Redwall discussion
Which of your fav. Character where killed off?
date
newest »
newest »
message 51:
by
Ephraim
(new)
Nov 26, 2010 04:48PM
Oh the one with the boy and his dog, and the creepy captian and his ghostly crew. My mom got it at garage sale .
reply
|
flag
I have read that one too. "You, your crew and the dead shall sail the seas for all eternitie."
Tallerine7 wrote: "I have read that one too. "You, your crew and the dead shall sail the seas for all eternitie.""Yeah, it's pretty good.
Joshua wrote: "I liked that one. It was a good book!"Ditto!
I am reading a series called Left Behind The Kids.
Cool, I've read them all, they are pretty good. Right now I'm almost done with the adult left behind series. I have like three more books to read, but I keep getting books at the library that I want to read, so then i don't finish the left behind ones.
I'm not religious, I have a relationship.
What a nice and wonderful way to put it. I finished the adult series last year.
:D Thanks! I've got like four more to read in the adult series. But I'm reading more interesting things, so they are on the back shelf right now.
~It Just Takes One~ (Elizabeth) wrote: "I'm not religious, I have a relationship."Me too!!! My dad is always saying we do not have a religion, we have a relationship.
Oh, I've read all of Brian Jacques' book except his two horror ones. I'm not allowed to read horror.
If you liked Castaways of the Flying Dutchman, you should read Isle of Swords by Wayne Thomas Batson. It is really cool!
Ok, I'll look it up. Same here with the horror.
Redwallcrazy- I love Digger! wrote: "~It Just Takes One~ (Elizabeth) wrote: "I'm not religious, I have a relationship."Me too!!! My dad is always saying we do not have a religion, we have a relationship.
Oh, I've read all of Brian J..."
WOW! Thats eaxtly how my dad puts it. And how is so mad at todays every days church
Mod
Anne wrote: "I don't think it was offensive... Just a little gramatically confusing perhaps?"Lol, yeah!
~Jesus Saves~ (Elizabeth) wrote: "Anne wrote: "I don't think it was offensive... Just a little gramatically confusing perhaps?"Lol, yeah!"
Yeah, that's the way I saw it too. Wha did you mean to say, Ephraim?
This place is a graveyard, does anyone post here anymore?
So do I! If there something to post back to.
Rose. I cried so hard when she died. Also Bragoon and Saro.
Giselle wrote: "Rose. I cried so hard when she died. Also Bragoon and Saro."Definitely Rose for me as well.
It seemed such a cruel fate for Martin after all he'd been through to lose one of the few people who'd come to be like family to him. Not to mention how hard it must have been for Brome and the people of Noonvale.
Probably why Martin the Warrior is my favourite Redwall novel.
I don't like when my favorite characters die. My sister hasn't read Martin the Warrior but she say the PBS version of the book and she cried when Rose died. I cried in the book. And I still cry when Finbarr Galedeep died, even though I've read that book over twenty times!
My favorite character that was killed was Log a log in Redwall and Rose from Martin the warrior.
My is Rose, but without Rose dying, there would not have been a Redwall.
My favorite characters that died are Rose and Slagar. Yes, i know, Slagar is evil and all that, but i seriously liked that dude!!
My favorite characters who got killed off are Bragoon and Saro. They're really awesome characters and I loved the friendship that they shared. I'd say they're some of the strongest characters Brian created.
Rose, Shogg, and Cregga. Loved 'em all. ;-;
Redwallcrazy- My God is Healer, Awesome in Power! wrote: "Which of your fav. character where killed off? Warning, this discussion my contain spoilers.Mine are Mask, Finbarr, Flandor, Bragoon and Saro, Rose, Felldoh, and I that's all I can think of right ..."
The first time I read Martin the Warrior, I cried when both Rose and Felldoh die. I pretended that Felldoh lives. In my mind, I created stories about him. I do understand why he dies, but I still wish that he survives.
Elizabeth wrote: "You should read the Flying DuchmanCastaways of the Flying Dutchman."This book is so good. Ben and Ned are a great pair.
Joshua wrote: "I don't like the ending of Martin the Warrior:("Because Felldoh and Rose die?
Redwallcrazy- My God is Healer, Awesome in Power! wrote: "I know! I think Martin should have got married. It would have done him some good, and he would be a little happier, and the book not so depressing."While I agree Rose dying broke my heart, I think the fact that he lost the love of his life adds an unseen element to Martin's character that I think makes him a deeper character in Mossflower and Legend of Luke
Bragoon and Saro, Jukka the Sling, Felldoh, Mask, Skarlath, Finbarr Galedeep,
Riley wrote: "Bragoon and Saro, Jukka the Sling, Felldoh, Mask, Skarlath, Finbarr Galedeep,"Felldoh!! =( Such an epic way to go, though.
Elizabeth wrote: "Most of the bad guys! Why can't any of them ever turn good?"well, there was one searat in the bellmaker who became a good guy.
Mine are : Tiria; Swiffo; Finnbarr Galedeep; Shogg; Felldoh; everyone from mattimeo, High rhulain and Every single other book in the series because, it has been 9 seasons since the Rogue crew was published, and according the aging between books, everyone would be dead.
