The Shining
discussion
too scared
date
newest »

message 51:
by
Lori
(new)
-
rated it 4 stars
Dec 07, 2011 09:22AM

reply
|
flag



That said...I find the original 'Shining' film to be utterly boring, trite, silly, bombastic, and just plain overrated. There, I said it.
But the book? SCARY. Very quiet, very eerie, very calculating and cunning as it orchestrates and builds its machinations of terror upon a foundation of subtlety that undermine your entire understanding of where terror can be found and what it can turn into.
But again, that's just me - and that shows against many of the reviewers on this page who find the book to be "somewhat" scary and the movie terrifying and even more favorable.
Too scared to read 'The Shining' for its reputation? Well, you won't know just how scary it really gets until you give it a chance...and once you do...you might end up deciding to leave the lights on in your room from then on.
Sleep well.

I was scared to read it too, because lots of people say it's one of the scariest books ever, but once I read it I actually found it bery boring and dissappointing. Didn't find it remotely scary.



Especially not after reading Anne Rice, Edgar Allan Poe, Bram Stoker and now Brian Keene.
If you're going to write horror, which is pretty hard to believe from the word go, then you should at least make OTHER information in the book actually believable - and he's never done that. All of his books have so many mistakes that result from little to no research that it operates as a strike against him.
He said himself that he's "trying to sew a fine seam when convincing people that the story could be real," so I don't know why he didn't take his own advice and at least do SOME research in the areas that all the "lesser" authors have been expected to research and include in their stories.
But not him, b/c he's special and never has to do a lick of research - so fine. Don't do the research.
But don't expect anyone to believe or be scared of your work either.
And if you want to see real fear, take a ride on the ambulance for a day. You'll see things that make Stephen King AND his tales pretty damn pale in comparison.
That's my opinion of the whole matter, and you know what they say about those.
I don't expect people to have the same opinion as I do anyway. Especially since my viewpoint has always been directly based on my own experiences.



After reading some of the messages, I am interested in knowing how old some of you were when you read The Shining and in what year. Are people in the last 10-15 years more desensitized to violence or "scariness?" And what do you think is scary? When I read The Shining some 25 years ago or so, there was little out there like it. I guess its like me saying that the Exorcist is the scariest movie ever made, but someone much younger may look at it and laugh, and think that a more current horror movie is far and away more horrifying. Has scary changed all that much?




The book, though, is great. It'..."
Ha ha, Donna - when Nicholson was running around with the axe, did you find yourself wishing he'd hurry up and get Duvall, just to stop her horrid screaming?
Really, though, as is usually the case, you just can't compare the book and the movie. The book - so much better, because all of the creepiness is created in your own mind.
I've read a lot of King's work, and always find that I have the same complaint - suspense is building, subtly disturbing images are in place, beginning to graze genuine horror - and then, it gets silly. The only book that I didn't feel that way about was The Dead Zone, which is somewhat different than his usual fare.
I would say go for it. You will probably be frightened by some things, but eventually it will just settle into the frenzied rhythm of a thriller, and you won't feel scared any more.



http://divaliciouzbookreviews.blogspo...

If you consider this when you read the book, it may scare you more than usual. I, for one, love books that make me afraid to put my feet on the floor.



Or maybe that is judging. I don't know.
It can be pretty scary if you are afraid of the "unknown" and the supernatural.
It is also a lot of writing for fun. It should be enjoyed and not just feared. . .

I believe that SK's book "It" was by far his best and scariest book to date.

That scene with the ghost in that specially numbered room is brief but still has a good jump with it.
It was good and the book is better.

Speaking of getting "too scared" there are many examples of his short-stories that got under my skin. One very unusual one was "The Moving Finger" because I personally had a very uncomfortable problem with that kind of situation (self-conscious with the bathroom), others that were seemingly real. . . and "The Boogeyman" which was a creature that would not stop terrorizing a family. . . it should have been in a Tales From the Darkside story it was good!
I no longer read King. I may get back to him though if some of these current writers continue to get on my nerves (annoyance not fear! lol).

{friends reference for all those who know what im talking about ;) }


anyway, that aside, it is a top notch story from beginning to end, and i love the setting


anyway, that aside, it is a top notch story from beginning..."
yeah i know, the atmosphere has to be just right and the narrative visceral enough to get at least a drop of sweat from books

I loved the Stand too.. one of my favourites. The book IT was the first stephen King book i ever read and nabbed it from my brothers room. That scared me sooo much as a 15 year old kid. I was afraid to sleep with the lights off for a very long time. I loved Cell, but hated the ending.


more reason to call it an adult book (although i read it last year and loved it-i am15)

I also think that the book and movie have to be taken as separate entities. I like the book much better, but I think the movie has its qualities on its own merit. But the book is engaging and thrilling and one of my definite favorites. I think one of the things that ruined the movie for me most was Shelley Duvall. :(


Judy wrote: "I really want to read this book, but I get scared so easily and I hear this book is super scary"
When it gets too scary, just stick it in the refridgerator like Joey did in "Friends."
When it gets too scary, just stick it in the refridgerator like Joey did in "Friends."
Valerie wrote: "Judy wrote: "I really want to read this book, but I get scared so easily and I hear this book is super scary"
This was the first Steven King book I read and it was sooo good. How scary it is depen..."
The scariest scene in the Book are all the chapters involving Rm 217.
The scariest scenes in the movie are
1. The rm 227 scene.
2. The twins standing in the middle of the Hall way.
3. "All work and no play make Jack a dull boy. "
This was the first Steven King book I read and it was sooo good. How scary it is depen..."
The scariest scene in the Book are all the chapters involving Rm 217.
The scariest scenes in the movie are
1. The rm 227 scene.
2. The twins standing in the middle of the Hall way.
3. "All work and no play make Jack a dull boy. "

Michael wrote: "I am a teenager and I am not easily scared, but, there are some things that I fear, is this very scary? Or is it slightly scary?"
It all depends. People see the imitations, the ripoffs before they see the original horror movies that inspired them.
Example: some people have seen friday the 13th BEFORE 1978 version of Halloween. The tragic result of that is not being affected by John Carpenter's Master piece.
It all depends. People see the imitations, the ripoffs before they see the original horror movies that inspired them.
Example: some people have seen friday the 13th BEFORE 1978 version of Halloween. The tragic result of that is not being affected by John Carpenter's Master piece.

It all depends. People see the imitations, the rip..." well i bought a copy and figured it isn't very scary. I'm right so far, i have a pretty wicked imagination, but i'm up for the task
Michael wrote: "Jason wrote: "Michael wrote: "I am a teenager and I am not easily scared, but, there are some things that I fear, is this very scary? Or is it slightly scary?"
It all depends. People see the imita..."
His scariest books as far as Horror in the tradtional sense,are "It", "Pet Semetary" and Salems Lot.
But hang in there, onece you get to the "217" scenes in the book, I think you'll be satisfied.
By the way I personally think, The movie is better.
It all depends. People see the imita..."
His scariest books as far as Horror in the tradtional sense,are "It", "Pet Semetary" and Salems Lot.
But hang in there, onece you get to the "217" scenes in the book, I think you'll be satisfied.
By the way I personally think, The movie is better.

all discussions on this book
|
post a new topic
Cujo (other topics)
The Shining (other topics)
The Haunting of Hill House (other topics)
Bag of Bones (other topics)
More...
Books mentioned in this topic
The Shining (other topics)Cujo (other topics)
The Shining (other topics)
The Haunting of Hill House (other topics)
Bag of Bones (other topics)
More...