City of Glass (The Mortal Instruments, #3) City of Glass discussion


510 views
Isabelle or Maia?

Comments Showing 1-50 of 207 (207 new)    post a comment »
« previous 1 3 4 5

Darby Karchut Hmmmm... guess I'll go for Maia, but I do like Isabelle, too.


Allison ya i did notlike the last 2 books of the twilight saga!first 2 could have been better! and i would have 2 choose maia... because in the begging simon wanted isabelle cuz he wanted the second bestt hing he could never have isabellle.. then he met maia and everything changed he became a man and he found some 1 who wanted him and he wants back too.. not just to have a sex partner


Zoha Maia. Isabelle is too Isabelle.


Kailee Hmmm... This is a hard decision. Isabelle did get Simon turned into a rat. Clairy got him turned into a vampire in the first place! And Maia just suddenly shows up in the third book, and BAM there's another love triangle happening. Simon should just stay solo for right now.


Lily Maia... Isabelle is an interesting character, but Maia would be better with Simon.


Athena I'd go for Maia. Isabelle is cool but I like Maia's character better.


Nurlely Isabelle should go with Simon, not Maia. Isabelle is a strong girl, act like she doesn't need anyone. But she likes Simon and she is happy with him. Isabelle likes Simon whether he is a vamp or not.


message 8: by M. (new) - rated it 4 stars

M. Honestly, I don't think Simon is good enough for either of them. They both have their strengths and deserve someone who really cares about them and Simon only has eyes for Clary.


Ashley Isabelle is more entertaining but I guess I would go with Maia for Simon. Isabelle seems to just want to have fun


Allison i would also choose maia because it seems like isabelle just cant stay steady with a boy and that seems just want simon wants is some onehe can be with.... plus maia always went looking for simon not the other way around where as simon always had to go loooking for isablee


Camilla Belle ISabelle


Rebecca MiaNicole, I couldn't agree with you more. :-)


message 13: by Zoha (new) - rated it 5 stars

Zoha Michelle wrote: "Honestly, I don't think Simon is good enough for either of them. They both have their strengths and deserve someone who really cares about them and Simon only has eyes for Clary."

Yeah but he knows Clary is all Jace's.


Allison ya i think he kinda gave up his feelings for clary after they broke up and he meat mia


Allison i meant maia


Kellie I vote Isabelle. She is passionate and strong. I feel that Maia is young and naive.


Kaitlyn I really like both. Maia would be my choice. I feel like Isabelle is a little too much for Simon to handle.


Allison ya isabele just cant stay with 1 guy and simon just wants some one who will be with huim


Tali28 Ithink Isabelle. Maia being a warewolf would bring more problems for Simon. Either way I think Isabelle would be a better choice for him.


Tali28 Kellie wrote: "I vote Isabelle. She is passionate and strong. I feel that Maia is young and naive."

I agree with you 100%


Tamara Kaitlyn wrote: "I really like both. Maia would be my choice. I feel like Isabelle is a little too much for Simon to handle."

i agree i think isebel is well...jsut to much for simon!! i like maia.


Bookrazy-Koi In all fairness..if you read CoFA...let's just say...it's ....should I spoil it for you guys?


Allison no way i wanna read it


Tamara no no dont ruin it!!!!!!!!!!!


message 25: by [deleted user] (last edited Apr 11, 2011 06:50PM) (new)

Kaitlyn wrote: "I really like both. Maia would be my choice. I feel like Isabelle is a little too much for Simon to handle."

i totaly agree 110%. i might change my mind after i read CoFA...


message 26: by [deleted user] (new)

Lily wrote: "Maia... Isabelle is an interesting character, but Maia would be better with Simon."

YES!!!!


message 27: by [deleted user] (new)

Bookrazy-Koi wrote: "In all fairness..if you read CoFA...let's just say...it's ....should I spoil it for you guys?"

u will ruin it if u do say it, so NO!!



Jenny Isabelle all the way! Simon and Isabelle! Isabelle seems like she likes Simon more than Maia, and to me, Maia seems like more of a friend of Simon's and Isabelle seems more of Simon's girlfriend! I hope Simon would pick Isabelle!


message 29: by [deleted user] (new)

Maia, there would be a destructible force..:).Isabelle, all will be whipping..and good hair dressing.:)


Stormy Maia. She's a werewolf, he's a vampire. They are suppose to hate each other but they are past that. They also liked each other right on the spot. We don't really read about her much but she cried hard when she thought Valentine killed Simon. I think she really likes him. Whereas Isabelle just looked past Simon when they first met (he wasn't a hunky faerie, i guess) while he was practically drooling on her and she's only using him to upset her parents. She might like him now but i think she will get over him easily enough. she's strong. Maia's intentions have always been true and i think her and Simon could have a genuine relationship being star-crossed lovers and all that.


