hope by Casey Berna |
|
|
Noorilhuda
rated a book liked it
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
“How have I made myself captive to this entitled, petulant knobhead?” is what Fatima Bhutto wonders in Chapter 15 of her latest memoir The Hour of the Wolf, at exactly 86% mark of the Advance Review Copy I read courtesy of the publisher Scribner. The
“How have I made myself captive to this entitled, petulant knobhead?” is what Fatima Bhutto wonders in Chapter 15 of her latest memoir The Hour of the Wolf, at exactly 86% mark of the Advance Review Copy I read courtesy of the publisher Scribner. The ARC is in digital format and so whenever I quote from the book you’ll see me give the percentage instead of the page number. The entitled petulant knobhead in the question is a mystery man Bhutto was involved with and in love with for 10 years from 2010 to 2020, which she refers to as her “lost decade” in Chapter 6 (at 39% mark). A relationship that went nowhere while going everywhere. This is the same decade that was most fruitful for her professionally - she launched her career as a published author of non-fiction and fiction books, her work was translated into various languages, she had successful book tours, she traveled all over the world to write commissioned pieces for well-reputed international magazines and websites. Her instagram account created in 2013 shows that she stayed in parts of Peru, Lebanon, Egypt, Iran, Nepal, Pakistan, India, Netherlands, France, Italy and Spain, America and UK. She established herself as a paid speaker. She was in demand as an activist and an interviewee giving her voice to causes close to her heart. And yet she felt unheard and unappreciated in a dead-end coercive relationship with a non-committal man who wouldn’t have a child with her. How did an intelligent, well-educated, successful and independent woman settle for something like this? In Chapter 7 at 47% mark she says, “There is a version of this story that is a love story. I have written drafts of that story before abandoning them.” So the reader will see the lows, of how the relationship disintegrated, but not the highs. And she lays out all the red flags that everyone except her saw. She says in Chapter 5, at 31% mark, that she met him during the book tour for Songs of Blood and Sword when she was 28. She introduces us the readers to him in Chap. 6, at 34% mark as “When we met, the man didn’t want anything from me. He wasn’t intimidated by me; in contrast to almost everyone I encountered, he was preternaturally cool, unruffled, unfazed. He was curious about me, he told me, because he saw I was suffering and he knew he could fix it……The man had a wild confidence, a surety about everything he said that made you believe him too, as outlandish as some of his claims were—that he could take away pain, remove suffering, proffer insight into any problem, no matter how large or how small.” “He had many stories in his personal archive of all the women he had helped stand up for themselves, empowering them by engaging and guiding them. He helped me to stand up for myself with other people, insisting I confront them and have uncomfortable conversations in order not to be pushed around. He delighted in his ability to deliver powerful insights to strangers just as he had helped me with my grief.” [35%, chap. 6] She is swept off her feet. From her descriptions, he comes across as a learned, confident, fit man of great stamina who is busy enough to frequently travel for work and rich enough to drop everything and take up whatever hobby fancies him. He’s unmarried. As she writes at 38% mark [chap.6]: “He held forth on Buddhism, industrial history, World War II, the Mongols, and counterespionage tactics……He taught me how to walk against the howling wind and protect myself against the cold, how to catch and free fireflies, and—with great resistance on my part—how to ride a motorcycle.” “During our time together, I relied on him the way a student does a teacher or a patient their doctor.” [34% mark, Chap. 6] “He could run in sneakers or barefoot, it didn’t matter. This was what made him unusually excellent at most things he chose to do—his stamina, fortitude, but most of all his patience. When he was determined about something, he was tenacious.” [57%, chap.8.] She trusts him completely (as she recounts the anecdote of how she allowed him to walk her down and up again a countryside hill with her eyes shut and feet completely bare.) [35%, chap.6] You will be shocked to find the many instances in which she recounts being coercively controlled by the unnamed man. For one thing: he wanted to remain anonymous, never go public with her, which meant that none of her friends, colleagues or family members would ever meet him or spend time with him. He’s a feminist and he believes in equality, or so he says. But Bhutto pays for everything, even the hormone injections that she needs for producing enough eggs so that they can be extracted and frozen for future eventual maybe babies, before her biological clock runs out. You’ll read with horror the intimate details of Bhutto’s attempt to inject her stomach and weeks later to go through the procedure requiring general anaesthesia in a Barcelona clinic to retrieve the eggs - a process she calls ‘Eggxit’ in Chapter 8, at 55% mark. Her boyfriend makes up an excuse to not be there for any of it and tells her about this difficult and fear-inducing process that if it doesn’t work, “you can do it again in five years.” [57% mark, Chap. 8, Day11] and how he thinks her dog Coco is like a daughter to him. [82%, Chapter 13] I wish Bhutto had been a bit more transparent about their long distance arrangement, on where he lived or whether he was in the same field as her, on whether she ever felt he was seeing other women when not with her, because it felt like a situation where he was having his cake and eating it too, and she was left to pick up the pieces of his free bird nature, arrogance or rudeness or absence. He - who is not named or identified in any discernible manner - is written as an insufferable twat. He disses her writing, undermines her nomination for an award, goads her to leave friends he thinks are insincere. 47% [Chapter 7]: “I never pushed too hard, though, partly because I was victim to the same rotten thinking that plagues so many women: that this would pass, and it would pass because I could change him.” 48% [Chapter 7]: “By year seven, this “logic” took on a new, slightly manic overtone. When I had outrun reason, I started to pray, and I visited shrines and temples on my travels. Allegra and I drove all day one summer in Italy to see the shrine of Saint Rita, saint of impossible causes. I bought crystals, I wore talismans. I took vitamins…..If I couldn’t convince the man that seven years was a terrible amount of time to make a woman wait to have a baby, then God would persuade him. Or the dynamic power of tourmaline. Or chanting……By my late thirties, I could think of nothing else. I drove myself crazy with a ragged determination to blame everything except my decision to stay with the man for my failure to have a family. I looked up surahs and listened to Alan Watts and Thich Nhat Hanh. I channeled my frustration into writing. I exercised. I tumbled into a deep depression and stopped eating, seeing people. I lost weight. I started eating again. I injured myself running. I stopped exercising. I stopped eating chocolate, renouncing it as an offering to the universe in exchange for what I wanted, chocolate in exchange for my life’s dream. I ran away. I hid. I studied my horoscope. I wrote gratitude lists. At the height of my desperation, at the age of thirty-eight, I called an astrologer a friend swore by. I asked her to do a chart for the whole year, and when she asked me if there was anything in particular I was interested in knowing about, I didn’t hedge—will I have a child? After a week or so, the astrologer sent me a recording and prefaced the year’s forecast by gently telling me that she didn’t see anything to do with children. Or much else, for that matter.” Here is the entire gamut of psychological roller coaster that gaslit people go through. Privilege does not protect you from being vulnerable or from becoming emotionally dependent and trying to manifest a different outcome when you’ve invested so much time in a man. Plenty of women have fallen for this and will identify with Bhutto, but only to a certain extent. Because Bhutto mourns the loss of a future she thought she’d have with this boyfriend without real world problems or therapeutic adventures. She doesn’t mention any mental health or wellness intervention that she may have sought. Maybe the act of writing this book and exorcising the past was revelatory therapy for her. As a financially independent woman with no strings or contracts (legal or moral) attaching her to this nameless boyfriend, it was easy for her to let go. Reading the book one feels that she simply grew tired of waiting and when she faced an endless impasse (of him not wanting to ‘plant roots’ and have kids with her, wasting her time), with no resolution and no intimacy, hating him and resenting him, all pretense gone, she makes a clean break from him. And remarkably does not suffer the ignominy and awkwardness of meeting him in her circle (professional or personal) thereafter because it had been a secret / private relationship. The anonymity of the man remains intact, with no possibility of ‘his side of the story’ (like James Hewitt or Hasnat Khan or Prince Charles of Diana fame) and counter accusations (like Ejaz Rehman of Reham Khan fame.) The possibility of him answering uncomfortable questions like the politician Mustafa Khar on the memoir of his ex-wife Tehmina Durrani is non-existent. The chance he may capitalize and try to make a quick buck over Fatima Bhutto’s activist-celebrity status remains. The chance of him having a kid with someone else is more than likely, because men don’t have a biological clock. The book’s title is derived from Ingmar