Challenge: 50 Books discussion
Pet reading hates


Someone else said it already, but I also hate it when people are disparaging toward other people’s reading choices. I’ve been a big romance reader since I was a kid (literally since junior high school) and I despise the fact that some people who don’t read romance are so snobby and dismissive of the genre. I remember reading a romance author interview in which she said that someone came up to her at a book-signing and asked her when she was going to write a “real book.” That’s so disrespectful, in my opinion. Some of the best books I’ve ever read have been romances. I’m not saying that every romance novel is an outstanding work of literature or anything like that -- as with any genre there are bad ones along with the good -- but there is a reason that romance outsells every other book genre and accounts for about 50% of total book sales.


I know it sounds nasty, but I'm fairly sure most people have them.
For me, after working in a busy bookstore, it's whe..."
I hate to admit it, but I do agree with you (let the scathing begin). But seriously, I have some friends that I've recommended some GREAT books to who look at me and say "is it a mystery? I ONLY read mysteries." Don't get me wrong, I read mysteries too and I throw in some YA lit, as well as the typical beach reads (Koontz, Patterson, Sookie Stackhouse), but people really do themselves an injustice by refusing to Grow a little in their reading habits. Even though I should just be happy that these other people are reading anything, it just irks me a little.


It's funny you said this. Last year I was watching CSPAN's book t.v. and they had a discussion panel about ereaders. The writer from the NY Times said that a lot of the literary types disliked the Kindle or ereaders because they make it impossible to see what someone is reading (ie. so that they can't pass their judgment on this person particular reading habits.). She said it jokingly, but you know those literary types, it's probably partially true.

i confess that i do bend the page sometimes...but only when i cant find anything to put between the pages. and my English teacher, when we were reading the hobbit, made us write in the books! Ag! i felt like i was disgracing it!!




Bj wrote: "I have a friend who is a huge Harry Potter fan, and she has tried millions of times to get me to read them, but I just can't... I have tried several YA novels and they just don't do anything for me..."
This is my biggest peeve. When someone says the HATED a book, but then go on and on about how they hate a character or hate the subject because it's depressing. I just want to shake them and say "you hate the character, not the book! The book obviously has some impact on you due to your huge reaction to it". I agree, they should revere or embrace the book, not shun it. Hate a book for it poor writing not for it's characters...

My sister who reads at least one book a year,and yes you did read that properly and even better it is always the same book, is one of the worst offenders for this. Why are you reading that book? I'm reading it because I want to, because the blurb on the back caught my imagination or because it was recommended to me by people who have read some of the same books I have and they thought I might like it.
As for people mistreating books, that really winds me up and it doesn't matter if it's my book, their own or a library book. Don't fold over the pages, don't write in it and certainly don't leave it open face down.


I don't like to bend books either, but I must admit that I do sometimes write in them. To me, if there is a book that I really connect with or find particularly interesting/inspiring/etc, it is not disrespectful at all to make notes in it. I actually feel like I am developing a relationship with the content. I love rereading books with my old notes in them and seeing how my thoughts and feelings have changed (or not). I also love finding used books with other people's notes. I agree that books are something to cherish, and I see my notes and underlines as a mark of my love for them.



Hahahaha, and here I thought I was the only one when I came across these grammatical errors and wanting to do the same. Too bad their mistakes are in print, hopefully they are bright enough to figure it out and fix it when they put the book on the next printing run.

You'd hate my library -- I am an underliner and a dog-earer, but it's only because I get so enthralled with what I'm reading.


Actually, we'd probably love your library since they obviously don't fine you for the destruction. Mine sure does.

Actually, we'd probably love your library since they obviously don't fine ..."
Oh, I meant my personal library! I don't always use the public library because of my need to write/jot/doodle/highlight books. :)

As for people mistreating books, that really winds me up and it doesn't matter if it's my book, their own or a library book. Don't fold over the pages, don't write in it and certainly don't leave it open face down..."
I won't look down on your reading selections if you don't look down on me for writing in my own books.
The way I see it, reading should be encouraged, so it shouldn't matter what people read - just that they do.
As for the proper treatment of books - as long as they aren't being banned I see nothing wrong with handling them however you like - provided you own them and they aren't borrowed from others.

I guess if you are someone who eats, drinks or cuts yourself while reading, please be aware that a library book is not YOUR book. That is all I have to say.
Then again I don't know if it would have bothered me quite as much if I hadn't read this thread. LOL!
BTW... the book is about a butcher so the bleeding rust stains all over the book make the situation more disturbing, and a little funny.

Mind you, I can see the funny side of the whole butcher thing, maybe someon thought they were being hilarious..


As for people mistreating books..."
I know I'm completely anal and I would never say to anybody about them writing in their books I know that it is their property and they can do what they like with it but I do say something if it's my book they are abusing.
Anyway the joys of sharing the planet with other people means that there will always be somebody doing something that annoys us.


