City of Glass (The Mortal Instruments, #3) City of Glass discussion


510 views
Isabelle or Maia?

Comments Showing 101-150 of 207 (207 new)    post a comment »

message 101: by Jenny (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jenny Abby wrote: "isabelle, i cant stand mia, shes a cry baby. and all u haters on isabelle, u just hate her cuz shes prettier than all of us."

LOL! i like what you said! :D i'm Team Isabelle and Simon all the way! :D


message 102: by Abby (new) - rated it 4 stars

Abby :) thanks, ya i like isablle, but jace is my fave. :):)


message 103: by [deleted user] (new)

ISABELLE!! Maia should go back with her old bf.


message 104: by Victoria (new) - added it

Victoria Maia, because simon is a vampire and she is a werewolf and its cute that they're supposed to hate each other,but they like each other instead...


message 105: by Kania (new) - rated it 4 stars

Kania Maia, because Simon matching with shy but tough girl like maia and i think isabelle is a playgirl..


message 106: by Rena (new) - rated it 5 stars

Rena Maia


Nurlely Isabelle is better for Simon. Maia should be with her ex. But I think any readers who have read City of Fallen Angels understand who Simon supposed to be...:)


message 108: by Sarah (new) - rated it 5 stars

Sarah at first isabelle seemed to just be playing around with simon for a while not even rly wanting a relationship, just flirting and getting his attention. at that point i wanted maia to be with him. but with new characters being introduced, it kinda all switches around what with isabelle being a lot more serious about simon and *spoiler* maia getting back together with her ex, jordan. this is why i rly did lyk COFA as opposed to other's opinions because cassie keeps it interesting! she mixes everything up! i mean after all, in my opinion, its not a good story-book or movie- if u know what is going to happen in the future...to me that is no fun at all. thus, i adore the mortal instruments series much much more than the alternative, twilight or some other series, which brings us to a totally different discussion....ok im gonna stop now. :)


Wennifred Maia


message 110: by Claire (new) - rated it 5 stars

Claire Wennifred wrote: "Maia"

Why?


message 111: by Steph (new) - rated it 5 stars

Steph Guys. Just read "City Of Fallen Angels"...


message 112: by Claire (new) - rated it 5 stars

Claire I have, but why do you think Maia should be with Simon?


message 113: by Tammie (new) - rated it 4 stars

Tammie Definitely Maia


Michele Perry Definitely Maia - I really love all the characters in this series. So life-like...bring on the movie I say!!! :)


Nurlely Isabelle!


message 116: by Darlene (last edited Aug 02, 2011 07:32AM) (new) - rated it 4 stars

Darlene I love Isabelle but she just doesn't seem right for Simon--in my opinion anyway. I wouldn't mind them together, but since he didn't get Clary, Isabelle and Maia just happened to be there, then Maia's ex walks in so Plan Maia's a fail that Izzy & Simon as a couple seem kind of... convenient. I mean, I guess things do have a chance of perfectly falling together like that, but since this is a book its kinda like since the fans wanted them together, they are. I always thought Maia was more compatible for him. And I thought the idea of Vampire-Werewolf romance would be cool. Camille would appreciate that ;) Oh wait, I think you need to read Clockwork Angel to get that last sentence


Carolina Oh man!, I really like the 2 girls,but Isabell has something special & I would love that she & Simon end up together :)


message 118: by [deleted user] (new)

Isabelle, she is more for Simon than Maia is.


Sancando Okay this is kind of a spoiler, but may i remind all of you in the end of CoFA Maia ends up with Kyle/Jordan, who i think she was perfect with. SO like ya Isabelle


message 120: by Nika (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nika Isabelle!! She's special and different, for me Maia is like a normal girl :)


Victoria I would have to say Maia,she loves Simon for who he is and doesnt just want him for the thrill of having a vampire boyfriend(Isabelle)


message 122: by Nika (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nika well yes thats also right


Victoria but i would also have to agree with you because of the last book...not giving anything away!!!


message 124: by Emilie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emilie Isabelle. Simon and Maia are more friends than romantics. And I think Simon would be good for Izzy


message 125: by Nika (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nika yeah!!


