Comfort Reads discussion
note: This topic has been closed to new comments.
General
>
What are you reading right now? (SEE NEW THREAD)
message 201:
by
Lee, Mod Mama
(new)
Mar 15, 2010 01:52PM

reply
|
flag
Mary wrote: "Lee, I am a sucker for a pretty book cover!"
Aren't we all?!? That hummingbird is so pretty!
Aren't we all?!? That hummingbird is so pretty!



Middlemarch by George Eliot which discussion starts tomorrow at Classics and the Western Canon.

Middlemarch by George Eliot which discussion starts tomorrow at Classics and the Western Canon."
That sounds interesting, Laura (I read the novel ages ago), I think I might join the group. Even though I don't usually see many of the classics as comfort reads, I love reading and discussing them.


I did and that is exactly my kind of group. I love history and in university I always got sidetracked by historical aspects in novels etc. Well, actually, I should not call that sidetracked, I believe that the historical background for books (or the historical information present in books) is just as important as textual analysis, literary theory etc. (of course, many of my professors did not agree with me). I'll be ordering (or trying to order) a cheap copy of the book from Amazon today, and hopefully will start reading by this weekend. By the way, does your group ever read any German literature in translation (like Thomas Mann or Goethe)?


I just ordered mine from Amazon Canada. That means I will probably get the book by Thursday or Friday. I've got a huge amount of book club read to go through, but this sounds so interesting. By the way, thanks for mentioning the book and the group, otherwise I would have never known about it.



Chrissie-- I just added both of these books to my TBR. My partner is from Hungary and I'd love to learn more about Hungarian history as well. Thanks for the tip! I think I would pick up Nicki first.....but I worry about your comment about the ending?

The Storyteller isn't just a history book. It is a biography of a family living through Hungarian history in the 1900s. To see if you like the writing style, check out my running review b/c I have quoted bits. You get Hungarian history and tales going back to the Huns, rhe 1400s, but predominantly the 1900s after WW2. If you want a dry history book, don't read this. Does this help you decide? I hope so.

5 stars and definitely a comfort book. This is why I read, for stories like this.
I've just started The Magicians and Mrs. Quent. It is a sci-fi/fantasy story, written in the style of Austen and Bronte. Right now I wish I had a big chunk of time to read it in!

Hi Chrissie. Yes it helps me decide and thanks for posting such a thorough explanation. I also read your review. To see that Nicki is a NY classic has me even more intrigued. I am going to stop at my library and see if I can get both books. Thanks too for mentioning Merle's Door, The Art of Racing in the Rain, and James Herriott. I've read all those books and understand when you say Nicki can't be compared. I'll remember to talk with you once I've gotten one of these books read. I'm excited to show them to my partner too.


I simply adore the writing style of The Storyteller!!!! The impossibility of understanding what happens to you that was described in Nikki, is also described tin this book! Everything is lies. Everybody was spying on each other. How do you teach a child honesty with all this going on around you?! Vili says to his granddaughter that lies in school are self-preservation; only the lies at home are the ones that count! These little kids comprehend this duplicity immediately.

I read The Zookeeper's Wife: A War Story about a year ago....that might be right up your alley.
Peregrine wrote: "Lisa wrote: "Peregrine, I really enjoyed The Speed of Dark. I hope that you do too."
5 stars and definitely a comfort book. This is why I read, for stories like this."
I get so excited when someone gives a book five stars and it's on my to-read list! Yay!
5 stars and definitely a comfort book. This is why I read, for stories like this."
I get so excited when someone gives a book five stars and it's on my to-read list! Yay!


That's who I read it with Lisa, my live book club.
Lisa wrote: "Oh, I'm eager to read The Zookeeper's Wife: A War Story. It's one of the books I've suggested to my real world book club several times."
It's really good, Lisa.
It's really good, Lisa.

Okay. Hopefully, I'll get to it, sometime this year. My on-deck and to-read list is soooooooooo long. But, thanks; I'll keep that in mind!

I actually like any book that shows a different part of the war that I had never really thought about. It's a wonderful history lesson to find those books. This one had a very unique story, and I was just really taken with it. It might not be everyone's cup of tea.



Also, Christine, I agree with you about reading and learning about parts of WWII that I hadn't previously given a lot of thought. I just finished Blackout by Connie Willis and learned so much about what people in London went through during the bombing of their city by the Germans. Also, another one of my favorite books is The Good German, a story that takes place in post-war Berlin, something I knew nothing about, and a book that takes a hard look at peoples' motivations and actions during war time and after.



Lori wrote: "So what did you think of Blackout? I just finished it too. While any book from Connie Willis is cause for celebration, this one was slightly disappointing."
Oh, I'm sorry to hear it was a little disappointing! I was really looking forward to it. How did you rate it?
Oh, I'm sorry to hear it was a little disappointing! I was really looking forward to it. How did you rate it?
Chrissie wrote: "Lee and Lisa, it is marvelous! Lots of history but told in a form that it goes down like ice cream. The text is funny too. The Spanish Civil War was "an uncivil civil war against civilians". Hunga..."
Chrissie, thanks for sharing more info about this memoir! You always find such interesting books.
Chrissie, thanks for sharing more info about this memoir! You always find such interesting books.

Lee, don't go by what I say! :D Most everyone seems to have loved it. And I thoroughly enjoyed it, couldn't wait to get back to reading. As always she has great characters. My biggest complaints are: 1. It's a bit repetitive, and; 2. It's very much the first part of a book that will be completed this fall with All Clear. Which was frustrating! I'm a very tough rater, and I'm still deliberating between a 3 (which means I quite liked it) and 4 which means it was something that sticks with me for awhile. While the repetitiveness irked me somewhat, it also added to the general anxiety of being in London during the Blitz.


This topic has been frozen by the moderator. No new comments can be posted.
Books mentioned in this topic
Forever (other topics)The Big Sky (other topics)
Anil's Ghost (other topics)
Burial Rites (other topics)
Goodbye Sarajevo: A True Story of Courage, Love and Survival (other topics)
More...
Authors mentioned in this topic
Michael Ondaatje (other topics)Wendell Berry (other topics)
Robert K. Massie (other topics)
Edmund Morris (other topics)
Susan Fromberg Schaeffer (other topics)
More...