Bergman’s film Hour of the Wolf and was suggested to her by one of her friends. At 75% mark, in Chapter 12, she writes, “Ingmar Bergman’s 1968 film Hour of the Wolf is about an artist who has a breakdown while on a secluded island with his wife. It takes place mostly between midnight and dawn—at the time when people are supposed to lay down their worries for rest, Bergman’s artist hallucinates and goes slowly mad. Bergman calls this time in the dark of the night the “hours of the wolf”; it is “when most people die, when sleep is the deepest, when nightmares are more real. It is when the sleepless are haunted by their deepest fear, when ghosts and demons are most powerful.”27 The Hour of the Wolf is also the hour when most children are born, Bergman says. I think about this at night, lying in the sleepless dark. I was born during the hours of the wolf. I don’t know when exactly, there is no one I can ask.” Maybe through this title, Bhutto means to say that her “lost decade” was the hour of the wolf - a time when she was dying in the relationship and then was reborn, once she left it. And she stayed firm in this resolution, even when he tried to insinuate himself back in her life. You’ll rejoice when you find out at the end of the book that she not only got married to another man (called Graham ‘Gibran’ Byra) but was five months pregnant when she finished this book (their son, whom she named Mir in memory of her father, was born when she was 42.) Her second son Caspian Mustafa was born last year. Her instagram feed has pictures of her husband and the wedding. She has also shared pictures of her baby in the arms of her brother. This book is not just about a bad relationship but also about finding roots and comfort in extended family which in her case comprised of her girlfriends Allegra, Ortensia and Sophie who were there for her when the man wasn’t, and her Jack Russell terrier Coco and the dog’s offsprings, the one that was still-born during Covid-19 lockdown (given in heart-rending detail in Chapter 3, at 17% mark) and the puppies from another pregnancy Teeni, Stellina, Caro, Tokyo, (whose birth she witnesses in Chapter 12, at 77% mark) as well as the adoption of a Daschund. At 79% mark, in Chap. 12 she writes, “I didn’t expect to learn this much about love or God or grace from any of this (i.e. when she is caring for the puppies). I didn’t expect to be so moved by the simple act of care.” Dog lovers and animal lovers will rejoice at Bhutto’s treatment and conversations about her dogs as if they are human beings: she writes at 77% mark of the same chapter (chapter 12) about how her friend Allegra blessed the newborns in the name of the Father, Son, and Holy Spirit (as per Chritsian tradition) and Bhutto “(I) whisper(ed) the azan in the puppies’ ears, echoing Muslim tradition that sings the call to prayer in a newborn’s ear after birth so it is the first sound they hear,” and when the puppies are 3 years old, while out on a walk with them, she meets a priest talking to 2 brothers and these 3 people then sing the Franciscan blessing for the animals to them (as told at 90% mark in the Epilogue.) Her insta account is littered with pictures of Coco and her puppies. The book is strongest in the elements mentioned above, but Bhutto provides nothing more than word salad on nature and climate change. Her verbiage on deer, ants, wolves seems derivative and inspired from iconic books such as H is for Hawk (a book that she recommends on her insta account.) WHO IS FATIMA BHUTTO: For the readers who don’t know who Fatima Bhutto is, here’s a brief summary: Bhutto family is a feudal landed gentry from the province of Sindh in Pakistan that saw its ascent in national politics in 1960s with the cultivated rise of firebrand Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto opposing the fiery Bengali Sheikh Mujibur Rehman. Bhutto became the first democratically elected prime minister of a divided Pakistan and soon ran into trouble with the military establishment. He was hanged. Z.A. Bhutto was married to Nusrat Bhutto and they had 4 children together - 2 sons, and 2 daughters. One of the daughters was Benazir Bhutto who herself became prime minister twice and was killed on her third attempt. She had three children with Asif Ali Zardari, the current president of Pakistan. Z. A. Bhutto’s other daughter Sanam Bhutto settled in London and does not take part in active politics. The sons died under mysterious circumstances: Shahnawaz Bhutto was poisoned to death in France while Mir Murtaza Bhutto was shot to death by police when his sister was in power. A case full of conspiracy theories (which assassination isn’t?), I still remember the horrific video shown on an international news channel of a bullet riddled but still alive Murtaza Bhutto as he sat erect on a hospital bed or stretcher bleeding profusely from the torso and mouth with no doctor knowing what to do with him. He was Fatima Bhutto’s father. Z. A. Bhutto is her paternal grandfather. Nusrat Bhutto is her paternal grandmother. She frequently commemorates their lives as well as that of her father and uncle on instagram. No mention of Benazir Bhutto - none that I could find (other than her picture with a dog in a post about pet dogs that Bhutto family has had over the decades). Murtaza Bhutto’s other child is a son Murtaza Bhutto Junior, an artist activist. He is Fatima Bhutto’s half-brother. She mentions in this book that she has two brothers. THIS BOOK’S PLACE IN CELEB MEMOIRS: The Bhutto dynasty is splintered into two groups: the children of Benazir Bhutto who actively take part in elections and politics, making and breaking alliances, etc. i.e. Aseefa Bhutto Zardari, groomed and styled in the image of her murdered mother, is an elected parliamentarian and serving as the First Lady of Pakistan while her father is the president, and Bilawal Bhutto Zardari is the country’s Foreign Minister, something that Z. A. Bhutto was once too, and is heading Bhutto political party. Their sibling Bakhtawar Bhutto joins them on occasion but has been busy raising her family in U.A.E. The other group is that of the children of Mir Murtaza Bhutto who have chosen for now to not be part of the political or democratic or any ‘hybrid’ process: These include Fatima Bhutto and her brother. She generated a lot of buzz in Pakistani media in 2019, when she abruptly went to Larkana, Sindh and laid wreaths on the graves of the murdered / assassinated / hanged Bhuttos. It was seen as a sign of her entry into politics before general elections. But nothing came of it. In a rapidly changing world, it’s an interesting dynamic to have two sets of young leaders - some would say nepo political kids - who take different roads to political engagement. The distance from active politics gives Fatima Bhutto and Z.A.Bhutto Junior freedom to say and do and live their truth without the inconvenience of being answerable to any one. However, electoral process and resultant alliances, limits and binds Aseefa Bhutto, Bilawal Bhutto and even the non-political Bakhtawar Bhutto, to accountability, judgement and criticism. The rigid, official and aristocratic airs of Benazir Bhutto’s children are off-set by the casual rag-a-tag grassroot PR campaigns launched by Murtaza Bhutto’s kids. The doers versus the idealists. Though in recent years, Fatima Bhutto and Z.A.Bhutto Junior have stepped up their visibility and charitable work in Pakistan. Maybe the biggest lesson from the lives of all these Bhutto kids is that you can have a long, comfortable life as long as you don’t threaten or resist the status quo. That bargain is a sacrifice in itself. Through this book, Fatima Bhutto goes a step further - she makes herself relevant to the young generation looking for authentic idols by talking about her disaster in dating and disappointment in love. Her story is relatable to women because she talks about coercive control, gender inequality, motherhood, fertility treatment and its side effects - all of which are hot button trending issues. Her soulful connection with her dog is relatable to everyone who has or ever had a pet. Maybe in a few years she’ll write about perimenopause and menopause and explain what options (medical, herbal or meditative) she chose for flourishing in her fifties, another non-electoral connection to the masses as a global citizen. LINK TO REVIEW ON YOUTUBE: https://youtu.be/B5SYxNr0yS4 ...more |
|
|
Feb 02, 2026 09:19PM
· like
· see review ·
preview book
See a Problem?
We’d love your help.
Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of
The Hour of the Wolf by Fatima Bhutto.
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Not the book you’re looking for?
Preview — The Hour of the Wolf by Fatima Bhutto |
|
|
Noorilhuda
has read
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
'Sometimes when you are in a dark place, you think you have been buried, but you've actually been planted.' Christaine Caine (page 148, Detours, 2025) By the time the reader reaches the Christine Caine quote on page 148, Smart has made sure that her a 'Sometimes when you are in a dark place, you think you have been buried, but you've actually been planted.' Christaine Caine (page 148, Detours, 2025) By the time the reader reaches the Christine Caine quote on page 148, Smart has made sure that her analogy of roadslides and not losing focus of who you are and not letting a horrible act or event define you or your life, sticks with you. It's about turning a negative into a positive. I urge readers to heed her words of wisdom and advice given on Pg.11, Pg.12, Pg. 16, Pg. 17, Pg. 22, Pg. 48, Pg. 71-72, Pg.120, Pg.148. Thanks to the publisher for the ARC. And all the best to Mrs. Smart. Review and reading posted on youtube: https://youtu.be/IlLcHFw_AuM ...more |
|
|
Jan 05, 2026 11:48AM
· like
· see review ·
preview book
See a Problem?
We’d love your help.
Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of
Detours by Elizabeth Smart.
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Not the book you’re looking for?