Victoria that is true...but like i said,Izzy is just using Simon.


message 127: by Emilie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emilie I don't think so, at least not anymore..


Victoria your right...but she was like that.


message 129: by Emilie (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emilie Yeah, she was. I hope she has changed..


message 130: by Nika (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nika Mee too


message 131: by [deleted user] (new)

I think Isabelle.


Isabelle isabelle because she has the same name as me and because I think maia is gonna end up with that werewolf that i forgot the name


Victoria im not spoiling anything!!!


message 134: by Jojo (new) - rated it 5 stars

Jojo Trinity, you're completely right. Isabelle has a whip. Big deal. Maia, however, can change into a wolf AND kill demons. I know the whole werewolf/vampire conflict, but come on! Maia is waaaaay more down to earth (and not just because she's a Downworlder) and Simon appreciates that. He isn't the high-maintenance kinda guy in my opinion. Isabelle is DEFINITELY high-maintenance, but Maia? She's just all around cool and laid back.


Crystal Faye Faye Before reading City of Fallen Angels, I would have said Maia....but now I would pick Isabelle...I won't give COFA away to those who haven't read it. But, after reading this book, I think Simon would be better off with Isabelle for sure!!!! =]


*Book Euphoria * I like Isabelle for Simon, I know she is a little to girly and has an attitude but,I like her better than Maia. I don't really like Maia that much, I guess its because we hear about her way less, then we hear about Isabelle, I kind of felt that when Maia was brought into the picture, I was rolling my eyes every time she was in the scenes. She tried to attack Simon in CoA, damn it.


*Book Euphoria * We find out that Isabelle kinder in CoFA, and Simon is starting to like her more, well Maia was just another character that wad pointless to me, and that ends up with her ex,, of course , I know I'm sounding like a hater, my bad,


 Taya I'd go with Isabelle. With Simon around she has opened up quite a bit.
And I'd like to see some more of Maia and Jordan together.


Hydrangea If I didn't read CoFA, then I would want Maia with Simon, but all fails nicely into place. I agree Maia is the female version of Simon. I like the tension and ultimate drama of natural enemies, werewolf and vampire, falling in love kind of like Edward and Bella. I like Maia A LOT and I would want her for a friend if I knew her. I think Isabelle is a good role model of a strong, independent woman, but she scares me. I think Simon is too nice and probably not interesting enough for Isabelle. I also worry that in Book 5 or 6, maybe the author will somehow weave it so that Clary ultimately ends up with Simon. Believe me as the books have gone on, Simon has become most intriguing and a beloved character. I read the author designed Simon after her husband, so I hope the story doesn't spin back that Clary ends up with the nice boy next door, Simon, rather than Jace who sets her heart on fire :) I love this new vulnerable Jace too :) I guess we'll see how it all plays out! The waiting is the hardest part :)


message 140: by Emily (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emily at first I wouldve said maia but after COFA there are certain things that happen and certain characters that come into play that changed my mind to isabelle


message 141: by Emily (new) - rated it 5 stars

Emily and if you think of it simon has always cared for izzy differently than any of the others


message 142: by Olivia (new) - rated it 5 stars

Olivia Isabelle......I think Maia belongs with the other werewolf guy. Besides Isabelle's a SHADOWHUNTER!!!! :)


Vanessa i like Isabelle more :)


Karyssa Allen i think Maia... just cuz :3


Valerie Isabelle. She was vulnerable, at least a little more. Anyways, she's a Shadowhunter!!


Makayla I love Maia, but for some reason, I`m gonna have to go with Izzy :)


Osudinee I love both girls, they both know how to kick butt! But for Simon I think he'll end up with Isabelle while Maia will end up with Jordan! They are sooo good together! For those who disagree I recomend for you to read The City of Fallen Angels


message 148: by Lucy (new) - rated it 4 stars

Lucy I would have to pick Maia she is a were wolf and an downworlder too so it would make more sense and I like maia better


Elizabeth Issy!


Melissa Well i like a lot both of them. But i prefer Maia for Simon.


back to top