What is the ONE review you are most proud to have written?

[Scribble]

I think I like The Egg Said Nothing best, now that I've written it.

[Michael, Sonic the Hegemon]

Since this thread is so fun, I'm going to set up another thread of favorite reviews by OTHER reviewers. So, when y'all are done whoring your own reviews, start whoring for others over there.

[Jason]

Whores get money or drugs as compensation..

we are just sluts.

[Scribble]

Michael wrote: "Since this thread is so fun, I'm going to set up another thread of favorite reviews by OTHER reviewers. So, when y'all are done whoring your own reviews, start whoring for others over there."

That's the basis of my egg review, actually.

[Joshua Nomen-Mutatio]

Jason (FNORDinc) wrote: "Whores get money or drugs as compensation..

we are just sluts."

And sluts are just aspiring whores. Which is worse than being a whore. At least whores follow through on their dreams and get real paid.

[Books Ring Mah Bell]

I'm going to set up another thread of favorite reviews by OTHER reviewers. So, when y'all are done whoring your own reviews, start whoring for others over there.



You must!

Sadly, one of my favorite reviews (by David) is gone.
(The Giving Tree)

I wish that it was stored away somewhere...

*sigh*

[Eh?Eh!]

Books Ring My Bell wrote: "Sadly, one of my favorite reviews (by David) is gone.
(The Giving Tree)

I wish that it was stored away somewhere...

*sigh*"

I miss that one, too! That was the beginning of my downward spiral into gr.

[Paul]

Favourite reviews by other people - I got tired waiting for some section on one's profile to be created by GR so I did this already -

http://www.goodreads.com/story/show/2...

[Brian R.]

Jasmine wrote: "Brian R. wrote: "I don't know how to post links, but the review of mine I most like was of Cryptonomicon."

http://www.goodreads.com/review/show/..."

Jasmine, thank you much. It's good that Goodreads has so many helpful and coolaceous people who can cover for those of use who are comparatively clue-deficient.

[David]

My best review was for Flowers in the Attic, but like many delicious things, it's no longer extant.

My most popular review was (far and away) my The Giving Tree review, which I never really loved. I wrote it (in January 2008) before I realized that a lot of people might in theory read my review. It was subsequently censored and deleted once by Goodreads. Several Goodreaders launched a campaign to have it reinstated, and it was, with an apology -- but then it was deleted by GR again! (Otis explained that it was deleted by an 'overzealous intern' who objected to all the obscenity.) Then I deleted my account and it was lost. But then someone had a copy of it and I reinstated it. But then I deleted my account again and it's gone. For good, probably. Goodbye, Giving Tree.

[Jimmy]

It gives no more :`(

[Jason]

David wrote: "My best review was for Flowers in the Attic, but like many delicious things, it's no longer extant.

My most popular review was (far and away) my The Giving Tree review, which I never really love..."

did they give you a copy via email?

[Books Ring Mah Bell]

My best review was for Flowers in the Attic, but like many delicious things, it's no longer extant.



Twat!

[Paul]

David, if I may be so bold, why did you delete your account, not once, but twice?

[David]

Because I'm a pissy little temperamental bitch.

And that's being honest, not flippant.

[Bill]

Paul wrote: "Favourite reviews by other people - I got tired waiting for some section on one's profile to be created by GR so I did this already -

http://www.goodreads.com/story/show/2......"

How does one create a page like this?

[Jimmy]

GR homepage > writing (on the right hand menu) > add new writing

[Joyzi]

This was a very difficult question, can I post not just one, since it was hard to pick?

1. Water for Elephants

2. Crescendo

3. I Am Number Four

4. Beautiful Darkness

5. The Iron King

6. A Great and Terrible Beauty

7. Until You

8. The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo

9. The Girl With The Dragon Tattoo

10. Mockingjay

[Bill]

I have not written a really-proud-of review yet. I don't feel I really know how to write a review.

[Nancy]

Kernos wrote: "I have not written a really-proud-of review yet. I don't feel I really know how to write a review."

You're too modest, Kernos. I enjoyed your review of Dhalgren

[Paul]

BTW did you all notice David's Giving Tree is BACK?

[Bill]

Nancy wrote: "Kernos wrote: "I have not written a really-proud-of review yet. I don't feel I really know how to write a review."

You're too modest, Kernos. I enjoyed your review of Dhalgren"

Thanks Nancy. I started to do a formal review, but thought it'd have toto be a thesis, so I just wrote down some general thoughts.

[Desperado]

Hmmm. I'd have to say Kiss of Midnight. I'm new to GR (been a member less than a year) & even newer to writing reviews. This was the review that finally got me into my "groove." I established my personal style writing this review.