Preview — Detours by Elizabeth Smart |
|
|
Noorilhuda
has read
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
Noorilhuda
rated a book really liked it
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
So the best true crime book that I read in 2025 is Society Girl by Saba Imtiaz and Tooba Masood-Khan. Originally published in 2024 in Pakistan by Liberty Publishing and in India by Roli Books Publishers. The edition I read is the latest paperback, pu
So the best true crime book that I read in 2025 is Society Girl by Saba Imtiaz and Tooba Masood-Khan. Originally published in 2024 in Pakistan by Liberty Publishing and in India by Roli Books Publishers. The edition I read is the latest paperback, published in 2025. I’m a fan of Saba Imtiaz’s writing. I liked her fictional ‘Karachi, you’re killing me’ which was adapted by an Indian production house as a Sonakshi Sinha starrer ‘Noor’. Imtiaz researched for ‘Society Girl’ with her co-author Masood-Khan. Both did a two-season podcast ‘Notes on a Scandal’ on this story. The book is well-written, is a real page-turner and takes you on a smooth ride by vigilant co-author researchers. Mustafa Zaidi was a 40 year old poet and out of work bureaucrat. He was married to a German woman and had 2 children. At the time of his death, they were living abroad while he was in Karachi, the port city. He had been having an affair with Shahnaz Gul, a 26-year old married woman with 2 kids of her own. They moved in the same swinging high society social circle that can best be described as Pakistani version of desperate housewives and sex and the city. Even though you can still find such cocktail parties and events, they are a bit more hush-hush. The 60s and 70s were openly wild. In fact, Zaidi socialized with both Gul and her husband, who btw, with his glasses and receding hairline and features resembled Zaidi. Their affair had fizzled out around his removal from office but either he wanted to marry her or she wanted to marry him or he wanted to teach her a lesson for leaving him or she wanted to be rid of him over blackmail. Whatever the catalyst, it all led to him being dead in his bedroom of barbituate poisoning and or strangulation, while she’s found in the room next door, either pretending to be unconscious or actually unconscious. She has Librium, a tranquilizer in her stomach [as washed on page 226]. The phone is off the receiver and Zaidi’s body is entangled in the phone line. There is blood on his nose and mouth and on the bed. This is a locked room mystery because all the latches were in place from inside. The chowkidar / guard was conveniently off duty for the day of the death. Gul’s husband brought Zaidi’s friends with him to the house to look for his missing wife. On getting no response from inside the house, all of them went back without probing further or checking inside the house. Zaidi had mental health issues, having attempted suicide twice before, once in college, and once in university, both times over being unlucky in love. He was clearly unhinged in the months leading up to his death (the fact that he had printed 3500 defamatory flyers about Gul insinuating she was a high end prostitute provides a motive for the alleged murder). He seems to have had a good career in civil service during the decade of General Ayub, the ruler of United Pakistan, i.e. East and West Pakistan. The authors ignore the politics of Ayub years. They say Zaidi was selected on merit, but I’m sure plenty of Bengali people could do just as well who were openly discriminated against. Zaidi rose through the ranks. He was posted in good locations such as Sialkot and Lahore during Ayub’s tenure, and was awarded one of the higest civilian honors Tamghai-Quaid-e-Azam, so I don’t know whether there’s a correlation here, but in Pakistan contacts matter. Once Gen. Yahya took over from Gen. Ayub, Zaidi was unceremoniously removed from his job over charges of corruption. He was one of the 300 government officers (38 of whom were civil service officers) who were dismissed (the removal and its aftermath is given on page 114). The sex scandals of these two generals, true or exaggerated, are mentioned on pages 82 and 238 respectively. On page 48, the authors generate a line about to-be PM Zulfiqar Ali Bhutto’s ‘patronage’ of a less than reputable nightclub Excelsior. The journey of Zaidi’s German wife Vera is given in detail from pages 64-71, as she adapted to West Pakistan and navigated as a committed partner to a philandering husband. There’s a passage on page 69 about how a friend was told to knock on Zaidi’s bedroom before entering. The bedroom door had a sign “keep silent, God is sleeping inside.” (!!!) And a famous actress came out with Zaidi. It is heavily suggested that it was film actress Aliya. The wife seems okay with all of this. As to the woman at the heart of the mystery, and on the book cover, Shahnaz Gul appears to be a cross between a lady of the evening, Mata Hari and a conniving socialite going to great lengths to protect her reputation and marriage. She declared herself to be of Afghan nobility, a relative of an Afghan King Sultan who back in the day long long ago in 1800s, forfeited the Koh-i-Noor diamond to the then-ruler of Punjab, Raja Ranjit Singh. She said her noble family, royalty to be exact, was exiled to Ludhiana first, and then after partition of India, to Gujranwala. This is given on page 36. The authors make no attempt to investigate the veracity of this royal fairytale. On page 44, authors speak of her beauty “Shahnaz was beautiful. She had been the most stunning girl in that horse cart of girls in Gujranwala, the most goodlooking of her sisters.” I don’t understand the need to identify her looks one way or the other. Is it because these authors believe a man would only go bonkers over a woman if she were some reputed beauty? Gul isn’t, and in this book no person who knew her says she was. She is recalled as charming, which can mean a number of things. However, Zaidi IS described as a womanizer by plenty of people, friends and foes. I don’t know how much of a standard he had. I don’t think beauty had much to do with his taste in and inclination for women and I’m just commenting on the basis of how he is portrayed in this book. Infact, in any other write-up, Gul and her husband would be called social climbers. Here, they are simply a misunderstood couple. Gul’s ever-changing statements to the police from the hospital bed, her home and before a judge are eyeopening because I believe they are full of lies and inconsistencies. Her answers are suspicious bordering on the classic ‘I don’t remember’ defense of many a criminal. She does give a zinger of a reply to prosecutor though. On page 244, he asks her in court, “It has come in evidence that after his dismissal from service, you started giving the deceased cold shoulder and finally declined even to see him and instead developed friendship with other wealthy persons like Ahmed Pirbhai,” the prosecutor asked. “What have you to say?” And she replies, “Since I was never warmly interested in the deceased,” Shahnaz replied, “the question of giving him a cold shoulder did not arise.” She has the authors’ sympathies through and through who declare on page 257 that they believe Zaidi killed himself but that it is unclear to them whether he wanted to take Gul’s life or not. They also portray her as a heroic victim of West Pakistan, media, society and misogynisic, salivacious men. Her husband, a plumper older version of Zaidi, stood by her. And I wondered whether anyone had asked for his alibi for the 24 hours when his wife went missing because at the time that Zaidi is alleged to have died - mid afternoon - is when the husband said he had been on a school run. And he’s the one who came knocking on Zaidi’s door with witnesses to extend that alibi. He was suspicious. His statement to the police as reported in Jang daily newspaper is given on page 200. The authors grip you with this retelling of events of Zaidi’s life, beautifully capturing the high drama, intrigue and chaos of a sensational case, his wife’s press conference at 101-105 and her opinion on his affair with Gul on page 129, Gul’s interview to a newspaper is on pages 91-93, a police constable’s brush with ghosts in a graveyard (which seemed like an attempt by him to get attention frankly) is given on page 164, wife swapping club the key club is mentioned on page 133, the elections that led to the creation of bangladesh are narrated on page 203, and an interesting angle to the Zaidi mystery is laid out between pages 222- 229 by the forensic consultant Dr. Summaiya Syed-Tariq who reviewed the case for the authors. A lot of work has been done by the authors in compiling information and it is amazing. I found three things off-putting in this book: one is that the book has no solitary solo shot of Mustafa Zaidi while it has several pictures of Shahnaz Gul, given to the co-authors by veteran photographer Zahid Hussein from his personal archive. In a book that deals with the enduring mystery of what happened to the dead poet, he is barely there. Two miniature-sized group photos of Mustafa Zaidi are displayed: one with a friend and one with Gul. Also included is the front page of Hurriyat daily newspaper which has a few shots of him. I don’t know whether this erasure of the dead man is by choice or not but you get more clear images of the poet on the internet, either solo shots or with his family and with other poets, by just googling him. This is a feminist retelling where authors take pains to identify all the sexist labels thrown at Gul for sensationalism and ridicule. They want to hold a mirror to society that has a problem with female choice, consent and agency. And here is the second thing that I dislike in the book. In recounting the jet set lifestyle of the rich and powerful elites, the authors cherry pick their favorites, the ones given the pass and the ones they wish to demonize. Gul and bird-brained socialites are given a free pass by the authors, while legendary singer, actress, performer and fashion icon Noor Jehan is written about disparagingly just because of her connection to Gen. Yahya, the military head whose arrogance and actions led to the division of Pakistan and creation of Bangladesh. A fixture in Pakistani pop culture and music and playback singing from 1940s to her death in late 2000s, Noor Jehan is reduced to nothing more than being a participant in a cat fight as described on pages 240-241, a verbal sling fest that occurs between her and Gen. Yahya’s alleged pimp. Yes, pimp. An illustrated image of Gen. Yahya with Noor Jehan from a mediocre weekly magazine that nobody has heard of is reproduced here for the same scandalous effect authors lament should not have happened to Gul. In a book that does not include a single clear picture of the dead poet, an editorial decision has been made by the authors to dedicate a full page to the cartoonish campy illustration that has nothing to do with the subject of the book. It’s obvious that the authors are peddling a paper clickbait. Stars are called stars because they are right up there in the sky, through their talent, hard work and perseverance. They are exceptional human beings. And they are more powerful than any general, president, prime minister, monarch or religious leader because all of these titled individuals are time-barred, the respect for them is limited to their tenure. They are also divisive and don’t enjoy universal fandom. Pakistan is spoken of fondly because of its artists and creative people, no matter what it’s institutions may be to a local or a foreigner. And that’s true power. That’s why creative entities are used by armed forces, by elected officials and political parties, by religious groups and by royal families to look good, relevant or personable. Their time is bought to have fun. On the other side of the coin, creative entities need patronages and sponsors to make a living or to stay relevant. I mean, one of the richest men in the world (Mukesh Ambani) has the entire Indian film industry and most of news media in the palm of his hand because he wants a soft image and they want the business and the platform. It’s about having enough skin in the game so that no one can criticize you or go against you, where you control all of the media and players in one way or another. You don’t see the sweat, the compromises or the sacrifices the artists make. I believe no celebrity or entertainer in Pakistan has been bigger than Noor Jehan. Imran Khan may be second but he is divisive. It’s a shame we don’t give credit where it’s due. Noor Jehan lived a full life, in both a personal and professional capacity. In my view, a greater singer than her, male or female, does not exist in South Asia. The expression in her voice, the way she performed her songs, her beauty and her saris, her love life and her well-adjusted children, she had it all. She was a larger than life, self-made, independently wealthy, ambitious woman. If she had lived in India, a country that genuinely respects it’s stars, her manner of singing would be studied in Institutes, her life would be cause celebre and subject of a major motion picture, she would be given an honorary seat in the Parliament. But Noor Jehan became Noor Jehan inspite of living in Pakistan which has a topsy turvy film industry, politics, social history and lack of organized platforms for talented people. The acerbic way in which she has been brushed off in this book by the authors is not the first time I’ve seen Pakistani media talk negatively about her. After her death, I remember Shami sahib on his Duniya TV show speak of her entanglement with Gen. Yahya as if that was the highlight of her long illustrious life. It’s great to blame a woman for the crimes of men, isn’t it? Especially when she’s in the public eye but not a public servant? Next, a less-than-flattering portrayal of hers was generated in the Sarmad Khoosat directed TV series Manto. In it, she is played by Saba Qamar as an uncouth woman who cannot speak properly in Urdu (a racist linguistic trope that is often used in Pakistan against the Punjabis, Sindhis, Balochis, Pathans and people from the Northern Areas - everyone is considered illiterate if they don’t know Urdu). In this lame TV series, Noor Jehan’s determination to evolve and be a better singer is shown as grooming classes on how to sit, stand and talk. Her work ethic and passion for music is brushed off, not shown. On a broader structural level, Noor Jehan’s birthday and death anniversary is not recognized or celebrated by government. Television channels don’t play her film songs or ghazals or interviews. Seminars are not