Boxall's 1001 Books You Must Read Before You Die discussion
Popular Topics
>
How many of the 1001 books have you read?
message 101:
by
Silver
(new)
May 07, 2009 11:33PM

reply
|
flag


It's not impressive, but damn it I'm 16 and trying."
You're in the right track, you have lots of time to read them all ;)



Kayla,
It is a real eye opener, isn't it? But make sure you keep a little trash to satisfy the light side of life. Maybe every third book. The trash reads faster.
Debbie

I was just curious on which books you've read so far on the list so I looked at your profile. You "only" have 348 books marked as read from the list. Have you not had the time to add them all to your Goodreads profile yet?



PLEASE JOIN THE SITE: http://percyfans.webs.com/
CAUSE ITS AWESOME AND U GET SPOILERS ALL THE TIME AND SNEAKPEAKS OF THE MOVIE COMING OUT IN FEB.!!!!




Sorry to jump topics, but what new country? What's the job look like? Is this the kind of thing you do often?

I was born in the UK, moved to New Zealand in jan 2004 and stayed there until 2008. Then moved to Vancouver for a year from jan 2008 to feb 2009. Now I'm back in the UK in Nottingham, city of Robin Hood and sherwood forest. I work as a nurse in operating rooms and is a pretty good way of working all over the world.

My list would be higher if I counted high school reads.
I'm doing the same thing! I feel as an adult, I will appreciate them more.
I'm doing the same thing! I feel as an adult, I will appreciate them more.

GerryC



I have many of the books on the list and access, through my work in our library, to many others. Feel free to write me for info about any books you are interested in. You can contact me off-site at smacasamilagro@yahoo.com.
Gerry Camp


There are a couple of threads on this group that might give you a little help. One is Quick Reads and the other is Long Books. May not give you exactly what you're looking for but it'll at least give you a general idea and some of the posts include brief reviews of the books they mention. Hope you enjoy your time with us.


I started going down the list to answer the questoin of this topic, but I found myself more and more mystified at what was excluded. Maybe they explain that they are leaving out many of the books that traditionally would be on such a list and concentrating only on the ones that readers are less likely to know, but I still consider some of their choices inexplicable.
But since this is a thread on "how many have you read," I'll start there and say:
Of the 2000s: none of 69.
Of the 1900s: 77 of 716
Of the 1800s: 84 of 157
Of the 1700s: 27 of 46
Of the pre-1700s: 7 of 13
But I'm very disappointed that people who believe in this list apparently accept that it's okay to die without having read a single word of Homer, Plato, Aristotle, any of the Greek dramatists, Augustine, Cicero, Herodotus, Thucydides, Dante, Virgil, Milton, Wordsworth -- and it's not only the ancient writers. I Robot but not Atlas Shrugged or Fountainhead?
Ah well.

I haven't read the book myself (either version), but someone who has read it will probably respond soon to give insight into the selections on this list.
For now, here is a great blog entry written by a GoodReads member on the subject.

Boxall's list is a list of novels (with a few weird exceptions). I don't think he would frown on your reading the authors you suggest. I read a lot of stuff that is not on his list as does everyone I know who is using the list. I've read all of the authors you mention,except Ayn Rand, whom I consider garbage. The one novel he's missing on both lists (2006 and 2008) that I think is essential is "Red Badge of Courage." But that's just my opinion; I could be wrong.
Gerry C in San Miguel de Allende

But as you note there are a few weird exceptions. He includes Metamorphoses and Aesop's Fables, neither even remotely a novel. And if he's going to include the Thousand and one Nights, how does he exclude the Decameron, which is far more influential, IMO, than the Nights? (An aside: how many people here have actually read the entire Thousand and one Nights? Hands up, please? Hmmm -- I don't see any. Mine isn't -- I've read the Modern Library Bennett Cerf selection, but not the whole collection, which I think Burton put out in eight volumes. )
I haven't thought about novels that should be on the list but aren't, but there are for sure a few (or more than a few) that are on it that I will be perfectly content dying without having read.

