Fantasy Book Club discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
Group business and info
>
Introductions - tell us a little about yourself



I am Noni, Indonesian, and I work at a trading company.
I always love reading, and just recently picked fantasy series. Every time I read a book, I always felt like being sucked into the world and living it. That’s why I should not read one whole series from beginning volume to end continuously; or my mind would become too disconnected from the real world I am living in :)
I am now in the middle sequel of Wheel of Time, Song of Ice and Fire, Discworld, and The Last Olympian; a good mix between epic fantasy, political game, satire and young adult adventure. They are all good and entertaining in its own way. Once I finish these series, I look forward to read other series recommended from this group, maybe The Malazan Book of Fallen and some books by Janny Wurts. They look promising.

I always had fantasy books around when I was growing up, but my first memory of a proper grown up fantasy novel is when I was nine and my parents read me 'The Lord of the Rings'. They took it in turns to read each night and, thanks to them pronouncing all the names of the characters completely differently, I had only a vague idea what was going on a lot of the time, but I still absolutely loved it. Since then I have re-read the book myself (much more intelligible without parental confusion), and have acquired many other favourites such as Robin Hobb, David Eddings and Jacqueline Carey. I also really loved the first novel by Patrick Rothfuss and I'm eagerly awaiting the next installment. For years I laboured under the illusion that I didn't like Terry Pratchett, until I was introduced to Death and the Witches and realised that I just really dislike Rincewind.
I'm a medievalist by education , if not by trade alas, so I also read a lot of the retellings of Arthurian legends and pseduo-Celtic/British myths and 'histories'. Favourites of this brand of fantasy include Juliet Marillier, Marion Zimmer Bradley and of course Mary Stewart.
I look forward to picking up many new recommendations to add to my ever-growing Amazon wishlist.

Katie - as a historian, are you familiar with Judith Tarr? She is a historian also, and wrote a number of Celtic based fantasies, and several that center around the Crusades. You may enjoy the scholarship in her works.

I have a close friend (I've known her for maybe 30 years) a school teacher who still won't read fantasy. I suppose she just can't get into it. Huge reader, but hasn't even read the Lord of the Rings... I keep trying to "open her eyes"(LOL)
Looking forward to your comments.

I also have hundreds of painted pewter figures, a mat marked off in squares on one side and hexes on the other that you can use water erase markers on, hundreds of floor tiles depicting wooden floors, stone floors, traps, stairs, doorways, dungeons, etc., etc, etc. Okay...so if you look up "nerd" in the dictionary they have my picture. But, Im secure enough that I'm comfortable with it...LOL!

I have a Spinx I need to get done tomorrow for Saturday's game.
The biggest differences in 2 and 3.5 (I think) is that the armor class in 2 gets better as the numbers go down and the way they do proficiencies, traits, and feats.

I'm Sarah, 27 years old born & living in Minnesota my entire life. I became a reading addict in 2nd grade when my dad gave me my very first "chapter boo..."
Hi, Katie! Have you tried Janny Wurts' Mistwraith series? It's awesome and we're reading it in Beyond Reality group and in the Fantasy Book Club Series group.

Thanks very much for the recommendation. I've not come across her before as it doesn't look like she's published in the UK, as is so often the case with interesting American authors I hear about. It looks like some of them are available for less than extortionate prices on Amazon marketplace though, so I'll have to have a look.

Only started reading just over a year ago. Before then i had no real interest in sitting down and reading a book. Now though as im a little older the idea of sitting down on the sofa and reading is fun to me.
I'm enjoying Fantasy books such as The Night Angel Trilogy by Brent Weeks and the Farseer Trilogy by Robin Hobb.
Good to be part of the group.
Alan

Katie - in this case, she may be of particular interest to you since she is an academic historian, as well as an author. I hope you can find the books.

I am a fan of Robert Jordan and George R.R. Martin, John Marco and Joe Abercrombie, Patrick Rothfuss and more recently Peter V. Brett.
I am blessed to have a nine year-old son who loves to read and enjoys reading with me. We loved The Hobbit and Mouse Guard and are just about done with Redwall by Brian Jacques.


From there I moved on to Lloyd Alexander, C.S Lewis, David Eddings, Peter S. Beagle, Simon R. Green, some Gaiman and Patricia K. McKillip. Currently I’m in the middle of His Majesty’s Dragon by Naomi Novik and loving it. I look forward to chatting with you all!

My father was and is an avid Wizard of Oz fan. I grew up with the whole library in my room! Is it any wonder I write fantasy novels now?