held in her honor. Newspapers don’t print an article on what she meant for Pakistan and what is her place in cinema. Several youtube videos mention her in relation to the men in her life, even though she’s a bigger name than all of them combined. I am a huge radio listener, because I am on the road most of the time. I can confirm that her songs are only sporadically played on the radio and that too primarily on Radio Pakistan. FM89, operated by Dawn newspaper, once did a series on NoorJehan but that’s about it. The other radio channels ignore her music. No true blue books, biographies or clinical assessments of her legacy have been generated in Pakistan. And it’s not like we don’t have a fat budget for literary or cultural activities. When I see Pakistanis lamenting the small-mindedness of Indian political leaders and media for banning Pakistani artists, I wonder what respect they envision for their artists in a foreign country when they don’t give a damn about their own legends. Entertainment is a serious thing, as serious as the civil-military relations. But guess what is covered by news channels and talk show hosts? Politics and mudslinging politics. Usually news channels and talk show hosts look down upon Pakistan’s creative people and artists. They only want to cover politics and military because they are paid sycophants? Um, no, because they think entertainment is beneath them and not a serious enough topic. I know this from my own experience working for major cable TV channels. At that time, artists were used for and dumped in shows airing on Eid because the anchors knew nobody watched television during Eid, since everyone is busy with Eid-related stuff, and they didn’t care what ran on those 3 days as content. Currently, all of the anchors have their own youtube channels and podcasts - and yet, not a single one of them interviews artists or talks about pop cultural phenomena. But they love to compare Pakistan with India. Well, India gave its highest honor, a state funeral, to Lata Mangeshkar, its legendary playback singer. What did we give to Noor Jehan? In this book, Noor Jehan deserved better, especially since the authors sound like progressive, well-educated women. The third off-putting thing are the snide remarks the authors make about Lahore versus Karachi. This is to be expected because a certain rivalry exists between residents of the two cities, Karachiites look down upon Lahoris and Lahoris have some beef with Karachi. It’s fun till it isn’t. The authors make a very good research-based comparison between the night life and party culture of the two cities, as it pertains to the 60s and the 70s, so far so good, but in their attempt to showcase the cosmopolitan feel of the port city of Karachi, they end up calling Lahore snooty and elitist, and much more. In the book, a Lahori billionaire thinks her city is ‘provincial’, a Karachiite says Lahore is ‘shallow’. On page 44, the authors write “(Karachi) was open, free and fun. There was simply more of everything - art, writing, culture, poetry, shopping markets, a bevy of eligible men, and more glamorous women than anyone could count.” I have no idea how the authors came up with this distinction about Karachi of the 50s, 60s or even the 70s. It simply isn’t true. I don’t want this review to turn into a culture war, but the unconscious bias of the co-authors is apparent when they mention the presumably fair-skinned Iranian Parsis and Anglo-Indians of Karachi, but not the Sindhis, as if Karachi was separate from Sindh. In fact, they clearly see the injustice meted out to Bengalis but not the second-class status given to Sindhis in Karachi. And all of this is done for what? To show cultural superiority of a people and a color and a language? No, the reason why the authors go to all this trouble to label Lahore as backward is because they feel obliged to come up with some reason for movement of Gul and her husband from Lahore to Karachi. The fact that her husband found a job with the Dawn Group of Newspapers in Karachi and that’s why the couple went to Karachi and not because Karachi was more diverse and open than Lahore, is not a good enough reason for them. They have to roast Lahore. I feel authors were unfair in these 3 areas. Overall, bravo to them for putting this project together. Review on Youtube: https://youtu.be/9VQ3RIAPZ6c ...more |
|
|
Noorilhuda
rated a book really liked it
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
At the start of the year, American Horticultural Society dropped Essential Guide to Organic Vegetable Gardening: Techniques and Know-how for planning, and tending a home vegetable garden organically. It’s published by Quarto Publishing Group - Cool S
At the start of the year, American Horticultural Society dropped Essential Guide to Organic Vegetable Gardening: Techniques and Know-how for planning, and tending a home vegetable garden organically. It’s published by Quarto Publishing Group - Cool Springs Press. AHS is a national gardening organization and the chapters I was most interested in were Chapters 8 Garden and Plant Care (page 153) and Chapter 9 Plant Protection (page 189). In the last couple of years, I’ve started putting the veggie and fruit peel leftovers back into the overall land to enrich it naturally, but this year I started creating my own compost piles, experimenting with different methods to have a home-made fertilizer (for e.g. a drum with leftovers plus cow dung plus charcoal and water, putting leftovers with cow dug in a dug up hole and the yeast and sugar fermentation in warm water solution, and I now store leaves, flowers and grass clippings for use in beds, I’ll share the videos and success and failures of each when I get time) This book has easy-to-follow tables such as types of Compost Feedstocks with the carbon to nitrogen ratio and (page 107-108) Common Compost Problems and Solutions (page 109) These should be read with other forms of fertilizers given on page 167. And with cover crops (such as mustard seeds, buckwheat, oats and peas) given on pages 174-175 used to restore soil health in between seasonal plantation (for e.g. before frost to spring). There’s a drainage test on page 112 that enlightened me: Called a Perc Test, AHS recommends digging a hole approx. 1 foot wide by 1 foot deep and filling it with water. “Wait until the water has completely drained and fill the hole again. After 15 minutes measure the drop in water with a measuring tape or ruler. The measurement will tell you the hourly drainage rate when multiplied by 4. Soils that drain less than 1 inch an hour are considered poorly drained. You’re in the sweet spot if the soil drains between 1.5 and 6 inches. Soils that drain more than 6 inches an hour are considered drought-prone.” (page 112) Water pools in my garden after rain and I think that’s why my mosambi and mango trees and citrus shrub are under a bit of stress. Page 118 shows underground drainage options. This ties in with signs of water stress given on page 171. There’s a very helpful Soil Quality Progress Report chart on page 115. As per the book, this chart was adapted from the Michigan Soil Health Progress Report Recording Sheet, so of course I looked for their sheet on Michigan State University’s website: This pdf document has a schedule (Suggested Assessment Timing) of sorts to check the health of a soil. In the AHS book, I learnt about soil ribbon to see what kind of texture the soil has. Soil Ribbon Test is when you take a bit of garden soil in your hand and add water to it to make a mud ball and once the mud ball is formed, you press it with thumb to see whether the ball crumbles immediately or the mudball forms a ‘ribbon’ . As per it’s worksheet given on page 115, AHS defines fair to good soil health as being the one in which “soil ribbon extends over 2 inches or is difficult to break”. I think this is an excellent book. As to getting rid of the weeds naturally, AHS tip is to scorch weeds by putting a plastic tarp on them during months of June, July and August (when the sun is in full swing and temperatures are high). This is called solarizing and it is given on Page 119. Symptoms of bacterial, fungal and viral diseases are distinguished in an informative table on page 204. On page 121 common organic herbicides such as non-culinary vinegar (which is called acetic acid) and citric acid as well as essential oils of cinnamon, clove and lemon are laid out, while a list of organic pesticides is given on page 200 which includes diatomaceous earth and neem. I didn’t know Diatomaceous earth lost its potency when wet, so that was good to know. I used a few organic herbicides to treat gummosis on my mango and citrus and mosambi (Orange) trees. My favorite line of the book is on page 190 in the passage ‘Dealing with Pests’ “The best organic pest defense is noticing problems before they spin out of control. Looking for pests is a great excuse to stroll through the garden each week. Why not admire the flowers or harvest a few carrots as you search for unwanted insects……Once you’ve identified pests, decide how much damage you can tolerate. Do you need picture-perfect arugula, or can you accept a few holes? Learning to live with less-than-perfect yet equally delicious produce can ease your pest woes.” (page 190) So all in all, for an amateur gardener such as I, this is a a good reference book that I can peek into to refresh my memory. I read this book specifically for suggestions and tips on compost, soil and plant diseases and organic solutions to handle and eradicate those diseases. This is a good book for that. It's a nice, comfortable, easy to follow guide from an organisation I really wanted to get advice from. Thanks to the publisher for the ARC. Review posted on Youtube: https://youtu.be/g0Pl2fx5yqc ...more |
|
|
Dec 29, 2025 10:59PM
· like
· see review ·
preview book
See a Problem?
We’d love your help.
Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of
Essential Guide to Organic Vegetable Gardening by American Horticultural Society.
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Not the book you’re looking for?
Preview — Essential Guide to Organic Vegetable Gardening by American Horticultural Society |
|
|
Noorilhuda
rated a book really liked it
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
How is 2025’s Martha Stewart’s Gardening Handbook: The Essential Guide to Designing, Planting and Growing different from 1991’s Martha Stewart’s Gardening Month by Month? The blurb on that one told us she has been gardening since she was 3 years old.
How is 2025’s Martha Stewart’s Gardening Handbook: The Essential Guide to Designing, Planting and Growing different from 1991’s Martha Stewart’s Gardening Month by Month? The blurb on that one told us she has been gardening since she was 3 years old. She’s 84 now. There have been shorter illustrated Do-It-Yourself step-by-step guides in the form of 1999’s Gardening from Seed (112 pages), 2000’s Gardening 101: Learn How to Plan, Plant, and Maintain a Garden (144 pages) and 2018’s Martha's Flowers: A Practical Guide to Growing, Gathering, and Enjoying (288 pages). At 368 pages, the 2025 tome is as long as the 1991 version. Both have been released in coffee-table-sized format hardcover. So what is new? The new book has been released as an audiobook with Stewart and Gabra Zackman as narrators. In 1991, her advice came from her trial and error over the course of 20 years on the six acre land located in Westport Connecticut (called the Turkey Hill farmstead). She sold that place by 2007. The 2025 book features lessons she’s learnt in her 153-acre Bedford estate in Katonah, New York. Both farms fall in USDA Plant Hardiness Zone 6. Btw, in the good old days a dedicated spread on gardening was published every March in Martha Stewart Living Magazine. Unlike others, who think they can wing it, by selling dried flower sprinkles because some marketing guy told them they could make money this way, Martha gets her hands dirty. This snippet is of her handmade dried flower potpourri for guests from the 1991 book. Martha Stewart is probably the original influencer, instragrammable before there ever was an instagram. The pictures and illustrations in her books are always gorgeous, detailed and authentic. Her keen eye, strong aesthetic and hard work is supplanted by an army of helpers, landscape designers, plantsmen, caretakers and botanical experts. She thanks all of them. She thanked all of them in the 1991 handbook which took 4 years to produce. Since she grows everything from the ground up, i.e. from seed, i.e. various flowers (annuals, perennials and bulbs), succulents and cacti, shrubs and trees, grasses, fruits and vegetables and herbs, her latest is good for beginners as well as established gardeners and for cooks looking for fresh seasonal meals. You can either try a new thing or re-do something old or remove what’s not working. She is a teacher and this is a tutorial. The longest chapter is on specialty gardens such as rose garden, water-wise garden (i.e. a garden that incorporates water conservation principles) and habitat garden (i.e. a garden that nurtures birds, bees and animals for a healthy ecosystem). She is into informal, idiosyncratic, wild-looking low-maintenance cottage gardens and fields which reminded me of the beautiful English country side and Miss Marple’s St. Mary Mead. The 1991 guide had recipes and there are none here. But of course, you can get them in most of her 100 previous books (this is her 101st), from Martha Stewart wesbite and the Martha Stewart blog. I’ll recommend checking out her favorite gardening books as well, which are given on her website. She has an entire library on gardening, of course: There’s instruction and vanity-laced joy and then there’s dedication, evolution, sentiment, satisfaction and gratitude in the act of gardening itself and incorporating it in cooking, entertaining, crafting. That’s timeless inspiration right there to get something going. This is a way to be food sovereign and combat climate change. This is a way of life. The great outdoors that start one big adventure. “If you want to be happy for a year, get married. If you want to be happy for a decade, get a dog. And if you want to be happy for the rest of your life, make a garden.” —Martha Stewart, Martha Netflix Documentary The big takeaway from this book (which is a lush collector's item) and Martha's life is to take a leap of faith and take a risk and just do it. You can read a hundred books on gardening but you'll never get it unless you get the actual experience. Review on Youtube: https://youtu.be/qCAJAgKvRbg ...more |
|
|
Dec 29, 2025 10:49PM
· like
· see review ·
preview book
See a Problem?
