The Seasonal Reading Challenge discussion
SPRING CHALLENGE 2012: FIRE
>
20.5. Bigger is Better: Masanobu's Task - A Game of Books
date
newest »
newest »
message 51:
by
Debra
(new)
Mar 13, 2012 05:55AM
Would A Game of Thrones count for option 5 as a family saga?
reply
|
flag
Kazza wrote: "For family saga (5) - does it have to be stated that as genre on book page?Red Sorghum - the genre does not specify family saga but part of blurb states "From 1923 to 1976 three gen..."
No, it isn't necessary that 'family saga' appears as a genre.
Red Sorghum sounds like it works, just be sure to say it was accepted in the task help thread when you post. ;)
Lindsey wrote: "Would any "for dummies" book work for option 1? They all have yellow and black covers.
"Not all of them work. Some of them have other colors beside black and yellow taking up a significant portion of the cover.
The one you have posted as example works, because the pentagram looks golden-colored.
Does it make sense?
Yep! I will most likely be reading that one, but I will be sure to ask if I read a different one instead. Thank you!!
Debra wrote: "Would A Game of Thrones count for option 5 as a family saga?"No, sorry, it doesn't work. A Game of Thrones doesn't follow generations of a family (or in this case, families), and it all happens during just one year, so it is not a significant period of history, either.
I hope you find another task for that book!
Hi! I just wanted to make sure that the following book will work for this challenge. I rolled a 4. This books has a red &black cover.
Mariya wrote: "Hi! I just wanted to make sure that the following book will work for this challenge. I rolled a 4. This books has a red &black cover.
"Yes, it works :)
Anne (Booklady) wrote: "I rolled a 1 and 6.For Book 1: 1. Black and Gold Cover
Would
work?The box is Gold."
Yes, it works :)
Debra wrote: "What about The Bleeding Season for a red and blue cover?"This has been a tough one. I've finally decided that it doesn't work, because of the amount of brown taking up the bottom half of the cover. However, if you can't find a better option, I could let you use it. Please come back to tell me first!
Masanobu wrote: "Debra wrote: "What about The Bleeding Season for a red and blue cover?"This has been a tough one. I've finally decided that it doesn't work, because of the amount of brown taking u..."
Ok, I'll see if I can come up with something better.
Masanobu wrote: "Anne (Booklady) wrote: "I rolled a 1 and 6.For Book 1: 1. Black and Gold Cover
Would
work?The box is Gold."
Yes, it works :)"
Thank you so much!
Rachel Renee wrote: "How about Finding George Orwell in Burma for a blue and white cover:
"There's too little white in it. Could you find something else? If not, I could let you use it, but please come back to tell me first!
I need some clarification for the mods. I rolled a 5 and read The Maid for a person in the army. It is about Joan of Arc and most of it is about her leading her army in France. Does this work or does it have to be US army?Thanks.
Amanda (Pearl the Book Girl) wrote: "This is probably my favorite task SRC have ever had. I love game of thrones so much!"Wow, thank you! :)
Tracy wrote: "Tracy wrote: "For Tully ( red and blue)would these count?
or
""Flowers for Algernon is perfect.
I'm not so sure about The House on Mango Street - is the title orange or reddish?
Bluemoon wrote: "I need some clarification for the mods. I rolled a 5 and read The Maid for a person in the army. It is about Joan of Arc and most of it is about her leading her army in France. Does..."It works. I meant any army, not just the US Army. I hadn't even realized that could be a possible interpretation.
Also, I've already commented on the Completed Tasks with Problems thread.
Masanobu wrote: "Bluemoon wrote: "I need some clarification for the mods. I rolled a 5 and read The Maid for a person in the army. It is about Joan of Arc and most of it is about her leading her arm..."Thanks!!
Cindy AL wrote: "Does this work for red and black? The background is black, words are red, but some are white.
"It works. Red and black are the colors that stand out the most. :)
Just remember to say it was approved in the task help thread.
Sassafrass wrote: "Is this red/yellow enough?
"Yes, it is. Also, the synopsis fits the Lannisters like a glove! :)
Masanobu wrote: "Tracy wrote: "Tracy wrote: "For Tully ( red and blue)would these count?
or
""Flowers for Algernon is perfect.
I'm not so sure..."
Ummmmm...
The letters are orange, the background is more reddish, but my other pick works...Thanks for taking the time to look :-)
OK, I think I have my picks worked out for this task:2. Mystery
3. Blue cover
5. Favorite genre - Young Adult
I may swap Maniac Magee out for
. Does that work?
Chris wrote: "OK, I think I have my picks worked out for this task:2. Mystery

3. Blue cover

5. Favorite genre - Young Adult

I ma..."
I am not entirely sure of what you mean there. You just have to read ONE book for this task.
Assuming you rolled a 6, Arryn, you could read
a. A mystery: Wicked Appetite works.
OR
b. A book with a white and blue cover:
doesn't work, because there is no white.
works for this option, though.OR
c. A book with the word 'moon' in the title.
I don't know what you mean by favourite genre, since that isn't an option for this task.
Monica S wrote: "Hello. Would Game of Thrones be enough gold/yellow and black for option #1?
"Sure :)
Masanobu wrote: "Chris wrote: "OK, I think I have my picks worked out for this task:2. Mystery

3. Blue cover

5. Favorite genre - Young Adult
[bookcover:Mania..."
Sorry - I spaced out. This was supposed to be for the 50 point task. I thought I had posted it and then couldn't find it. Now I know where it went!
Chris wrote: "Masanobu wrote: "Chris wrote: "OK, I think I have my picks worked out for this task:2. Mystery

3. Blue cover

5. Favorite genre - Young Adult..."
Now it makes sense! :) It's okay, and at least you now know the internet didn't eat your post.
I hope you enjoy the 50 point task! :)
Jennifer FL wrote: "Hi would this work for option one black/gold?[bookcover:Year of Wonders: A Novel of the Plague]"
It has little gold in it, but I'm going to take it. Especially when there are just ten days left!
Be sure to say it was approved in the task help thread.
I'm sorry to say that no variations are allowed, so 'wolves' won't work. I hope you still have time to find a book for this task!
Books mentioned in this topic
Year of Wonders (other topics)Wicked Appetite (other topics)
The Graduate (other topics)
The Graduate (other topics)
Wicked Appetite (other topics)
More...