Gerry

Gerry"
If I have to read his numbers 1-20 to get into heaven, I'll pick a different heaven to go to, thank you very kindly. :)


I have read the book, and one key point to note is that it is supposed to be a recommendation of novels only. There are exceptions- essays and short stories; but as far as I have found, no poetry (except one novel written in verse) or plays. The Greeks may have been left out because of this restriction....I couldn't say. I use Bloom's Western Canon for those genres which is pretty inclusive.

The book I like even better than Bloom is the original edition of Clifton Fadiman's Lifetime Reading Plan. It's been replaced by the not so good (IMO) New Lifetime Reading Plan, but the original is still available on alibris and abebooks -- look for a publication date of 1986 or earlier. Alibris has new copies of the 1968 printing for $20 and up, and several of the first edition, 1960, edition in good condition, for $1.99.
Judith wrote: "Everyman:
I have read the book, and one key point to note is that it is supposed to be a recommendation of novels only. There are exceptions- essays and short stories; but as far as I have found,..."

Here's my solution to the "books on the list I don't want to (or can't) read". In the 2008 edition, he added about 250 books. He also eliminated many of the books on his original list that I had read. I figure that I only need to read 1001 from both lists to get into heaven, and since I'm 70 and have read about 255, it isn't fair or reasonable to make me read "The Taeback Mountans" for example, a 9 volume epic only available in Korean. So since there are many books on the 2008 list that interest me, when I read one of those I give myself credit on the 2006 list for a book I'm sure I will never read. That way I can read 1001 books I find enjoyable, and insure myself a place in heaven. I figure I can finish 1001 by the time I'm 90 and include a number of great books that are not on either list if I keep to my average of one plus books per week. You know what worries me, though, is that there is also a book of "1001 Movies You Must See Before You Die" and since I live in Mexico, I'm making very slow progress on this list. Do you think both lists are required? :)
GerryC

So instead of reading, say, Duskland, I can read (well, reread; I'm not going to back and start substituting in retrospect, or I would be done already) Paradise Lost and count it as the substitute book for Duskland. Since I've read 195 of his books, I now have to read 806 books either from his list or substituting for books on his list, and I'm home free. Won't be a piece of cake at my age, since tend to prefer substantive books to fluff books -- Dombey and Son, near the top of my TBR shelf, will take more than a few days -- but I'll work on it.
But this approach has given me new hope that I won't die with my reading obligations unfulfilled. Just redefine the task and it becomes achievable!
Thanks for the great suggestion.
Gerald wrote: "...since there are many books on the 2008 list that interest me, when I read one of those I give myself credit on the 2006 list for a book I'm sure I will never read. That way I can read 1001 books I find enjoyable, and insure myself a place in heaven. I figure I can finish 1001 by the time I'm 90 and include a number of great books that are not on either list..."

Which raises an interesting question. If somebody had read the entire 2006 list (assuming, which I frankly doubt, that such a person actually exists) but died in 2007, now that there are other books they must read before they die, but they can't because they've died, do they get into book heaven anyhow? Or are they soomed to live forever in book forever in book limbo???

Gerry

Gerry

You're ahead of me. The first two volumes, plus Botton's How Proust can Change your Life have been sitting on my TBR shelf for longer than I care to admit, but every time I reach for them I realize that they will mean putting back quite a few of my other urgent TBR choices, and I sigh and move my hand to another volume on the shelves.

GerryC
Books mentioned in this topic
Kidnapped (other topics)Ragtime (other topics)
Lives of Girls and Women (other topics)
Lives of Girls and Women (other topics)
Lives of Girls and Women (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Robert Louis Stevenson (other topics)E.L. Doctorow (other topics)
E.L. Doctorow (other topics)
Thomas Hardy (other topics)
Emily Brontë (other topics)
More...