We’d love your help.
Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of
Martha Stewart's Gardening Handbook by Martha Stewart.
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Not the book you’re looking for?
Preview — Martha Stewart's Gardening Handbook by Martha Stewart |
|
|
Noorilhuda
rated a book really liked it
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
This is a genre-bending memoir that packs a lot of divergent material in a stream of consciousness style of writing. The audiobook was released by Harper Focus in May 2025 and is 14 hours and 3 minutes long. I listened to it while driving, gardening
This is a genre-bending memoir that packs a lot of divergent material in a stream of consciousness style of writing. The audiobook was released by Harper Focus in May 2025 and is 14 hours and 3 minutes long. I listened to it while driving, gardening and cooking, stopping at some tough moments narrated therein. Throughout the summer, Grammar gave a lot of interviews as part of the press tour to promote this book. He spoke to Diane Sawyer and Tamron Hall and the panel from The View, and via video link, joined Michel (‘Michelle’) Martin for PBS’s Amanpour & Company and Anderson Cooper for his new series on CNN ‘All There is’. Interestingly, Rob Lowe, Billy Bush, Graham Bensinger had him on their youtube channels. Leonard Picker asked him questions for Publisher’s Weekly. PW gave the memoir a starred review. People Magazine, NY Post and other news sites such as The Times on Sunday and The Australian have featured him too. In most of these interviews Grammer has said that he approached the book inspired by James Joyce’s narrative technique: Hence, what you get as a listener is an unfiltered, go-with-the-flow, fragmented and at time hyperbolic monologue in Grammar’s amazingly soothing, confident acting voice. There’s fond nostalgia, anecdotes on Grammar’s ancestors, mom, gam, grandpa, his cousins, his flings, loves and marriages, what they all mean to him, the values he wants his 7 children to have (his eighth was born after the book was published), his professional journey and career advancement through the decades is noted, as well as stories of deaths, accidents and murder in the family. Sprinkled inbetween are his thoughts on religion, spirituality, psychic phenomena as well as his opinion on abortion, death penalty and parole hearings for murder convicts. Chick Fillet’s Grilled Chicken Nuggets make an appearance. And yes, his 18-year old sister Karen’s life is eulogized in dignified pain and justified anger. Grammar makes it a point to remember every insignificant moment that he had with her to counter the horrific significance of her death. The audiobook serves as much as a 70 year old Grammar’s ‘memento mori’, i.e. an object kept as a reminder of inevitability of death, as much as it is on the joy of life, by honoring the threads that connect him, his sister with his extended family. It’s a true crime book and an allegory on grief with enough stardust to keep you interested and enough random verbosity to make you irritated. I love Kelsey Grammar and Frasier. I first read about his sister’s murder way back in the 90s, probably in People Magazine, when Frasier first started airing. Karen Elisa Grammer was born on 15 july 1956 in NJ to Alan and Sally and raised by Sally, Gam, and grandpa Gordon. She was just another teenage girl living it up in 70s America. She had completed college, had a boyfriend, an apartment, a job. But Grammar successfully brings out how normal, average and cool his sister was. Yes, there are adjectives and superlatives but there is also heart and a human being at the center of it. Grammar calls her the “true child of 60s” - 12:34 chap.26 In Chap. 26, at the 17:41 mark of a 20 minute 30 seconds chapter, he describes her as “an Oreo cookie dipped in ice-cold coca cola” (17:41-17:45 of Chap. 26). However, Grammar is limited in recounting his sister's life because of the refusal of her two best friends to be part of this project, he doesn’t give the reason as to why they refused, whether it was small money quote or his celebrity status or their need for privacy or something else, he does not say. And so, he has had to rely on his spurts of memory and her college roommate to fill in the gaps of what she was like in life and college, with friends and boyfriends. What you are left with is a feeling of what could or would have been. This book is the ultimate victim impact statement and also the ultimate biography for a young seemingly unremarkable victim whose true strength is revealed in her last moments, when she didn’t give up, despite bleeding profusely. She could have been any one of us. She had the misfortune of being kidnapped by strangers who proceeded to have their way with her. Just the bare minimum of facts are enough to chill a listener to his or her bone. Grammar recites the inevitable at the 7% mark of audiobook. In the 49 minute long chap. 3 titled ‘Then’. She was weeks away from her 19th birthday. chap. 3: titled Then: 00:00-00:57: “Karen approached 3 men entering the back of a Red Lobster restaurant. She had come to pick up her paycheque before heading out to the mountains for the fourth of July weekend. The 3 men had come to rob the place. There had been several murders in Colorado Springs that summer. These men were responsible. Karen had no idea who there were. She asked them what they were up to but I’m fairly certain she discerned quickly what suddenly faced her: Destruction. The story I was told by district attorney and others involved in the arrest of these men, has never really been clear. I think they hoped to spare my feelings, to keep the horror of what had actually happened from me. I appreciate that and I accept their reasons for being vague. The specific details of her suffering were kept from me but some information had to be offered. Conjecture of what she suffered is probably just as brutal as the reality. My imaginings paint the worst picture. But this is Karen’s tragedy, not mine….Yes I offered that perspective earlier, but this tragedy is Karen’s triumph as well. Her strength that evening is unfathomable. Her dignity stands forever an inspiration to me. What I’ve endured is nothing by comparison but it was enough for me, enough to hollow me in the journey of life and love and joy for a long time. I could not forgive myself.” (7% completed, 13 h 4 min left. Chap. 3: 00:00-01:29) Grammer further says that at the time of the abduction, Red Lobster restaurant had a rule that employees could not stay or wait inside the venue, and that’s why Karen had to stand outside. Grammer says this rule makes no sense to him. I think he mentions that after Karen’s murder, this rule was changed but I’m not sure. She worked in the kitchen and was waiting for her boyfriend to pick her up. She was by her friend’s car, in the back alley. “The men abducted Karen. They held her hostage for several hours. the district attorney told me Karen negotiated with them for her life, she would do whatever they asked if they spared her. I’m not sure she laid it out like that. Perhaps she implied she hoped they would spare her. I’m sure by the time they took her to the apartment where she was raped and tortured by them Karen understood that her life was at stake. I have thought for years at her heart in that moment, how it must have been beating, not like a rabbit’s frozen in terror before a wolf but increased in urgent and calculating as she tried to offer them a way out of killing her. Karen was always the brave one. Karen could even stand up to my grandmother.” (7% completed, 13 h 4 min left. Chap. 3: 01:35-02:17) Should Grammar have focussed a bit more on the horrific, cold, cruel, torturous, vicious, murder? I don’t know the answer to that. But what he reveals is still bone-chilling: Karen was knees, violated, punched, beaten, blindfolded with blue scarf, freddie (glenn) ties her hands, raped, sodomised (Grammer calls them "animals"; and that "I'm in prison 49 years of that night"), taken their turns, discussion on what to do with karen? openly discussed killing her, medium (to connect with karen; who told her she had been taken out before death), back in the car with 2: michael corbett was not there, karen escaped from car for mobile homes . “she escaped briefly”, 42 stab wounds. 7 wounds sufficient to kill her, each one could be fatal. police and da unclear one escaping. freddie gleen slashed her throat almost decapittating her, she staggered across the street few hundred yards away, crawled to trailer, man in trailer found her, paramedics tried to revive her, they could not. For context, Michael Corbett, Larry Dunn, and Freddie Glenn were spree killers responsible for three grisly murders in and around Colorado Springs, Colorado in 1975. Corbett and Dunn were soldiers. Freddie Glenn was a civilian employee at a Colorado army base. All three were young men. Of these 3, Dunn got full immunity to testify against the other two, Michael Corbett and Freddie Glenn. Corbett died in prison. Grammar is an openly conservative Republican, and there are important opinions expressed here, such as his feelings about death penalty and abortion. Unfortunately, his views on these subjects made more news during his book promotion tour than his sister or the nature of grief and coping mechanisms. Grammer speaks about parole hearings and death penalty in Chapter 4 (44 minutes long chapter, 15% completed audiobook, 11 h 55 min left of audiobook), right around the time he mentions (21:00 - 21:50). “Freddie Glenns said he was a good kid. So I wonder what happened to him that somewhere in his life he had the effrontery and self-loathing to plunge a knife 42 times into Karen’s body, over and over again, his hatred stabbed into her, after he and his friends had raped her, more than once. And there was more. Some good kid. And now whenever he appears for parole his protestations are never about how he longs to do something good for the world. Or how he wishes he could take it all back. According to Mr. Glenn as far as I can tell, he’s been in jail long enough. Just a good kid who somehow ended up in prison for a murder that doesn’t quite merit the rest of his life incarcerated. So he tore apart an innocent girl, ruthlessly, mercilessly, violently.” (21:00 - 21:50, Chapter 4, 15 % completed) “We were the good kids. Karen was the good kid. This man was an executioner, without any law to guide him, no decency at all, and no humanity. As I spent the next months and years about how to go on, he spent hoping he could get out. Not be held accountable. He and his friend actually pleaded not guilty and would have us believe to this day it was just a slip up when it was a vicious, premeditated assassination and destruction of my 18 year old sister. Letting her live would’ve threatened the freedom of his friends and himself. So they happily performed desecration of an innocent girl for what was to be an extra month of freedom before they were sent to die in prison. Freddie Glenn received the death penalty for his crime. During the Carter administration the Colorado Supreme Court agreed to review all death penalty cases and so his sentence was commuted to life in prison. He owes his life for what he did. He owes 42 lifetimes for every stab wound he plunged into my sister. My opinion.” (22:00-23:05, Chapter 4) And Grammer is not a fan of the parole hearings he has to attend every 5 years or so to make sure Glenn doesn’t get out. There are 2 abortions mentioned in the book: One occurs very early on in Grammer’s dating life, when he was in his early twenties and he expresses he left the choice to the girlfriend. The baby was a son. He says he’s remorseful over it. The second abortion that he recounts