Cathy A’s Reviews > The Complete Sherlock Holmes > Status Update

The Five Orange Pips. Loved this one! A tense, fast-moving mystery with a creepy little twist, and Holmes was brilliant as always. Even though it’s a shorter story, it really packs a punch and kept me hooked.

Hoscombe Valley Mystery…Really enjoyed this one! A solid, interesting mystery with great atmosphere and classic Holmes-style reasoning. I especially liked the ending—it was satisfying and wrapped everything up well.

A Case of Identity…Loved this one! I didn’t figure it out ahead of time, so the reveal really got me. Such an interesting case, and I loved watching Sherlock reason it out step by step. Classic Holmes—smart, satisfying, and so fun to read/listen to.

The Red Headed League…Loved this one! Such a clever little mystery, and I actually figured out part of what was going on before Holmes explained it—which made me feel pretty proud. 😄 Classic Sherlock charm, fun twists, and a super satisfying ending.

A Sign of Four. Good mystery. I loved the pursuit of the thief. I liked all the descriptions and Sherlock’s observations and deductions.

A Study in Scarlet. So good! I loved getting to know Sherlock and Watson. I love Sherlock’s sayings which I have frequently heard but did not realize they originated here.