I'm seventeen years old and I haven’t read too many adult fantasy novels, really only sticking with the Young Adult section. I joined this group hoping to see some of the better books available out there and to finally get around to tackling those adult shelves.
Yeah, about me: I still go to school, my last year, and I live in Australia. Harry Potter started me on the path of reading in grade three but I’ve been getting lazy as of late. I both a) Hardly read and B) Only read the easy, turn-off-your-brain sort of books. So hopefully this group will inspire me to stop that.
I look forward to hanging out here!
Hi Rachel, get to see you in the group. You forgot to mention you have studied at University doing Creative Writing courses. I know, because I heard you read your stories there ! :)
Am happy to see your interest in reading some adult fantasy. Maybe you would be keen to try Janny Wurts 'Wars of Light and Shadow' series that we will be doing in the Series group. It is a great opportunity to discuss the entire series with the author and hear her perspectives on how the story came about etc. Janny will be speaking about the publishing industry also and giving away free books, courtesy of her publishers.
If a series is too long maybe you would interested in Tender Morsels by Margo Lanagan as it a book that Maria is considering adding to the YA course. Or otherwise maybe the novel that wins our YA monthly reading poll.
Look forward to seeing your views on various topics.
Am happy to see your interest in reading some adult fantasy. Maybe you would be keen to try Janny Wurts 'Wars of Light and Shadow' series that we will be doing in the Series group. It is a great opportunity to discuss the entire series with the author and hear her perspectives on how the story came about etc. Janny will be speaking about the publishing industry also and giving away free books, courtesy of her publishers.
If a series is too long maybe you would interested in Tender Morsels by Margo Lanagan as it a book that Maria is considering adding to the YA course. Or otherwise maybe the novel that wins our YA monthly reading poll.
Look forward to seeing your views on various topics.

I'm seventeen years old and I haven’t read too many adult fantasy novels, really only sticking with the Young Adult section. I joined this group hoping to see some of the better..."
Hi Rachel, welcome here!
For wonderful fantasy reading that's not too challenging, but at the top end of YA, I do recommend The Blue Sword by Robin McKinley, and perhaps the lesser known Red Moon and Black Mountain by Joy Chant. At least, those were well worn favorites of mine, at your stage.
Rachel wrote: "Hey, I'm Rachel.
I'm seventeen years old and I haven’t read too many adult fantasy novels, really only sticking with the Young Adult section. I joined this group hoping to see some of the better..."
Hi Rachel! Welcome and join in.
If you're looking for a transition between YA and adult fantasy, Susan Dexter is a great place to start. She has a couple of short 3 book series and a few stand alones. All of them are worth trying out.
I'm seventeen years old and I haven’t read too many adult fantasy novels, really only sticking with the Young Adult section. I joined this group hoping to see some of the better..."
Hi Rachel! Welcome and join in.
If you're looking for a transition between YA and adult fantasy, Susan Dexter is a great place to start. She has a couple of short 3 book series and a few stand alones. All of them are worth trying out.


I'm rarely into YA, though I've tried some I've liked adequately. I'm probably one of those people who I saw YA advocates complain about, who dismiss the genre. I'm 34, and tend to feel that most YA is kind of like neutered "real" books. You cut out a lot of topics and potential darkness to make them "safe". Aaaaaaanyway, hope to talk to many of you in the future about awesome books.
I won't be joining actual book discussions this month. I'll try to read the correct book for next month.
Hi Aaron. I'm with you on YA. I read 4 recent YA books last month and came to the same conclusion about making them "safe" for teenage consumption. I think it's part of the growing risk aversion in our society and our desire to protect kids from bad things. I find YA a bit boring as a result. But there's lots of edgier stuff out there to enjoy! Welcome to the group.


A fan of Anne Bishop, Jennifer Fallon, Brandon Sanderson, China Mieville, Ilona Andrews, Terry Brooks, Matt Sturges and Lisa Shearin. just to name a few, but there are certainly more.
I recently started rereading Patricia C. wrede. she was one of the first fantasy authors i read as a kid and it's great to read the books with a new perspective. I look forward to chatting and sharing recommendations here!
Welcome Kate and thanks for posting Readercon into our Events section.

Speaking Kate-to-Kate, I know what you mean about some YA books feeling sanitized. There's some great, edgy YA out there, though! Marr's WICKED LOVELY springs to mind. I'd love to know what you'd think of MINDER--I think the first chapter is edgy enough to hook you. If you're interested, there's a free PDF excerpt at Ganzfield.com.
Hi Kate. I'll take a look at it. I don't really read much YA. Last month was an aberration, and I was definitely less than impressed with what I found. LOL.
The other Kate
The other Kate

Currently, the Terry Brooks trilogy I'm reading is more Sci Fi than fantasy, but it has the elves and magic too. Mostly it's post apocalyptic. It's called Armageddon's Children. I'm on the third one, Gypsy Morph. Really dark, and a little slow at times, but pretty good.


Donna, I loved HIS MAJESTY'S DRAGON. I used to read a lot of Terry Brooks--maybe I should check out his more recent work. Does any book or series really stand out for you?