is with his current wife, his fourth, Kayte. They lost one half of their unborn twins when one baby’s sack ruptured at 13 weeks (Chapter 23) and did not heal naturally, and he and his wife had to make the difficult decision to abort the baby, a fetus, a son, to keep the other twin, a daughter, alive. As Grammer says at the beginning of Chapter 23, “We begged God to spare us this tragic choice but sometimes we are asked to play God. So a needle through Kayte’s belly, into his heart, killed him. We killed him. We killed our son so Faith might live. We wept as we watched his heart stop. Saw it. It’s the greatest pain I have known. Kayte’s scream was enough to make a man mourn a lifetime. Another lifetime. Mom’s scream when she learnt of Karen’s murder.” (00:32-01:09, Chapter 23 (Chapter 23 occurs at 95% of audiobook, and is a 14 min.s 35 seconds long chapter). I like the 'stream of consciousness' style of writing that he adopted for this project but this book needed a strong editor who could gently tell Grammar to pipe it down a bit when he goes off on tangents, drifting off into a time he wants to memorialize for himself, and not for his sister or the listener. For example, while waiting around Barry College, Karen’s college, he eats Chick Fillet’s Grilled Nuggets for the first time in his life. As a 68 year old. His verdict: Not Bad. Maybe his age plays a role? He’s seventy years old and maybe that makes him more susceptible to look back and reminisce about anything and everything, to purge and create a historical record, no matter how insignificant it may be to a probable audience. In this regard, the one minute 30 second short Chapter 7 “A Letter to the Reader” works as his disclaimer for these excursions. He says he has several pictures of her in his home. He says he sees her everyday (‘He says he has several pictures of her in his home. He says he sees her everyday’ is from Chapter 15). In Chapter 15, that at the 20:09 mark, (2o:07-20:55) “Last night it seemed her presence was clearly with us. And it seemed she wanted us to know something. Something that might surprise me. Pothead. Maybe. Not earth shaking or any cause for shame. Makes sense. I see her reaching for that candy. Karen is coming into our realm. I’m not crazy. Perhaps I’m a little foolish or a bit too willing to believe I’m in touch with her. But I have spent a lifetime with Karen and I would know. Haven’t heard the sound of her voice as I long to but she was definitely around last night. It was a warm and enjoyable evening with her and my kids and Kayte. There was love and there was a bit of mischief. Karen. Yeah that was Karen.” The book is peppered with these sorts of manifestations of grief, for e.g. how it fractured his personality and relationships, how it contributed to his drug and alcohol use, how he wants to capture the vicissitudes of his sister’s brief experience in life by visiting her college, which she left after a semester to be with her boyfriend John, her last apartment, the ground floor apartment she shared with her boyfriend, and her last place of work, the red lobster restaurant that she was kidnapped from, which is now a pawnshop). He did not go to address where she was murdered, because he didn’t note down the address for the trip (as he reveals in Chap. 26). In these passages, he is as much a ghost as he is a narrator grieving all the adventures, mundane and iconic, that he got to have without her by his side. Like I said, I love him. I love his work. He has an amazing voice which is put to good use here, like elsewhere, and I wish him all the best. This is part of my summer 2025 recommendations. Thanks to the publisher for the ARC. Review posted on Youtube: https://youtu.be/qr55LFzmbXo ...more |
|
|
Dec 28, 2025 06:50AM
· like
· see review ·
preview book
See a Problem?
We’d love your help.
Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of
Karen by Kelsey Grammer.
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Not the book you’re looking for?
Preview — Karen by Kelsey Grammer |
|
|
Noorilhuda
rated a book it was ok
|
Error rating book. Refresh and try again.
Rate this book
Clear rating
|
|
Killer Althusser by Francis Dupuis-Déri translated by Mélissa Bull was published by Between the Lines, which is a member of Literary Press Group of Canada, in July 2025. On its website, Between the Lines publishing house defines itself as a “social m
Killer Althusser by Francis Dupuis-Déri translated by Mélissa Bull was published by Between the Lines, which is a member of Literary Press Group of Canada, in July 2025. On its website, Between the Lines publishing house defines itself as a “social movement press that publishes nonfiction books that expose and challenge oppression in our society. We aim to amplify the struggles of Black, Indigenous, and racialized communities; migrants; women; queer folks; and working-class people. BTL is proudly leftwing and the books we publish reflect our activist roots and our commitment to social justice struggles. BTL authors are academics, journalists, artists, and activists—all our authors hope their books will spark political and social change. As a product of New Left radicalism, BTL embodies the cooperative and democratic ideals of its founders. BTL has no boss, no individual owner; we are run by a small staff and a dedicated volunteer editorial committee. Decisions on what we publish are made by consensus. We publish books not to seek profit, but to document and promote struggles for a better world, challenge the mainstream, and offer readers new perspectives on critical political issues. Our press is situated in Tkaronto, traditional Wendat, Anishinaabe, and Haudenosaunee territory subject to the Dish with One Spoon treaty. This land was stewarded by the Mississauga of the Credit River (that’s a First Nations tribe) and is home to many Indigenous peoples, including the Métis, and those displaced from their homelands by Canadian extractive and other industries. Together we share a responsibility to care for and nurture these lands and to struggle for a better future for the earth and all peoples.” So it's obvious that their office or printing press is located in indigenous tribal land. I looked up on the internet and here is a map of the area covered and identified as Dish with One Spoon land. Dish with one Spoon literally means sharing the resources of the land and conserving it with other nations or people who live on it, and at first, as I’ve come to understand, this treaty was between two tribes, but now is seen as a covenant between all of the indigenous tribes as well as the settlers, migrants and the Canadian government. The area includes part of Ontario, moving along freshwater lakes and borders Quebec. This is a beautiful idea that makes people stewards and protectors of the land, makes them responsible for its maintenance and growth, by not just taking but also giving something back to it, and allows them, whether local people or newcomers, to benefit from it, equally, peacefully in a just manner without discrimination. Under this idea and treaty, nobody is deemed superior or disrespected. Nobody’s rights are usurped and everyone gets a piece of the pie so to speak. Nothing gets wasted because you are only taking what you need and you are sharing it with others. The world, and dare I say it, Pakistan needs more of this on an institutional level and it’s no surprise that indigenous people, more rooted in nature and less in commerce, came up with it and practiced it long before foreigners commodified and scavenged the Americas as conquerers. You can learn more about this treaty by going to Canadian Encyclopedia website or checking out multiple youtube videos on the subject]. Coming back to publisher of Killer Althusser, Between the Lines says it has published more than 300 titles since its inception 48 years ago. And now to the book itself. Way back in 1980, a famous French philosopher killed his partner of thirty years after she told him she did not want to live with him anymore. He got away with it citing mental illness that he had battled all his life with frequent hospitalization, the media and literary brass supported him, he wrote a memoir, spent some time in a psychiatric institution, and then died a natural death. Bottomline: he never served any time in prison for the murder. He wasn’t cancelled as people are nowadays. His work is still critiqued and discussed. He is after all, one of the most influential thinkers on Marxism. His name is Louis Althusser and I think by titling his book Killer Althusser, author Francis Dupuis-Déri wants people to identify the revered professor as a killer too, removing all the other labels that served to protect him during his lifetime. He strangled his wife Helene Legotien-Rytmann in the early morning hours of November 16, 1980 and I found a news report that originally aired on a French TV channel INA Société on 17 November, a day later. The one minute thirty seven second package is full of pictures of Althusser taken by Daniel Levy. There’s not a single picture of the victim, the killed wife, Helene Legotien-Rytmann in it. I find it unusual that she is not covered or spoken of in the report. As the author, Dupuis-Déri notes in the book, the widely respected and influential daily newspaper Le Monde wrote on 19 November, 1980, about how studying the mental disorder could help explain the murder, in effect presenting an explanation for his actions before the esteemed professor was put to any sort of judicial process. It is this erasure, this determination that the real victim of the killing was not the long-suffering wife but rather the great intellectual himself is what infuriates Dupuis-Déri. He calls Althusser “banal, just another woman killer.” (56, Conclusion, Killer Althusser). There were no obvious signs of struggle or violence on Helene and only an autopsy revealed the strangulation but Althusser was not checked either for scratches or signs that she put up a fight. Because he was immediately placed in a mental hospital by his prestigious university’s staff, and by the time the police came he was long gone. A judge went to the hospital to tell him that he was being charged with ‘Voluntary homicide’ but the judge was told by staff that Althusser was in no position to be served with a warrant since he was mentally fragile in fact “in a state of total mental collapse and was incapable of understanding the legal procedure” (vii, Introduction, twin autobiography, Vintage, 1994). The judge ordered 3 psychiatrists to guage whether he was sane or insane at the time of commission of the crime as well as whether he was mentally competent to understand the charge against him. Two months later, on the basis of their reports, the judge dismissed the case. “In French terms, he declared a non-lieu. In English the term non-suit, or no-grounds is usually used. i.e. a refusal to order prosecution.” (vii, introduction, twin autobiography, Vintage, 1994) Hence, Dupuis-Déri considers this case to be “a social revealer, as by revisiting this crime, and particularly by examining the public discourse around the crime, we can see how a network of male protection and solidarity established to benefit the killer makes it possible to highlight the ‘hidden strategies’ of male violence against women.” [page 3, Introduction, Killer Althusser, 2025] Francis Dupuis-Déri himself is a political science professor and researcher at the Institut de recherches et d'études féministes at Université du Québec à Montréal (Institute for Feminist Research and Studies of the University of Quebec in Montreal). He has written about incels, toxic masculinity and rise of masculinist terrorism in a French titled book La Crise de la masculinité. Autopsie d'un mythe