Into the Wild
discussion
who has ever wondered if smudge becomes a warrior?
date
newest »
newest »
message 1:
by
Lyla
(new)
-
rated it 5 stars
Jan 25, 2009 12:20PM
i have always wanted smudge to become a warrior maybe fireheart could go patroling and find smudge and ask if he wants to join as an apprentice. and become a warrior i will ask erin hunter that. you can ask her questions on www.warriorcats.com
reply
|
flag
Hi Michelle, I think Smudge's character seems to be more of the safe type although in the later books he makes several appearances and does help out. But for being a warrior, I'm not sure he would find it a good lifestyle.
i know but i would like to see it happen
It would be a good story, might be a good idea for one of her manga books.
message 5:
by
yojharobed || I have no sword. I don't need a sword. Because I am the Doctor and this is my spoon. En garde!
(new)
-
added it
yeah, I don't think he would be a good warrior, especially since he went to the Cutter(got fixed)
Hahahahaha! This was written SOOOOO long ago! XD
Scourge(Lyla) wrote: "i have always wanted smudge to become a warrior maybe fireheart could go patroling and find smudge and ask if he wants to join as an apprentice. and become a warrior i will ask erin hunter that. yo..."I dont think so he was just helping the clqan
Again, I was a little 11 yr old and I was naive. lol I know better now then to think such a thing as Smudge being a warrior. ^^
Gawd... I embarass myself. >.<
well, since the clans moved to the lake, smudge couldn't become a warrior if he wanted to. anyway, he thought warriors did all that silly stuff he was telling "Rusty" about.
Nah, he's not fit for it, and he's already been to the cutter so there's really no chance left.
Gleb wrote: "Nah, he's not fit for it, and he's already been to the cutter so there's really no chance left."Millie wen to the cutter, and it helped the clan. But I don't think smudge is fit for it either.
I don't really think Smudge would ever really want to be a warrior, he just doesn't seem like he'd want to live in the wild.
Smudge is cool and a nice cat and everything, but he just seems a bit to lazy to be a warrior. :)
yea, but he would make a good warrior if he trained a lot to become and worked really hard to become one.
Yeah, I think he would be a good, loyal warrior if he worked hard.
Elena wrote: "Gleb wrote: "Nah, he's not fit for it, and he's already been to the cutter so there's really no chance left."Millie wen to the cutter, and it helped the clan. But I don't think smudge is fit for..."
Yes she did but she wasn't spayed, Smudge was neutered making him less inclined to fight.
Spayed and neutered animals can still fight if they have to though, I know my dog can. :)
Smudge almost thought of becoming a warrior in Firestar's Quest, but he only thought that because he was having these weird dreams.
I don't think so
Can't even remember who smudge is >3<
Johanna wrote: "Can't even remember who smudge is >3<"
Firestar's kittypet neighbor.
Firestar's kittypet neighbor.
Oh! That one >3< No wonder I didn't remember him haha... he's only at the very beginning am I right?
though smudge does come up several times in the series but i have read every book and smuge DOES NOT become a warrior....besides.....he doesn't even understand why firestar leaft in the first place and in firestar's quest he has dreams of skyclan cats and thinks that he might have to join the clan but firestar reasures him that he doesn't have to and he said he was relieved so yeah.
i would love to know more about Smudge in general. After all, he was Rustys friend
Johanna ღ♣✽Hobbit and Proud✽♣ღ wrote: "Oh! That one >3< No wonder I didn't remember him haha... he's only at the very beginning am I right?"
Smudge appears later in "Into The Wild".
Smudge appears later in "Into The Wild".
I never wondered that because, Smudge wouldn`t be able to make it as a Warrior.
*stares off into space* Time to go write fanfiction!
Smudge obviously doesn't become a warrior. He is happy being a kitty pet.
It would've been interesting if Smudge became a warrior. It would've given Firestar a friend in his awkward situation. I wonder what his name would've been?!
Smudge fits him though, and I wouldn't have him an other way!
all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