But my favorite series within the Shannara storyline was Heritage of Shannara. Scions of Shannara and Elf Queen of Shannara stick out in my mind in particular.
So far, I'm not crazy about any of the prequels. The First King of Shannara was good but he killed off the main character and that always drives me crazy.

I haven't read the Crown Conspiracy. Maybe I should try it. My TBR pile is huge.


I find too many books are too similar to McCaffrey's Pern books. She was amazing and I guess no one else has quite that imagination.

I enjoy discussion of books and stories, as well as the art and philosophy of writing (I consider myself an amateur author, but I've never published anything due to my crippling inability to write good endings to stories). Good to meet you all.

My name is John Cicero and I am a fantasy / adventure author. My passion for writing is driven from the joy I receive from reading my stories to my children.
Watching the expressions on their face as I take them on a journey through the magical pages of my imagination is what drives me to find the time to write.
My recently released novels are in the Rainbow's Shadow Trilogy. They are Rainbow’s Shadow and the Tablets of Fate and Rainbow’s Shadow and the Covenant of Wisdom.
As a passionate writer in Northeast, Ohio I have been fortunate to hit the Best Sellers list with 'Tablets of Fate' and am on track currently with the 'Covenant of Wisdom'.
The final novel in my trilogy is Rainbow’s Shadow and the Other Side of Paradise which is currently in development.
If you have a moment check out my website and my Rainbow's Shadow Trilogy today at... www.RainbowsShadow.com
Take care, John

I've been reading fantasy since discovering it in my mid-20s (lo, these many years past). Started with MZB's "Mists of Avalon", which led me to her Darkover series. Didn't think I liked this stuff until I actually read it!
Favorite writers/series: I buy hardcover copies of Guy Gavriel Kay, GRR Martin, Diana Gabaldon, Jacqueline Carey. Holding "Under Heaven" in my hands this spring was an ecstatic experience (think spinning Sufis). I tried to read it slowly, savor its poetry, "be" the characters. That lasted about 3 evenings and then I couldn't stand it anymore and gobbled the rest of it up. Just re-read "Sailing to Sarantium" for the August discussion.
Looking forward to the next installments by Patrick Rothfuss and Ken Scholes and plan to re-read Dorothy Dunnett's Lymond Chronicles (not fantasy, but terrific historical fiction that sends my imagination soaring!).
Cheers!
Ellen wrote: "Hey Everyone! I'm Ellen. So glad to stumble onto GoodReads and this fantasy group. I'm down here in Alabama, though I grew up in Illinois and left my heart in the Pacific Northwest.
I've been rea..."
Hi Ellen! Glad to see another Lymond fan around here! I'm just starting "Under Heaven" due to delays at my local library. I adore Kay, but I'm in ebook only mode these days and my groaning triple stacked bookshelves thank me for it. Welcome.
I've been rea..."
Hi Ellen! Glad to see another Lymond fan around here! I'm just starting "Under Heaven" due to delays at my local library. I adore Kay, but I'm in ebook only mode these days and my groaning triple stacked bookshelves thank me for it. Welcome.

How wonderful you are getting to read "Under Heaven" for the FIRST time. I admit to feelings of envy, but the good news is that these days, with my memory being what it is, I have found that if I wait long enough (which isn't too long anymore), when I pick it up the next time, it will almost feel like the first time again. =)
Enjoy!

I've been rea..."
OMG! I have finally found someone else who is into the Lymond Chronicles! I read them all years ago and just adored them.

Welcome to the Club! It's so good to see intelligent readers of all ages and nationalities joining us. We have a really good time, and a bunch of interesting ideas emerge from the discussions. Good reads to all of you.

How wonderful y..."
Ellen and Charles - there are quite a few of us, here, who enjoyed Dunnett's works.
Welcome, Ellen, and great to see such a neat list, lots of my favorites. Look forward to seeing your posts.
Janny wrote: "Ellen and Charles - there are quite a few of us, here, who enjoyed Dunnett's works...."
Good to know. Everyone I've recommended them to has never heard of her. Obviously we fantasy crowd are a pretty well read bunch! :D
Good to know. Everyone I've recommended them to has never heard of her. Obviously we fantasy crowd are a pretty well read bunch! :D

..."
Hi Lymond fans,
If anyone can recommend anything even half as good as Dunnett, I'd love to know about it.
Thanks!
This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
The Name of the Wind (other topics)The Fault in Our Stars (other topics)
Prince of Fools (other topics)
The Whitefire Crossing (other topics)
To Ride Hell’s Chasm (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Michael J. Sullivan (other topics)Robin Hobb (other topics)
Patrick Rothfuss (other topics)
Daniel Abraham (other topics)
George R.R. Martin (other topics)
More...
My name is Dawn, I'm 27, a mechanical engineer and new..."
Hi Dawn. I also own most (not all) of the books I've read. I've always figured money spent on books doesn't count! And I love them.