tenace ("The Crisis of Masculinity: Autopsy of a Tenacious Myth", 2022). Killer Althusser is translated into English by Mélissa Bull. I cannot comment on the quality of the translation, but the book reads more like a PhD dissertation than a work of narrative non-fiction. It’s a frosty research paper in which Dupuis-Déri coldly studies the contours of what Althusser said about the crime, how the French press and cultural and literary elite protected him and his status, not just from prosecution but even from condemnation. He also analyzes that ultimate question: can the philosopher be separated from the murderer? A documentary on the development of his ideological framework is available online. It has proper subtitles. It was made by Bruno Oliviero (Altooser Althusser: An Intellectual Adventure. While watching an interview he gave to Italian TV in April 1980, a few months before the murder, I was struck by how similar his definition of communism sounds like The Dish with One Spoon treaty. The anti-thesis of capitalism. Here, Althusser defines communism as “a mode of production where there are no economic relationships of exploitation nor any political relationships of domination. Neither are there ideological relationships of intimidation or pressure, nor of ideological enslavement.” (Louis Althusser: The Crisis of Marxism (interview) Interview date: April 30, 1980. Host: Renato Parascandolo) Althusser’s views on Marxism, communism, anarchism, Catholicism, etc. have been cited as much as his biographies, his writings and his letters to Helene, even his dreams and the probable meaning behind them have been dissected. Though Dupuis-Déri laments that Helene has been ignored in the countless discussions on the crime and the man responsible for it, he offers no new insight or passage, save a small biographical paragraph, and a bibliography of her published work, on what Helene’s life was like for thirty years or so with a distinguished man who may or may not have been a pill behind closed doors. He says on page 52, (‘Conclusion’, Killer Althusser, 2025), “What do we know about Hélène Legotien today? Almost nothing, except that she was murdered by her illustrious husband. She’s ultimately died twice and her murderer is responsible tor both of her deaths. He killed her first with his own hands and then a second time by occupying the entire public space to talk about himself under the pretense of addressing her death. A quick web search (with Google) leads me to see that there is almost no information available about her. Searching for her in fact almost inevitably leads us instead to her killer, Althusser.” It’s this anger probably that led to many people to contact him after the publication of the French title ‘Althusser; Assassin’ in 2023. They shed more light into Helene’s life and work. He includes their feedback in this translation. In his examination, Dupuis-Déri quotes from Althusser’s autobiography, ’The Future Lasts a Long Time’ - it was published after his death, and you must read it as well. Dupuis-Déri calls it “filthy” (page 51, ‘Can we separate the author from his work?’ Killer Althusser, 2025) a “tedious text on a literary level, revolting from a political point of view and disgusting from a psychological perspective, given how the murderer presents himself as a victim.” (page 17, ‘Psychologization and Victimization’, Killer Althusser, 2025). But it can be seen as a character study and historical record which you, as a reader and an analyst, can choose to believe or disbelieve. He authored another autobiography as well - Les Faits (The Facts). The French and English versions of the two books are available online. The French version of both books was published by Editions STOCK/IMEC in 1992 and the English version of both was published by Vintage an imprint of Random House in 1994. I am double-minded about the extent of Louis Althusser’s culpability because he did have a long history of endless cycle of psychiatric hospitalizations and had been diagnosed with bipolar disorder. I don’t know how he was able to perform his professorship duties amongst this chaos. Except for a doctor who lived near his apartment, none of his students or faculty members knew about his mental health struggles. That’s surprising to me. There has never been any investigative expose’ on his mental health records, medications or social life. He was 8 years younger than Helene, he was a Catholic and she was Jewish. During World War 2 he was in a German prison war camp in Schlesweig-Holstein and kept there for almost 5 years. The couple had lived as lovers for more than thirty years before they got married in 1976. His relationship with her is described in various places as strained. I have no doubt he was difficult to live with though he had a longterm residency and employment in an ivy league university. She worked as a researcher for an NGO SEDES (société d'études pour le développement économique et social) till her retirement. According to Dupuis-Déri, by 1980, Helene had expressed a desire to leave him and had been looking at apartments to move into. He said he had no memory of strangulating her in bed but does remember massaging her neck in bed. Red flags anyone? Is this story a cautionary tale for a woman to make a clean break before officially declaring a separation or breakup and to not reside with a mentally unstable man who can use his illness as an excuse to get away with an act that is rooted in anger and resentment and inability to let go? An eerie passage from his ‘Future Lasts’ autobiography (page 251, autobiography, Future lasts, 1994. translator: Veasey Richard; passage quoted on page 14, Feminist Insights, Killer Althusser) is quoted on page 14 of Killer Althusser. In it, Althusser says “I do not know what exactly I put Helene through (I do know, however, that I was truly capable of the most terrible things), but she told me with a determination that terrified me that she could no longer live with me, that in her eyes I was a monster and that she wanted to leave me for good. She began quite openly to look for a flat, but did not find one immediately. She then made practical arrangements which I found unbearable; totally ignoring me, though I was still there, in our own flat. She got up before me and disappeared for the whole day. It she happened to stay at home she refused to talk to me and even to come face to face with me..…I was consumed with anguish. As you know, I always experienced intense anguish at being abandoned and especially by her, but being totally ignored, though I was still there, in our own home, was the most unbearable thing of all.” I think this would be seen as a motive or trigger for the killing by any investigator or prosecutor. And maybe this would have come out if Althusser had ever been allowed to be detained and questioned by the police. In every available picture, some which are are being displayed on the screen right now, Helene comes across as a very cute, affable, lovely woman. While Althusser looks, well doesn’t he look like a grouch? After the murder and three year hospitalization that ended in 1983, his teaching days behind him, Althusser moved away from the university that he had been a part of for the majority of his life. He continued to receive guests including a former student who was an adviser to then-President Mitterrand. He gave interviews on subjects such as philosophy and psychology. He engaged with the press by writing to them about how they had misinterpreted his work. He read books written on his work. He wrote the autobiographies mentioned before and told his life story to a biographer. Basically, he seems obsessed that he be remembered for his professional work from the 40s to early 80s than what happened in his personal life on 16 November 1980. In the introduction written by Douglas Johnson, (vii, introduction, autobiography, 1994) it is mentioned that “From time to time, in his despair, he would walk in the streets of Northern Paris, a shabby ageing figure, and would startle passerbys as he would shout ‘je suis le grande althusser’ (I am the great Althusser)” Amidst all this, the revolving cycle of being in and out of hospitals continued and he died of a heart attack in a hospital. In an interview that he gave to Italian TV in April of 1980, a few months before the murder, he was asked by the interviewer the difference between love and respect and he replied: “What do you do if you insist ‘I have to love you because Christ asked me to?’ You run away. But if you have respect for the other, then he will leave you to do whatever you want. If he wants you to love him, then it’s fine. But if he doesn’t, that’s also fine.” (Louis Althusser: The Crisis of Marxism (interview) Interview date: April 30, 1980. Host: Renato Parascandolo. A bit ironical considering what happened just a few months later. Francis Dupuis-Déri states that “even today, in France, a man kills his spouse or ex-spouse on average every 3 days.” (page 13, ‘Feminist Insights’, Killer Althusser, 2025) This thesis-like examination of how Althusser was reported on and written about post-murder adds to the study of this complicated, controversial figure. Two things can co-exist at the same time: Althusser’s work can be appreciated or debated while condemning the intimate partner violence against Helene. Dupuis-Déri thinks recognizing his professional accomplishments is akin to giving him immunity. What do you think? Thanks to the publisher for this book. Review on Youtube: https://youtu.be/YLX-YacmJfU ...more |
|
|
Dec 28, 2025 06:45AM
· like
· see review ·
preview book
See a Problem?
We’d love your help.
Let us know what’s wrong with this preview of
Killer Althusser by Francis Dupuis-Déri.
Thanks for telling us about the problem.
Not the book you’re looking for?
Preview — Killer Althusser by Francis Dupuis-Déri |
|
Quotes by Noorilhuda
(?)
Quotes are added by the Goodreads community and are not verified by Goodreads.
(Learn more)
“I choose to believe that my father is still alive, that he has survived death, outlived us all, and possesses the soul that goes on and lives forever; We just cannot see him yet, for we have not caught up with him. our time will come just as his did. and no matter how woeful and lost I was when he passed away, I know I will be glad to go to a place where I can see him, and know he is okay and happy. It’s just not my time yet and there is no way of knowing if any of it is true." - Jane Adams”
― Noorilhuda, The Governess
― Noorilhuda, The Governess
“She waited for a man who would marvel her with his intellect, wit and physique, all at the same time. Someone who would beguile her, unnerve her, possess her, and claim her and then make her jealous with deceit and accusations. Someone who wouldn’t bore her after a few hours of company. Someone who wouldn’t be distracted by someone younger than her - even at that age, she had her insecurities........ She waited for a man who would be worth a chase and a challenge, who would beguile her and ravage her, and be true to her. She was no fool. She knew the limitations of affectation and ceremonial overtures between husband and wife. She knew the limits of compatibility, being put off by a few of her suitors instantly. She knew that love was not a guarantee to lifetime of happiness. She knew the importance of money and it’s effect on men. She knew the value of having the best in jewelry, clothes and company, for a person was judged accordingly, and if one wished to be a success, one had to look the part. And that required continuity of resources, not affection. But still she waited. She waited for a man who would surprise her beyond her expectations. She waited for a man who would be magical. She waited for a man who would never come.”
