Fantasy Book Club discussion
Archived threads
>
What are you reading in March 2010?
date
newest »

message 51:
by
William
(new)
Mar 15, 2010 05:44AM

reply
|
flag

Any thoughts on the series as a whole? I hate committing to a series based on one decent book and then discovering that it weakens as time goes on. I think there's something like 7 that Carey has written, and I'm only a quarter the way through number 1. So far: fascinating and beautifully written!

My review is on my blog and here

Robyn Hawk
@ReadingItAll
Amazon Vine Voice: Reading It All
http://booksreadingitall.blogspot.com/
http://www.facebook.com/ReadingItAllR...

Well crafted books, all three.

It helps to have goals when you're approaching middle age. :)
Especially since I can't seem to read fast enough or say "No!" to non-reading projects.

Have you read any of Carol Berg's other works? I adored [book:Transformation (all three in the series), but couldn't get into the next series.... Dunno if I should try The Spirit Lens or not.

James, I've read everything she's done, and yes, I thought the first trilogy was brilliant.
If you haven't read her single standalone, that you may like, too. Her Lighthouse duology is every bit as good as the trilogy, in my opinion.
As to The Spirit Lens - she has an interesting magic system, excellent character development, and the plot moves fairly briskly. I had no trouble enjoying it, or finishing it, but like the Lighthouse duology, I think it suffers for not having its sequel - even though she gave it an ending, I have this sense (knowing her work) that the second book will bring it more resoundingly into focus.
I know what you mean about the second series...it had a somewhat softer touch - so far, this book falls somewhere between, to my mind. But it's tough to know where she's leading, since one of her earmarks is unpredictability and spectacular reverses. I'd expect to see that coming in the next volume - but no way to know until then. Definitely it has a more mannered feel to it - sort of victorian/french society with a court setting.

I was torn between two other library books for my next reading adventure: Eifelheim or The Warded Man. Both of these are upcoming book club reads. I opted for Eifelheim because it's shorter than The Warded Man and I may be able to complete it before the end of the weekend, what with the snow and all.


I'm currently reading: Psycho Fruits Basket, Volume 7 and Rebel Angels
I plan to read: The Sweet Far Thing The Hitchhiker's Guide to the Galaxy Ptolemy's Gate A Living Nightmare and probably many others as well. :)

Read A Game of Thrones. I haven't read The Master of Whitestorm, but A Game of Thrones is AMAZING!

Thanks for the additional pressure Hannah :P


I just started Gardens of the Moon, I am only on page 33 with no issues so far. Maybe it would be easier in text form.

I wouldn't count on it. He does throw you into an odd world without any context or explanation. However, I suppose anything's got to be smoother compared to Erikson. :) You'll probably get your bearings faster in Shades of Grey.

I had actually first tried reading the book but I felt so lost that I gave up. But after seeing how many other people really enjoyed Gardens of the Moon I decided to give it another try, in audio format, but I'm still just as lost. The advantage of listening to a book, though, is that it doesn't bother me a much when I don't know what's going on, as long as the narrator is good.But I'm thinking of pulling out my book again and skimming through the parts that I've listened to, to see if it helps. I don't think I've every put so much effort into a book before.
Shannon: At least I feel better knowing that others have found the book equally confusing. I might need some Fforde just as a break :)

This link will take you to summary by chapter, maybe it will help. http://encyclopediamalazica.pbworks.c...
I just made it to page 100. I did have to reread some sections, and I have been forced to turn to the character list and glossary multiple times, but I feel like I have a pretty good grasp of what is going on. I think that the hardest part is keeping up with all of the proper nouns.

So I offer my support here, please try to finish Gardens of the moon, and Deadhouse Gates after. You will not be able to stop after starting the #3th book, keeping up with the characters or not :P Believe me.

This link will take you to summary by chapter, maybe it will help. http://encyclopediamalazica.pbworks.com/..."
Thanks for the suggestion, that's a great idea. I'm going to go take a look at that link now.



Just picked up Perfume: The Story of a Murderer by Patrick Süskind. Did not realise until later that it won the World Fantasy Award in 1987 for best novel. Also found out later that Kurt Cobain said it was one of his favorite books and it inspired his song 'Scentless Apprentice'. So looking forward to reading this novel.


Later tonight I will be starting A Spell for Chameleon, another series recommended by my boyfriend. I've already read On a Pale Horse by Anthony and it was just ok, so I'm curious to see how the book one of Xanth compares.


Books mentioned in this topic
The Immortal Prince (other topics)The Eye of the World (other topics)
A Spell for Chameleon (other topics)
On a Pale Horse (other topics)
The Master of White Storm (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Gail Carriger (other topics)Patrick Süskind (other topics)
Juliet Marillier (other topics)
Carol Berg (other topics)
Carol Berg (other topics)
More...