New Moon question

Neither ..

Edward

Jacob :)

I would totally choose Edward. Love him for all his old-fashioned ways. I could deal with his possessiveness and the mood swings more than the juvenile, impulsive actions of Jacob.

Edward left her for her 'safety'. i would have been like forget the safety and love me. Jacob is a jerk when ever Edward is around, i know that is probably the alpha inside of him but still. i would get annoyed. i wouldn't pick either of them.
GO MORTAL INSTRUMENTS!!!!!

Hm, if I had to chose a team it was totally Edward when I read the books, but in the movies it's totally Jacob. And just a side note for all those people that constantly talk about "get a life" get over yourself. People read for different reasons, I chose to do so for entertainment and yes, these are enteretaining to me! I also have a life and a man but I can still participate and get into the books I chose to enjoy :) Just saying...

By personality Edward, but I do like the idea of werewolves more than the idea of vampires.

hands down, definitely Edward...

JACOB<3:)

Edwarddd!!!! <3

Cant I have them both?? LOL
If I HAD to choose, it would be Edward, hands down. Love me some sparkly vampire!! lol

For a romantic hero in a book, Edward all the way. In real life, Jacob. No posessive stalkers for me, thanks!

The heroes I love in books are not necessarily men I would want to date IRL. Sexy on paper doesn't always transfer to sexy in the flesh.

I LOVE EDWARD!!!!

Edward hands down. :)

Jacob for me, Edwards too cold.

EDWARD!!!! of course.

Edward <3

Edward is dead. Jacob is alive. I like my men breathing.

I would dump both and try to find a man who isn't a possessive weird semi-sociopath who sparkles like a princess (Edward- no duh) or an immature inexperienced hothead who can't seem to find a shirt ANYWHERE (guess who? oh yeah, JACOB!). The funny thing is that I like these characters, but to be involved in a relationship with each would be awkward and frustrating.

EDWARD!!! <3 <3

I LOVE JACOB! SO HAWT!! and he's also pitiful...and i love jacob much better than edward :P

edward. what if jacob got imprinted and left me?

Edward <3

Jacob!!!

My husband JACOB always and forever <3

So I would either have to be a necrophiliac, or partake in beastiality. Hmph, difficult choice.

Edward, you would understand if you read the book. People just like Jacob because of his looks... -_- <3

EDWARD!

Edward.

I will choose jacob

Edward, because Jacob pouts like a baby when he doesn't get what he wants.

Between the two of them, Edward, but really, I want Emmett.

none!!!!!!!!!!

How could she choose Jacob? She knows what happened to Leah, Sam and Emily. If she chose she would be waiting for his imprinting on someone else and discarding her. Jacob was never really an option imho.

I would secretly marry both, and then my life would be complete... <3

I could never get past having sex with an animal, what if he changes? ewww. I'd pick Edward definitely over those two.

All of twilight though? Riley was the cutest to me.

Can't I have both?

~D.

edward straight up no doubt about it

I would so choose edward he is old timie and caring and jacob really only cares about himself

Edward!!!!! :)

I would choose neither , their both attractive in their own way but not as cute as Jasper , anyone else agree ?

At this point in the story, I'd choose Jake. But... I like Edward more in the last book.

Jacob! He'd keep me warm ;)

Jacob....6 pack,keeps you warm,handsome,willing to save lifes,cares for others,doesn't suck on blood

Edward....sparkles ONLY in sunlight....Jacob Wins!!!!!!!! :)

Ofcourse edward,who wud beat him????

I would choose Jacob for many reasons.
1. Edward is completely controlling in my opinion. I hate that Bella always feels the need to ask for permission to do things. Edward is not her mother nor her father. It just seems ridiculous.
2. Jacob is more my style. I'm not a fan of guys that are prim and proper. Edward is clean cut and I like "men." Edward just doesn't seem manly. Jacob is rugged and even though he has a boyish charm, he is more of a man. I mean, what's so manly about a guy that sparkles?
3. Jacob is playful. Edward is constantly seeming so serious. I mean yeah occasionally, very rarely jokes around but, he's so uptight. Jacob knows how to turn a bad situation into something that can feel improved.
4. Jacob takes risks. He's rough and not afraid to be rough. I like that in a guy. He could easily take Bella into a room and have his way with her...doggy-style. :D

I cant pick, but look at this cominc, its so funny!

http://cdn.pimpmyspace.org/media/pms/...

NIETHER! Both of them are jerks... its that simple

I used to be Team Edward like 1000000% but now....

Edward. I like his charm and how he's old fashioned. And I think protecting her is cute.

Jacob. Why you may ask? Well I say Jacob because for one, he's adorable, I mean come onnnnn.. Haha. At first I loved Edward he was awesome then when I finished reading and watched the movies I saw the side of Jacob that I didn't happen to see when I read the books and that is his passion for Bella. You notice how much he really loves her when you watch the movie, you see the pain in his eyes and I would honestly rather be with someone who would actually be in pain if I were to leave him. Yes, I know that Edward is the same way but on the other hand, as a human you would always be in some kind of danger when with him. I'd rather be more safe. So Jacob Would be my choice.