Karthik either!simon seems 2 hav some feelings 4 both girls....not as much as 4 clary though....2 early 2 tell, he has 2 completely get ovr clary 1st!


Katherine For those who have read the recent instalment to this series City of Fallen Angels, they will probably understand when I say that I want Simon to end up with Isabell. I wont give anything away about the book except that you find out the reason why Isabell finds it hard to commit and when she does it's becuase she has really strong emotions that she doesn't want to admit due to fear of being left broken hearted. This is the reason previously you only see her partake in relationships that are shallow and meaning less.


Sarah maia...she cares more-or so it seems....isabelle thinks its all about being perfect-which its not!


message 34: by Alex (new) - rated it 4 stars

Alex Maia. She is sweeter. and it is more like the forbidden love kind of thing. I think that their love could create quite a bond. Isabelle is a jerk; not for Simon


Sarah i totally agree


Monique Gonzalez Katherine wrote: "For those who have read the recent instalment to this series City of Fallen Angels, they will probably understand when I say that I want Simon to end up with Isabell. I wont give anything away abou..."

I agree :) Before City of Fallen Angels, I actually couldn't decide between who I would like to see Simon end up with, because I loved both Maia & Isabelle for their own reasons. But seeing Isabelle's point of view in Fallen Angels clears up confusion when it came to why she acts the way she does. I love her even more now!


Rianne OMG this is such i hard dicision! they are both amazing characters! but i guess if i had to pick.. it would be isabelle, i find she had more emotion, i guess.


Nurlely Isabella! She liked Simon when he was still an ordinary mundane. Simon as vampire is quite attractive, so it is not a big deal when Maia is also drawn to him.


Stormy Maia liked him too when he was human. When she found out he was a vampire she flipped because they are sworn enemies or whatever but she got over it because she likes Simon for the person he is not what he is.


message 40: by Nurlely (last edited Apr 17, 2011 07:44PM) (new) - rated it 5 stars

Nurlely Maia liked him because Simon is not beautiful. Handsome boys scared her. Isabelle liked him because she liked him. She did not even understand why. I think that is what love should be.

As for Simon, I hope both Isabelle and Maia give him a lesson for going out with both of them. That will be something..:)


message 41: by Jess (new) - rated it 4 stars

Jess If Simon does go for Mia then what would happen with Jordan and Mia thing going on. Jordan would most likely beat Simon up or something. And if he goes for Isabelle...Well, they might have some trouble (shadowhunter-vampire, and her parents). I think Simon should find another vampire.


Hannah ISABELLE, by far!!!


Angelu Isabelle of course.. I think Maia should reunite with her ex.. Jordan Kyle.. since Jordan didn't mean to hurt and turn her.. plus Simon and Isabelle understand each other... :D for me they're meant to be with each other.. <3


Jenny Angelu wrote: "Isabelle of course.. I think Maia should reunite with her ex.. Jordan Kyle.. since Jordan didn't mean to hurt and turn her.. plus Simon and Isabelle understand each other... :D for me they're meant..."

oh god, me too! i love Simon and Isabelle. They are soooooo cute together! i loved the part when Simon told Isabelle that he will always love her! i was hoping that Simon would at least have one kiss scene in book! they were so close too! too bad the clave HAD to show up that time! when Maia kissed Jordan, i was like.... YES! YES! Maia kissed Jordan! Isabelle can have Simon now! i CAN'T wait till I read City of Lost Souls, i heard that Simon has a in depth kiss scene with * Hint Hint* Isabelle! i hope! my dream would come true!


Jenny in my heart, it will always be Simon and Isabelle, Simon deserves someone who is pretty and that loves him alot. If you have read COFA, you would understand. Isabelle did feel more hurt when Simon cheated on her, then Maia, Isabelle was so close in crying and Simon wanted to follow her....... awwwwwwwwww how sweet! i support you guys soooooooo much!

*spoiler alert!


Lupita i think maia is going to end up with her ex and isabelle with simon


Crystal i would pick Issabelle! she is sooo awsome! but I do think that Maia is great too. :)


Alya i would pick Issabelle too she is amazing. She suites Simon coz he is this cute geeky boy and she is outgoing hot and stuff. they look cute together and werewolf + werewolf is BOOORINNGGG but shadowhunter and werewolf... WOoooooooo XDDD and i love those two


Sarah Alya (loveeees drama) X) wrote: "i would pick Issabelle too she is amazing. She suites Simon coz he is this cute geeky boy and she is outgoing hot and stuff. they look cute together and werewolf + werewolf is BOOORINNGGG but shado..."

ummm...hate to break it to u but simons not a weerewolf...idk what ur talking about...he is a VAMPIRE


Angelu well we all agree on Simon and Isabelle being together.. :D that should be very nice...


« previous 1 3 4 5
back to top