I knew someone like that. I then informed him when I was in college I was a history major, and most my assigned reading was fiction. I must have read about 70 novels a semester. Nonfiction is great for facts or a specific reference, but if you want to learn about people and culture and political pulses, you have to read novels (the kings court jesters were the only ones allowed to tell the truth).

Wuthering Heights *gag* I can completely relate to this.
My personal pet peeve goes a little further. Why is it that if you have a female and male heroes in a book that they will fall in love/have sex/etc? Is it not possible for males and females to have some sort of relationship that is not romantic?
I also have to admit to having a very anal negative reaction to people writing in books. I'll even refuse to pickup a cheap used book I've been wanting if there is writing in it.
My point of view on this is that I really don't care or even want to know what you thought of the book, or thought was important in the book, or what you thought was fascinating with the book, or even what you disliked about the book. I considered murder the day I ran across a book that was filled with doodles of the main male character's name with little hearts around them. :)

(2) As much as I hate it when people get food, grease, creases, highlights, scribbles, and various variety of dirt and tears on books that they then have the nerve to sell as used, I really hate it even more when they do it to LIBRARY books. It takes away a lot of pleasure from reading to wonder if the brown stains all over the book meant the previous patron had used it for toilet paper.
(3) I hate it when people negatively rate and review a book based on the audio-book version, possibly an abridged version, and their opinions of the actors. I think it greatly unfair to the hard-working author and potential readers to give a 1 or 2 star rating to a good book just because the producers of the audio-book did a poor job of casting. Please, rate and review the work based on how you think the author did.

I hate that now that Twilight is so big, its taking over other works of fiction! There are now copies of Wuthering Heights, Jane Eyre and Pride and Prejudice in copycat Twilight covers... Wuthering Heights comes complete with a printed on "Bella and Edward's Favourite Book" sticker on it.
I guess its good that the covers might get young readers into classic books, but I dont know if they'd understand the writing style if they had only read Twilight before.
I don't know... I think the whole marketing to Twilight lovers almost cheapens the classics.


This is very sad. It is our history. The sad thing is the people who are asking for it to go away, more than likely have never read the stories. Some of these stories are thinly veiled rebellions, and hold a deeper message than the stereotype that tells the story.
FYI - There is a wonderful retelling of the Little Black Sambo story called Sam and the Tigers. It was written by Julius Lester and illustrated by Jerry Pinckney, both African American.


My biggest pet peeve... when flipping over the next page of a library book, brushing my fingers against something hard and crunchy, then seeing a booger or a dried snail trail plus booger there. Sorry, I know; so gross to even read, but this has happened to me more than once. Just DISGUSTING. I have to wash my hands a few times after that. Use a kleenex dammit.
Weirdly, I kind of like finding handwriting in a book. Sometimes comments seem so obscure out of context. Though I never write in books myself.
Weirdly, I kind of like finding handwriting in a book. Sometimes comments seem so obscure out of context. Though I never write in books myself.

Faye that is so gross, people are just disgusting. Most people wouldn't dream of doing that with a book they own but a borrowed one, although you could use other peoples disgusting habits as justification for buying new books.

I like mixing genres up too. But I'm very cautious about who or what I read. There is a certain pattern to my reading. A book must 'jump out' at me. The book chooses me, I think, that's what I like.
I rarely underline or write in books. As someone said, I only do it if I feel a connection with it. The last time I ever did any scribbling was with House of Leaves. Anyone who's read it will understand that you can't HELP it.
And lending a book and not getting it back. UGH! Been there, don't that. Never again ... The dried booger thing has happened to me though... that was nasty. Whever I take out boks from the library I always detol the plastic front cover. I can't abide not knowing where the book has been!!! But the pages inside... I can't use disinfectant on those unfortunately lol!
This is an excellent topic!

Carol, just spotted your comment. YES! I can't abide this either. I want to READ these books the way they were first printed. Get a feel and a taste for that era. Changing these stories is like taking a 1000 year old fossil and immersing it in acid. It should be stopped. Uncle Remus stories are a good example.



Books mentioned in this topic
The Sex Club (other topics)Secrets to Die for (other topics)
American Psycho (other topics)
House of Leaves (other topics)
I know it sounds nasty, but I'm fairly sure most people have them.
For me, after working in a busy bookstore, it's when people wont even try to read something different!
For instance, since the Twilight infatuation, so many more people just won't move out of the Vampire Romance genre. Don't get me wrong, I havent got a problem with the genre itself (I'm a mad Sookie Stackhouse fan), I just get annoyed when I show someone a book I'm fairly sure they'll like, but they wont try because it doesnt involve bloodsucking dead people! It goes for most genres, eg sci-fi, people who will only read capital L literature etc etc.
Also, people who borrow books and treat them badly! I dont mind if you do it to your own books, just dont hurt mine! (Maybe I'm just overprotective =P)
Does anyone else feel the same?
Or another thing people do that make you squirm?