― Noorilhuda, The Governess
― Noorilhuda, The Governess
“Had he not been the keeper of the flame, of anguish, trapped under the brilliance of what she had been to him? He had been a man of permanence, how could he have swayed to emotion like this?”
― Noorilhuda, The Governess
― Noorilhuda, The Governess
Topics Mentioning This Author
| topics | posts | views | last activity | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| All About Books: Literary romance? Is this a thing? | 38 | 174 | Nov 19, 2014 12:09PM | |
| Bookworm Bitches : Nice Girls Finish Last? | 1 | 23 | Nov 23, 2014 06:56AM | |
| Romance Lovers fo...: Favorite regency novels | 4 | 54 | Nov 23, 2014 07:46AM | |
| Romance Lovers fo...: Favorite Authors | 21 | 80 | Nov 23, 2014 09:28AM | |
| Of Human Bondage | 17 | 208 | Nov 26, 2014 11:58AM | |
| The Next Best Boo...: Blog List, Twitter, etc. | 81 | 464 | Nov 28, 2014 07:04AM | |
| THE Group for Aut...: How are you measuring your success? | 8 | 39 | Nov 30, 2014 08:41PM | |
| Review Group: Reviews and ratings questions for the group | 10 | 40 | Dec 14, 2014 08:50AM | |
| Book Nook Cafe: Recipes Thread #4 ~~ 2014 | 156 | 62 | Dec 17, 2014 07:11PM | |
Romance Lovers fo...:
Favorite Holiday Reads 2014
|
28 | 33 | Dec 27, 2014 07:49PM |
“I've learned that people will forget what you said, people will forget what you did, but people will never forget how you made them feel.”
― Maya Angelou
― Maya Angelou
“A happy man has no past, while an unhappy man has nothing else.”
― Richard Flanagan, The Narrow Road to the Deep North
― Richard Flanagan, The Narrow Road to the Deep North
“You don't get to choose if you get hurt in this world...but you do have some say in who hurts you. I like my choices.”
― John Green, The Fault in Our Stars
― John Green, The Fault in Our Stars
“For all the largesse of my mind’s colony where a vividly enflamed man would take off each of the precious stones and melt away the cast, his success ultimately lay in being nice to me, being nice to himself irrespective of the behavior of each; of being proud of me and of himself irrespective of worldly success; holding me in regard with an almost primitive sense of courage, irrespective of the purity of my body or spirit.”
― Noorilhuda, The Governess
― Noorilhuda, The Governess
Review Group
— 5656 members
— last activity 7 hours, 42 min ago
Reviews are very important for Self-Published (SP), and Indie authors, just as they are for others. Unfortunately, though, many SP/Indie books don't g Reviews are very important for Self-Published (SP), and Indie authors, just as they are for others. Unfortunately, though, many SP/Indie books don't get the review attention they deserve. In this group, authors can gain honest reviews from other author members. All members are encouraged to participate fully in the review process, rather than concentrating only on obtaining reviews for their own work. We are all in the same situation. ...more
All About Books
— 3830 members
— last activity 4 hours, 9 min ago
We're here because we like reading and we like chatting about reading. But we are here especially because we strongly believe that reading is not just We're here because we like reading and we like chatting about reading. But we are here especially because we strongly believe that reading is not just something we do alone, but something that can unite people of different kinds, all over the world! This group really is all about books! In terms of group reads we have a monthly fiction book and a bi-monthly group read of a classic. We feature dedicated sections for non-fiction, poetry, short stories and drama. We also have weekly poetry postings (the Monday Poem). Quarterly there is a group discussion of non-fiction books in which members are encouraged to read books that relate to a specific theme and another theme for short stories. We feature a yearly challenge which varies from year to year in form. In addition, we have a section for people to post their yearly personal challenges and books read during the year. ...more
UK Amazon Kindle Forum
— 6680 members
— last activity 11 hours, 52 min ago
Where every hour is happy hour.
Goodreads Authors/Readers
— 56043 members
— last activity 7 hours, 32 min ago
This group is dedicated to connecting readers with Goodreads authors. It is divided by genres, and includes folders for writing resources, book websit This group is dedicated to connecting readers with Goodreads authors. It is divided by genres, and includes folders for writing resources, book websites, videos/trailers, and blogs. Feel free to invite some friends to join our Round Table community!http://www.goodreads.com/group/invite_members/26989-goodreads-authors-readers -Vincent Lowry (Moderator, Author, & Photographer) *Masthead photo: Taos, NM (c) 2021 by Vincent Lowry Slide Show: http://youtu.be/QKOPP4kIGLc Authors and readers are invited to check out these additional links: 1) The Author Resource Round Table on Goodreads: http://www.goodreads.com/topic/group_folder/116489?group_id=26989 2) The E-Author Resources blog: http://eauthorresource.wordpress.com/ 3) The Book Video blog: http://ratemybookvideo.wordpress.com/ ...more
How to Promote YOUR book on Amazon
— 8746 members
— last activity Feb 04, 2026 05:46PM
Are YOU an author? If so I am sure you are aware of how hard it can be to market your book successfully. There is so much you can do on Amazon.com to Are YOU an author? If so I am sure you are aware of how hard it can be to market your book successfully. There is so much you can do on Amazon.com to help promote your book and give you the exposure you deserve. I use to work for a company that specialized in promoting authors via Amazon.com. These are free tips I have picked up along the way that I feel every author should be aware of. Take a look and leave your comments or email me at KaitNeese@KaitNeese.com ...more
Books, Blogs, Authors and More
— 3717 members
— last activity Jan 28, 2026 09:12AM
Need a place to advertise your blog? You can do that here. Need a place to advertise your book? You can do that here. Need a place to discuss books? Y Need a place to advertise your blog? You can do that here. Need a place to advertise your book? You can do that here. Need a place to discuss books? You can do that here. Need a place to... Well I've run out of things. Have Fun! Follow us on Twitter: @BBAMMods - https://twitter.com/BBAMMods ...more
Bookworm Bitches
— 12418 members
— last activity 8 hours, 26 min ago
This group now has a Discord! https://discord.gg/QC8vCNfzKa I would encourage everyone to join as it will become a primary hub for book-of-the-month d This group now has a Discord! https://discord.gg/QC8vCNfzKa I would encourage everyone to join as it will become a primary hub for book-of-the-month discussions, nominations, etc. Real Bitches Read Books! ;) This is a group for women only. Not trying to be a Bitch, but well... LOL! If you love to read, share book suggestions, do reading challenges & discuss some fun topics, This is the group for you. There is something for everyone! We currently feature a Book of the Month and a Book of the Quarter. All books are voted on as a group. We offer a lot of variety. You choose what you want to participate in. Participation is optional but strongly encouraged. Please see our Guidelines thread in the discussions. Happy Reading Bitches ;) NOTE: This group reads a WIDE variety of books. While the name is Bookworm Bitches, we are not a feminist group nor do we read female authors exclusively. We do not adhere to one theme or another. Variety is the spice of life, as they say. ...more
Goodreads Reviewers' Group
— 13352 members
— last activity 7 hours, 49 min ago
This group helps to bring Reviewers and Authors together! Reviewers can make their own thread to post their reviews in, or post their reviews in the r This group helps to bring Reviewers and Authors together! Reviewers can make their own thread to post their reviews in, or post their reviews in the relevant Genre folder. Authors can make their own thread in the Author's folder to find reviewers for their book. Please provide the synopsis of the book, and details of how to obtain a copy. ...more
Victorians!
— 3779 members
— last activity 6 hours, 24 min ago
Some of the best books in the world were written and published in Great Britain between 1837 and 1901. What's not to love? Dickens, the Brontes, Co Some of the best books in the world were written and published in Great Britain between 1837 and 1901. What's not to love? Dickens, the Brontes, Collins, Gaskell, Eliot & Hardy to name but a few. If you fancy chatting about your faves or joining in the group reads please come and join in. This is a friendly group of seasoned classics-lovers right through to those thinking about dipping their toe in the water (and everyone inbetween). Everyone is welcome! ...more
The Next Best Book Club
— 26011 members
— last activity Feb 12, 2026 05:16PM
Are you searching for the NEXT best book? Are you willing to kiss all your spare cash goodbye? Are you easily distracted by independent bookshops, bi Are you searching for the NEXT best book? Are you willing to kiss all your spare cash goodbye? Are you easily distracted by independent bookshops, big name book stores, and library or used book sales? Are your bookshelves currently a little tight of space? Joining this group is highly addictive. In a matter of weeks, your TBR list will be longer than you are tall, you will be wondering how the heck you walked into a bookstore for one little book, and walked out with two bags crammed full of new novels you never knew you wanted. Your bookshelves will be bursting at the seams and you wont remember what color the rug was as it will be buried under all the new purchases you have made! We are not here to hold you back, or pat your hand as you try to be strong and cut back on your purchases. We will be rallying behind you, chanting your name as you enter the bookstore, and we will throw a book-party in your honor when you come back and share all the wonderful new books youve adopted with us! I would love for you to follow TNBBC on Facebook and Twitter!!! And be sure to check out book reviews and special indie series and spotlights on TheNextBestBookBlog.blogspot.com. ****Effective Immediately - Due to blantant misuse and a disregard of group rules and guidelines, we will no longer allow self promotion of books. Creation of threads to promote your work will lead to deletion of posts and blocked membership. ...more





















