New Moon question

honestly Jacob, pre-werewolf.
although i think the change in his character after his transition was just Stephine Meyer deciding to make his character less enjoyable so that Edward would be the "obvious choice", but if we're talking werewolf Jacob vs Edward (like how it plays out in the books) probs my guy Edward

although if I could get werewolf Jacob BUT with his personality pre-werewolf... gimme

I dont find Edward attractive. I'm going with Jacob and he is sooo attractive!

edward for bella, jacob is hot but alice <3

jacob, edward is too possessive

jacob pre-werewolf :) as much as i love werewolves, Stephane meyer changed his whole personality after he became one and i was not a fan.

if we’re comparing eclipse or breaking dawn jacob vs edward, than edward 100%. although edward was an ass in breaking dawn during pregnant bella lol.

Jacob!! edward brings way too many problems if you're a human. The Volturi, James & victoria, other vampires!!!!!! The only way to be completely safe and not feel self conscious that your husband is eternally younger (looking) than you while you grow older, is if you decide to become a vampire yourself. Then you have a whole nother set of problems, but I won't get into that.. The werewolves are only there to protect humans from the vampires. They don't eat anybody. Also the amount of times the author describes Edward as strikingly beautiful just gets on my nerves.

Edward for sure especially in the Illustrated guide

Team Edward for life. Jacob is to cocky for me... And I liked when Edward was protective of Bella.

EDWARD

I’m not sure, probably Edward?

I am team Edward and would date him just because it has always been Edward and Jacob needs to realize Bella needed a friend and that's all it was. Yes, Bella said she loved him but like I would too?

Though I do think Jacob is more attractive than Edward, I would want to date Edward. Even though he's a creep, I see what Bella see's in him.

def Jake

Edward 4 ever. I realy love him.
I like jacob but edward always wins

edward theres
no other choice

I would definitely pick Edward. That's only because I'm a Vampire girl at heart. I love all Vampires anything. Not so much into the ware wolves. I give Jacob props for being there for here when she needed him, but he is "Just his best friend" Nothing more. That needs to be accepted. We all have that 1 guy who was in the friend zone. Thats Jacob.

Edward has my heart. I read the books before the movies came out, so I felt his love from the very start and wish I had someone like him when I was young. haha

Honestly I'm team Charlie, I had a crush on him since I was a teen. But if Edward and Jacob are my only options, I'd choose Jacob. At least he has a pulse and he's not creepy. He may by like annoying puppy, but at least he's announcing before getting in people's houses.

Jacob all the way, in the books Edward was ok, but in the movies I found him creepy ngl.

I go with the option none of the above

Jacob. Hear me out. He cares for someone he will never get. THAT IS DEDICATION

I totally think both of these boys have problems they need to work through, but personally I would pick Jacob. I really didn't like how Edward acted even if he was trying to protect Bella. Bella and Jacob are so close and I just thought they would be so great together.

well they are both good looking but edward is the best.

I'd rather give Bella a personality.

Jacob all the way!

Edward, definitely!

I like both, but i choose Jacob.

Definitely Edward

For a long term relationship I´ll choose Edward, he is mature, serious, romantic and a Gentelman, he is what you want for a husband to be...

Of course if I don´t want to get seriuos with someone I´ll probably pick Jacob. Jacob is stil a boy, so inmature. But thinking it twice, He´ll get to be just my best friend, when I´m in the mood for an adventure I´ll call him. i don´t think I can really be with someone that inmature.

Edward. Jacob is for Renesmee! ;)

edward!!

It'd be a tough choice so I don't know. I love them both.

I liked Twilight, but not enough to continue to talk about it and become obsessive over it. The movies were shitty the worst directing and terrible acting I have ever seen. Garbage. Why girls are so infatuated with them is beyond me. Time to get a life, grow up and stop fantasizing. Girls that sit around all day and "Team Edward" or " Team Jacob" are just little girls. Life is not a fairy tale children. They don't even know you walk this earth. Get off their dicks, and go find a real boyfriend. ;) If this post offends you tough shit, grow a pair. Suck it up and deal with it.

Come on..!! how many times these discussions will go on..No doubt EDWARD..!!!! Jacob himself doesn't know who is meant for him - Bella or Renesmee....

team Edward, obviously!